A Game of Thrones: B'twixt Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about a game of thrones betwixt which is a three to six player bidding card game by fantasy flight games this one takes 60 to 90 minutes to play so the game is going to look somewhat like this when you set it up we have a bunch of different decks of cards here you've got the influence decks which is going to be your actions and the things you're going to bid with throughout the game you're going to have this ally deck here which are the characters that you're trying to gain influence over and add them to your council to get victory points and you're also going to have a bunch of characters that you yourself are going to represent from the song of ice and fire series such as you know the lannisters uh you've got the tyrells there you've got dora martell and daenerys targaryen as well as other characters that i haven't used in this particular setup there's euron greyjoy eddard stark tyrion lannister melissandre and jon snow now the game is going to take a number of times depending on the player count here so according to the sheet let's say we're playing a three player game we're gonna have uh three seasons and each season is going to consist of four rounds but of course you see if we've got six players we're only going to play two seasons but each of those seasons is going to consist of six rounds and that's going to change the kind of income of the cars you have in your hand because you are not going to refresh your hand until the season is over so you have to manage how you're going to use these cards quite carefully now nine of your cards are going to be from the communal influence deck here but one of those cards is going to be character specific so you can see here this new middle ground card is specific
to cersei lannister who i'm playing as and they are usually particularly powerful cards and have some kind of thematics hi to that character um i suppose we should talk about the aim of the game here so we're going to be as i said earlier aiming towards to get control of these characters that are going to come up randomly from this ally deck and this number here is going to be how much influence they're going to be worth in your council and this part down here is going to be some kind of specific rule that's going to be active during that round or some cars might have an effect that will take place once you win that card but before we talk about how the gameplay works we need to work out how the scoring works so the scoring in this game is quite unique or at least borrowed from a unique game called between two cities where you're always working with a neighbor and you don't have a personal individual score so for example cersei is always working with elena and always working with daenerys and between them they're going to have a council of cards which they're going to win and at the end of the game only your lowest council of your two is going to be your final score so again so cersei's going to work with daenerys is going to work with cersei and dorian dorian is going to work with elena and daenerys and elena is going to work with dorian and cersei so each round is going to consist of flipping a new character over and then the first player is going to have one or two options or everybody's got one of two options each of their turns now the first thing you can do is to kneel which is basically to pass and say you know you're not going to play any more cards or not play any cards at all if you don't want to but the other one is to play a card from your hand and
there's a lot of things you have to consider when playing these cards because not only do these cards have a value in the top left-hand corner here which will of course be your bid essentially of what of claiming that character and the other one is going to be the actual ability of the card itself so let's have a look at some of the cards here so you've got this counting coppers here which is worth six which is not too bad but this one means that after a winner after a leader wins the bid you may draw a card from the influence deck so this one gives you a good option of replenishing your hand you've got the rule decree here which means that and once this one's played there's no way that any other player can tamper with it which is a big part of this game there's quite a lot of take that and quite a lot of kind of um shafting people and being a bit nasty there's a contingency plan here which means that if you didn't win when playing this card down you get the card back into your hand you've got the pulling the strings one here which is not worth a tremendous amount of influence but it does mean that if you played the most amount of pulling the strings cards and somebody else or one of your neighbors wins that card that means they have to play it between you and that particular player so this one gives you a bit of control even if you don't win you've got the corruption here which simply moves a power token from any leaders council to that other council which we'll talk about in a second we've got this big game of thrones cards here which is worth a massive 11 but it has no special ability on it and you've got little ones here that's these little birds which means that you can add one power token from supply to the current ally um which is the um center card so if you're confident you're going to win a card and you can add these power tokens on them and these power tokens are going to be worth a
number of points ranging from one to three at the end of the game so i've advanced the game a few turns here and let's just say that cersei's just played her third card completing a total value of 15 and let's just say the next players aren't interested in raising their bids any further therefore they're gonna kneel and therefore discard any cars that they've bid with unless they have that contingency plan card which means they'll actually take it back into their hand so no one else is interested in bidding any further therefore they've all knelt and are out of the round so then cersei as the winner is going to take the card that's been bid for and place it in one of our councils let's just say two places in this one here and they're also going to draw an additional tile here randomly from the um from the bonus tokens which again will not be revealed until the end of the game and once a character's been claimed you're going to go to the next round by moving this marker down here passing the first player token refreshing your character so that you're still in the bid and then drawing the next ally from the deck which might be something like this where the shay character here will give you three influence points but when you claim her by winning that bid you're going to move an ally to shay's council from your other council to give you more manipulation to keep your your councils balanced as possible so the end of the game is going to look a bit more like this where a bunch of these allies have been claimed and placed in councils again you're going to calculate your lowest of your two councils and whoever's lowest is the highest of all the councils is going to be declared the winner if it's a tie then you'll go to your other council to see who's got the highest in that way so in this example
