Valor & Villainy: Minions of Mordak - Discussion
Transcript
Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Valorin Villainy, Minions of Mordac, which was a game that I was I wouldn't say anticipating for uh 2020, but it definitely was a game that I got and I was like, "Oh yeah. Yeah, this is this I can't wait to get this to the table uh cuz it might make my best games of 2020." You know what list it wouldn't have made? My best games of 2020. It definitely might have actually made You know what it was like there's a disappointing list. I I had to combine the disappointing and worst uh list. Um I don't think it would have made those because I didn't have the anticipation of this game to make it disappointing. right. Um and once again, these games that are coming out highly produced.
I feel like they put in more effort on production quality and like you mentioned, this game is whimsical and funny. So, they put a lot effort into that and then they're like, "Oh [ __ ] we have to make a game." Mhm. Um and It's easier to forgive the quality of a game when it's solid and good, but it is harder to forgive a game that is not good, but it's like, "Oh, it looks great." Cuz it's like, "Well, we don't want to play it." Exactly. But it looks great. Yeah. I want to show it off. I want to put it on our shelf Yeah. and look at it. Right. I mean, yes, so let's get the positives out of the way. The miniatures are fantastic. Like they're they're molded in such a way that they could be easily painted. Bright and colorful game. The map tiles are oak I mean, they're the the the cardstock, the the cardboard stock, everything is just fantastic.
Super thick and nice. trays are wonderful. Um I the the theme I I enjoy quite a bit. Uh what I don't really care for is the fact and I know that I know it would have been impossible to actually do because you shuffle the tiles but it does slightly bug me that sometimes the the roads don't connect but other times they do. Um there's no way they could have fixed that but it is just kind of aesthetically uh displeasing. Yes. They could have made them all in the same spot on every single tile. True but then then you're missing a lot of the other extra artwork. Yeah. Or not have just like a hard stop path just something. Sure. way yeah. But yeah so so those are there the backstories are hilarious and unique.
Yeah. Yeah the cards there's some cards that are funny or just clever in general that are fun. They have uh diversity in the game with with the characters. You have you know Lots of representation. Yeah lots of representation. and even non-human. Yeah. Even non-human. It's all there. The game is not. This is a lackluster game. Yeah. This is just and and we had played it before with literally me as Mordecai and and just you both you controlling one and I was like you know maybe we're missing something. It says it's best with four maybe they meant four total or they meant four heroes. So we did it with we did it with I guess five total and we had you control it. Um it's literally would have been the same.
Yeah. It was somehow way worse. Like It was way longer. It doesn't I don't think it added anything to the to the experience it just took longer. It just took longer. Like I really thought that I was going to be in bed by 9:30 because tomorrow's Friday like I just want to wind down like I just want to prepare for the weekend and now I'm just mad it's 10:00 and I'm going to go to bed like this like Um it's it was exactly what I said it was going to do. You No one does enough to warrant more people. Yeah. Like it it all it did was add more minions to block your way. Harder minions to block your way. Um just because one of my actions is literally to bring more minions in. Oh, and I'm going to spawn them and then okay, it's my turn to you know, minion step, I'm going to move them so you can't go scout. Uh and it's the whole game the whole scheme of Mordak is to stall the game.
I hate that. Yeah. There is nothing cuz like nothing strategic about that except oh, block you, block you, block you for six rounds. Yep. You have to have a solid why are you blocking me? Oh, just to make the game longer? No, that's not No. It's like be cuz like it doesn't come down to any kind of cool back and forth. It's literally oh, in your way. All right, I dealt three damage. Like it just We just pick away at each other. Oh, you died. All right, no real loss there. I just level up a little more. All right, you're back. And we don't lose anything. We just regain our all our health, move back to the center. Yep. Yep. It is the worst idea in a game in a competitive game where it's like uh cuz you you think that there'd be a tug-of-war. Okay, you know, the longer it takes you guys to scout, the the more powerful I'll become. Um so, I'm going to try and stop you so you don't whittle me down on health. And then it literally was like, all right.
So, you guys you guys found all the shrines, villain round. Okay, now I have to summon Okay, I have all these spells, eight damage, boom. Okay, I killed all of you. The the the steps to what this game wants it to be is that you guys are running around the land, defeating minions, gathering loot to power up to fight the big bad Mordak at the end. And oh, wow, he wiped us all out immediately. We didn't even get to go. No. Yeah. And we accidentally overpowered ourselves. over leveled. Yes. And that just shows how unbalanced the game is because yeah, we literally cuz we played it like I said with two. So yeah, it's it's basically one for one for your XP. Yeah. And this time you guys got a [ __ ] ton more. But it compensates to be like oh actually okay, you're at six, you gain two XP each and an extra you got to you get you know a white die.
