Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arborea - Core Loop and Review

Transcript 17:08

you might just look at a photograph of arboria and think oh whoa there's a lot going on here and you wouldn't be wrong there's a lot going on in this board game but in this video I can teach the entire game in about 10 minutes I'll give you reasons for and against the game and we'll summarize its profile in terms of its design its Artistry engagement strategy and complexity this is arboria at first glance it can seem pretty overwhelming so to teach this game we're going to start by narrowing our Focus to a very simple example turn there are four steps step one I can decide to advance a pilgrimage track or place a villager advancing a track only makes sense after a villager is placed so we'll do that there are four locations to choose from but don't worry about what they do just yet I'll place my villager on this one and receive a special bonus which is an increase on this track I don't want to get diverted into explaining what this means yet but later in this explanation you'll understand the significance of this bonus you'll notice I can pay a price to repeat this action which I will not do in step two you might expect that I would use the Villager I just placed but actually when activating a villager you can only activate one that has been removed from a track on a previous turn so let's activate him now activation means moving the Villager down the trail and activating all icons at this time we're going to look at a few elements of the game in Greater detail first I attract a mush frog arboria is about

regenerating the environment and repopulating it with fantastic creatures however unlike most games where components are taken from a supply players must first create a supply by attracting the creatures this mush frog will be added to the board I'll earn the bonus and now this mush frog is available for any player to add to their own environment attracting animals also advances the sun marker this is how we'll identify when the game is over I've set up a three-player game so we are approxim halfway done next I'm going to regenerate a biome in this case it is the green resource and it's going to happen twice along this Trail let's look at the biome Reserve just like the supply of creatures are shared by all players the biomes represent shared resources so to generate the green resource I simply increase the top marker I'll show you what the bottom marker does in just a minute last I'll earn Sage rewards I can receive a reward if I've given a gift to the sage and every track has its own Sage as you can see by this marker I've given one gift so I'll earn one reward had I given two or three gifts I would earn just as many rewards but they must all be different this icon represents inviting a creature since I just attracted that mush frog let's choose him I'll get a bonus for doing this and I'll add it to my invited creatures area I'd like to point out something else there's another bonus here that might be a better move for me but I don't want to explain it just yet just make note of the space and later when I explain more about strategy we can understand why this might be a better move once I've reached the end of my pilgrimage my worker is returned to

my player board there are actually three types of villagers in arboria Young Veterans and Elders the difference between the three types will be made clear as I finish this turn the bottom of my board is for workers who are available to be used one difference between workers is that The Young and the veterans the smaller workers need to be trained before they're Reed by contrast Elders are always ready this worker is a veteran so it'll go back here until it is ready again that is one activated villager as you can see by the plade I can activate up to two villagers and pay a price to activate a third but I choose not to in step three I can complete an ecosystem card ecosystem cards are in a common Supply like the creatures I haven't shown you the action that's used to draft these cards but earlier in the game I drafted this card I can complete it if I spend the biome resources I'm going to need more of the green and red resources to do this or I could use water which serves as a wild but in any case the needed resources aren't available so I can't do this now in step four this is the last step and doesn't involve any choices rather this is more like a cleanup phase the first step is to update the biome Reserve remember the green resource I generated earlier I didn't end up using that resource so as compensation for my contribution to the environment I'll receive victory points that's what this bottom marker is for I receive the indicated points for each resource in this case six points it's now time to advance tracks there's two things things to be aware of first tracks Advance a different amount based on the type of

worker simply said veterans or white workers are the only workers that Advance twice the two tracks that have my workers on them aren't veterans though so these tracks will advance one space the second thing you must know is that the advancement of a track is the only time a worker can hop off onto a trail head this decision is made in the order of the players on the track so on this track I will stay but blue will jump off in this track red will stay stay and I will also stay the advantage of staying is that later Trails will provide more events than closer Trails so at this point the complexity of the board should become more clear the reason the board is so busy is because each track leads to two sides and each side has multiple Trail heads the differences between these Trail heads aren't really that complicated for example if you compare the trail that I used on this turn with the next one the only difference is that I would have attracted a grimster instead of a mush frog and generated an extra resource my turn is now done however while other players take their turns I must place any completed ecosystem cards and invited creatures I'm allowed to do this now because generally speaking nothing that an opponent does should influence me and neither will my choice influence them this is a good time to talk about scoring you've already seen that I was able to earn six points by generating the green resource and leaving it available to other players another major scoring mechanic is the placement of creatures my player age shows me how all the creatures are scor scored generally you can earn more points by placing creatures adjacent to biomes of their

matching color but it's also important to note that some creatures score by being in the same row or column as other creatures the mush frog is simple three points per pink resource so this placement is worth six points it's worth instructing you on some of the restrictions I can't place the mush frog if it isn't completely surrounded by a biome so this is illegal however a creature is not required to be in a position that has its specified resource so had this been the situation it would have been a legal move just not worth any points a creature can't be directly adjacent to another creature which is why I put my mush frog here and not here though I don't have a completed ecosystem card to place right now I'd also like to point out that an ecosystem card can be placed anywhere in this grid even overlapping other cards and even partially underlying a creature so as an example if on a later turn I was placing this card I would be allowed to place it under the mush frog and therefore increase its point value value now while we prepare for the next turn let's look at the game elements we haven't seen yet this is the spirit track spirit is the resource that gets spent to perform extra actions it gets replenished by attracting animals and building environment cards it'll also cause you to lose or gain points at the end of the game let's look at all the actions now the two tracks at the bottom of the board are very similar both tracks generate resources and both tracks attract creatures they differ only in the type and Sage bonuses the track in the top left corner is the most effective way to train your villagers and invite creatures this action is one

way to give a gift to a sage this action allows you to place another villager on the same turn usually you have to pay Spirit points to place a second villager so doing it for free can be pretty powerful the upper right track is where you can take cards from the display or generate the water biome it also has another action for placing a free villager or giving a gift finally let's talk about in-game scoring you already saw how you can score points during the game by generating resources you also saw how creatures score at the end of the game these two mechanics are a constant in every game but the one I'm about to show you is variable at setup four tokens are dealt at the top of these tracks these are multipliers for various objectives you can pursue in this game the objectives are Baron biomes Sage gifs water biomes and mush frogs and antler worms if you look at my player board I already have four Baron biomes and I can probably build more before the game is over remember the bonus I didn't take earlier if I had taken this bonus instead of the mush frog I could have further increased my multiplier for at least four more endgame points so maybe I didn't need that mush frog so badly now let's look at our next turn in the game to better understand strategy at the end of the blue player turn this track is advancing red is getting off but I'm in no rush so again I will stay it's Red's turn next now it's my turn again and the state of the board has changed a little bit bit so it can be helpful by start by considering the available biomes there's two red coral one green weed and a blue

water if I use the water as a green then I would only need one more red and one more green to finish this card I could pull it off like this I could place a villager on this track pay three Spirit to advance the track and immediately hop off I could then generate one weed and use my sage reward to generate one red this would work but I think it's sure excited I have a better idea I'm going to go here and move up on the yellow track as a bonus I'm going to pay the spirit to advance the track and then I'm going to hop off with both villagers for the activation phase I'll activate this villager first I can give a gift to any Sage but I'm going to choose this Sage below I'll then invite two creatures and for my sage bonus I'm going to place another villager on this track of course now I'm going to move up on the red track which by the way vindicates the mush frog I took earlier activating the second villager I'll train one young and for my sage reward I'll take this ecosystem card now I'll use two pink and one blue to complete this card the bonus is a trained veteran and a spirit point for the last step I have no biomes to resolve but this track will advance twice PR is I have two villagers each worth one step and yes once again I'm going to stay on having

concluded my turn I'll add this card and both creatures and later in the game when this card is completed should I wish to I could place it underneath this creature to increase its point value here are what I see as a few Pros about arboria one I love that every person's turn provides every other player a chance to make a decision whether they want to hop off those tracks as they move secondly I love that the game motivates you to pay attention to what people are doing because if you can predict which track they'll use you can also get an idea of which tracks will advance faster and that informs your own decision- making I love that third this is a game that rewards you for planning and resourcefulness again it comes back to those time tracks something you do several turns earlier is going to pay off down the line fourth this game oozes strategic twist and turns you can start the game thinking that you're going to be focusing on one column of scoring and maybe one strategy but as the game is played and as you see how your opponents are playing you need to stay flexible and then finally while the game has so much going on so much that may seem like a distraction I find that as I play it more and more I'm learning to see through the fog and identify those things worth focusing on and that especially for me is the attractive quality of this game this is a very difficult game to master and every time I play it I'm enjoying uh getting better at it and then for the cons despite what

I called attractive about the game it is undeniably overwhelming there are so many mechanics let's see if we can count them so you've got time tracks different worker types shared resources the question of do you take resources or do you use them for victory points you've got card drafting for the ecosystem cards you've got Victory Point multiplier tracks and and variable scoring there's card and tile placement and then on top of that you've got creature placement there's Sage gifts which are essentially upgrading an action which actions do you want to upgrade and then after you've upgraded the actions you still have the choice of which reward do you take every time you take that action and then finally you always have to ask yourself do you want to pay Spirit in order to perform an extra action so that's 11 mechanics and all of these decisions are non-trivial whether or not you're going to like this game is really going to depend heavily on how you can handle so much going on this is a point solid game the score markers go up to 399 points so what that means is that essentially there's so many ways to make points that points kind of start to lose their value a little bit it's like well there's just points everywhere and then thematically I call this game A's and B's which is that all of the resources that you're trading is pretty meaningless I mean it's so abstract so I call that A's and B's and then finally this is the only complaint about the game that actually bothers me everything else I'm willing to overlook but uh there's very little luck in this game there's no dice rolling to resolve anything the only thing in the entire game that involves

an element of luck is that ecosystem card draw and before you take cards you have the option of refreshing all of those decks whenever you have a game that takes this much effort to play to have a decision that boils down to luck is a disappointment for me you know you could refresh it and you get like the best card ever and it's not because you did any planning at all you just got lucky I don't like that so to summarize let's look at this game's profile starting with the game's design what is the experience of this game designed to be about I think this is a very mechanically driven game the one element of theme that I think uh comes out very clearly in game play is that of everything being shared you really are working in an environment here because the resources that get generated are for everybody I'd say that this game because of that time track being Advanced by your opponents it has a moderate degree of interaction uh there is some potential for you to have some table talk and try to compel one of your opponents to join you on a track like hey you know get on this track because if we advance it may you know maybe it'd be good for you and me but in practice what I find is that rather than talking with my opponents about what I think they should do I kind of just get bogged down on planning my own turn for Artistry I'd like to point out that this is the kickstarter edition of the game with the kickstarter there are a few wooden components that are included only in this Edition the sun markers and the

player markers have custom design printed on them whereas in the in the retail Edition it's just going to be little wooden tokens without any design on that however with Alat games their Kickstarter uh editions don't have as much premium uh comp opponents it's more about expansions mini expansions that are included in the game which I did not show in this video you saw most of what just the base game looks like so what you see for the most part is going to look like what the retail Edition looks like I think it's a beautiful world that they've created in this colorful track some people might say that it's distracting that there's too much going on it's not focused enough on you know what you're supposed to do rather there's all this kind of decorative Trails I think it's really quite beautiful especially when you get accustomed to interpreting how to read that board and then for strategy and complexity this game is way over on the far extreme the only thing that it scores higher on in strategy is probably complexity and that's only because I really really hate the card refresh uh I think that adds an unnecessary element of luck but absolutely going to be a heavy heavy game for you at the end of the day I personally love this game because I'm a big fan of heavy games that have a degree of interaction still my only obstacle with games like this is that it can be difficult to get it on the table because it's a challenging game to learn and play you've got to find the right group for this game that

is my review of arboria thank you for watching this video and a special thank you to my patrons for supporting this channel if you would like to be involved in the conversation on Discord talking about the games what's coming up and my opinion on games even games that I don't review on the YouTube channel you should consider becoming a patreon member of course there are links in the description thank you so much for watching I'll see you next time bye-bye

Progress saved