Earth Express Review - The Best Parts of Earth, But In Only 15 Minutes
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from BoardGameCo, and today I'm reviewing Earth Express from Inside Up. Earth Express is a shorter version of Earth that attempts to give you the same Earth experience, but in a shorter playtime while accommodating more players, while hopefully maintaining the full Earth experience. Before we dive into this, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. In Earth Express Oh, and prototype. This is a prototype. Rules, components have to change, and I'll have a link to the crowdfunding campaign down below. In fact, there's actually another campaign another game in this campaign behind the lens. I'll have coverage on that as well, which may have gone up before this or after this. I don't know. Check out the channel to see more. But with that, in Earth Express, you're basically going to be playing through five rounds and building out nine cards. Players have a 3 by 3 grid. So, 1 2 3 1 2 1 2 3. You're going to be playing out nine cards total, but you're going to be playing out two cards in rounds 1 through 4 for a total of eight cards, and then the ninth card in round five.
So, you're basically going to be playing out two cards per round with the final card to top it all off. The first thing you're going to do every round is play two cards. Now, I should note, I will not be trying to play this efficiently. I'm just going to go ahead and play them and then show you how it all feeds together. So, I'm going to play two cards. You can play them anywhere into your grid, and I'm going to I just said I'm not going to play it efficiently, but this one does reward me for trees, so I'll see if I can play some tree cards. So, I'm going to play this plum tree. This is a good one to play in my top left. I'll explain how the order matters as you do so. Also, this is a multicolor ability, which means it's going to trigger regardless of which of these I'll choose, but we haven't gotten that far. Uh then, I'm going to look at my hand for other things, and you know what? Actually, I'm speaking of trees, I'm going to play this one. I'm going to play this one over here. Uh no, this is four points per tree diagonally adjacent to this train. So, if I'm placing this here, I can maximize diagonal points by placing trees there. So, I'm going to place this down over here, and that's going to be my landscape. So, you see a flora and a landscape in play, and then I'll pass my hand to the next player uh before drawing back up to seven. But before we do that, the next step you're going to do is you're going to activate an ability. So, you're going to choose one of these abilities, and each player chooses and activates whichever side they want. In my case, I don't have a strong preference. I guess I'll go ahead and activate this side. That's going to give me two. I'm going to take two of these over here, and I'm going to place them down on here. We'll talk more about how scoring works, but effectively, your tree is going to be gathering these like little tree things as well as dirt on the side. Uh then, I'm going to activate all multicolor abilities and all yellow abilities. This is a multicolor ability, so I'm going to be able to add one. This can store up to two on that. And then, I get to add another one. This particular thing says it says that it's for if I
can put up to five here, and I'll get six points if I have all five. Otherwise, they're worth one point each. That's going to be my abilities. This is a scoring ability, so I won't do that. Before we end the round, the next thing you do is you're going to look to see if you've accomplished any of the end-game objectives. There's going to be end-game objectives. Players have their own way that they're personally scoring. This is six points for every three cards, each with a dirt ability, so that's going to count towards that. And then, we have over here public objective, seven points for every two cards with a negative point value. This is a negative point value, so it's negative seven, which is not great, but that will help me towards this. And then, we have earn points depending on the total number of those symbols in your tableau, which I don't have any yet. Over here, you're going to check these. These are all end-game abilities. Here, you're going to check these, which over here, four points uh for each uh four plus flora, each with four plus dirt on it, which I don't have yet. And then, we have three trees.
These are first come, first serve. So, whoever achieves them first goes ahead and takes the highest point value. Other players take lower point values as they go. If players achieve it in the same round, they can go both get the same point value. So, looking at my hand, continuing this uh process, we're into round two now. I'm going to play two more cards, and I do have I haven't decided if they're good for me, but I do actually have three trees in my hand. I have a bunch of these. This is useful for that, and then I have three trees, but we do need to move to the next ability stack over here. So, we're going to be activating another ability instead. Let's take a look. Place this out. I do have apple trees. I have red mangrove. Um because I don't have access to yellow ability, I'm more inclined, although these would both These would be nice for um It's not the best for right now, but if I can play these off, they have any negative values. Uh these None of these are negative values, but I could get three trees out if I place these. So, I'm definitely placing two trees because that will help me get this right away on the second turn. Uh to that end, I think I will lean in towards yellow. It may not be the best. These can help me now, but I think I'm going to be able to activate strong yellow turns. So, I'm going to place this down over here, and then this down over here.
Although, we don't have any seeds, so we do want to try to see if we can get our hands on seeds before the next round. Uh that's going to be that. Then, we activate our abilities. I'm going to be choosing uh It doesn't matter in this case. I got seeds. I'll choose seeds so that I can have this for the next turn. So, I'm going to take two seeds, and then I still will be able to activate this, so I'll move this up one, and then add another to my tree. And then, that's basically it. That's what you're doing. Oh, right now then, I check. I have three of these, so I'll immediately put this down here, and I'll get 16 points. Anyone who didn't achieve it this round, they're now fighting over those 11 points instead. That's basically how a game of Earth Express works. You're playing through five rounds. Rounds 1 through 4, you're playing two cards each as you slowly fill out your grid with landscapes and floras. The floras are going to have abilities on them. The landscapes have uh end-game abilities, but then you have end-game one-time use abilities with the vast majority of abilities are going to be the three colors, yellow, red, and blue. And each round, you choose a side to activate, activating all of those uh multicolor abilities, as well as specific sides.
