Skip to main content
Loading video...

We played All True Believers - One More Game! - Board game playthrough

Transcript 56:39

Should we shame people?

We could just do it for fun.

Yeah,

we've got to lubricate this cult.

Hello everyone and welcome to One More Game. I'm your host Bailey Meyers and I'm joined by five fabulous fellow players who are going to be playing All True Believers with me. Let's have you guys introduce yourselves. Start on my left here. Hello, I'm Becca Scott and I am a true believer.

How's it going? on a Miffy Watty way and I am a true believer.

Hi, I'm Teao Yang and I am a true believer.

WHAT?

UH, HELLO. I'm Dom Allen and I'm the believer believer of them all.

And I'm Jonathan Brown. I I don't stop believing.

Oh, I love that journey for you.

Today we're playing All True Believers by Pillbox Games. And the thing about these true believers is two of them are lying except for Sullivan. We know he's telling the truth naturally.

All true believers is a social deduction game set in a cult. Four of us are true believers just like in the title. Two of us are secretly defectors trying to destroy the cult from within by failing missions. But we would never do that. Boo.

Our goal as the true cult members is to succeed at missions, bring our message to the masses, and reach taxexempt status. 501c3. Be sure to check out the Kickstarter campaign for all true believers linked in the description below. And of course, you can pick up this game at the Many Realms website. Another sponsor of this show, Many Realms is a trusted destination for trading card games and board games featuring a curated selection of titles, including this one and others like Raw Sunot Edition, War of the Ring, and more. You can order online to have your games handled with care at an unbeatable price and get free shipping when you spend at least $125. Without further ado, shall we start believing?

Yeah.

What do we believe in? That's a great question, Becca. I feel like this is a cult that's really based on a lot of sex stuff personally. Yeah, for sure.

You said it because Okay, but what kind of sex?

What kind?

I think it involves dental floss.

Oh, nice.

Innovative and new.

What are you guys bringing to the orgy?

Yeah. Um, reservations, stiff upper lip,

conversations about the weather.

Do you normally want to cry?

Oh dear. You must be cold.

You're going to want to put a coat on, I'd imagine.

It is warm in here today. Unseasonably, yes.

Whoa.

Yeah.

You turned on. Yes.

Stop directly quoting the cult's bylaws. These people are new. That's the guide into flirting.

Yeah.

All right. We're now going to sneakily look at our alignments and not show the people around us because that would give the game away.

I believe

I I saw Justin himself on my card and I gave the card a little kiss.

And then you two are the defectors. Yeah. It's obviously you guys the defectors.

Yeah,

I like that.

Just cuz you didn't want to pay off that extra money for tea.

Yeah,

I think it's time for the defectors to reveal themselves to each other in secret.

All right.

All right, everyone. This game always begins with a little bit of guided meditation. Let's all close our eyes,

take a deep breath in.

We believe in the cult. The cult believes in us. defectors, while we're doing this breathing, both of you, open your eyes.

Make good sexy eye contact at each other.

Ooh.

Ooh.

All right, take another deep breath. Boy,

we're going to open our eyes.

There is a lot of sex stuff.

Really breathing.

To determine turn order, we have one of these virtue cards for everybody, but only one of these virtue cards is the devotion card. That person's going to go first, and it's going to be determined randomly. I

deal these out to everybody. My favorite. Thank you.

Thanks so much.

All right, everyone take a look at your card and let's see who goes first.

No, not I.

Your boy is devoted.

Very good.

All right, so Iffy is going to be the first one. Who is the eye? He'll get to determine who the hand is. Everyone gets to start with a one cost disciple card that's free to use, and they each have a different power. Ify, what's yours?

Yes. Uh, mine is the libertine. I choose another player, and we both draw three virtues. I'm the guru. I've got really cool glasses. Uh um and I can once per game discard all my virtues and draw five new ones.

That's good. Uh I'm the grifter.

I choose a player and blindly steal three of their virtues.

Oh,

I'm the thief. I swap virtue hands with another player that I choose.

I have the muse with two paint brushes. So, they're really trying to become the artist, too. Uh, all players draw one virtue, you draw two.

Interesting.

The ambidextrous.

And I'm the siren. She's got a tambourine, and she appears to be Warblin. Her power is skip this round immediately. Next player becomes the eye. Now, all of our disciples are blue, as you might have noticed. That means they are a onetime use. But there are some disciples in here who are yellow. They're steadfast and that means their power goes for the entire game because we peed on them because we

that's part of it.

Part of the cult, right?

Does anyone want to start off by using their disciples?

No, bro.

No, I pick

I will use the muse.

Oh,

so all players will draw one virtue.

And this is a a sign of good faith. I am a true believer. You and I draw two.

I believe it. I believe it. Discard it rightful

here. It's our discard pile. Thank you so much, T. Very good cult member.

I brought a bunch of scones to the sex orgy thing.

Oh my god. What flavor?

Oh yeah. What flavor?

Uh, apricot.

Cool.

Marmalade.

A marmalade is lovely. It's turning into a very British or

Yes.

Is there some good flavor text on there?

Yes. It says, "Rejoice. You are the eye. Lead the cult to victory. To begin, call for your disciples. If any declared, go clockwise through all players. Then nominate your chosen hand. Reveal the mission and pass this tablet. Receive your virtues and choose one for the mission. And I think I will start by choosing Bailey to my right. Yes.

Oh my goodness. Thank you so much. I'm the hand. So that means I get this nifty token which lets everyone know that I'm the hand this time and so I can't be the hand next mission. Yeah.

