Skip to main content
Loading video...

Merchants of the Dark Road: Discussion

Transcript 38:34

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for merchants of the dark road this is gonna actually be a combination discussion for the multiplayer and the solo variant as well um so for most of the most of the time whenever i do a solo variant like or solo you know play through uh i also have another one that incorporates a discussion because i like to have everyone else around um but sometimes there are games where you don't see a point in playing with other people and this and so a solo variant is kind of the better option especially for me it's like okay well i could try and get some people over teach them the game you know we play the game and then you know we'll play it a few more times and then we'll record it uh and and then that's kind of just the the format and then sometimes it's just better to get the video up whenever i can play it and still showcase everything about the game and you know showing the solo variant at the same time this game this game is good don't get me wrong like emergence of a dark road is a solid game but it's weird because i i feel conflicted about how good it is and if it's worth playing which happens every now and then there's times where i'm like this is good don't

want to touch it again that's not the case here like if someone were to be like do you want to play i'd be like yeah uh but if they were to be like hey do you want to set it up and have and play with three other people you know plays up to um four i knew that i don't know why i looked at the box uh it's like do you want to set up and play with three other people and do you want to teach it i'd probably say no this game this game has a lot going on um i wouldn't say it's necessarily complex but it feels like it's harder to teach it than it is to play it and that's a very weird dynamic you have so let's go ahead and go into um let's talk about some of the the negatives of the game first i did i did a video that showed that was an unboxing and a re-boxing highly recommend uh you go check that out because uh this is elf creek yeah elf creek games uh basically should have just given you you know shitty ass toilet paper instead of the sheet that they gave you into to organize this it is the biggest botch of an organizer i have seen um not that the organizer is bad once you get everything once you figure out where everything goes but it is such a headache to figure out all that then uh then it's worth you know so go check out that video that's not like i'm not saying that for you to be like oh go watch my other videos you know like there was nothing out there other companies make videos on how to put

their games together especially like uh petrichor for example just got the collector's edition for that and they made a video being like hey you know the designer shows you how they organize it and how everything needs to be organized that's fantastic because whenever you get a bunch of stuff you and they if the company made an organizer you want to know how it gets put together you don't have to um it's just relying on the community to do it which i ended up doing is extremely you know bad business in my in my mind so whenever you finally figure it out it's the most convoluted cumbersome organizer that i they it's really it's two inserts like two plastic inserts which sounds really cool that it's that concise you just pop them out but because it's layered upon layered upon layered it's not an easy setup and that's my first complaint is you besides that it's the fact that i don't know if i if the game is worth that headache that i normally for setup and tear down i don't really care i kind of enjoy setting it up because i like i'm meticulous like that i like to have it all organized uh and then i mean putting up is not as fun but i but in this it's so just cumbersome you have to you always have to pull [ __ ] out i mean you're gonna need it but it's like okay to get to the solo variant stuff i have to rip out all these dice i'm not gonna need to get to you know the tiles i'm gonna have to pull out all

these cards and yeah you pull all that all that stuff out anyway but it's just the fact that you it's it's a chore to set up the game and then it's even more of a chore to put it all back because it's like okay you have to weirdly hold these dice here while you put others so then they're all like flush and then you put stuff on stack and it doesn't even necessarily quite fit with sleeved cards and so you have to kind of like stack them and then just keep them balanced while you put the lid on and that's kind of the weirdness of this game is that it's like it doesn't feel worth all that the game is really good but if someone were to if it'd be better if i was already going to someone's house and they had it set up instead of me being the one that's going to do it um the other negative so that's kind of a just a logistical problem it feels like just with getting even playing the game but the game itself it's really cool like the the theme is awesome uh the the dice placement like every really a lot of the game is is extremely solid uh yeah you're kind of going through the motions in terms of what you're doing this isn't the most open-ended sandbox euro in the world like you're a merchant so you're getting jobs to go sell and you're having you're delivering people to the to their towns like they're riding with you uh that's really everything you do is kind of uh to support that

