Skip to main content
Loading video...

Merchants Cove - Review and Character Breakdown

Transcript 12:35

foreign this time on allies are enemies we are looking at Merchants Cove and all of the expansions that have come out so far which means three characters and the secret stash with its not so secret character Merchant's Cove is designed by Johnny pack Carl Van ostrand and Drake Via Real and is set in an island world with a bit of a seedy underbelly and Oodles of boats full of adventurers looking to buy stuff players take on the role of one of the many incredibly asymmetric Merchants who are forging Brewing treasure hunting time traveling in keeping dragon poop scooping fortune telling and thieving their way to a small fortune and perhaps early retirement on Dragon Island there is a lot to talk about here but let's start with the bare bones of how it plays we'll deal with the exceptions when we look at the individual characters but in general players will be making Goods in different ways and then selling them at the Docks to do this they will be moving to action spaces on their player boards and paying a Time cost usually either one or two hours while most of the actions are unique to the different characters a couple of them are common across all of the boards such as recruiting townsfolk and putting them to work after any actions players move their timepiece Around the Clock the merchant that is behind on the clock always takes the next turn which does mean that sometimes one player will get a couple of turns in a row when anyone

passes an adventurer space they pull an adventure from the bag and choose one of the boats to add it to when a boat is full it sails to a dock and unloads its passengers so they're ready to buy Goods when two ships on one side of the board are full the stragglers in the other ship are moved to the action halls in town once all players have passed the marketplace icon it's time to sell and players can unload their goods to the various docs multiplying the number of goods by the number of customers of the same color at that Dock and then they add up the faction Hall bonuses they might have unlocked before resetting and going again after three rounds of making and selling you check the final tally of gold and the greatest Merchant is name foreign Cove is about as variable as a game can get each of the four base game characters and four expansion characters don't just play differently they feel almost like separate games that exist within the same framework every character has their own board Goods display Shelf mini and specifically focused way of making money and boy are they focused on making money let's walk through each of these starting with the base game the blacksmith is unsurprisingly all about forging Goods in his furnace which is done by way of dice placement and manipulation this is probably the easiest character to play in the game

and the best choice for brand new players you are just putting dice in the various furnaces making sure the added value meets a certain threshold high for large Goods low for small and then smelting them up the biggest tricks here are making sure you load enough before you smelt and gaining and using townsfolk wisely it's a low bar to entry and probably a medium bar to playing well but it is a bit straightforward and not the most exciting character in the game this one is good for those that like a guaranteed return without too much stress The Alchemist is a bit of a fan favorite she's a smidge trickier than the blacksmith though still okay from most newbies but she UPS the fun level by a good chunk in order to brew your concoctions you will play a kind of mini potion explosion taking ingredients and putting them into cauldrons hopefully causing some chain reactions the dark magic key to success here is both in lining up the ingredient Marbles and placing them cleverly in the cauldrons as well as getting your i-core out quickly to fill cauldron slots this is one of the most tactile characters in the game and it's great for players that want a Mini Puzzle that lets them think a step ahead the captain collects booty both near and far by sending out ships and trawling for treasure the big mechanics here are the spinner that decides movement and curse coins and the secret treasure

chests which provide the captain's large Goods both of which involve a decent amount of Randomness with big risks and big rewards players can take the safe route by focusing on fishing for small goods and that can actually be a good strategy but players who will have the most fun with this one will be the ones that are okay with taking risks and dealing with a few cursed coins while letting it ride on the Winds of fate this Duo of characters that is an homage to Marty McFly and Doc Brown is probably the trickiest to play in the base game although that is a comparative scale so take it with a grain of salt the chronomancer duo don't make good so much as snatch them from time portals with total disregard for the time continuum it's kind of a rondelle system but with constantly moving action spaces which makes for an interesting puzzle and something that feels a bit more euro-ish or abstract than some of the other characters time itself also becomes a resource here with players balancing when to use their Frozen hour markers to get back time and one to keep them to score faction points it's not quite 1.21 gigawatts of complexity but it wouldn't be one that I would give to a new player The Innkeeper isn't really bothered about selling Goods instead like his name implies he wants to put the adventurers up for the night by offering