Just Plus, it's just nice to have an accessory.

Yeah. A badge that shows you're into hand stuff.

Exactly. And I've been looking for a badge like that for quite some time.

Let's reveal our first mission. Okay. Commence branding of the newcomers. This is achieved through conviction or dominion. A really strong start for the cult. I'm excited.

Important first step. Ify, do you want to explain what the brand looks like, what the methodology is going to be while I look in my virtues and see if we can do this?

Oh, yeah. A lot of people think that it's, you know, kind of like a astrological maybe like Pisces hands on, but it's really a 69. It's it's give and take, you know. It's not you're not coming in here and just only, you know, here for your pleasure. It's for everyone's pleasure. Um, that is the life cycle of our

69 is the yin and yang of this cult.

Yes. Well, I have given you two of my virtue cards. You get to keep one just for you and then the other one is going on the mission.

All right. So, hopefully you gave me either conviction or dominion.

I hope I did, too.

And you did. So, we accomplish.

Y start cuz there's 10 types of virtue, right? Yeah. And sometimes you can fail a mission and you mean well, you just don't have the right stuff for it.

You shouldn't necessarily be suspicious of people who fail.

Yeah. But we shouldn't.

Yeah. We didn't get the right like what B12 lotion that you put on after

get a big scar.

Failure is not an end here. It's simply a pathway to new beginnings. If we fail, we get to draw a virtue card.

Okay. That's right. All right. So, we'll pass that your way. I am the eye.

And I'm going to pluck mine out just to prove that I'm into this cult. You do it dare me. I'll do it. I'll do it. No one. Okay. But if anybody asks me to, I will. One person asked me to. And I will pluck out.

Okay.

Set precedent.

What I'm going to ask is does anyone want to play any disciples?

Oo, not yet.

Still safe.

Okay. John, you seem really enthusiastic. I should keep both my eyes. So, would you be the hand?

Yes.

I did enjoy the branding.

That was my favorite picture.

Enjoy your hand stuff.

Here's your hand. So,

thank you. You're into hand stuff now.

Lovely. Perfect.

Uh, well, we should see what we have to do.

Manufacture sacred garments achieving prosperity or devotion. I'm imagining a sort of thong.

Yes.

Yeah.

And that's it. And

it goes different for Britishers. It starts over the shoulders, goes all the way down like a manini. Goes all the way down back up the other side.

And then it does go up the butt crack like an American thong.

It goes right up the whole

It goes over the butt crack. It It works as dental floss.

Something we worship.

It all comes together full circle just like us.

Yeah. Like a borat. Borat wears out. Right. Exactly. Can we please put Borat image right here for that just in case

people don't know what I'm talking about.

And now can we please

put it on Teao's body?

Yes.

I actually do own one of those because it was like a sketch at UCB where me and Lamar had to wear that and I just have it now.

Oh yeah, you have it. You didn't wear it?

Well, I mean I wore it for the sketch. I wore it on

We've all written sketches just to buy something. I didn't write the sketch. I didn't write the sketch. I was just, you know, assigned it.

Do we

The face is telling me I might not enjoy this uh ritualistic manufacturing of garments.

Oh. Oh. Prosperity and devotion. And these are not those.

But don't like we said, we're not going to read into failure as something that's suspicious.

I will. I am.

You don't have to. I will. You don't have to. I don't have to. I'm choosing to. You said that. We never said anything like that.

It's almost like you anticipated you were going to fail regardless of what the card was.

I feel like we all agreed with that.

Hey, well, let's not all decide we're going to fail before YOU

and we succeed. No, just kidding. I want us to remember who failed this for us. So, I'm going to say it's Dom Minion pretty good. That's his name.

Because you failed, you and Becca both get to draw a card. I'm not mad at that part. So maybe you won't fail next time and you'll learn a lesson from this.

Maybe. Maybe.

Yeah.

If Dom gets one more shame, he won't get to do missions for the rest of the row.

Well, I love shame new people all over.

Piling on. That's what cults are all about, right?

Shame me out of the rest of the This is outrageous.

Don't let him shame you out OF SHAMING HIM. NOW I HAVE TO GO WITH IT. Shave shake shave shave shake shave shave.

Thoroughly welld deserved stuff. This is great. I gave you all those maninis as well.

No, you failed to make the maninis. Rub it.

Yeah, they were made with hemp, so they're real itchy.

Just we just we just couldn't get the materials we needed. Okay.

I went with my It's not my fault. It's not my fault.

Unbelievable. Well, I'm going to make tea.

Thank you.

Oh, did anyone play Disciples?

Oh, yes.

Sorry. Does anyone want to play Disciples

or indeed shame anyone else?

Yeah. No, I'm I'm holding on. Oh, great. Then I will.

Thank you.

You are the hand.

I am the hand. Where's the hand token right here? I already have it.

Yes. Very good. Very good.

And what we'll need from you is uh commence doomsday celebrations.

Very good. Pleasure. or foresight.

Those two things go together for sure.

They do. They do.

So, Sully, what's the commence doomsday celebration look like? What are you envisioning for this party?

Well, we're going to need balloons. We're going to need uh party poppers. Uh

well, okay. Of all kinds.

We need every type of popper we can find. and um

jalapeno and other. Yes.

Will there be a a parade?

Uh a little parade. Yes. Yes. Yes.

We do have our cute hemp outfits.

We're shaving but look good.

Fashion.

What's our doomsday?

What's our doomsday?

What's our doomsday look like?

We're celebrating doomsday.

Yeah. Yeah. What the actual how the world will end, do you mean? Or Yeah.

