Skip to main content
Loading video...

Calimala Review - JonGetsGames

Transcript 30:37

welcome to jacket's games today I'll be reviewing at Kali mala this game was designed by Fabio LoBiondo and in it players take on the role of cloth merchants in Florence and they utilize an innovative action selection mechanic that allows them to get more bang for their buck depending on the amount of opponents that jump on and want to copy what they've already done as they play the game players will compete in numerous different areas from shipping cloth to various cities as well as building the beautiful cathedrals and Florence first I'll show you how the game plays in a little more detail and then I'll jump into my review now here in the middle of the table we have the main board for Kali mala and the first thing I'd like to show you is this 3x3 grid over here now these are all actions that you'll be taking throughout the game and it's worth knowing that all of the perimeter actions are shuffled up and randomly put out each game but the middle one is printed on and then up here we have the city council in each one of these tiles is also randomly put out at the beginning of each game next up we have this map over here which shows some of Europe and we are all in Florence right here but what this shows is that we can send a cloth overland to these three cities and by boat to these three over here and lastly up at the top we have these four buildings now these three are cathedrals that are getting built in Florence and we don't just make clots we're also going to be donating our resources to the construction of these cathedrals to help bolster up our prestige as a guild and lastly over here the city council it's already built but you can hang some art on its walls down here we can see that this is a three player game and each person has a player board and let's now talk about how it turn works and it's quite simple the starting player token is right here and

the starting player is going to take one of their action disks most likely one of their own color for the beginning of the game and they're gonna put an out on to this action grid when we look a little closer at this area we can see a 12 different circles each of which are between two of the nine actions and what you do is you place your disk down onto one of those whether or not it is empty or has somebody else's disk on it at the beginning of the game it will all be empty and one of the easiest things we could do is put down right here and the moment you put your disk down the first thing you do is activate both of the actions that are adjacent to that disk in any order you want now these two are very basic actions this one just says you can't gather a brick and this one says you gain a marble when we come back to the players board we can see a wood brick and mob warehouse they're all empty at the moment so in order to generate a brick simply take one of your cubes and you're gonna put it down into your warehouse and then same thing goes for the marble so these cubes are different based on where they are and with that the green player is done with their turn the next player clockwise might go here and the player after that may go over here and now it is once again that the green player is certain they can play one other action disks and again it can be either a one of their color or one of these white ones but I'll talk about the white ones in just a minute so now they have quite a few options they can go down onto one of these empty spots or on top of a spot that already has another player so in this case let's say they go down right over here in this case the first thing that happens is a we will get to evaluate both actions as normal but once we're done with our turn the blue player will then get to evaluate both of these actions as if they had just put their token down and if there was a third disc underneath

here they would also get to evaluate those again even if it was say our disc or the blue player's disc so first of all let's go ahead and gather these things up this is gonna get us a wood but this is gonna allow us to build something at the workshop gathering wood is easy we just take a cube and put it down here but when we go to the workshop we actually have three different things that we can build the first thing is we can build a boat and that will cost us two wood we can build a trading house as our second option 242 brick or our third thing is we can spend a wood and a brick in order to build another silk warehouse now if you look along the top here we only have one silk warehouse but we have two new locations and whenever you evaluate an action if you have the ability to do that action you must do that action so we don't actually have a choice we must spend our wood and our brick in order to build a new silk warehouse which we can put right up here and now as I mentioned before with our turnover the blue player would get to evaluate both of these actions at this point let's run through a couple more example turns so that I can explain the rest of these actions before we move on and the next one will be right down here now this action is gonna allow us to gather up some cloth and this one lets us send out a caravan with a single cloth to action you're gonna take one cube and put it down into each one of your cloth warehouses so the single action it generated to cloth for ourselves because we already built at this extra warehouse next up we have our caravan action and you'll notice this icon it matches these three cities out here on the map now the thing is you can only send cloth to one of these cities if you already have a trading house in that city and in fact for each Caravan action you can send one cloth from your