and there's something wrong with that uh they do have different ways for you to get um you know prestige and then coins uh like in terms of like the deeds different goals but i can see myself not wanting to play this all the time because okay for example there's another game that kind of does that lost runes of our knack another worker placement game this isn't this is a worker placement where you really just have the one worker um and it's definitely not a deck builder but lost ruins has that same complaint from a lot of people where the research track is the game like that's where you're gonna get a bunch of your points if you go up on that track that's that's how you're mainly gonna win and if you're if the players are competing to go the highest uh and then everything else you do in that game is to support you to then go higher up on the track the difference between that one than this one is lost ruins is doesn't isn't a cumbersome setup it's not a cumbersome teardown uh the game probably takes around the same time but i feel like there's a lot more going on versus this one i feel like it's very chore like it's chore like you put in a lot more work to then go and deliver a commission and get six prestige points so the it light lost ruins feels very charming and fluid and cohesive and well this doesn't feel disjointed in any way um it you're very much aware of the the different like the different steps that you're doing you know um which could be good for some people and

bad for others uh the so so i can feel myself after if you know playing this i mean luckily just sheer nature of the hobby and the way running the channel i don't play the same game a lot like i'm not playing merchants of the dark road every day for a month um but but yeah it's so it's like if if i were to play it it would i wouldn't be like oh man just doing the same thing over i wouldn't have that feeling but for people who don't have hundreds of games and they have they might have 10 15 and this was one of them i could see it i could see people looking at it on their shelf and be like eh is it really worth it um you know we could just play we can just play vide culture or something like i'm trying to think of other work replacements we can play [ __ ] uh cornbread i'm just looking at my shelf but that so that's kind of that's kind of where it's coming from uh the other negative and uh i like it i but i i know the people i've played this with had issues with it is your dice so the dice system it's kind of a double-edged sword the die system is very very cool like i really like the bumping mechanism other games kind of do that um for example you like your actions were based off tiles and you bump tiles out um this kind of has another similar idea

where you have dice which are your movement dice in locked slots uh and then you have you know available dice that you uh that you roll and then uh and then that's how you kind of you know you bump those up and so whatever the die you bump up is the one that you are uh using that's your movement the problem with that is you are still at the whim of your night dice and there's not a lot of mitigation there are ways to kind of help you out in movement but you have to work to get those ways so for example if i have you know you always start out at one two and three so you have those three as options and i mean something that did think of if all your dice are the same value in that in your three locked ones you can then be like before you do anything you can be like oh i'm changing those two one two and three so that is that's the one way to mitigate it where you don't have to earn something but let's say and you you'd have to kind of plan for that you have to realize oh i have shitty dice i now have to lock those to then be able to turn them into something but the other way is horseshoes horseshoes that you can only ever have a total of three held on your card uh you can spend those to let you move one you know one forward or one back but to get horseshoes you have to uh you know hire workers that give them

to you you have to you have to take a deed that gives you a horseshoe and a good however together deed you have to travel and choose that as one of your options or go to the dark market and choose that as your option so to mitigate dice it's like you have to sacrifice other things it's like oh man i have a i have a lot of prestige but i don't have a lot of money well i'd like to i traveled i'd like to pick you know money but i have like all zero so i need to it's like i need to go and instead get a horseshoe and that could feel very punishing in fact the the times i've played this there have there's always been one person who happened to just roll really bad and that's not fun when everyone else is rolling a variety of things you know oh i got two twos and you know a four and a one and so people are always kind of getting to do what they need to do especially because oh hey i i have horseshoes or i don't have to spend it uh right now so i'm kind of always getting around the area whatever this world is called so that can be extremely unfun when you are literally just going nope got more zeros okay well unfortunately like my current three lock dice aren't zero so i have to then like i have to then just set up so i can turn my zeros into nothing you know and the chances of you

