Humanity - Board Game Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about Humanity which is designed by yoanne levit and published by bomx who did provide us with this review copy but the thoughts in this video are all our own humanity is a resource management tile placement game in which you are astronauts setting up a base on Titan the largest moon of Saturn but let's not get too much into it now let's take a closer look at how it plays you start the game with a small collection of buildings a bit of rubble that will need to be cleared and a few astronauts each turn you can do one of two things either turn an astronaut at your base to gain resources so for example this level two astronaut could get you one ice and one food AKA bugs or you can place an astronaut on any space of the market and pay the cost for either the module or the experiment at that space if it's a module place it in a space your ashnut came from if it's an experiment gain its benefit and place it with your other experiments benefits will let you do things like moving up the science track resetting the astronauts at your base or moving your astronauts in the market closer to the arm this last one is important because after each round a couple of modules are discarded and then the arm is moved clockwise and any astronauts that end up
on or behind it get to come back to your base you keep doing this until there are no more modules of the current ERA left to refill the market and then you check the science track and players gain secret game end points according to their position you do all of this again for a total of three eras gaining points along the way for buildings connecting experiments together and the three shared goal tiles and then when the last draw pile is empty you also get a few points points for your leftover resources and reveal your secret science points and then the head of the Titan science department is named so let's kick this off by talking about the components cuz the components are phenomenal in this game like every part of this is so nice the people these little um astronaut people are amazing looking and everything works so well too like they really thought about what it does like this little tile wheel because you slide this tile arm around and then that decides when you pick up people but it's such a great Market mechanism and then it works so nicely because this is just inset a little bit and all of the art is so nice and clear there's just there's no part of the presentation that I don't like yeah it does work really nicely functionally the fit of it is just so smooth and the tiles all are really clear but they look good too like
when you are building out your base all the different colors and even like the different shapes of the buildings that all looks really nice as well and it's just really amazing with like the rule yeah the rule book is ridiculous yeah this is incredible so this copy was in French so all of our stuff is in French but it has like real science stuff and pictures and stories behind each of the individual like astronauts that you are yeah and then all of the Science Background to like what would happen if we actually did a trip to Titan and how would we actually set that up and how how are these different resources work and all of that is tied into the game too this is a fairly simple game so the rule set to this is fairly simple so don't expect you're doing like every step of a trip to Saturn this isn't like like vatel Asser is like on Mars kind of thing but you definitely get like a bit of the sense of it and that the resour resources are stuff like it's um it's electricity water and then uh food but food is bugs cuz food would be bugs which I have a hard time with but I understand it yeah and other tiles that you start off with are these obstacle tiles that look like craters and even between for those ones between the four different players those all look different as well and I play Yellow which unfortunately has the the more boring version of it but I do appreciate that they look different and then as you're building out your base it all
fits together so nicely and when you have all four of them and you can put the onepoint token in again that's such a perfect fit so let's talk a little bit more about the like actually playing the game and kind of the strategies and how it plays outside of the literal how it plays and it has some interesting mechanics like this little market system of when you put down your guy this arm swings around around a certain amount depending on how many of these clear out but the big thing is if your guy so if a few of these are gone and your gu is a bit too far and this swings around you don't get them back for the next round and that's a big thing about deciding do I want to take one that's far away but I really need or do I want to take one that's close enough that I'm going to pick up that guy and then have three workers for the next round yeah if you're a one worker short you really miss out cuz you won't be able to use them to get the resources or use them to send them out again but you're often competing with the other players for the tiles so it could be worth going really far and you might get lucky cuz if everyone is going out or in two-player game if two astronauts are going out and getting tiles that means that arm is actually going to swing quite a bit more that you might be able to go pretty far and and still come back if enough tiles are purchased so there is a lot to consider for which T you want knowing that your astronaut might also be left
there and one thing that can help you as well in that decision is that some of these science experiments they let you move your guys back on this track as well so if you can time things right you can go a little bit further then by one of the experiments and then move yourself backwards so that you get picked up by the arm and that can be a really satisfying combo yeah the science experiments I think keep it more interesting it adds that extra layer because you have a lot to decide for like what tiles you want and whether you're sending somebody out or you're using them at the base to be able to gain resources I think it's really clever how you gain Resources with like just rotating the tiles but the science experiments not only could they maybe move you your people on the this part forward but they might be able to reset the people at the base so the timing of when you get those can get you an extra resource turn and there's also there's other bits in play as well CU we are talking about how it's important of the tiles that you're getting and putting out a big part of that is you've got these three goals that you're kind of fighting out over throughout the game and often well at least two of those have to do with the tiles that you have out and where they're placed and as soon as you get one more and whatever that goal is you steal it from the other player so if it starts at you need three diagonals if you get four diagonals you've got it then they need to get five diagonals to take it back but those are worth three points each so that's like a six-point swing in this game our scores
tend to be around the 40 point mark So six points is an enormous difference in this game so those are a big part of the the interaction in this and they really play a big role in what we do yeah we just had a game where you had to have four yellow tiles connected we got up to 10 so we kept handing it backwards and forwards and backwards and forward and competing right to the very end for that TI and that made the difference in the end yeah yeah it's and I wasn't happy about that because Jess ended up winning by two points so if that had gone the other way it would have been four points for me oh it's it was so close and I'd never won this so I almost won it but let's talk a little bit about the replayability too because that is kind of the big it's really the main point of variability is you've got a bunch of those different scoring tiles and those are going to make you know a slightly different Focus each time not a hugely different Focus it's going to be like am I doing yellow tiles or blue tiles or green tiles um and are they going to be like a diagonal or straight across so that's not going to have like the huge huge impact but it does change things a little bit and then there's also obviously the market how things come out and when the the different science experiments and how that all works yeah and for for the goals there are six for each of the three sets so that is enough of difference like I agree with you though that it's not a massive difference but it does shift your focus a little bit the market is certainly the the biggest one what the other players