warehouses into that city so in this case we could take the two cloth we just generated and put them both down like that or if we had had two of these trading houses like this we could put both of them down here and if you remember you build a training house by spending two brick when you do the warehouse action but in this case we actually don't have any trading houses at all as we're evaluating this action which means we can't do anything with it well fortunately for us that there is this deck of cards over here and the way this works is whenever you do an action and you cannot do the action because maybe you're trying to gather bricks but you have 4 bricks in your warehouse already and you can't put a 5th one in or you're trying to do a caravan in action but you don't have any training houses or any soak to send well you'll simply drop the top card from the deck and it is gonna be an action that matches one of these in nine out here on the board in fact we started the game with one of these in this case a workshop tool and this is part of set up you get to draft these from a hand but I'm not going to talk about that but the way it goes with these action cards is you can spend as many of these as you want to at any point whenever you're taking actions so that means that you are not necessarily just gonna do the actions from your disk I could place something down and then spend this to generate a marble and then spend this to do a workshop action in between or before or after the main actions that I might be wanting to do on my turn so whenever you can't do an action you essentially get a random bonus action for later on in the game ok it's time for our next example turn and we go up here and this is gonna allow us to do a sailing action and a making art action for sailing we can come back to the map

and we notice that this icon matches these three city spots and this means that we can ship to these locations and the only way that you can ship is if you have built boats now the thing about boats is that they go down here into your own canal so if we add one boat we would put it right here and it's not associated with any one of these spots but whenever you do this shipping action then you get to deliver one silk for each one of these boats that you have and you can send those to any of the port cities so if we add all three of our votes deployed we could send a three silk to the single city or three different cities if we wanted to but once again in this case we don't have any boats built so for this action we just another one from the top of the deck and it looks like we get a make art action which is actually the other option that we did with our disks so let's go ahead and talk about that if we look back over to the left hand side of our board which is a cheat sheet for all of the nine actions we can see that we can spend one marble in order to make an art and we do have a marble which means we are forced to do this so this goes back into our supply and then we take a cube out of our supply and put it down into the art section on one of these four structures so in this case perhaps we would go ahead and put it right there let's now come back to the action grid for the final example and for this one let's use a white disc now you may have noticed that all three of the players have these white disks and that's because they are a neutral color and whenever you put these down you get a double activation so instead of just activating each thing if it's adjacent to the disc once in this case we could just do it twice and you could actually do it as in 1 2 3 4 or 1 2 3 4 or just staggering them back

and forth as much as you want and in this case we know how the brick works already that's gonna generate us 2 brick with this one white placement which we put down into our warehouse and then we finally get to do the contribute action in this case twice because of our white disk and if you look on the action you see some wood brick or marble this means that for each activation you're gonna take a wood brick or marble from at your warehouse and put it down into one of the available spots in these three cathedrals that are being built so in this case we have two brick so we can put both of them right here or who wanted to or we could split them up like that and like that if it made more sense for us with all of these actions now explained it's now time to talk about what happens when the stack of discus gets into its fourth level so I mentioned before that when you put a disk down you evaluate the top the second one and the third one but in this case we have four so we will evaluate the top three but we get down to the fourth it will not evaluate as an action instead we are gonna kick this out and put it down onto the next available scoring tile in the City Council so you always start at the top and on the left so we put it right here and immediately we would do a brick scoring evaluating it is easy and I've gone ahead and added a couple more cubes for this example you add up all of the cubes of each player in the brick line for all three of the cathedrals under construction and whoever has put the most cubes in is going to get three points these second-most cubes is going to get two points and the third most cubes is gonna get one point although you do have to add something so in this case the purple player did not put any in and they're not gonna get at that third-place point but we also notice that blue has two and we also have to soar in a tie in this case we come back

to the City Council over here and we count up the number of discs on the different scoring's as well as the cubes in the art area so if for instance we had had one cube we'd put one piece of art in the City Council then we would have one and the blue player would once again have one we would be tied again in which case we would ignore the arts and then see whoever has the most disks out here so in this case the blue player is winning the second tiebreaker or of course if I had not cheated there blue would easily win it because it would be more of their colored items in the City Hall then we do and so that means blue wins it they're gonna get one two three points we will get two and then of course purple would not get any points because they had no cubes in the brick areas when this disc went down once the scoring is completed you once again move on to the next players turn and as you can see there are a variety of different scoring options you might have some that are specific to cities like this as London and this says tois well that just means that you add up all of the cloth in London when that one scores or tois when that one specifically scores you also have situations where you have like this boat which is just you add up all of the cloth on all of the port cities and then you get the three points two points and one point just like before and then of course you have these specific cathedrals like this one right here that is this one right here and you would add up all of your cubes in the wood a brick marble and the art area and then once again see who has the most and score those three two and one points so players will continue taking turns around and around the table until one of two endgame conditions are met the first is every player will have spent all of their action discs and this is gonna vary depending on the player count in