i mean because whenever you run out of available dice you remove one get them back you roll them so you have you have less and less actions as the game goes on which i like uh i think uh i mean it depends on how it's done but i kind of like it whenever you start out with a lot and then you have to be more finite and succinct whenever you're playing the game but you therefore should be doing better some games do it where you have like nothing then you like everdell you start out with very few workers and you get more as the game goes on so i like them both but it has happened i've seen a game where the pers one person was rolling badly every time we were re-rolling dice so he just he was like scrounging for anything and that's probably the big besides everything else i mentioned that's probably in terms of gameplay the biggest complaint it is nice that your dice if they're all the same value that you can change them to one two and three but i almost would prefer that in your available dice which i know is very like the chance of you rolling the same value on you know all the remaining dice i think it's because you're almost always having three locked besides the end of the game where those are the only things available uh but it's um it's just it's not fun especially when that is your absolute mode of transportation are dice everything you do in this game relies on you having the correct pip to be able to go to where you need to go

now when the dice are working you know as they should then the the game is extremely solid like every location is somewhere is a place that you're going to be able to benefit from it and you can mitigate a lot of things there like the in you could go and hire people you're spending money and throughout the entire game the best thing about the game is the duality of prestige and money thematically making sense hey i'm a rich merchant therefore i'm the better one but am i a well-known one you know how famous am i and i think that's really cool other games kind of do that i think uh i know i have it over there oh uh rushes of the ganges have that dual track there's others that i've played that i can't think of them but i like that dual track method and uh between two cities or between two castles kind of has that which one of the two cities is your lowest that's your score this is this kind of it does a little bit better because it's like okay i have a lot of money like i have 30 gold but oh no i have 28 prestige and you can quickly because there's not a lot of ways to get victory points victory points are very precious because they add to your lowest score however you can very much clear you could see how clearly everyone's doing so if you're sitting there and you're like well i'm higher than them on prestige so at the if i can get hot more coins in my prestige therefore i'll probably win

because it's going to be based off the lowest you know and that's the only thing that's visible is the proceeds track so whenever you're competing and that's the only thing it's like oh man okay so he's higher than me on prestige hopefully his gold is lower because i'm getting some victory points i don't know if he is but if i get my victory points i might be able to edge him out so i really like that thought process which is in your head the entire game there is a balance that you're trying to do throughout the game of okay do i you you really have to unfortunately at the same time like you have to really like balance out so therefore whenever you gain a bunch of prestige you then have to kind of flip and be like okay time to go sell some goods like so i can get some money like i gained 10 prestige here i have five five coins so i need to get you know at least five uh gold so you kind of go back and forth on that uh but i still like that element and then the fact that victory points are so precious based off the deeds they are getting some give you two one of these ship or the wagon upgrades is just a flat two points but it locks you up um i do i do like that and uh so yeah so whenever the dice are working i do like that um i do like that system the fact that okay well these are the movements i have available whenever you bump them up you get a bonus so do i want lanterns well i'm at two lanterns so if i use the middle die

then that'll get me a third one that i can use on the on the short path i do have a commission to sell oh well look at that well the number i have currently there isn't going to get me you know to where i can travel but i do have a die available that'll get me there you know it's a one um so instead i will i'll move my zero up there so i can move one there and then stay there so those are the kind of uh you know strategies you're trying to think of you're prepping all the dice available are really what you're you're always forward thinking or you should be because that's how you're gonna do well in the game uh is that these dice the ones that you have available on your wheel are really you have to try and think okay what can i currently do and then what die do i want to replace that with because am i going to use that again next time i like the fact that there's an upgrade that lets you get uh two money because since money is huge for you know buying goods that you need to sell commissions for it's also competing for your prestige uh or instead of be like well i've been getting a bunch of money okay i need to buy some items i need two instruments they cost three right now um so i'll just uh i'll just move that down because another thing about the great bizarre that i might have messed up in the run through is it's not per you don't spend gold per uh instrument it's just there so like there's two you know instrument or dice right there

you just spend the three gold and you get two instruments i think i paid whenever books and um weapons were really cheap i think i paid for each book but i ended up winning anyway so uh i would have had just probably like one more point uh but yeah so so i mean there's a lot of ways to you know mitigate the cheapness there's a there is a lot of ways to gain money there's a lot of ways to get prestige what you do with like in terms of winning the game isn't necessarily hard to do everything's available there for you to see oh i need to go selling curse karen they they want a potion a staff and a book okay and uh i mean there's people over here there's one guy i can hire that goes to curse karen so if i deliver him at you there i'll get a coin and a prestige and then so every you could see everything the only thing that might change is someone could also just take that from you or you can uh like or someone might buy you know the good but when you go to the great bazaar you can make them cheaper and also take a die and change it so there's a lot of mitigation in what you're doing really the only lack of mitigation is your dice um which in my experience hasn't ever really really been that bad uh but it i have seen it happen um but yeah there's tons of ways for you not tons everything is very finite in the game but it's okay you don't feel like you're like god i just really need this one good like