Yeah. Um And so we overpowered you guys. And yeah, you were wiping through minions like it was nothing. Still you probably none of you can one shot the level threes. They've got yeah. Um and we still each of us got killed I think at least once during the course of the the thing. Well, it didn't help that all the minions that came out had long shot and [ __ ] just ranged. So I just picked you guys off from a distance. Yeah. It was just it was disgusting. Um I I I don't I don't think this game's balanced in any way. I don't think that, no, that was not a balanced display whatsoever. There's no give and take. I You guys it's like you guys kill my minions who cares I'll bring out more. This is a really good example of a one verse many where it's like yeah, but we can't win. Like how we're always doesn't it doesn't feel oppressive the entire game.
Yeah. I mean maybe it did. I don't know. I wasn't in your shoes. I mean there was definitely it wasn't like the others where you just felt beaten down the entire game. we knew we could at least get You guys were killing minions left and right and yada yada and you're like yeah okay, we could probably do this cuz I was like hey you guys have been doing your XP right. And then whoop didn't matter. Yeah. I Wow. Yeah. It's just I I don't get So all the positives are the physical aspects of the game. Yeah. Literally. Yeah. And and and the thought that went into the theme. The writing. All the negatives are about playing the game. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um Yeah, because it's it's way too long with more people it definitely overstays its welcome. Um Yeah. Because that's more harder minions coming out and more of them that they block your way. So it it just this game comes to a screeching halt.
being able to move out of an area, like if you get stuck with a hard minion, it's like, "Oh, Oh, I guess I'm here. I mean, yeah, someone can run and just range them and and kill them. Or you get an eagle and you get, you know, evade. And knowing also that it is that we leveled up incorrectly, like we wouldn't have had as many actions. actions. Yeah. Like I can't imagine only still having two actions, being totally stuck in the middle of like That's actually Okay. That's a good point, because even if you got six total bounty, you only get two. So, you'd have to save up your XP to get another action at at another at another round. And the game lasts six rounds, but it takes two hours to play. Yeah. Um I I really, with more people, I really don't like any of any aspect of the game.
Uh the compensation for the dice, "Oh, you know, I missed, so I can get a plus one." Who gives a [ __ ] It's plus one. It doesn't matter ever. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it would have, but I didn't get a chance to use what I what I ended up with. Oh, I see. Yes, because you you took all the plus ones to power up that that one spell. But even then, all it did was kill minions. Yeah. And it didn't matter. Well, it would have it would have wiped out all our distractions. We could have focused just on you. Right. Um Not all of them, but some. Sure. Uh but then like Ah. That would have just sped up the end of the game, which Every in wasn't satisfying. We mentioned it during the discussion where each time each level up step the game the the rules do specify, "Hey, you know, let the other person take their turn while the heroes are leveling up um or while the while the the players are leveling up, cuz what they do isn't going to impact anything." Which is true. However, it's it's you like when I'm leveling up or when I'm doing my turn, you guys don't care. When you guys are doing your turn, I have to care because I'm the it's just me to see what you guys are doing. But at the end of the day, I never felt like I did anything to halt you. It was just a natural progression of the game. Oh, minions will show up by the time you scout, they're just going to be there to stop you anyway.
I even told you, hey by the way, scout here because that's your best chance of finding a shrine to end this game. Hey by the way, maybe you guys should divide and conquer. You kill minions, you go scout to end the game. I should not be sitting here trying to help my enemy. Well, it was clear that you were a little impatient, which I totally understand. Yeah, I was getting that way too. It would suck cuz you don't want to play a game and feel like that. Yeah, I mean the game it's like well then let's just pack it up. Like the game hinges on randomness. I mean, both both on the spells that you get um and the die rolling. Granted, as you it it does give you enough to level them level up your dice that that with Gwenvael Gwenavel, whatever her name is. Gwenvael, it's probably Gwen I don't know Gwenvael.
It's Gwenvael. Um it's still I still didn't get it. Still didn't get it. I I think the cost of the spells and the dice that you're rolling, like and again, knowing how long it takes to truly level up now, that's [ __ ] to me. To me, that's I was not It's one of those okay, whether you whether you're whether you're rolls, you're the ranger. Okay, focus on range. You're the rogue. I guess do both. Is is in her Well, she Yeah, well she her's said go hang, but um The the ranger it says specifically it's like oh, you're an expert in ranged weaponry and offensive spells. She's not. Well, she starts with some. I mean, two yellow is not horrible. an expert though. Yeah, but you kept putting stuff in the melee, so you like you go off of both.
more likely to melee than I was to successfully pull off a spell spell. No, by your starting stuff you are not because you have two yellow. See, I but I would have to get two of them. casting a decent spell is significantly higher than the cost of doing some damage to a minion. No, I actually I I disagree because roll. Well, you got it. I see. do either way. But that gives you a plus up puts you at red dice instead of especially with the XP, you have to spend two to get to one red versus your double red. So then it's already All right, three Yeah. It doesn't either way. It doesn't matter. I don't like it. That's fine. I'm just saying that Which is Yeah, which is cool. Let's Yeah.