the three player game you have 15 of these discs available to you and then in the 4 and 5 player game you have at les disques so the game will be a similar issue amount of actions total or the game will end at once all 15 of these scoring's have been evaluated at which point you will keep playing until you get back to the starting player token once the game has reached its end players will generate some endgame points the first is if the game ended because players used all of their disks and not because all of the scoring's happened then you will evaluate every one of the score rings in order so that every time play the game you will always score everything so in this case we would immediately score Lisbon and Santa Menotti oh and then Hamburg and then we go into the other end game scoring which involves this card right here which you may have noticed now there are ten of these cards in the game and at the very beginning of the game as part of setup you deal out two or three of these to each player depending on the player count and they're gonna choose one and have it face down in front of themselves all game along and depending on the player count you might also have one of these face up all game along as well so when you get to the end of the game you will put this one right up here and then everybody will reveal the cards that they've been holding and you're gonna put them up here as well these are not personal objectives they're just hidden information that you know and at this point you won't then evaluate each one of these but instead of getting three two and one point at like at normal with the scoring's each one of these is five points three points and one point and you will just evaluate them like normal using the same tiebreakers so it's just evaluating to see how many cubes are on this Cathedral this Cathedral as well as Lisbon and tois in this case and once you add up all of those extra victory points you

check to see who has the most and they're the winner let's now begin the review for Kali mala by starting off with a few positive points and the first of these has got to be discussing that innovative action selection mechanic you've got these nine seemingly simplistic actions in that grid like it might be and gather a wood or donate a brick or spend a marble to put an art out onto the board but the ramifications of figuring out where to put that one this down give you a wonderful variety of great decisions the first thing that you're considering is just well what do I need right now you know you don't want to go on to a spot that doesn't help you out in the slightest but the second thing to consider is what will this do for your opponents like if I really want this spot and I go there but it helps my opponents out even more than it helps me well then maybe I shouldn't do that maybe I should do something else perhaps I go on to a spot where I already am so that I get to do multiple activations of this particular combination that might be good for me right now but on top of all of these things is considering where do you think your opponents are gonna go in the future so you obviously don't want to help them out by putting your token down but if you think it's a really hot spot then you go there and maybe other people will go on top of you and in particular in the earlier parts of the game where there are somewhat clear board you really want to focus on figuring out where the spots are that will be activated multiple times because you want to get your tokens on to the bottom of four stack as quickly as possible to get them over into the City Council and it's gonna activate the scoring's but more importantly bolster your position to win tie breakers and ties are humongously important in this game there's a reason why the rule have rules have like six

layers of tie breakers or something crazy like that but the number one one is just have the most discs and art cubes down and the City Council area so you might actually find yourself going on to a spot that's okay for you but not great but you're going there because you can tell that everyone else is gonna want to go there multiple times and it will end up cashing that disk out so that you will get multiple activations for it you know up to a maximum of three but the ideal thing is three activations and discs over there on to the City Council the last thing of course you're considering is that you have two different types of disks you have your own color disks and then you have these white double activator disks and you have a varying amount of those based off of the player counts but these white disks are really potent if you put that down on to a spot where you already have some stuff you might have an explosive turn like I've seen it happened before where the somebody puts it down there they get two for the white and then they also have two more down there activating four times which could give just a ton of resources and cards and all that type of good stuff but the interesting thing with the white tokens is that you get the two activations and that's it it's a max of two and minimum of two whereas the color tokens are a minimum of one and a maximum of three which means they have a higher ceiling so it's just all these great decisions come into play like what token do I play and where do I play it and when do I play it all comes out of this seemingly simple grid of nine easy to evaluate actions for positive point number two I'd like to discuss the 15 different races that you are essentially competing in every time you played the game you've got all these little uh fifteen tokens you shuffle up