How um I think it'll uh be be sucked into a black hole.

Oh. Oh yeah,

but we'll be sucked.

Yeah. Oh yes,

we will be sucked.

We'll be sucked off involve a lot of sucking and holes.

I just had a big stink about failure AS

I will just say sometimes you draw bad virtues.

Mhm.

Well, well, well.

Is there enough shame left?

I know you have failed us.

Wow.

I think you should be shamed.

Yeah.

Can I still shame you if I'm shamed? The shame. The shame fool can shame.

As long as you have the shame, you can shame.

That's how shame works.

It's fun to be the third one.

It really makes a difference.

Okay. Appreciate it.

Fair. Your hands are officially tied

and not in a sexy way. In a way you don't like.

Stop enjoying this so much, Tao. The

rope is too loose.

I hate this.

This is not hot. This is not hot.

I can get out of here. So we can if I'm shamed I can we I can still be the eye but I can't be the hand.

Correct.

Exactly.

So do our eye.

So I can still look but I cannot touch.

Yeah. That's that's perfect. Perfect.

Well, Becca made such a big deal out of how imperfect my handling of the situation was. Maybe she'll be able to show me how it should be done.

I can do this.

I can use your hand stuff token. Hand stuff for me. What is the mission?

Harass those who mean us harm.

It's achieved through justice or dominion.

It's kind of classic.

Kind of dead.

I think we're going to uh go outside of our cult headquarters. There's a bunch of protesters there.

And we're just going to fling dildos at them.

This is good. This is good.

Okay. So, justice or dominion. Oh, no. Oh, the card I gave up.

Okay. Okay.

You told me you haven't got the card.

I don't have the card. I don't have the card. I gave it up.

It's a shame.

You gave it up for a bit.

For a bit.

This cult is trying its best, but I'm starting to think we may have some cracks at the seams.

There's a lot of friction. There's a lot of friction.

A lot of friction. And not the fun kind that we like. The bad kind that we don't like. Right.

We need to lubricate this friction away. We've got to lubricate this cult. And we'll start by getting rid of the cards that I have duplicates of.

I'm really sorry, you guys.

Uhoh. Let's hope this is the emotional Vaseline we need.

Well, uh, evangelism isn't going to cut the mustard, I'm afraid. Not for harassment.

WORSHIP THESE.

WELL, both of you get a virtue card, so maybe we won't fail next time. Yeah, we would have got it,

but it doesn't mean we failed the Oh, you as well.

Oh, I forgot to pick up my virty card. And those of you who picked up for the last card get to pick up a second one for the whole round for the row. Got it.

Mhm.

It's going to be okay, everyone. We're going to get the next row. I'm I believe in us. I got a lot of cards now. So,

I believe in us and I believe in sex stuff.

Sex stuff. Sex stuff. I feel like we chant a lot about the sex stuff. We don't really do much. Yeah, I imagine we're all we're all actually too nervous.

I'd like to complain. We talk a lot about it.

All right. Before we can proceed into our next row of missions, we must take stock on our previous failures, everyone, please, let's close our eyes together. Now, while we're closing our eyes and discussing the minutia of the cult, our defectors may commune with each other to insert to

inserts a crisis of faith card in front of a believer of their choice.

So, everyone, I think one of the things that we need to reflect upon with the failures is that they weren't sexy enough. If we're going to fail, we've really got to take our clothes off when we do it.

How do you feel about that? I feel sometimes more clothes is freakier.

H interesting. Interesting. Expand on that.

Like a turtleneck, a snow pants.

Yeah. Then there's more to remove.

The spirit has moved me to say that we should count backwards from three together.

Okay. Three, two, one.

Someone's got a crisis of faith card in front of them. Who is it? It's Becca. Becca, what does it say?

You knew immediately it was me.

Well, I see it in front of you because of my eyes. I still will pluck one out if I have to. Just saying. I'll do it.

Now, Becca, what crisis of faith did you get?

I get to draw three virtues, making me look guilty. What's the name? What's the name of it?

Oh, gluttony.

Well, that makes sense.

Nice.

I think you know what? Let's just call this a win for the cult.

Win for the true believers.

All true believers.

I mean,

now you won't be able to embarrass yourself like you did last time and not have the right virtue.

Now, it will be awfully suspicious if you don't have the right virtue.

That's true.

Okay, I'm feeling good. We got some new stuff.

Okay, fantastic. That could have been worse. Mhm.

Let's move on to this market phase. We're going to indoctrinate some new disciples. See if maybe anyone can help us out by bringing just a little bit of new blood into the cult, so to speak. We're not going to kill anyone yet. So, our three out here right now, we've got the Herald, which will cost you three virtues. If you want to buy it, you choose the eye effective immediately. The twins costs one virtue, gain three virtues. Player with the fewest also gains three. Choose if tied. And the sage costs one. You get to draw four brand new virtues. put them right into your hand. Pretty good deal.

And of course that is going to start with Teao, our newest eye.

Ooh, I will go with the Herald.

Oh, bold.

Now, I believe the Herald was a form created by Dell Close. Correct.

Oh, look at the outsider.

We've been We've revealed the outsider. This costs five virtues. This round is over. You decide the outcome of the next mission. This cannot be played on the last row.

Whoa. Powerful

pony boy. Pretty scary stuff. I can't afford that. Too rich for my blood. I am going to do a little bit of spending though.

I'm going to spend one virtue

in order to pull the sage. That's a good one. I'd love to have some cards. We have revealed the artist, which is a steadfast card, meaning that its effect is enduring. Give X virtues to another player of your choice. Pretty good if you're on the good team.

