TDG: Limits of Glory: Bonaparte's Eastern Empire
Transcript
Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, my neighbor recently told me to put cow manure on my strawberries. I'm going back to whipped cream. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Bonaparts Eastern Empire from Form Square Games.
In Bonapart's Eastern Empire from form square games, one player takes on the role of the British, the Malalukes and various others in Egypt, although some can switch sides and the other player will actually take on the role of Napoleon Bonapart as he leads the French forces to invade Egypt. Now, this game is the first game in the Limits of Glory series. Now, essentially how this game plays out is in kind of three phases. you have kind of a phase where Napoleon actually has to uh get from France to Egypt and kind of evade British naval squadrons. There's a bit of a hidden movement aspect here. Then you actually have the invasion where you you put your armies on land where they actually conquer. And then you have kind of the the conquest phase where actually moving around and trying to take cities and victory points as Napoleon. Now, as I say this first part, you kind of have three different possible ports that you can leave from as Napoleon. Um, and you are only you only actually have your army on one of them. So, as you're sailing out, you've got British fleets that are trying to find you and stop you. And there they're kind of some rules that that follow with that. I'm not going to get into the weeds, but essentially what you're doing in this game is every space on the board, land and sea, has a number printed on it. And when you're in that space, that number says how many dye you can roll, how many dice you can roll. So you can roll that number of dice and you need fives or sixes to activate that space. So essentially if I'm in a space I can roll that number of dice and if I roll a five
or a six I can move again. And if I'm in the next space I roll that number of dice and I got to roll a five or a six and I keep going until I can't roll a five or a six. But because this is a limits of glory game, the commanders of the various fleets you have will have glory points. And you can actually and if you ever you fail any dieice rolls, you can spend glory any number of glory points to reroll any number of your die in order to try to succeed again. Now, as I say, you're using this system to try to get Napoleon's forces to the Middle East. And you can actually land them anywhere in North Africa. And then the British again are trying to intercept you. Now, if they succeed, they will s if they succeed, if they find you, they'll actually succeed in kind of uh uh lowering the number of army units you'll actually be able to invade with. But Napoleon lands and he, as he's on land, again, it's the same thing. As he's moving, he's got to roll dice to activate the place he's at and then he can move to an adjacent space.
And he can keep moving as long as he can successfully roll fives or sixes. Now again, Napoleon starts out with a lot of glory, so he can do a roll, but you can only do kind of one-roll per failure. You can't just keep spending that again and again and again. Now, there are different cities and spaces that are garrison garrisoned by some of the natives. The British may come in there and and try to fight you, too. Uh try to fight Napoleon, too. And again, if you actually get into a fight, you uh are going to look at a kind of a a chart. you're going to see kind of what your forces are. Each like like Napoleon's forces fight really well. The native forces, the Malukes and and and and Egyptians, the Ottomans, they don't fight as well, but they may have a lot more units, so they got a lot more fodder, but it's harder for them to score hits. And you are rolling die.
Again, you're trying to get uh you're rolling a number of dice. You're trying to get the appropriate number of successes. you look and see depending on what you've rolled, how many uh casualties you're inflicting upon your enemy and how many do they lose. Now, throughout the game, Napoleon and his enemies are also kind of splitting their troops or bringing new troops onto the board, new commanders, that is to say, new generals or admirals. And whenever they come on the board, you actually look on a chart that says um how many glory points they get plus a die roll. So, you're going to be rolling a certain number of dice. whatever that die roll is plus what'sever printed there is how many glory points they have for the game. So they come on the board and they've got that limited number of glory that they can have for rerolls. Again, that's rerolls in combat, that's rerolls for activation, anything else. Now, after each uh turn, you're going to have kind of an event phase. You're going to roll the dieice to find out what event you've got. Now, some events are repeatable. They can happen over and over again. Some events are going to force you to kind of start rolling higher on the event track, and you may replace uh certain events with tiles that do different things. Now, at the beginning of every new year, both players are going to roll the dice.
Again, they're looking for successes, fives or sixes, and that will tell them how many uh momentum markers they're going to get. And momentum markers are what you're going to place on the board to show what units you're activating essentially. Now, the game can end in certain ways. If the Ottomans and the British are in control of, you know, certain spaces on the board, uh, at any time, they're going to win the game. If Napoleon and his forces control a bunch of spaces on the board, then at any one time, then they control the game. But also too, if you roll a 14 on the event board, the event clock, uh, with four dice, you're up to rolling four dice, and you roll a 14, that immediately ends the game. I believe that's the piece of Amy. Now, generally speaking, who'sever got the most points, that is to say, who controls the most victory cities um at the end of the game will win if it goes to the piece of Amy. If it's a tie, whoever controls Cairo wins the game.