otherwise i can't do anything it's not as it's not tight like that it's more just oh okay well i'm gonna go to your excursion i'll go to the ruins hey okay i can i can move that to get an upgraded staff that's perfect because that one of the commissions i want or i want needs a staff so therefore i'll get more prestige or better yet i'll just get an upgraded item and go sell it because it's worth five right now and they'll give me five six money because it's upgraded and a quartz and the quartz lets you you know use special abilities for um the companions that you can get which could be huge so the game is pretty smooth it's weird to teach um it's a straightforward game like this is a clean game it makes sense when you're explaining it hey on your turn take one of your available dice move that die up that's how many spaces you move the value of the die is only ever used for travel you have illuminated isolate you get double actions these are invaluable they're very hard to get but you you basically can get them if you happen to roll the same symbol twice in the ruins or that is your reward at the when you travel so let's explain like the traveling is pretty i like it i think it's i think it's neat uh i like the idea of the shortcut or the law or the dark path but they're not interesting the the paths themselves i feel like

they're events and i don't know i think i definitely think that they're balanced so going on the dark road that might be a weird thing to say because i just said there are there are only events going on the dark road um allows well actually just traveling in general allows people to go with you and that's that's an interesting uh you know play kind of just in general if since you know everyone can come with you just when anyone does it you time your travel a little bit weird so because they have to you pick where you're going then they decide like if they want to join like you kind of announce the whole town and you bring in the bell hey i'm going to win glass i know a shortcut you know and then people could be like oh yep hey uh we're gonna come with you the theming of this whenever i was first learning i thought it was gonna be a lot that was gonna be a lot more i thought it was gonna be more of an not an adventure game but like i thought that was gonna be a bigger deal uh go into those towns but it's it's really not it's kind of it is it's its own separate mini game kind of but but yeah so people can come with you so whenever you're looking at all the stuff you have you could be like well they also have to go there i think i'll wait like the only difference is if you're the leader you're the one that gets the benefit no one else does they get to sell their stuff deliver their people sell their goods um for prestige and all that but they don't

get the travel bonus only the leader gets that um or they can just go just to have a little journey see what happens on the event and so whenever they're going or you could just be like yeah we're not gonna no one goes with them so they only you only roll a travel die equal to how many people on the party and if you happen to pick the companion that gives you an extra dime so you could really be like oh man they're taking a shortcut they only have three lanterns you know what i think we'll all pass and then so therefore and they don't pick the companion um they only have to roll one die and heads their bets they have no lanterns they it's a six good for them yeah that's gonna be great or they could be like what happens and they roll a two and one of the goods that they have to uh we're gonna sell ends up getting lost so that that is that's really the only interaction that players have is is trying to read what other people are doing kind of like roll for the galaxy like what action are they most likely gonna do that's probably it so i'm not gonna allocate my dice to do that and hope that i was right and then yeah i was right or oh no like because you could be essentially playing chicken like oh i have three commissions that are at you know win glass you have two am i gonna go or am i gonna wait for you to go or we're gonna just keep kind of like like reading each other uh but ultimately people go with you you go you sell your stuff you get prestige you get

some money and then you make the like you make the decision on what upgrade you want which could be an enlightened eye you can uh which could be money uh or a wagon upgrade which the wagon upgrades are really good but they're limited but yeah the difference between the dark path and the and the shortcuts i haven't found a i mean the shortcut technically has better options or your your die options are higher it's like sometimes a one might be the only bad thing on a shortcut whereas on the dark path a one two three and four might be bad but here's the thing when you take the shortcut you're the one that has to provide the lantern dice and you're the one that picks last on the upgrades so you already spent your lanterns which which are used for re-rolls and if everyone goes with you and you roll three dice and you're just like okay well there's a five you know two and one guess i'm getting the one because no one's gonna so it's just kind of you get screwed on the event but i think they balanced it by you getting two upgrades and they can be the same one so that's kind of nice the dark path you just get the one but you get to pick first so if it's a high die you're gonna have that option and it doesn't require you any lanterns so if you roll shitty if you have lanterns you get to then spend them uh but you only get the one option and let me tell you getting two picks on a upgrade on the short is pretty damn good i'm pretty sure that's