Speaking of the good team, one, two, three, five.

Fast and loose with your virtue.

No defector is going to be running our game.

Yes, indeed. Yes, indeed. Indeed, Lee.

That's good because I think Ify's a true believer.

Yes. And I truly believe I'm putting a stop to any of the shenanigan.

The one we revealed is the enforcer. Costs two. Command one player to give you all but one of their virtues.

I'll take the twins. The twins.

And I will discard something I've got two of.

The prepper is what was revealed. Cost two. No one can steal virtues from you.

Ooh, that's really good.

Bad. I I think I might save my virtues. We found a lot of those. Yes. For marriage.

Um

Oh, we get to see what a cult marriage ceremony looks like.

It's going to be bloody.

Yeah. No, I'm going to I'm going to save cuz we failed three out of four because we didn't have enough virtues.

So, yeah.

Well, I would like to buy the prepper. Okay, that sounds like a good purchase if you're

on the good team.

We're all on the good, right? Just revealed another expensive card. The auditor costs five. See another player's faith.

That's good.

Pretty powerful. Would you like to make any purchases?

I will buy nothing.

Okay. I'm also going to pass.

I think I'm going to go with the artist.

Okay. so that I can uh help out folks.

All right, we've revealed the torchbearer costs one. Discard all three disciples from the top of the pool.

Oh, that's sinister that they're the torchbearer. I see.

They're burning people.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. Look at you with the story brain.

Welcome to Dominic Allen story brain. He's got a 100 stories in there.

Is that A LIVERPOOL ACCENT? I'M FROM LIVERPOOL.

I like Sully's advice. I want to be prepared for the next round. I'm not going to fail you all. I got some good stuff here.

Great. Have we all passed?

Have we all passed?

I believe I I will pass.

Okay. Okay. Good. Good. Good. Good. Good.

Then it is on to the disciples. Would anyone like to play their disciples?

Yes, I actually would like to play a disciple. I'd like to play the one that I just bought, the sage, to draw four more virtues. Freaking sweet.

Freaking sweet.

That'd be pretty helpful as we go into the next round.

Very nice.

Anyone else?

Yes. I'm going to choose me. And how many virtues do you have?

Three, four.

All right. The same seven.

Yeah.

Use the libertine. We both draw three virtues.

Smart,

my man. I'll see you in the room.

It's got a bed and it's got a bucket.

Do what you will.

Anyone else?

Anyone else?

I don't think I will.

Nope. I'm all good.

All right.

Should I pop the circle out of this eye?

No.

Okay.

I don't know. Seems like it should be there.

Yeah.

I really want to pop it out.

I know. I do.

Um

Oh, you could peek through it though. Yeah,

that would be fun.

Um, Bailey,

yes,

I think you had a success last round.

I did. I had my only success.

Then I will choose you as the hand.

Thank you so much. Where's my handst token, man? Indeed.

Thank you so much. I love hand stuff. Can

I reveal the mission?

Thank you.

Oops.

Oh, what is it? What is that?

Insane way to do that. Cut ties with all former burdens.

Some people call them friends. And this includes all pets and parents.

Yeah. And therapist.

Therapist. Are you going to get therapist?

What's like the phone call look like?

Oh, the phone call looks like, "Hey, mom and dad, get hand stuff now.

We love you. Please come on."

I'm doing hand stuff. You guys are anti- hand stuff. I'm doing hand stuff. Don't put the door back on your room.

Oh, fabulous. I I've brought to you beautiful gifts.

How we doing?

Uh, we got rid of all our burdens.

Dad, this is my family now.

And I keep the other one. Yes.

Okay, great.

Thank you so much. And now I'm the eye. And I can't choose myself as the hand. That's okay.

I have a lot of cards.

I do see that you have a lot. I want to redeem myself.

I Becca, you know, I'd actually love to give you the opportunity to redeem yourself. That's very compelling to me. Here I appoint you

my hand. And here I appoint you my hand stuff.

Okay, let's reveal that mission.

Really?

Train disciples to open the third eye. Pretty sexy. And that's achieved through mastery or foresight.

Hell yeah. We got this, y'all. I think we do. Now, what are we going to do to train the disciples to open their third eye? First of all, and this is a joke I made before we started rolling, but I'm going to say it again because it was funny then and it's going to be funny now.

You didn't have You didn't have to tell them that part. We would laugh again. We would laugh.

Everyone laugh anyway. If you check the bylaws, none of you should have four sides at this point.

Absolutely. It was

I had one attached.

Yes. All of them get attached to Becca.

Yes. It's okay to have a jar of them, though.

Yeah. Yeah.

Oh, certainly.

Just have a little

Wow, Becca.

Wow.

It's impossible for you to fail.

Becca has made it impossible to fail. Not that I would want to.

Wow.

Maybe I should have given her the option, but

I just think you should lose your foresight when you're 18 if you choose to. You know, that's my that's my take.

Well, I think we're going to lose our foresight right now by winning this round.

Fantastic. Great.

Pretty good. Wait, did we learn anything about training disciples to open the third eye?

We learned that some some minor surgeries involved.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah.

You put it in a jar.

Minor pass.

This is very exciting because that means that no matter what, we've succeeded this row. But if we succeed this mission, we get two success tokens, not just one.

So, does anybody want to use a disciple ability?

No. All good.