the right kinds of beds and also selling a few Libations along the way the biggest challenge to playing The Innkeeper is to manage the docks if the majority on a dock matches the bed in the corresponding room you gain a guest and those guests will hang around and multiply your points in later rounds but if you have the wrong kind of bed the adventurer joins the brawl which means you'll need to bounce them later there are also points for your various drinks which are sold normally generally we have found that the Innkeeper has the potential to either score huge or have a tough time depending on their dock management the Oracle is probably the toughest to manage of all of the characters but with that extra bit of rules overhead also comes a lot of satisfying combos the Oracle is a rolling right character and her board is actually a glossy erasable board which you can write directly on and right you will this board features a few little mini games which all tie into the runes in your divining dish which you toss each turn as the rolling part of the game from this you will be charting the Stars reading horoscopes and divining the future which means drawing lines writing numbers and guessing the next adventure to come out of the bag it all feels super thematic and very satisfying when the runes line up just right and there's a nice blend of clever play mixed with a bit of luck

the dragon Rancher is basically a mancala game where players are placing food from a bag and then Gathering it to grow dragons but there are some clever twists to add a bit of theme first and foremost being the poop mechanic where every Dragon you gain also leaves a poop that later needs cleaning there is also tree chopping that leads to sponsorship icons because a lot of the actions take two time the satisfaction from playing the dragon Rancher comes from pre-planning and setting yourself up for some big efficient turns both in growing and gaining dragons and in scooping that poop the thief is kind of a secret bonus character that comes in the secret stash but now that a figure has been announced for the upcoming Kickstarter that cat is fully out of the bag the thief's board is actually the bottom of the box and his Goods aren't really Goods at all but intelligence as the thief you'll be using a growing network of Rogues to spy on other players Goods gain Intel about townsfolk and hang around the docks all while moving up various tracks which rate the level of the Intel you'll be selling it's meant to be more of a bonus character than a fully fledged character so it is a smidge Rough Around the Edges but for players that are willing to take on the challenge it is a fun way to mess with the game even further this isn't really a character but rather an AI that acts like a character for

solo modes but it does work pretty well The Peddler is powered by a deck of cards with a pair of those cards deciding on what it will do each turn from this he pushes the clock decides on the placement of adventurers and gathers Goods to sell in a way that feels not too far off of being a real opponent plus there are expert level cards that you can add to its deck if you want a bigger challenge this game could conceivably work for one to five players depending on the expansions you have but because most of what you're doing is Solitaire we would probably shy away from the higher player counts two players works well with a nice Push Pull with the pacing and the docks while three or four will add a little bit of play time but will also refresh the townsfolk market a bit quicker and increase Chaos on the docks also as we just mentioned the solo mode is surprisingly good and can be added to bulk out two-player games as well if you really want you've probably already noticed this but the components are terrific the little boats are all unique and functional and surprisingly have held up well even after 20-ish plays the characters all have their own feel which is reflected in their boards and figures and their goods and even in the unique display shells the adventurers are nice and chunky and pleasing to pull out of the bag and all of it is pulled together by

the terrific art from the micho who is always a favorite of ours and we can't imagine anyone else doing the art for this game it's not an easy task to make something that is kind of pirate kind of magic kind of Back to the Future but the micho nails it the only real tricky here is storing it all but this is a five-star production all the way Merchants Cove is going to have a somewhat specific audience for a few reasons first of all it's more of a system than a game the main board is like your NES that you need to plug your various characters into and that has some obvious pluses with infinite expandability but you need to know that you may be in for a bit of an expensive haul it also has a bit of a unique niche in that all of the characters play differently but none of them are that complex which can mean a smidge too much rules overhead for newbies but not quite enough meat for heavy Gamers that said it lands right in the sweet spot for those that want that Variety in asymmetry without needing to understand how all of their opponents characters work also it is unlikely that you will connect with all of the characters and systems both of us have a few that we gravitate to and a few that we don't really jive with at all but if you're looking for a mid weight experience with a lot of variety and a heck of a high

production value Merchant's Cove is well worth a visit and that is it have you played Merchants Cove who's your favorite Merchant are you excited for the Recently announced expansion and as always please do like comment and subscribe and hopefully we will see you all next time for another game

Progress saved