you put them out on the board and it'll provide you with a different race track so to speak for each play and now it's enjoyable trying to figure out how that's a random set of tokens is going to dictate the game as well as every single decision that you are making because if you look out there and you notice that maybe all over the port cities are evaluating really early in the game then you're gonna be much more motivated to try and pick up some wood and build some ships to get Syl to those as quickly as possible to get points for them when they score versus if all the ships are really late-game maybe you don't get ships out at all or just one or two versus a whole bunch of ships depending on where all these things are aligned in that overall grid and it's great the way that many of these spots well every single spot gets scored multiple times you know the cathedrals each one's gonna get scored for the most wood the most brick the most marble and art and then the cathedral itself you know of course the wood brick marble that's for all of the cathedrals but it means you put one brick down into a Cathedral and that is gonna help you scoring for the overall bricks as well as the cathedral itself and it means you can run multiple races at once which is good because 15 is a lot of different races to be running so you want to be able to synergize be as efficiently as possible to play as well as you can and as many of those as possible and it's of course good to win these but I've also seen players be very successful kind of streamlining and just getting a lot of second place finishes as opposed to another player who maybe gets a couple first places and then doesn't even score and some of the other ones so you definitely want to balance all these together and I think it's just a wonderful mechanic just having all of

those different things that you're gonna score and having them shuffled up it works really well compositive number three let's now discuss the pacing and overall length of the game and why I think both of these are spot-on when it comes to the pacing it starts out nice and slow you know you're putting it token out then you're putting another token out things are kind of trickling up maybe one particular spot is very good so on the fourth or fifth round a single scoring happens but you will likely usually be well over the halfway point on before you get a significant number of these activations happening and near the end of the game you can't not activate like almost every single spot is maxed out at three disks so no matter what you want to do you're gonna go down and it's gonna initiate a scoring which means you have a lot of time to prepare in the early game you know things are nice and slow but at the end of the game when things are consequential and hurried and fast you you don't like you have to just do the best you can another scoring happens do the best you can adjust it races through maybe three scoring's will happen before your next turn and it's just something you have to deal with it and I think it's a great ramp up of pacing it really works especially when you consider how short this game is like I was expecting a 90 minute experience and what I got was a 60 minute experience three player game I played was definitely under sixty minutes even and there's just a lot of bang for your buck when it comes to the amount of time I guess a bang for your minutes in this case like it's definitely a quicker game than I expected but that was not a problem in fact it was a very pleasant surprise and how satisfying and engaging and deep the game is for its 60 or so min a play time alright next up let's

talk about a couple neutral points and the first of these is the card draw mechanic now if you remember this is every time you do an activation and you do not have the ability to activate it you draw a random card from the top of the deck put it into your hand and it is a action that you can do at any point in the future when you are doing other actions and it is essentially a random action it's any one of benign actions that are printed on the board it's like the game is letting you Bank an action like it's like a raincheck it's like oh well you couldn't do that now take a random one and hopefully you can do something with it later and from my personal perspective I think this is a brilliant mechanic I almost put this in as a positive point because I think that it allows you to put yourself in situations where you get a bunch of activations where you can't actually get stuff because you intentionally want to mine down into that card deck to try and get something that really works for you and it allows you because it's very unrestrictive to have humongous terms and by unrestrictive I mean you could play as many cards as you want your turn and you can hold as many cards as you want there's no hand limit so you're someone sent device to get a big hand and then you will occasionally have a turn where you're like okay I do this and this and this and this and this and this and those are just really satisfying turns but the flip side of this and the reason why this is a neutral point is because I have also seen this aggravate people you know this is card drawn luck it's random it's from the top of the deck and if you have no trade houses and you keep drawing the caravan action into your hand that is going to be aggravating and to a certain extent my perspective is this forces tactics onto the players it says well if you keep drawing caravans maybe you