I can give the player with the fewest three. Who's got the fewest? many four seven five

I kind of want to have suspicions before I use it actually sense

how many tokens do we need to succeed at the our cult overall

we need five so if we have five blue tokens that's a win for the good team five red tokens is a win for the defectors but there's only four rows the final row right here is automatically worth double

but if there's a tie, then we get to keep going. And then at that point, it's just whoever has the most at the end.

Okay. And if the evil team wins, just a heads up, they're going to make a tell all documentary about us. So, we really don't know.

No.

No.

Becca, you especially don't want that footage getting out.

Who has the Netflix crew following them?

I can't believe I didn't notice the cameras before we started. I surgically put all these foreskins on my body and I don't know if I can get that removed before the documentary.

All right, Sullivan.

Oh yes,

it's time for some hand stuff.

Oh yeah.

I love it.

That's fantastic.

So for your mission

is now through devotion or justice we will cover up misdeeds of the faithful.

Fantastic.

So yeah, we're going to break all the UV lights. uh in town. We're going to Yeah. Yeah. We're going to get a big hose.

I'm on the edge of my seat.

Yes, indeed. Thank you. We just need devotion or justice.

Belly has so many cards. Surely one of those cards is going to be there.

It must be. Right.

It must be.

Yes. He made it so that it it was devotion and justice.

So, no matter what, we're going to win. Great job. Very good.

Okay. He's a that's a good player. I trust you. Thank you.

Um I trusted you anyway, but I thought

why not? Why not do that?

Tokens for the good.

Starting to doubt certain other people in this group.

Yeah, the people who are just like I don't know from them all the time.

I wasn't tested at all that that row. So, you know,

just because I still have my foresight and I believe children should keep their foresight.

Yeah.

All right, we've completed the row. It's time for us to again close our eyes in a moment of group meditation where hopefully no defectors will do anything like put a crisis of faith in front of a good player.

I would hate that personally as a good player. Mhm.

Can we talk about the food situation?

The next banquet.

Food situation.

I would like donuts.

You'd like donuts?

Well, that's good because we we've only been serving hot dogs so far. So, we got hot dogs into the donut.

Put them together. Yeah.

What about chili?

Or you can rub two donuts.

We just two hot dogs. We've got the one bathroom. We have to be considerate of the needs of the cult. The gastrointestinal needs of the cult. There's just the one room and one bucket. I know. Yeah. Maybe that's we expand the We can do more than one room. I don't think we need to. Yeah.

Whose idea was the bucket?

Oh,

everyone please a deep breath in and out. And let's count to three and we'll release.

Three 2 one.

It looks like Iffy's been given a crisis of faith.

Arrogance. Give all but one virtue to other players.

Oh no.

Okay.

Well, this makes look good.

Yeah. If also succeeded both of the three times, right?

Yeah. And I Well, jokes's on whoever gave this to me. I have a lot of doubles. Uh, so I will keep the one I don't have a double of. And do I just uh I guess one, two.

I don't think you have to give them out evenly. Okay,

great.

Perfect. Thank you,

Dom. twins on you.

I feel like I've been ostracized. I

for no reason.

I noticed that I'm always in the cup chair.

To be fair, you said it was your favorite chair.

Yeah, it is. It's not the most comfortable of all.

Well, you got to sit there for a long time depending on a lot of rights and rituals.

Am I Is this me?

Yes, you're the now. But before we proceed on our next row of missions, it's time to go shopping again. Yay. So, just a reminder, we have the enforcer, the auditor, and the torchbearer. Starting with Becca. Is there anything you want to buy over here?

Well, it's a good thing I turned in all my stupid outside world money so I could only trade in cult bucks.

And I got a good amount of them. What? Anything new? The auditor is five. See another player's faith. Uh, enforcer cost two. Command one player to give you all but one of their virtues. And of course, a torch fair. Discard all three from the top of the pool. Start a new.

What is the auditor holding? Some kind of

some kind of hat. Like a like a helmet to to test

like a truth device.

Yeah.

I think I want to do it just so I'm not out for the rest of the buying round.

Um, so I'll take the torchbearer.

Okay.

Okay.

And now we have the charmer. For two virtues, steal one virtue from every player.

Oh my goodness. Does Sally anything look interesting to you here?

I'm wondering whether I get that order to cuz it is handy.

Yeah.

Like handsy actually.

Oh yeah. Yeah. It's how you check the f invasive. It's a real procedure. Um yeah, go on. I'll I'll spend I'll spend five.

Well, I hope you're on the good team.

Yes. Yes. Trust me. Trust me. Trust me.

So, we've revealed the bureaucrat. It costs three. You choose the hand. M

left.

Agreed.

You know what? I might buy that bureaucrat.

Okay.

What do you think of that?

Everyone trusts me, right?

No.

And look at that.

And what did we reveal? We revealed the actor costs four. Steal another player's disciple.

I will buy that.

No drama.

Congrats on your sad card.

Thank you. I'm finally in. I get the screeners.

Okay, our revealed card is the psychic. It costs two. You can peek at the next mission card. I don't want to be out of the round. I love to shop. Women be shopping. So, I'm going to go with the charmer. I like that he has a guitar.

Yeah,

the lawyer. He is steadfast. He costs two. Every new mission success, you draw one virtue. So, success or failure, you're getting those cards.

Ify, what do you think? Interested?

I only have one virtue, so I'm out.

Okay. I love buying stuff.

No, I'm showing restraint.

Lovely.

And I'm also heavily restrained.

Very good.

Yeah, it's a good cult.

We cult is great. We had a great time. It's a good time.

Anyone make a documentary about us crazy dog cameras. It would suck to be dirty fun. The cameras

I'm not making a documentary. The cameras are for my personal use.