cersei lannister is the highest character because her worst council is stronger than everybody else's worst council so you can tell from the demo there that this game is very simple you just keep either putting a card down and using its ability or kneeling and going out of the round but where all the kind of fun and all the flavor lies is in the allied deck you know some of these allies are absolutely fascinating and in the of course the influence deck itself because you know not only the bidding value important but the actual ability of this card is very important as well so let's take a look at some more of these um ally abilities and see how these are going to change each round like this one here for example you know theon greyjoy each time you a leader plays a red card they can resolve its ability again so you've got a double strength red cards that round i mean that's gonna affect all the players so it's like everybody's singing from the same hymn sheet which makes every single ally feel massively different when it's the active character or even ones like um we've got samurai talia up here when after the first red green or purple card has played that round then the um then that's the only color of that type that can be played so you've got a real kind of um race to get these cards down and be the first person to play them because everyone else is going to get locked out of doing so or you've got like viserys targaryen here where you can move up to two player tokens from any council to his council and then move another ally from viserys's council to your other council so you've got lots of mitigation tools which you might really need and even trump the ability of the um influence value itself you know there might be a really strong character but
you're more interested in the ability that it can do and some more here like you've got barristan selmy where you can choose a leader and during the next round that leader must kneel as their first turn so you've got a lot of um control if you've got a threat on the board or on the table that you want to not compete with you this round um you've got ones like shea which i mentioned earlier you can move counts uh move a character to your other council or this one here like matt's raider you can actually place mad in another council and just give them negative points so again you're always not only worrying about your own council but worrying about other characters as well um so yeah there's tons of different characters here you've got a massive deck and each time you play the game a different formation is going to come out and you're going to see new characters the decision space in this game is a strange one because you do have a really solid amount of hand management here but the game is quite chaotic and there's a lot of unpredictability which you'd probably expect from a game of thrones game um but it's all about kind of knowing when you're going to go all in on a character you know are you going to get that big chunk of points by getting a particularly strong character or are you going to kind of go all in on the ability of a character but that means of course that you're going to massively diminish the strength of your hand for the remainder of the season because you only have this many cards to work with or perhaps you want to use the cards to make sure you've got a steady income of influenced cars going forward there are different tools you can use you know such as the contingency plans which means that even if you don't win you can get them back in your hand but sometimes you'll use them just to kind of rake up the bidding for the other players to make them get rid of more cars but if you end up winning it then you that's even more cards you're going
to lose from your from your hand and it's also a good interesting balancing act of keeping both your councils as strong as you can because you know you could have the strongest council in the world it doesn't matter if your other council is weak and all the other players are kind of doing the same thing so sometimes you can kind of sit back and let your team not teammate but semi teammate and boost the council for you and you can focus on the other one i'm not gonna sit here and pretend that this game is amazingly balanced it really is not you really do have to be on your toes and prepare for anything to happen and that is kind of leads into the decisions as well because you know sometimes like this it might be the last round of the season and all of a sudden i force all the other players to kneel and i win and then nobody else has any real control that they can do about that and you know normally that kind of thing i would really rub me the wrong way but because you know what you're getting into when you play this game it really does kind of add that tension of how you're going to manage your hands i think the time investment for this game is pretty much spot on really and the box does say 90 minutes so i do think that's probably only when you're playing with that full complement of six players if you're playing at three players it's probably gonna only gonna take around 45 minutes to play which feels just about right for me um i would say that the game does scale well as well you know three to six players is not the easiest play account because a lot of people do want to play games with two but of course you need that that third player for that council mechanism um and i think a lot of people would say this game does really shine out you know at least four players really but i don't have a problem playing it with um with three it does make it feel faster and i've had