the only reason why i won because i took a shortcut and i took six money because i had like 20 gold at that time and i was like oh i have a decently high amount of prestige i really need money now um but having enlightened dice is really good double actions is strong so i like the travel minigame i think it's neat i think the shortcut even though you pick last can be balanced because the the benefits or the the punishments really aren't that bad like it's like i'll lose an item okay i have a potion that i that i can't sell anyway so i'll just get rid of that it's never been one of those words like that just [ __ ] my entire game you know it's never been that bad um but they're good because i think there was one where i was i got i rolled a six and i got to get a person and that person i delivered to uh where i was going so it ended up working out yeah the the traveling is i think i think really balanced i like it quite a bit um so that is that's my thoughts on like kind of merchants the solo variant is really good and i'm very glad for that because my favorite types of solo variants are the ones where you don't have to change how you play like i don't like solo variants where it's like now it's this weird thing you have to like break your board in half and only use one half and then you have to eat that it's like like it's those are just so annoying because it's like oh god now i have to learn how this guy works and i have to learn how i have to play just to make a solo variant work you do not have to do that here when i

read that like because it was basically i think it even tells you like the rules for how you how you play remain unchanged for the core game but there are additional rules that govern your opponent once whenever i read that i was like i'm doing this solo like because this is you don't interact with anyone else you don't block people from going anywhere they can go to the same spot the only thing is kind of like with any other dice drafting game it's kind of like oh man you took out you took the guy i might i wanted okay but yeah the solar variant is very smooth they did a really really good job balancing these cards like because you would think with how much you have to manage you have to manage the the you know limited space which i like as well i think that's neat that your wagon you do have a little like it's a little small little game of how you want to store things makes thematic sense i do enjoy that but uh the solo player yeah oh anyway so because you have to manage you know goods and commissions and people and then you go sell and all that uh i was like how is how are they gonna make that work and they did a pretty good job i think having just a generic goods track is the smartest way they could have gone about it uh because while you need specific goods um you are in control of that the entire time so you can look and be like i'm gonna buy some staffs or i'm gonna get some stats because i know they're going to sell for a lot the solo player

doesn't get any of that now granted he always will most likely have a bunch of goods but it really does balance out like so he just keeps a generic pile of goods and the fact of the the conditions from top to bottom of what he's gonna do oh he moves to this location how many commissions does he have zero he's getting one you know uh otherwise he's gonna you know buy some goods that just go up because he already has a commission so he's gonna get these they did a really fantastic job of of balancing these i think there's only ten three four five six seven eight nine ten yeah so i mean even going to the dark market that just okay it's just a generic amount of goods like he never uses the buildings the excess buildings uh his his illuminated dice or either victory points at the end or give him a bonus uh for his like his die ability like you have those abilities in your locked dice that's kind of to represent him um and uh he kind of just does something like another player would do yeah he doesn't go after these deeds but he can take them oh he goes there he just grabs that and uh it's like oh crap that's the one i wanted just like another person would they if they might see they are going for one or they might also be trying to go for that and so they take the deed or the commission that you're that you're doing so really really smart how they how he travels is very straightforward it's just oh does he have three lanterns well