Oh yeah. Yes.

I love that you bring around shutters with you everywhere you go so you can peek through.

He's the ultimate [ __ ]

Have a set of blinds on some wheels.

Yeah. No matter where you are, you could be cut.

Don't look at me. Don't look at me. Don't look at me. focus on what you're doing with the with the with the socks or whatever it is.

Tom, does this mean you're passing?

I do tend to pass. Um,

passes straight, I think. Thank you for the clarity.

It's the beard.

I've also I've also passed, by the way. I didn't say that. You got a beard as well. That is true.

Uh, yes, I will pass.

Okay, then I will buy the enforcer. Ooh,

very nice.

Tony Soprano.

What is

Oh, command one player to give you all but one of their virtues.

Oh,

okay. Scary.

The anarchist. Every new mission failure, draw one virtue. Steadfast.

Dare I?

Yes. Yes, I do.

I going to spend two.

I'm going to do it really good. And I'm actually going to buy the lawyer cuz I believe we're going to have more successes than failures. And I want cards.

And we're going to need litigation against this documentarian.

Absolutely. So that has revealed the engineer. See another player's virtues and steal, too.

Ooh, very good.

All right. If he has passed, Becca has passed. Sully has passed. Dom has passed.

I passed.

I also pass.

It's now time to use our disciples, I think.

Yes. And there's only three potentially four missions left.

Yeah,

it sounds Becca, right? Yeah.

Oh, I am going to use the twins. Gain three virtues. Player with the fewest also gains three. I think that's really handy for

I just want to help you out ify cuz I feel like you're good.

Yeah, I'm going to use the auditor. I'm going to have a look at little domumbles faith.

Oh,

let's have a little look. I have nothing to hide.

Except for the fact you're a defector.

Except for the finger you have.

You can't just believe someone cuz they've got a British accent. Listen to me. I'm not a defector.

I'm a very faithful person.

Don't think I'm evil cuz I have a British accent. This guy's evil. Listen to him.

Evil Dom, did you want to play any of your cards?

Yeah. I'm going to use my thief. I'm going to swap virtue hands with another player. I choose uh Bailey.

Okay. You just want my three?

Yeah. And you can have my two.

Well, that's really interesting.

Interesting.

Oh, fantastic. Well,

well, I find that very suspicious and I'm going to shame Teao.

What? What? What have I done?

Please don't kick me out of the sex cult.

No, no, no. We need someone to shame you. You're going to say it for a long time.

Yeah. Yeah.

I will prove my goodness

by playing the actor and stealing Dom's bureaucrat.

And I choose the hand.

I steal a disciple.

I steal a disciple.

Nice.

Okay. I have very few cards, so I hope you all don't mind. I am going to use the charmer to steal one virtue from all of you. Please know it's for the greater good. Do we do a rando? I think just at random. Yes. Okay.

Here, take a pick. Oh my gosh. Thank you so much, Becca.

Thank you so much, Teao. Thank you so much, Sully. Thank you so much, Iffy. I feel much more prepared for our missions now. I feel charmed.

Beautiful.

I hope you all feel charmed. I played a beautiful guitar solo. You were all inspired to throw your cards at me.

I really needed that bureaucrat.

Oh, no.

Oh,

I bet you did.

Yeah. H. So, Teao is beyond suspicion. Is it back to me? Is it back to me? And

I think uh if you like to use any of your cards No. Becca, is there anyone that you'd like to use?

I'm going to do something random and burn those three people

so I can stay in the round just in case.

Yeah, that's good.

Um, so I'm using my torch bearer. Discard all three disciples from the top of the bride. They are gone. We've got the Reverend costs two. You and a player of your choice must both discard all disciples. The Professor costs three. When a non-steadfast disciple is played, draw one virtue. And the Renegade, force a player to discard one disciple of your choice. That costs one.

I'm going to play the Grifter.

Uh, so I choose a player and blindly steal three of their virtues. Well done. You've only just got three virtues.

You only got two. Yeah.

Did you spend one or three?

Oh, you had to give one up. Oh, never mind. I Anyway, thank you very much.

I would rather take them off you than off Becca. Who

feels like we have a lot of

I'd like you to take them. Good cult people here.

Yeah.

Yeah. It was all me.

Yep. And now you're So Okay, so it's back to me. I will Tony Soprano you.

Well, that's kind of evil of you, I'd say.

Yeah, I don't think so.

That's it. No defense.

That's a good I see what he did there.

That's a good point.

Good lord.

You just have the most.

I do. It's awfully evil of you. Well, why don't you go to Bailey cuz I'm good.

I'm also good.

Who's good or iffy? I believe you.

I think the good team is these three and me.

I'm not sure between these two.

Between I think they're both

the most I think I think they're both good.

You're going to have to successes.

Yeah,

I've only tried to get successes.

I'm trying to get on your team. He believes us. Who should I steal from? You tell me.

No, no, no. I think they're both good, so I'm not going to interrupt.

Okay, then Bailey, I will take your virtues, please.

Interesting. All but one you say.

I think you all need to be stopped.

I cannot believe I made it through with this.

I messed up. I sure messed up. You sure did.

Sometimes Tony Soprano makes a mistake. Okay,

sure freaking did.

He's not.

You are just canonically Tony Soprano. Well, I don't have anything really to do here, so I am going to skip and hope that there our mission is a success so I can get virtues.

Yes. Makes sense.

What's unfortunate is that I am the eye and I have so many cards and it looks like nobody else has.

Okay, wait a minute. Then I will then other

actually. Should I wait for it? So it skips Dom.