So, whoever can go ahead and meet those specific victory conditions wins. Bonapart's Eastern Empire. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now back to the review. Okay, Bonaparts Eastern Empire. There's there's a lot more going on. That's just a basic basic overview of gameplay. There's there's there's there's a lot of nuance here. There's a lot of different events that can kick in that do can do different things. Um I'm just giving you the kind of the basic overview of how you play the game. Now, first of all, I will say um Andrew Ror, the designer of this game, he actually did uh Coalitions, which was a game that I know they kickstarted I did a preview video like I want to say like five years ago, four or five years ago. I'm not even sure if that game's out yet, but I really like that game. I actually played it and then as as I was doing my review, they actually got back to me and said, "Hey, we changed uh we did a big rule change and I played it again with that rule change and it was even better." Um, so I I really enjoyed Coalitions. I thought Coalitions was spectacular and so I was really looking forward to to actually getting this one to the table.
Unfortunately, I got this game and it I think I got it not long before I was preparing to move and I got married last year and things just kind of it kind of got unfortunately some of my games kind of got pushed into aside and they were in boxes and it took a while to find them and I got I got to get this one to the table, right? I was really excited to get this one to the table. Al actually um I was talking to him about it and he said, "Let let me take it and uh and play with it a little bit first." So, he actually took it and he played with it and then then he brought it over and we played it together. I had read the rules and then Al was kind of explaining to me the practical application of the game. Um the rule book is not terribly difficult. Uh it's not a it's not a bad rule book.
Um, I do kind of wish some things had been a little more laid out here and there. There were a few little things that weren't as intuitive as I would have liked, but generally it's not a bad rule book. Um, but we went ahead and we played this game. And I like that hidden movement thing at the beginning where you've got the the different um ships sailing, the French ships sailing to the African coast and how the British are trying to intercept, but they don't know who to go after. I thought that was was was really fun. I big fan of hidden movement games and that was kind of a fun hidden movement aspect. But that's just the beginning. You can also land on Malta and and Garrison Malta which kind of can give you more points too at the end of the game. So I thought that was pretty pretty fun. Um now the game itself when it came to combat uh I really liked it. I really like the combat system of, you know, you've got the French have like really powerful troops and then like, you know, a lot of the the Malukes and and Ottomans, they don't have very powerful troops, but they got a lot of them, like considerably more than the French do.
But the way the the the battles played out was cool. And then of course you can again opt to spend some of your glory points to to do rerolls. I thought that was pretty cool. And then you you've also got some interesting things like with the events you've got like uprisings and revolts you got to put down and stuff. So a lot of that is cool. Now we were playing this game and the first time and it kind of becomes clear that this game is a dice fest. This game is really all about the dice rolls because you're rolling dice like I say for the activations. Every time you want to activate an army to move it, you're you're every time you go into a new area and you want to activate it, you're rolling for that. Um, every of course combat, you're rolling.
Everything for the event clock, you're rolling. And you've always got that option for bad rolls to spend glory to roll. Now, I love dice rolling. I love dice combat. I I love dice. I love dice. I'm a big dice guy. And yet, I admit in this game, after a while, I kind of found the dice rolls a little tedious. And the game kind of felt a little sy. It kind of felt like the dice were playing me more than I was playing the dice. Now, there's not a lot of ways to mitigate the dice other than spending glory to to go again, which is is fun for a while, but then it it like I say, it it got a little tedious. Now, this game, the games between Al and I, the games we played were about two and a half hours.
And honestly, for a game that is this dice driven with very little to do to mitigate the luck except the the glory points, I think this should have been like an hour game. I think I would have liked it better if this game played in an hour. If there was some way they could have condensed the game, maybe made the board a little smaller or something, that to me would have been, I think, a more fun experience. as it is. Um, I there's a lot of stuff in this game I like and I appreciate, but it didn't wow me. And like I say, toward after about an hour or so, it starts to get a little tedious. And it was funny because I was playing the game and then the first time Al had played it before I did. And I was playing the game the first time and and after about an hour or so or no it was actually after we finished I I said something to him like you know I I think it kind of gets a little tedious with the dice rolls and he's like oh I'm glad you said it. I was thinking the same thing and I didn't want to color your your attitude. So we both kind of felt that. I know they're going to they're planning on doing more in this system and that's cool but I wish they'd find ways to condense it because honestly like I say if this game were about an hour long I think it'd be great. I think I would really really like it. As it is, I think it's a fun and interesting game, but it wears out its welcome. It just it's just a bit much. So, on the Cody scale, I'm going to give Bonapart's Eastern Empire a five out of 10. Um, I'm glad I played it, but
honestly, I don't know that I'll be coming back to it. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for joining us once again today here on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we would ask you to please leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Gamegegeek, on our Facebook page, or on X. We'd love to hear back from you. We would ask you to please like this video and subscribe to our channel. That really helps us out. We would also ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where I talk about military history and books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on there. I would humbly ask you to click on uh that uh channel and subscribe to it as well. And also too, if you really do like the kind of content we bring to you here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. I was recently offered a job at an ice cream parlor, but I turned it down. I don't work on Sundays.
Please somebody on my feet again. And I don't know where I'm going. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody ground. It's a long time and I'll be dying.
I'm looking for a good ally. I'm looking for somebody that's got my back. And you know like
so far you've been kind of everywhere. So,