pretty much just as much fun playing with that player account but if you're looking for a game that scales well and something isn't such a you know a party game you want to play six players and you want to play something a bit more meaty and a bit more cutthroat then you know this is a good option for that in a good amount of time additionally you are invested in the game when it's not actually your turn because you know even if you folded or you know knelt and you know other people are still bidding then you might even benefit from that because the players who are left to right might win that card and add it to your council so no you are still trying to on support your your neighbors even when you're not playing yourself i also think that the replayability of this game is rock solid because there are so many different cards in the game you know just a bunch of characters we talk about a bunch of them but there's a there's absolutely stacks of them and they all are completely unique and um work very differently and feel drastically differently as well um additionally you can of course play with the different characters yourself all of which come with their own little deck of cards you can add in which again are very thematic and add a lot of different abilities which you which almost feel you know so strong but because everybody's deck is as strong as the next then it doesn't really you know it doesn't really feel like um in balance or anything like that um additionally you can add in these blue cards as well which you can add at the end of the i think it's the second and the third season um which are really powerful benefits to just to ramp up the um the tension and to add more powerful cards into the fold as with a lot of bidding style games the interaction in this one is pretty ferocious and probably even more so than a lot of other building games out there because your hand is so
tight and you and another player or even several players get into a bidding war then that is going to have a not only a direct impact on each other because you're going to be probably gunning for each other trying to nullify your hands horrible take that cards getting involved but also you've got to be considered that all the other players are probably going to benefit from that because they're not the ones diminishing their hands and they're going to be in a stronger position to bid for future characters so everything you do in this game has some level of interaction because not only are you worrying about your councils and how they balance out working with your neighbors that way but also the card play and you know how you're going to manage your personal hand of cards throughout the season the production for this game is really good and all the cards are linen finished which is great you know nice to handle nice to shuffle and they're going to stand up to repeated plays um additionally the actual symbology and the layout of these cards is nice and clean you can see what all the different suits are quite clearly and i'm colorblind and i have no issue at all um and also the actual verbiage of how the cars are worded is nicely done because you know i played i played this game with people who normally don't like words on cards and they had no problem understanding all the kind of text and how it was written so that's that's a good touch and additionally the artwork on the character cards and even the influence cards themselves is absolutely stellar i'm pretty sure this is all recycled artwork from the living card game which you know understandably so why would you use it again if you have that in your library but yeah it has that proper a song of ice and fire feel to it all the characters look as they should and even then some so yeah i'm very happy with the production of this game your cards galore and all the characters look fantastic
okay so let's get into some final thoughts on a game of thrones betwixt so despite this game having so many ingredients that normally i'd run a mile from very swingy cars and take that cars that you can do nothing about things you have no idea was coming up and you couldn't plan for i always found myself this finding this game fun from start to finish always engaged always excited about what was going to come out next and i just love the anticipation and the excitement about what these characters do because each one does feel so different from the last and not only do you have to worry about the points of managing your councils but also how much that ability is going to affect you for better or for worse i love the bidding wars that you can get into with the other players because you do have such a tight amount of cards in your hand and you do have to kind of spread these accordingly depending on which part of the game you're in you know if you're in the first round and a strong card comes out you know am i willing to basically lay all my cards on the table here and leave myself without anything for the next ones which could be even better characters now i did stop and think you know is it my love for the ip you know my big george r martin fan um you know is there rose scented glasses but i have played this game with people who knew nothing about the series um books or tv series and they found it equally as enjoyable and even people who normally share the same concerns i do about take that cards and the sweetness they enjoyed it as well so there must be something they've got right here because i think you know what you're getting into when you're playing a game like this all those uh things that might affect you quite negatively are just kind of easier to swallow and they don't
leave you feeling disgruntled or anything which is quite a weird thing to achieve this is definitely the best implementation of this between two cities uh mechanism that i've seen and because there is so much manipulation you can gain throughout the game you know moving council council moving these power tokens around there's just a lot you can do to tinker with your councils and try and keep them balanced and mess with the other players additionally for a game to scale like this up to six players really well it's quite unusual you know if you have a regular six player group you probably find yourself quite often leaning towards party games this one is not a party game and it has a lot of things going on here a lot of things to mull over some good juicy decisions so i know these ip based games are generally tied with the same brush of being rushed out money grabs but this is not what this game is there's a lot of fun to be had here there's some good gameplay some really cool card interactions and some just longevity in the game and excitement that a lot of games don't tend to deliver so i really enjoyed this one i think it's a solid design and i'm one that i'm enjoying quite a lot yes it's not going to be for everybody you know particularly if you're not a fan of game of thrones um and you know some of the mechanisms are going to be quite jarring you know it's quite confrontational there's some take that cards in there there's some things that you can do nothing about at times but if you embrace that chaos you can get quite a lot of fun out of this one so that is my thoughts on a game of thrones betwixt don't overlook it it's a fun fun design