Why would you skip me?

He's such a cute little

I can choose the eye.

Oh

yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

I've been holding on to this since the beginning.

I think Becca's good, though. I think Becca.

Is it? Oh, we've already done our disciples this round. I was going to say I was going to request that you use your outsider now.

Um, okay. Who's got the most cards?

Well, now I have a lot.

Unfortunately, it's Teao, but

do I'm asking Sullivan and I iffy.

Should I give Teao a chance because he has the most cards?

Mhm. I think you should get

or should I take a bet on one of you two that I feel the most confident in?

Do how much variety do you have in yours? Cuz I I want to just X out.

I've got three and they're all different.

Okay,

that's it.

So,

I think go with Sully, I think. Yeah,

more than testing. I don't think not with two.

He just he is evil.

I am not evil. Bailey is evil or Bailey.

Yeah. Anyway,

I think Sully was right with who the good team is.

Um, okay.

So, living,

would you go look at that bucket with me?

Yeah, absolutely.

It's my favorite.

It's my favorite job.

Oh my goodness. God initiates in supplication ritual. So, this is where we clean the bucket.

We will need the bucket. Yes. either devotion or pleasure. So, you better enjoy cleaning those buckets.

Devotion or pleasure.

Maybe we make the bucket filled.

Yeah.

And the initiates, they got they got to take care of the bucket.

Yeah, they got to they got to clean it up. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, put those sponges away. You won't need those. But you will be cleaning it. Um, sadly, I'm no help. Oh, look at that.

Okay. I Hey, our chances were bad.

I've only got three. But we if we get one wrong, one right, we'll get a third try because it's a tie.

Unbelievable. When I haven't got the card, it's shame, shame, shame.

I can play this.

Also made sure this was good.

Oh yeah. To cover up to cover up the game.

Neither of these.

Although

our devotion skipping two would

we want Sully to be the eye. We don't want these two to be the eye. It's back to back. You can only play this.

You can choose me this time, but you can make it be a success.

Flavorwise, I think we're all big fans of foresight around here.

Yeah. Yeah.

Oh, but that's a fail, so I put it upside down.

Santa. Yes.

Yes. It's unfortunate, but don't forget to draw your cards if you if you didn't.

Oh. Oh, I guess I should um actually

Oh, yeah. I haven't.

Oh, no. Wait, hold on. Hold on. Hold on. I need this.

Yeah, keep that.

I'm keeping that for me. Um, you know what? There's there's some trust fund kids who were in the initiates bunch and tried to pay their way to a clean bucket.

Yeah. They tried to hire a a a a maid who almost snitched us out.

Yeah. No, no, no. So, that's why it's prosperity, which doesn't work here. We don't like the outside money.

Yes. No babies in the cult.

None. Okay.

Well, unless they give all their money to the culture. Duh.

Once again, between rounds, it is time to use our disciples. Mhm.

Well, I have no disciples, so it moves on.

I will play the bureaucrat.

What does it do?

Uh, you choose the hand.

Wow.

And I believe I can choose myself.

You can feel free to do that.

I'm doing it to prove that I am good.

I'm not going.

Give me a chance to prove that I am good.

Yeah, you don't. You will not get a chance because I will play the outsider where the round ends and I decide the outcome and that's when I reveal that I am evil

because the outcome is that we fail.

I trusted you.

What a crazy play.

Sorry.

Tao, you were so good.

No, he's not though. Teao's with me. I don't know what if he's doing.

Is it one or is it two? because they won the whole round.

THEY WON THE WHOLE ROW.

So then we need to Good needs to win this.

But I'm the eye.

We've lost that. That means

actually we're not there yet. So first we're going to close our eyes.

Oh no. Oh no. We

We're going to close our eyes. No way.

And we are going

Is there any need really

to take a deep breath?

That have already revealed themselves are going to decide where the final crisis of faith is going to go. And we are not going to stress about it.

And we're not going to have a hard time with it. And it's going to be okay. I don't even know why they're trying to be subtle at this point.

Okay, we're going to count backwards from three.

Wait, let me sit down.

Three, two, one.

Yeah, that makes sense.

Oh my goodness, Bailey.

I received a card. That's the uh indifference card. Return my disciples to the pool. Guys, we can still win this.

Dom is the eye. I think we need to all shame ify if we're good. So iffy can be chosen as the hand.

I can choose the eye

or that.

Whichever.

But also we're we we're back to buying, right? We're back to

Oh, sorry. They went back to the pool. They didn't go back into this card pile. That was

Oh, yeah. You get to choose what goes on top.

Did we all get to draw a card for failing the failing the

We do also all get to draw a card for failing the row. Thank you for the reminder, Dom. That was actually very uncharacteristically good of you.

We'll let you keep peeking through the blinds for a little while on

women be shopping. Does anyone want to indoctrinate some disciples? Currently, we are showing the siren who costs one. The professor who costs three. When a non-steadfast disciple is played, draw one virtue. And of course, the lawyer costs two. Every new mission success, draw one virtue. And then the siren is, of course, skip the round immediately. Next player becomes the eye. Well,

and you get to choose first.

First,

huh?

I've only got one card, so I can only afford the siren, which would mean I could skip the round immediately.

I'm going to buy the siren, I think.

Okay.

Oh, no.

Don't worry. You haven't played this yet. And we have all our shame cards. Good. Can still take this.

I believe in us. We're so good. We love doing sex stuff.

Well, you don't like it the way I like it. And that's my problem. I have a I have a question though. Hypothetically, if I was a defector

in theory and I skipped this round immediately, what would happen?