So, for example, when I activate yellow next, I'm going to be able to activate all three cards, and hopefully, I'll have even more cards that I've played as well. Then, you check to see if you got any end-game scoring, and you go through five rounds of doing that before you resolve end-game scoring. End-game scoring is as follows. You're going to get the base victory points on cards. So, right now, I have -7, 2, 1, and 8 over here. You're going to get one victory point per sprout. So, over here, for example, I have two right now. You get one victory point per seed. So again, that's two points there. You get victory points from your fauna board. So again, right now, I have 16 victory points there. You get victory points from your growth. So, that's going to be the number of growth tokens you have, but wherever you have a full stack, meaning the max capacity, you get the rightmost number instead. So, for example, on this card, I only have four points because I only have four, but if I had all five, I would get six points.
And sometimes, the gaps are bigger or smaller. Like sometimes, it's only an extra point. Other times, it's like seven, and if you get all seven, you get an extra four points. So, there could be a nice jump sometimes when you do that. You get victory points from your terrain card. So again, for example, this landscape over here is going to be scoring uh 12 points right now, but I could get another uh four over here if I place another tree. And then, victory points from your ecosystem cards, both the shared board as well as your personal ecosystem card. That's basically how you play Earth Express. The other thing I didn't really touch upon is seed tokens. You can use seed tokens to discard your hand and draw more cards, or alternatively, to go hunting for specific cards. You could say, "I want a card with a red ability," and then hunt until you have that specific thing. You can choose one feature and hunt for that feature in the deck. That is how you play Earth Express. Those of you who have played Earth before will recognize that this is very similar to Earth. The main difference is instead of activating an ability and then having other players benefit from that ability, everyone can just activate the ability on the board, choosing from one of two different sides. So, there's some limitations, but not the same way it was in the original game. That also allows it to play at higher player counts because you can just all do your own thing. It's not quite as much checking with everyone.
Also, you're playing a three-card grid instead of a nine-card grid, but outside Sorry, a 3 by 3 grid instead of a 4 by 4 grid. But outside of those main differences, it's functionally mostly Earth, just faster, quicker, more player counts, uh while maintaining the same core elements of Earth. With that said, time to dive into my review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking, starting off with what I like. Put frankly, this is the best parts of Earth, but it's faster, better Well, better, yeah, it's better. For me, it's better. We'll talk about that more. But this is the best parts of Earth in a faster package uh that also removes some of the fiddly parts of Earth that to me didn't necessarily experience. That's the main aspect. But what do I actually like about this? I enjoy building up your tableau. I enjoy finding the synergies of how to optimize your scoring. Even things like this right now, the trade-off of okay, wait.
Oh, great. I'm really focusing on these trees because I can be the first one here for 16 points, but also, this is in my starting hand, which is really great because that means I can I have double the reason to lean into it. Also, I got this negative point value over here, which again, it's a trade-off there because generally, the negative value of a card is accounted for in how good that card is, but I get additional perk of these over here uh because of the the ecosystems, I'm going to get additional seven points for every two point two cards with negative points. So, maybe if I lean into that a little bit more. I'll grant my board already has bunch of cards, but again, it gives you that balancing act. How much do I want to go for trees? Now that I have these trees, maybe I want to get one more tree, and then now start working on the Great Hungarian Plain to get those other symbols around the board over there instead. You also have your own personal card, and then the cards themselves and the abilities and synergies, and even the order of them. We didn't really talk about it a lot, but you do have to activate your cards in order. So, the way you structure your board as to making sure you get the things you need so that you can spend them on other things. For the most part, this game has a lot of remove two of this, get three of that. Remove one of those, get two of those. You're mostly playing around with the uh various elements in your tableau in order to get extra things back and slightly improve your points every time you activate a set of abilities. It does all of that playing in around 20 minutes. I I think the box The box I have has a type-o. It doesn't have the right number on it, but I believe it's supposed to be like a 15-minute game.
I've so far been playing this in around I want to say 50 Maybe not 50. Maybe 20, 25 minutes per round, but it does play pretty quickly. Gives you a giant stack of cards with tons of variety to go through, and it gives you that just how do I build up a tableau that activates multiple scoring criteria, and I do so better than other players all in a 20-minute experience. So, overall, it's the best things about Earth in a shorter, faster playtime. As far as things I don't like about Earth, for example, not even don't like, but I just find unnecessary. Like I The the the ability aspect of I activate an ability, everyone else shares. This to me is a faster system that maintains that core concept. It maintains the feel of that, while allowing you to have more agency over the experience, and it doesn't feel It doesn't feel any worse off for this. There's still a limitation. You still can't activate your thing every single time. So, building a tableau in multiple colors is going to benefit you in the long run. But you also have more agency each round what to choose, and it just doesn't slow down the game, allowing for higher player counts.