should build some trade houses you know that's the game forcing you out of your comfort zone you know maybe you are playing the game you're like well I see the different scoring's and I you know based off of how it goes I think I'm just gonna go with ships not really worried about trade houses but I keep drawing these cargo cards well you know what let's get a trade house or two bill because I have the to do that in playing these cards first of all people won't expect it I hid one game where Jessica actually played for shipping cards at once she had this hand of like seven cards four of them were shipping she had a single ship but she shipped four times with it he caught everybody by surprise and she made a good amount of points with that action and she only built that ship because she kept drawing those ship cards and to a certain extent you can lament the fact that you're just having bad card draw luck but on the other side I like the game pushing players towards actually needed to deal with the luck then they got but that being said you can win or lose this game on the luck of the draw the first game I played I lost because my opponent pulled the one out of nine cards that would allow them to do a thing on their last turn and so that is something you need to keep in mind and why it's ultimately a neutral I think this will turn some people off although for me I think it is a wonderful addition to the game next up we have a neutral number two and for this one I'd like to talk about the artistic aesthetic of this game it really seems like the design directive here was make this game look like the epitome of all things euro you've got this big board it's got like eight different shades of brown on it you've got kind of a hand-drawn map you've got different cubes and disks in various colors and it really does feel comfortable to me like

I play a lot of Euro games and I think this is a great representation of an artist that of a euro art aesthetic like it works like the the colors they all pop off the board with the cubes of the disks because the board is kind of so drab looking you know it's well done but just a bunch of brown but it feels like that was intentional so that the vibrant cubes and disks pop off and you're easy it's easy to analyze them but all that being said if you're somebody who is used to more thematic games with vibrant illustrations and you're throwing a lot of dice around and then you've walked by a table of people playing calling mullet you might be shocked as to why everybody isn't asleep just based off of the art aesthetic that's going on here so it definitely seems like this one is playing towards its base and I think it works I do like how the game looks moving on we now have a the negative section and I just have one to talk about here and this is gonna sound like a little bit of a nitpick but hear me out so we have these end games scoring cards that are hidden everybody is going to get two of them at the beginning of the game they're gonna choose one discard the other and when the game is over you reveal all of them and everybody scores ease so they are public objectives but you have some hidden information as to what is going to be scoring in the issue that I have is that not all of these cards feel like they are created equal now every single one of them score is the same it's five points for the person as the most in that hidden scoring three points for the second and one point for the third the problem is that for some of these they are well for for them in particular they are the cathedral areas well three of them are cathedrals one is for the city council and if you pick a cathedral then that Cathedral is going

to score five times you have the cathedral scoring you've got marble wood brick and art scoring so that's five different times that you have a reason to be putting a cube down into that Cathedral versus if maybe you pick up one of the other six cards which are the three port cities or the three inland trading cities those only score twice these school were once for the city itself and then once for either all ships or all caravans and that's it so that means it's a lot harder to sneak cubes into these cities to maintain control and depending on how with the 15 tokens come out at the beginning of the game you might really find yourself in a bind like you know obviously it's good to win those things so maybe you tried to go hard on them early to take first place and then just leave it with first place until the end of the game because nobody suspects a thing but that's not always how these things are going to work themselves out and it's very hard to disguise that you have one of these port or trading cities versus the cathedrals you know we had a game where the shipping had already scored and the actual city had already scored and one of my opponents kind of slyly tried to sneak a qubit into that city hoping nobody would notice and I saw that and immediately knew what their hidden scoring information was and you know they knew that they were broadcasting that they were hoping that nobody would notice but for me I had one of the cathedrals so it was so easy to maintain control in that one spot and not have it look as obvious because it just looked like hey I'm just trying to win the art thing you know hey look I'm just trying to win the would one and you know I'm of course not trying to dominate it because I don't want it to be too obvious and also you don't want to be too inefficient with your cubes but you know

you have these ten different objectives and it just it's a bit of a bummer to me that four of them just feel better than the other six and you know if I get two of these in my hand and one of them is a building one of the city it's just it's easy for me I'm just gonna take one of the cathedrals and I wish the game had been designed in such a way that it was not so hard to potentially this guy's you trying to take over one of those other cities so again it feels like a nitpick but honestly it also kind of feels like a flat to me so that's honestly the only problem I found with this game up next let's talk about the variability for Kali mala and I think then it's pretty much what I expected going in you don't have anything new swapped in around from game to game you always have those same set of actions you always have those same races the competitions that you're doing but just the act of shuffling up the actions and shuffling up those competitions is gonna make one game play pretty different for the next and then of course you have the hidden information of what did the secret public goals are gonna be at the end which is going to suddenly dictate how you played this game to the next like if you keep one of the trading cities maybe you go a little bit harder on trying to get trade houses out because winning one of those is five victory points and five is a lot in this game so yeah I've been quite pleased with the variability of this game I don't think it's exceptionally huge but it's definitely as much as I would have expected and it has made the game feel different from one plate to the next when it comes to player counts Kali mala supports three to five players which in and of itself is a little bit unusual because most games support two players specifically euro games so I haven't even heard of a variant for two but I can't say that I

played three four and five and I think that four player is best the three player game was great honestly the only issue with it compared to the four player game is that everybody can kind of score for everything because whenever you score any of those competitions it does first second and third so that means in a three player game all you need is one cube anywhere to get that kind of free one victory point versus a four player game you have to compete like even one cube isn't necessarily gonna be enough one person is gonna be left out of every single one of the scoring's and I think that's why that is the ideal way to play the game I did play a 5 player game and it worked it was fine it was pretty darn chaotic though and having four different actions before your next turn means especially at the late-game when things really take off that might be like three or four scoring's before you have another turn and you just you don't have as much control so I don't think I necessarily soup recommend the five player game like it worked I don't think you should avoid it but four player is absolutely the sweet spot and the place where you should play this game the most and it did work just fine I three I don't really see a problem with three at all so three and four are the best ways to play this one four in particular in conclusion I've played Kali mala three times at this point and this game has really impressed me in particular the three and four player game that I played I really enjoyed those experiences and I went into this game expecting it to be okay I was definitely intrigued to see how that action selection mechanism was going to work but I was a bit hesitant about the 15 different competitions that you'll be running because in general I don't really love games that are heavy

on area majority and just having more than your opponents and that is all that this game is it's just 15 competitions of trying to have it more than your opponents but an interesting thing happens here where when you have so many of these competitions and you have some of them happen early and you have others that you could plan for pretty much the whole game it makes each one feel less impactful less important and less stressful and realistically this is a marathon game where you're trying to do as good as you can over a broad stretch of 15 different competitions so you don't really sweat too bad when you were in a really good spot and somebody just kind of totally wiped you out of that location well maybe you lost a point or two and you might lose the game by a point or two but it just doesn't feel as consequential and mean and I think that's why I don't like area majority games in general but for this one it is definitely won me over in fact I am not just tolerating that aspect to the game I think it is a really great aspect of the game it adds a lot of fun a lot of great decisions for me a person who doesn't generally like that I think part of it is also the multiple ways in which a single qubit can get scored you know depending on where it is it will get bit score between two and five different times which means you really need to think about the impact and the efficiency of these cubes as you're putting them down and then when it comes to the action selection I just think it's brilliant I think it works so well it's such a great idea where it has this a worker placement vine but it is it really it's action selection because you put your worker down but then other people can go on top of it and they are disincentivize to do that because it helps you out but if they just need to do a thing well then they're gonna do it and it's great getting stuff when it's

not your turn and in Kali mala if you play things right you are constantly getting stuff when it's not your turn you're playing on other people's turns which makes downtime much less of a problem especially at the higher player counts you know it might be a little bit til he comes back to you and there can be some analysis process especially on the last couple terms of this game I've seen like the last action take like many minutes as somebody processes all of the ramifications of where the single disc is gonna go down but then they put that down and then maybe you get to jump in there as well so I don't think that the downtime is this is necessarily a problem and a big part of that is jumping in on other people's turns so yeah in general this game has really impressed me I think it looks very comfortably euro way out in the table and I have just enjoyed my experiences with this game I think it has the feeling of a bit of a classic like you know the mechanics themselves are very streamlined it's an elegant game everything kind of feeds back in on itself you know with the actions kicking a discount on to the scoring's and when you teach this game there's kind of a moment where you go and that's it so let's start playing and everyone's like oh that's it okay well let's go and then and they dive into it and they find that there is some wonderful complexity and depth here even though it is just a series of rather simple things that just work really well too with each other so yes I heartily recommend this game I think I think it's wonderful and I hope it gets a broader distribution I'm not sure how available it is in general because again I did pick this up from Germany and essence peel but if you have a chance to give this one a shot I hardly recommend you give it a go as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer

level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash junkets Games and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching

Progress saved