The the next person would get the eye. So, it wouldn't it doesn't skip this. It just skips the eye.

Oh, I see. I see.

It wouldn't be advent. I think so.

All right. So, we now have the reverend. You and a player of your choice must both discard all disciples.

I will buy that.

All right. Very nice.

Goodbye,

Taylor. I always knew you were good.

I've been saying it since the first moment.

Very beginning.

This has revealed the protector. You are immune from crisis of faith. I'm not even going to say how much it costs. Whatever.

Useless now.

I am not going to spend. I'm going to keep my cards.

All right. Let's see. And then I'll see what's under the protector. Let's see. So, I'm going to go ahead and just draw six virtues. Give one to another player. That's pretty cool. It costs two. Becca, what do you think of that?

Do you Do you want them?

No, I don't. I actually think that we have a good I have a a good game plan for us to win. And it involves you keeping your cards.

Oh, no. I need to spend some cards. We don't need all these cards.

I think I will pass.

I'm going to also pass.

Who do we think should be the hand? Uh, I think it should be Becca, but I do think

it's disciple time, baby.

Starting with Dom. Are there any disciples you'd like to play?

I mean, there is, but not in this order. So, I'm going to say no.

No.

Mhm.

Then I will play the Herald.

Let me take that.

And

remind us the text.

Yes. You choose the eye. Effective immediately. Who do you choose?

That's great.

I will choose if he's good.

Yeah. I will choose myself to then give the hand will be to Becca.

There we go. I see. Right. Because you're the I I keep mixing up the body parts. They're all hot.

I plucked out my hand by accident. I don't have any disciples to play for some reason.

Uh yes. I none of my disciples can be played, so they're they're just uh steadfast. They're here with me.

I'm just in awe. I've never been so reliably good in a game. Wouldn't it be funny if I was the defector? Uh,

pass.

Yeah, I I also will pass. But should we shame people?

We could just do it for fun.

Yeah,

we could.

Yeah. Should we shame Dom?

He'll love it.

Yeah, because that means he can't be the hand. Let's go for it. Three shamed.

Three shamed.

Just in case.

You're shamed.

You've been shamed.

Consider yourself shame. Me?

I saw what you did through those blinds.

No, that was hot and cool. And just to rub it in, I will also reverend you.

Oh, please rub me in.

You and I will discard our disciples.

Oh, YOUR DISCIPLES.

OH, that's a beautiful one. Two punch. Tio, you are good. I'm sorry I ever doubted you.

So good.

Really irrelevant. Really cruel.

Really pointless.

Really pointless rubbing.

I believe we've all passed. You've appointed yourself the eye. You really dry

the hand.

Yay.

Final hand sub token. Hopefully

hopeful. And what are the odds?

Pray everyone. Pray everyone.

Would you like to see a mission?

I don't. Yeah. Should we let Don flip it?

No, you can't flip it.

Damn.

He's a genius.

He is switched it out with his mind powers.

You must share sips of the prophetic tea. If you fur recyc you've got to have those

mama like

mama like

rubbish.

All right. Um share sips of the prophetic tea. Anybody know what we're steeping?

Well, foresight I think it says in there.

Pure foresight in your tea.

I like my tea with pulp.

I put my purity right in there, too. Well, that's a health hazard and we can talk about that later.

No health department. Don't let them in.

You should.

No choice here. We're sipping on foresight tea.

I put them both in.

Sip. Sip. Sip.

HOGEN FOR THE GOOD.

COME ON. FANTASTIC.

SHOULD WE DO IT?

YES.

I think so. Yes. Because it's time.

Four is more than three. Four is more than three. More than three.

Oh my gosh. Oh my goodness.

Good. How do you feel? We're tax exempt. The nation sees us as a legitimate religion even though we were not even hiding the sex stuff.

Do we have a giant building on Hollywood also?

Ooh. Can we paint it blue?

At least a dozen.

We probably own everything on the block

and several weird billboards.

Do you guys have Scientology over there or don't believe it? That was a very fabulous, intriguing, and deceitful game.

Wait a minute. We haven't revealed our secret cards yet.

Oh my god, you're so right. You forgot my review alignments. The most important thing in a social deduction game is, of course, finding out if you were right all along. Now, let's reveal who our defectors were. We've got everybody out. There we go. Yep. I'm a true believer.

I WAS A DEFECTOR.

WHAT? YOU READ IT wrong if you wanted to see that. But I did I did think you were so good up until

I know it was like there was no way to

show you public no way to like do that without like I was like if you if I do the card I'm going to reveal it and since it was double I was like well then we just have to have the gamble and I didn't even want to because yeah I think I would be like yeah choose Becca because Becca had so many but that just would feel too evil. So I think he

I think he made the right move at the exact right moment. Had Teao not had the perfect disciple, you guys would have won because Dom was the eye on this last card.

It was a close game.

It was a very close game, but fortunately, good triumphs over evil and the

Colts prevails.

Go Colt. Go. Go. Go Colts. Go.

I'll get you next time, Colts. Uh, thanks again to Pillbox Games for sponsoring this rousing rendition of All True Believers. If you're interested in the game, you can check out all the info you need at the link below. Thanks to my fellow players and deceivers. I'll trust you again one day. I will. I promise. Maybe. Uh, and thanks to you, of course, for watching. Uh, be sure to support us on Patreon. Links down below as well. And always remember, when in doubt, do hand stuff. Yes. Hi everyone.

Should we do our secret handshake? Everybody in. Everybody in.

That's a good a very tidy button.

Progress saved