he's taking a short path as well and uh and then it even tells you what upgrades he wants okay here's the short one he wants an eliminated die and the bottom uh the bottom deed mainly because those are victory points he doesn't go for the deed specifically it says how many he has those are victory points courts are victory points because he never spends them he never gets companions and an illuminated dice and i and normally in certain solo games having the solo player not ever have to do upkeep or have to like if they're unlimited while you're limited usually that could be very frustrating because you're only limited to uh to three people and three commissions he's not he's he has an unlimited amount of people and commissions but because of the randomness of his deck he's not just stockpiling on commissions and then stockpiling on goods and traveling once and then sandbagging you and getting 30 prestige and money out of nowhere it felt very fluid everything that he did when he was going somewhere i was like i mean because when you're playing multiplayer you don't really care where anyone else is going you're just trying to wait for your next turn so whenever he went yeah i had to manage what he was doing but the cards are just so clean that you could easily look at and be like yep he's going there okay he's immediately getting that he's he's taken that and okay his turn's done back to my turn

you know he's kind of a side thing for so you can play the game but you get to strategize you get to play this game as if you were playing with three other people because they don't matter in a multiplayer game and and neither really does he because at the end of the at the end of the game you can't 100 be certain what your opponents are getting so really you're just like okay well i'm higher than you on prestige um i got 36 points and they're like oh i got 31. i got 25 i got five and you're like okay i guess i win but then here it's pretty much the exact same thing but you got to play the game so it's just like oh man whenever because whenever i was adding everything up i'm like oh okay yeah i won by like four points sweet and then you just pack it up you didn't have to teach anyone the game you didn't have to wait for their turn like you'd be like okay yep that's the day you're moving up that's the commission you're getting nothing nothing i'm saying people like turns take forever but when you're playing a three or four player game you're just like okay you everything you're doing doesn't affect me oh are you traveling oh okay now i know i'm involved uh but in here in the solo variant you're in you're involved the entire time because you're playing and then you have to manage him so the solo variant is really really good very very clean incredibly smart because

i i'm surprised that they were able to manage like just kind of the the system of how how your turn works in with 10 cards uh i don't know unfortunately how the adventures are i'm not even 100 certain if the adventures are specifically no okay yeah they're for the uh solo variant uh that includes other stuff there's these tiles here and then some extra cards i just played the the base solar variant um but it's uh it's really good this is definitely one of those games that if i'm playing it i'm playing it with two or solo that is i i don't want to play that three um and i definitely do not want to play it at four um but other than that that's pretty that's pretty much it like i i can't really think of anything else to mention that i haven't haven't already mentioned um so with that being said uh well i guess i mean if i'm going to complain about their insert and stuff i at least will praise them for their deluxe quality like oh my god they're so sexy these these unique dice or dice these unique coins are super awesome the quartz really cool like they're not just orange they have like a weird like resin on them uh the lanterns are so neat the

the boards are really good yeah the quality is amazing uh whenever you do get over how it's set up it is relatively you know quick because then you just have these of all the goods love the magnetic portion of that uh and the gold inlay to represent upgraded goods all that is really nice the dice are super sexy like very pretty the the game is really really pretty it's just a very weird feeling because it's like i don't know if i'll keep it or not but it is a good game in elf creek i think i've played um what else have they done i think they did uh did they do the atlantis one i can't remember i know i've played their games before at first i thought it was in the hall of the mountain king but that's burnt island huh i know elfqueer games has done i've played their games before uh but yeah i think on a scale of one to ten the solo variant itself is gonna get a 9.

it is it is really really good like if you're thinking about getting this and you have a constant group of four pass but if it's you and your significant other you and maybe one other person or yourself i highly recommend this game for the solo variant um but overall it's a very clean game it's not super complex but it can be it can come off as complex it's a [ __ ] and a half to set up and tear down if i'm taking into consideration you know the the horrible horrible way to teach you how to do an ins uh you know store it um it would drop to the point but since my video's out and i figured i did end up figuring it out then yay it's not i guess it's not can't be that bad i'm gonna give it a seven i think merchants of the dark road is a is a good game it's not as amazing as i was hoping it was gonna be um it doesn't necessarily reinvent the wheel like people aren't gonna be like oh my god this is so radically different from every other game but it does feel different like the it's this is a rondelle game like now that i think about it like you utilize pips to move around a rondelle and rondo games are a lot of fun i've i haven't played tolkien but um there's i'm trying to think of other

rondelle games but i'm throwing the blank right now so uh that's exactly what this is it's good it's a solid game um so yeah that's uh that's my thoughts on merchants of the dark road let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved