Ponzi Scheme - First Play Review
Transcript
Hi there. I'm Jonathan with Getting Games, and this is my first play review for Ponzi Scheme. In this video, I'll be giving you an overview of what the game is like to play at a high level, and then I'll be talking about what my thoughts are on this game after I played it the first time. Now, what you're going to see here is a segment that was recorded for the Patreon supporters of the channel, and you can learn more about how you can join in on that by going to gettinggames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, maybe you've played it in the past, then please leave that as a comment down below. Also, if you enjoyed the video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down there. Okay, let's talk about the game. This game came out in 2015, and I vaguely remember hearing about it back then, and just slowly over the course of the last 10 or 11 years or so, I have friends who played this one and enjoyed it, and I've been curious about it. The idea of Ponzi schemes is kind of fascinating as long as you don't get your finances ruined by it. It's the concept of I'm going to take your money, and I'm going to pay you out a strangely high interest rate, probably more than it should be, and then, in order to afford being able to do that, I need more people to invest in my fund. So, I essentially use new investments to pay off the interest on my previous investments, and it's all great until it all comes tumbling down, and then, you know, the new people don't get their money back because it's already been spent. So, that is what this game is trying to essentially simulate, and this is what it looks like on the table.
I actually played this one online, so I'm going to be using this image to show the the game off. This is how I played it. And let's dig into an overview. This is not going to be all the rules. I'm going to be skipping over some stuff, maybe even some phases, but this is a high-level overview. So, in this game, you're going to go through a series of rounds, and as soon as anybody can't afford their payments, the game ends immediately, and you score up points, and the people with the most points wins, but the people who could not afford, well, they they lose. They can't win the game. So, you're going to go through these rounds, and you're going to go through various steps. And the first thing that you're going to do is acquire a new uh funding tile. Essentially, different industries, I guess, or funding indexes. And once you take it, you put it in front of you, and then you count the number of that type that you have already. So, I am purple. Let's say I took one of these reds, and I put it down here. I now have two of these reds. So, then I look over here, and I have to fund the acquisition of that. And since it's my second red, I have to take from the second row. If it was my first red, I take from the first row. If it was my third red, I take from the bottom-most row. And these are sorted by how skewed their payouts are.
So, as soon as I take one of these, let's pretend that I took this red and grabbed this one from the second row. It's going to give me 56 bucks immediately. That's awesome. It's free money. Everything is awesome. But I also have to take this tile and put it onto the three spot on this hexagonal tile, which is essentially a timing clock in front of me. And once three rounds have gone by, or maybe less than three rounds, once this arrow goes clockwise and points towards that tile, I have to pay $81. That is obviously a lot more than $56, and that's what this percentage has to do with. So, the more you take things that you already have, the the worse, the more skewed the payouts essentially are compared to what you get versus what you'll have to pay in the future. You know, if that future comes, maybe somebody will lose and run out of their money before you have to pay off that $140. Well, that'd be great for you.
Hopefully, that happens if you have to take this. The reason you want these is because this is the primary way you score points at the end of the game. I looked through the rulebook, and apparently we were playing with an advanced um not variant, but version of the rules, where you can buy victory point tiles, and you can score these at the end of the game when your money's worth nothing. So, over here, you can see that if you have two of a tile, it's worth three points at the end of the game. If you have three of a tile, it's worth six points. So, having more tiles is good, which is why you have to take you know, steeper and more worrisome investments in order to make this happen. Now, over here, it shows that you could have four or five or even more of a kind, but you can't actually take another tile in addition to three because the third tile takes you to the bottom row. Well, with that in mind, you move into the one of the next steps, where you do a clandestine trade with somebody, or you could spend money to buy one of these victory point tokens.
Now, in this game, nobody bought the victory point tokens. We just did the trades. And the way this works is again, let's say I am purple, and I have this yellow right here, and I can see that Marcus would like this yellow. That would be a third yellow. That would be an increase of three victory points, which is pretty good considering I tied for the win and lost on the tiebreaker six. I'm sure this could be skewed all over the place, but this is a very low score scoring game. So, I might initiate a trade for yellow with Marcus. Now, what I do is I take a certain amount of money, and it could be any amount of money that I have. I put it in a little envelope, and I hand it over to Marcus, and Marcus looks at it in secret. And they could do one of two things. They could either take the money and not show anybody else how much money it was, and then give them me one of the yellows, so I just bought it for that price. Or, Marcus could take that same amount of money, put it into the envelope, again, not showing anybody, and then pass that back to me and take this yellow. So, essentially, you are price setting. You are saying, I am willing to sell my token for this, but also, I'm willing to buy my token for this. And this is a huge part of the game. This is how you can get more than three of these tokens, and it is really strange to put your mind into.