As far as things I don't like about the game, some of these might be prototype issues, so I don't know for sure. First of all, I appreciate the uh economical aspect of having little uh little sticks kind of. And these, by the way, can go multiple ways. So, you can have your tableau that way, or have your tableau that way. But, as much as these are kind of nice, they also move and slide a lot in a way that is both visually not pleasing when you want things exactly right. And even worse, if you actually hit it a decent amount, then it can be annoying. That's true of these cardboards as well, where these are often like they just kind of overlay. They don't even overlay fully on it. So, again, I don't know what the final version's going to be like, but having the cards not fully on it does allow you to be able to pick it up more easily. But, it kind of just looks like it doesn't fit perfectly. And again, they they pivot around a lot. So, these are small little just finicky aspects about the about the components of the game. But, as far as the gameplay itself, it still does have the main element of Earth that I don't love. The reason Earth for me is a game that I enjoy and not a game that I love, as well received as it is, is specifically so many elements of scoring feel like it's just a point for this, a point for that, a point for that. You want to see it, it's a point. You want some seeds, it's a point. You want some You want to count your growth over there, your growth over there, they're all points. What do you do in your turn? You lose two points here, you gain three points here. What do you do with your next action? You lose a point here, you gain two points here.
Granted, all games all Euro games with that aspect are kind of just a trade-off in points, but I think more so in Earth than other similar games do I really feel that lose two points, gain three points, lose one point, gain two points, lose four points, gain five points. That's what all of your actions are. They just subtract some, add others. You have to have those currencies in play, but it doesn't feel particularly clever. Like the growth aspect, sure, you get the extra bonus points for capping that out. But, it doesn't feel There's synergy around how to build my tableau overall, but the core abilities you're doing mostly feel like minus one plus two again and again and again. That element is still present. And then lastly, I'll say that as much as I appreciate this experience, I think it could have still been a faster, better game even with a 4 by 4 tableau. So, they they're really leaning into making it Earth Express, so they're condensing multiple aspects from the player interaction, from the table space, from the 3 by 3 tableau. But, I think this game could still be fast with a 4 by 4 tableau. I almost wish I almost I almost hope they do this. Like if they put an expansion in the box, a little mini thing where you have You could play Earth Express Express, or you could just play a faster version of Earth where you have a 4 by 4 instead, but with the same core structure of everything else, because I think this did a very good job at making Earth more condensed. And I think that a 4 by 4 just gives you more room to play around with those various ways that terrain cards will score, or just how you build your structure in general. As far as what I can see others not liking, you still might You just might like the bigger Earth experience.
For me, I feel that this really really distills the core things about Earth that I like the most into a smaller, faster package, but you might not vibe with that. One of the big things I need to be mindful of is I am a fan of Earth, but not to the extent that other people like Earth. So, if you're a huge Earth super fan, you might feel that this is not the best experience. Versus for myself, it is an improved version of Earth. So, it is that weird aspect I always need to be mindful. Whenever you have similar games, and you have Maracaibo or Pirates of Maracaibo, you have Terraforming Mars, you have Ares Expedition. Whenever you have games built off the backs of others, you often find there are different camps as far as who likes one version versus the other. So, I personally like this one more, you might not. Which brings us to final thoughts. For me, this is a better version of Earth, like I said already. Yeah, I The biggest complaint I have is that point counting aspect. I like everything else about Earth, and I hate how everything comes down to subtract two, add four. It's a It kind of removes a little bit of the soul from the game, because that math feels so present in every action you take. For me, I enjoy this, though. It's a 3.5 out of 5. It is definitely the version of Earth that I would prefer to play every single time. It's faster.
It's It's I hesitate to use the word better, cuz that's so subjective, but for me, it's definitely better. It has the best parts of Earth, and it's in a shorter playtime, easier to table, removes unnecessary interaction. If If they just had a slightly more interesting ways of getting those pluses and minuses, that would move it up to the next level for me. A 3.5 out of 5. As far as other game recommendations, definitely if you're looking for a nature-themed game about crunching numbers and building a little ecosystem, check out Harmonies, a very popular game of building ecosystems and trying to get your animals onto the board by how you measure the tokens as you put them all out into play. And then also check out Point City. If you're looking for a fast version of a fast point scoring, just try to min-max as you gather a bunch of cards, Point City from Flatout Games has you putting cards into a grid in a Splendor-adjacent game where everything's going to be trying to score off each other as you build up a tableau at the same time. And I mentioned at the beginning of this video that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find games both from All Play as well as their partner publishers. And if you check out Oddland, Oddland is a game from All Play that has you building out a tableau, placing various things into those tableaux, and trying to score Each thing scores differently. You're trying to optimize your scoring. Again, if you like this kind of genre, that's another game that might be worth checking out.
And in any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you enjoyed this video. And as always, I hope you have a good one.