are doing as well if they're buying a lot of tiles and and meaning you'll be able to go farther there isn't like different player variability so they have this great thing with the different stories for each of the different astronauts but that doesn't correlate to having like a special power that you get to have in the game yeah each character it's it's not asymmetric in any way but you know it doesn't need to be like basically this is a tile placement game this is a tile placement game that also has a market part of the game and competing for goals which is in a lot of tile placement games but it is a really clever tile placement game I just I think perhaps the box and the presentation might lead people into thinking this is a little bit of a heavier game than it is and this is very rules light like and I think that's one of the terrific things about it is we've got a rule book in French Jess can mostly read French I could read French if this was just about like grapefruit and how to get to the library and otherwise I'm mostly lost and that barely comes up in this rule book but even with that we you know we printed out the English rules we read them once we've never needed to look at them again because the back of these player boards has enough and you need so little to remind you of every single thing that you need to do because it's really just you're gaining resources you're spending resources and so it's ve like it's a very easy teach very very simple game but there is quite a bit of thinking in that like we have some really thinky
turns even within that light rule set yeah it is a really light rule set it means we don't have to go back and look at a bunch of things and clarify things but there are enough decisions and one thing we hadn't mentioned too is the astronaut that you send out to get the tile that tile has to go where that astronaut is so that's another decision of when they're coming back back is where you want them to go because you're restricted to putting out a tile where where they are as well so between putting your astronauts out choosing what tile you're getting the different types of tiles because there's enough different types between the the resources the research and and and all of the science experiments and everything it does lead to some interesting decisions so even though it's really approachable and maybe lighter than a big experience I I think there's a lot of doubt here as well and that science is an interesting thing too so a part of the game as well is that you're trying to gather up this science to move up this science track and then at the end of each age you're scoring that science well that kind of brings us to player count because the science track scores a little bit differently depending on the player count at the end of each of the the years whoever is furthest ahead gets an extra point so at two players you get two points at more than two players you get the number of points for how many people are behind you and so at two players it's really a competition so we're always going big on science yeah and I think that that is kind of the big difference because you
use actually the same number of tiles in a two in like regardless of the number of players so it's really just going to be slightly lower scores in a four-player game versus a two-player game yeah cuz you'll have less tiles so your base will be a bit smaller I would imagine that at three player you're probably each going to try and almost gun for one of these goals instead of competing as well whereas at two they're pretty heavily contested I I feel like at higher player counts you'll just like really focus on getting at Le one just wrap one of them up yeah I don't we've only played this at two so we are just kind of spitballing how we feel it might go at three or four but these are so important I don't I don't think you can get by without winning at least one of those but at two players you definitely can't get by without winning at least one of those yeah and and likely it's the person who's won two of them that is going to be probably the winner in the end so let's talk about who this game is for and this is a little bit of kind of a tweener kind of game where it's a little bit light in terms of its rule set but it looks like it's kind of a heavier game but it does have like a a fairly large decision space within the lightness of its rules so it's a little bit hard to place who exactly is the audience yeah maybe would it qualify it under that Gateway plus category cuz it's maybe a little bit heavier than that so I definitely wouldn't recommend it for brand new Gamers there is a lot of decisions and I think it would just
be that step too complicated but if people have enjoyed some tile placement games some Resource Management games and they're looking for a bit of that next step I think this is just really interesting with the resource management the tile placement and the market so maybe along those line or for people who do like heavier games who appreciate that lighter rule set that play time of an hour being able to get a a full Rich game but in a short time which I think is us like we really like that sweet spot of an hour Play Time a light rule set but still like a thinky puzzle yeah and I think this is what this is kind of a nice gateway to is those heavier bigger decision- making games because this does have that decision space and it does have those kind of satisfying Combos and like those smart plays where you've put your guy just a little bit out of the range of the arm and then you've bought that experiment that brings him back so that he's going to get picked up by the arm and then you get the other experiment that like lets you reset your other person and I think that's great and also that it isn't going to go so long because you're only ever going to have three workers so even if you manage like the perfect combo you maybe get to do five actions and probably three of those ACS at least are just turning things yeah so it's you're never going to be waiting that long for your turn yeah I also really appreciate that it just feels really positive I don't get super frustrated and I think
part of that is if I can't buy a tile I and I have somebody on my base I can always get resources so there's always something I can do even if it's just setting myself up for a future turn and I think also the the theme is is great and it does kind of come out in it as as well and it's nice that like the tiles are nice but also they're like functional like these look like real science buildings and they're just on like a dirt planet and I kind of appreciate that that it's like it's cool and the science is cool and it's got a little bit of that like Stanley kubric Space Odyssey feel to it a little bit but it's not like outrageous you can look at this and think yeah okay maybe we could do that yeah and the components too are phenomenal so if you like tile PL placement games Resource Management an interesting market system this one could be well be worth checking out and that is it that is Humanity thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you've played Humanity or what your favorite space tile placement game is and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game he