Normally, when you're playing economic games, especially games that like, this doesn't have auctions, but games that might have auctions or markets, you know, you're spending money to get things hopefully to make points. Generally, you can get a sense of the meta. Like, a lot of these games, things can start cheap, and as people get more and more money, then people spend more and more money. Well, in this game, you never know what the meta is. There is no meta because it's clandestine. Like, if I passed $20 over for this yellow, and you take it or not, I've no idea what the next person is offering. Like, let's say I'm done, and the next person goes, and they make a trade, and somebody also buys that. Did they just buy it for 10? Did they just buy it for 40? Who knows? It's completely unknown, except for unless you're one of those people in that, but you can't get a sense of what other people are are spending until they potentially trade with you, which may or may not happen. It's just really peculiar.
Then, I think somebody gets to knock one of these tiles away, and you refill. And if there's a number of these blue tiles, I guess bear market tiles, on the the board equal to the player count, then there's a market crash. When this happens, everybody has to get rid of one of their tokens from the one they have the most of. So, essentially, they're going to lose as many points as possible by losing that one token. And then, everyone is always going to move their timer once, but if there's a market crash, you move the timer twice. So, this is why it might be three or less turns, depending on, you know, how many of these bear cards are being taken. If people are avoiding these because they might not be a great investment, then that market crash is going to be happening sooner rather than later. Well, maybe you have, you know, three or four of a kind in one of these. You really don't want a crash to happen because that fourth one is worth so many points to you. Maybe you start taking these so that it's less likely that there's a market crash. But of course, that means you're taking on even more lopsided investments that you might have to pay out at some point in the future.
So, that's essentially the game. You should hopefully have an idea of how this leans into the Ponzi Scheme mentality because you get this funding. That's awesome. But then this ticks forward. And as soon as it hits that spot, you have to pay the money. Like, as you could see right here, this has a five on it. So, I had five rounds, or maybe less with the crashes, until I had to pay this off. I got $48, but I had to pay $111. You could see how these will stack up as well over here. These happened to all get stacked on top of each other. Each time one of these pays, you move them forward the same amount of time. So, they're, you know, on a recurring calendar. But this person has to pay 61 + 12 + 13, which is of course less than this 111. I think later on in the game, I had multiple stacked up on this slot, and I was really getting worried, and then the game ended because somebody went bankrupt. And that person had the most tokens because they kept receiving offers, and they would buy. They'd give the money and take it back, but money is hidden in this game.
So, you're watching them taking funding. I think it was this player. You're watching them taking funding. You're watching them try to get money that they will then use to pay off the upcoming interest payments that are are coming. But of course, the money they just got is going to have even more interest payments that they'll have to do in the future. And everybody's starting to think like, they've got to be running out of money, right? So, people are starting to trade with them more often, hoping to like get a steal because maybe they're desperate, and they're willing to take a small amount of money to offload one of these so that maybe they're slightly more likely to win. It was really peculiar. Then the game ended, and like I said, I lost on the tiebreaker. It was super close with a score of six. And I am fascinated by this game. I'm not sure how much I actually played the game. It was definitely an experience, like a bit of a roller coaster as things went on.
I I witnessed things happen. I participated in things happening. I was putting out, you know, bids essentially with this trading, and sometimes people took it, sometimes people didn't. And I was just like so bewildered as to whether or not I was doing well. I had like I tied for the win, so I guess I was doing relatively well there at the end. It was fascinating from like a simulation perspective. It absolutely puts you into that mindset of um how do I juggle all of these debts? Well, I'll take on more debt, and then deal with that later. And it just gets worse and worse and worse, and then you're just hoping that you are not the person that causes the market to essentially crumble. And, you know, that it worked out pretty well for me even though I lost on the freaking tiebreaker. So, yeah, that's Ponzi Scheme. I think it does a very good job of modeling this kind of brain state, essentially, putting you into this brain state. It's relatively quick. And the game probably took about an hour for these five players. And I would certainly try this one again.
Although, I don't think I'm necessarily clamoring. Like I said, I found myself intrigued by how the game was progressing, like from a simulation perspective. But as far as a playing the game and trying to play the game to win perspective, I feel like I kind of happened into uh having such a good score. And maybe that's just the way this tends to go. It's probably going to really sway from one group to the next. If you have somebody um like we did who was just buying way too many things and getting way too low in cash flow, then uh that's going to cause the game to end maybe sooner than later. I don't know. Maybe you could win this game with 20 points or something like that. I have no idea if the game ever gets into that late stage or not because I've only played this game once. But it's it's peculiar. It's strange. It's fascinating. I highly recommend giving this one a try if this sounds even remotely interesting to you.
Uh if you're somebody who enjoys the experience of games and the experience of seeing how simulations can happen, uh definitely give this one a go. Uh I don't think I'm going to be seeking out a copy of this one, but I do hope to get more plays of it in the future.