The choices that you made ended up you you drew the conclusion for the choices. They might have been different Mhm. if we had we had played a little differently, but I I I My character is actually one specially fighter, one was pretty well balanced, and neither of them were particularly interesting to Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I thought the the healing spells would have been cool. You never once healed. No, I didn't. I had I had one good opportunity to heal a bunch of people at once, but they all died. Yeah. So we Yeah, so it's like, all right, you guys just auto healed. The I don't know. I feel like that's a lot of the terrain tiles like that actually have abilities aren't ever useful. Going somewhere and healing, it's just like, okay, not going to do that. even remember.
Yeah, exactly. Cuz Well, the problem is it's actually usability. This is actually really bad because it's like, oh, hey, wandering to Okay, the summon here. So the tiles text is immediately forgotten cuz it's covered up by a minion. And it's like, well, do do the rules say does that mean that the text is gone? Or because this just says heroes who end their turn here may have a drink. It doesn't Okay, well, can you go in the inn while monsters are there? You would think not, but but I mean, It could go either way. it doesn't say cuz like this one says if no heroes are here, well, that means Okay, boom, meaning that if you guys are here, that that doesn't happen. Yeah. Uh I will note this game builds up to a whole lot of nothing. And I'm And I'm going to go out and just say that once again, did any of you feel like you were a special character?
No. No. No. You didn't feel like a ranger and a rogue? I mean, not really. Especially not the rogue. You didn't feel like a fighter and a cleric? Yeah, but I didn't care. I really didn't feel like a rogue, so Yeah. Kind I mean, ranger I Yeah, I was a ranger. It's almost like loosely based. Hey, okay, what's a ranger? What's the bare minimum that a ranger does? Shoot a bow. We got it. Call it a day. It's We've been here 30 minutes. Let's just go home. Let's just go get shit-faced. Oh, the rogue? Uh-huh, we'll give her dodge. Got it. Fighter? We got nothing for him. Ah, he takes less damage. Yeah. And then cleric? Ah, he gets some meaningless [ __ ] Oh, bonus for beneficial. Yeah, spells. He gets an extra for that. have to hopefully get. Now, I'm assuming a lot of those spells probably do heal.
Um several. Yeah. I had the opportunity, but I never really get kind of good opportunity to use Honestly, the the only fun I had was Asmorai casting spells. Yeah. Like That that really messed us up and totally interrupted my movement. Right. Right. Like okay, doubles my minions. Boom. Now, I will say that that wasn't overly frustrating to be a victim of that. Okay. You just pull out this It's like, crap. Yeah. But it wasn't I've lost everything because the game is over. Uh Because I didn't have that much invested in in any particular movement. Right. I mean, some of them were fun. it got screwed up. Yeah. Okay. Like cat goes into a mountain, gets erupted on, and then, you know, almost dies. Uh Yeah, the the thunder struck just crashes down on someone, immediately kills them. Magma rain. Why I killed my own minions. I'm like, I don't care. I don't care. It's going to deal you guys all damage anyway and I'll boost it with another spell.
Um but even then, once more that comes out, it's just like, why? Why? I mean, yeah, I have actions that I can do, but I don't know. I feel like It just gives you more attacks, really. Yeah. I really don't like how the game ends. And for what they're going for, it's just This is the only guy. I don't like how the game plays and I don't like how it ends. Yeah. It's not like, oh, okay, well, now this time. I mean, they have an expansion coming out this year, which probably brings out a new villain. I don't care. I don't know. It brings It may not. Bring out more minions. It may have more heroes and more minions. Yeah, but I I think that the pacing of the game is its problem. Mhm. It's It's just It's slow. It's a grind. It's a slog. Like any other one versus many game, like the one that came out in last year was Dark Rituals, which actually had strategic like back and forth. Oh, okay, well, I'm going to attack you. Oh, man, do I want to defend? Yeah, I guess I'll spend some of my stamina, which lessens what I can do. And you know, the back and forth of everything that everyone can do, trying to complete an objective versus just the one objective that's this game is going to play out the exact same way every single time.
Yeah. Yeah. But the tiles will be a little bit different. Mhm. And the dice rolls. Sure. But I mean, probably on average, they will be the same. I don't know. And imagine if you guys didn't have all those reds. Yeah. It'd just be more minions out. Yeah. I don't know. I think I honestly I see what they were going for with the corruption, being able to bring out higher level minions. Um but I almost feel like that the tiles bring out enough. Yeah. That me just adding insult to injury and being like, oh, okay, I roll all of these dice. All right, I'm bringing out three these two level threes. that you can't kill anyway. What I was thinking this time let's try wiping out the minions mostly and then we stalled achieving the larger goal.
Right. time we tried to get the larger goal we got overrun by minions. Yeah. So I mean But again dying isn't like a big penalty. It's just a benefit for you. It almost just sounds like that there's no uh there's no right way for you guys to play cuz it's going to ultimately end up end up the same way. Mhm. Yeah, I mean I can't imagine right now a scenario where where the heroes would triumph. Yeah, because like if if you had stalled it out then all it would have done it would have given me more spells and then I would have gotten another item which I could have just gotten the flagon of mead which means I can heal. Mhm. It's like Or like we did last time, rushing to make sure you don't get strong. Yeah. Means we also don't get strong and then can't take you on. Yeah, exactly. Like I could have taken the Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim Grim How annoying is that going to be?
Yeah. So Yeah. I I don't get it. This game has a [ __ ] eight on Board Game Geek and I'm I Yeah. I can't think of why. Like Maybe we should play with them to figure out what if we're doing something fundamentally wrong. No, because we I verified No, I know the rules are all there. The mechanics are all there. There's no There's not enough strategy for that to be a factor. Which is interesting because the games that I tend to like for strategy like you think there's too much strategy. So for you to think there's nothing here means that there's really nothing here. Yeah. Um Yeah, it it's it's a slog. Um All right, I really got no I got nothing else. I got nothing else to talk about.
Um all right, on a scale of one to 10 we'll start with Brett. Um this play through would be a two. for the record, yeah, what did you give it the the first time? A six? Between a five and six. Okay. Um I'm I'm definitely lowering it to a four. Okay. Which feels a little high, but I don't want to say three. That's fair. Cat? Yeah, I'm all putting it at a three. Yeah. I mean, just knowing that the only good thing, and honestly, I think three might be a little too high just because we literally did not have a good thing to say about it unless it was about like the aesthetics. True. Like, but I'll keep it at a three. Um I definitely I I'm not going to give it a three because it's not frustrating. Like, I've played games that make me mad that they exist.
Uh Splendor. No, I'm kidding. Uh no. This game reminds me Uh do you remember Dice Settlers? Kind of. Oh, wow. I was going to stop I was hoping you'd say no cuz I'm like, right, cuz no one does. That game had nothing to it that I almost didn't want to give it a rating cuz it's just so blah. Like, uh no, [ __ ] it, it's a game. This is a game. They it it exists in our world. Uh that it's almost so blah that a five sound Every every rating I could give it sounds too high. Uh but it's not bad enough to for me to just be like, Yeah. [ __ ] this game. This is a two. Um but I I think there has to be a sweet spot.
Like, don't play this with five. Don't play it with two. Don't play it with three. Play it with four or whatever. Yeah. Uh but I almost also want to say that some of these characters aren't worth it. That you almost have to have Gwenevere for her horse to go scout. Sometimes. Like Cuz we get bogged down with The locks lead to dodge, yeah. I I don't know. The it's just there's a lot of cool characters here. Maybe the maid starts out with three. Maybe peop- maybe those people who are giving it an eight have the perfect sweet spot. Maybe they're role-playing. Someone's dressed they get their old, you know, old grandpa out of a home to play Mordecai. They stopped giving him his meds so he's really Yeah, so he's really out of it, but somehow he just whiz at at this [ __ ] role.
Uh they role-play all the characters and then they they [ __ ] play with three or four and it just zips on by and they get it. I I don't know. Um this is not the game for us. No. Uh I'm going to give it a four. I think it's a below-average game. Um the it would be a three, but I got to take everything into account the production quality. It's very good. It's there. Very good. Um so the one thing I do want to do real quick because that will actually determine um what if it if it does drop down to a three is how much this game was. Oh, yeah. Um because Oh, with this production quality $70.
Okay, that's not bad. All right, yeah. I'm I'm going to keep it at a four. That's not bad. A $70 game is is really for the deluxe edition. Yeah. Uh that's that's that's a pretty good pretty good pretty good price cuz I've definitely paid I've definitely paid paid higher for a similar type of game or less. So So I'm going to keep it at a four. So we got four Four. Four, three. All right. So that's our thoughts on Valor and Villainy. The name's cool. Uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.