I, Napoleon - A Bone to Pick with Bonaparte? - TCbH Review
Transcript
say same say muffin say better say foree
magn iolan is the new solo only board game by g&t games where you take on the role of the titular Emperor Napoleon bonapart living through his turmoils and victories each round you'll draw cards that will put future events into motion and then you turn your attention towards his military campaigns across Europe and the Mediterranean the goal of this game is to make you feel like Napoleon bonapart and I think it mostly does that but that leads us to a discussion of what's more important the magic circle or having fun we'll get back to that later but first let's take a look at this game every round in this game consists of drawing cards and following their text sometimes being forced to put them into effect immediately other times being given the option of enacting them now or later your goal is to gain as much Glory as possible and hopefully put an air on the throne to follow in your footsteps before you get to the throne though you have to work your way there in the first age of I Napoleon the commander age Napoleon's role as a cog and machine beholden to hire bureaucratic Powers is on Full display your choices in this age only affect the game to put into motion events way down the line sure there are battles to fight and glory to be had but the choices of which battles to take on are not yours you'll randomly stumble upon them as you draw through the deck with no way of anticipating when they'll sneak up on
you once you've taken over's first console you get a lot more agency but you also have to start paying attention to the domestic and foreign politics of France you can only ever lose Glory but you can kind of mitigate it by spending some of your attention and luck away from battles and more on keeping the general populace happy if you reach the first consolation age which I do say if because you can die in the commander age if you reach the first console age you get to choose what campaigns you fight you no longer have to rely on the deck to give them to you wage Wars successfully and you get glorious Glory lose Wars and you are more likely to become a minor footnote in history and now's probably a good time to go into how the combat system in this game works and why I think it's great and why I think it makes the game not for me when you enter combat you take note of any campaign modifiers that entered play through randomly drawing them from the deck and add those to the dice roll modifier referred to as DRM in the game you then can assign commanders to this combat paying their price now usually in administrative points but occasionally in political sway or your own Glory these commanders interplay randomly from the deck and you're going to want a lot of them probably after spinning your points to assign commanders to this combat you then can activate them once through all rounds of combat hopefully combat only lasts one
round with a bloodless Victory but more likely you'll end up with a bloody Victory which really upsets the people of France or you get a stalemate which means you need to do another round of combat right now to determine the actual winner of this conflict and getting a stalemate also upsets the people of France which makes you more likely to fail your domestic policy role later in this round if there's a second round of combat you don't get to use those commanders you got Boost from again so you can either have from the start assigned more commanders than you could possibly need in the first round paying their cost just in case or use strategy and tactics cards that are also a one-time use per combat the almost push your luck mechanic of only trying to spin what you have to works great and is one of the few ways I feel the player has of affecting the game so if I think the combat system is great why do I say that it makes this game not for me it has everything to do with these modifiers you can only ever get to plus four on your modifier and it just always makes sense to do that because the margins for victory are so small you have to get a seven or higher just to get a victory and a ner higher to get that bloodless victory that will keep the people of France a little less upset and the consequences for failing
to get a victory are almost always so astronomically high in my opinion losing glory is always a a a price that I'm not really willing to pay in this game but because the consequences are so high it always makes sense to spend whatever cost it takes takes to make sure you get that plus4 dice roll modifier and it kind of goes hand inand with my other big issue with this game which is the player choices kind of make themselves it for example the card drawing mechanic in this game also feels like it takes a lot of the choices out of the player's hand each round you'll draw between five to 12 cards with the variability based off of a die roll after your first card draw on average I got about eight cards per round I'd say this mechanic has a cool back and forth as early in the game I felt like I wanted more cards drawn to get things into position for later but at the end I was hoping the rounds would end before more damage was done each card has instructions on what to do with it some have mandatory must place in xpot While others give you an option of whether or not you want to place it now or or let it filter back into the deck to hopefully save you from a worst card down the road because you can't see what cards are about to be drawn or sometimes
even what cards are in the deck it is really tough to make any sort of plans in this game at the first console era you are kind of hoping for the best but you don't really have much say player agency is really low that's kind of because it's supposed to be you're playing as Napoleon who is being the commander of an army he's not actually on the battlefield in this iteration he is in his War Room miles away from any conflicts and just kind of waiting to hear back on reports of whether or not his team won or lost a battle and that's kind of fitting for what he actually did most of the time he wasn't on the battlefield himself with a sword swathing down waves and waves of Russians and prussians and austrians he was in his throne room doing domestic politic things and not really being on the battlefield like he really wanted to be and in a similar way in this game you can't control the randomness of what cards you are pulling you just pull them and kind of hope for the best some years playing this game you end up with nothing happening you just draw five cards that all go to campaign modifiers because they must be placed there and
you didn't get a say in that but then you don't actually draw a campaign and you don't have a campaign that you can do and so at the end of the year all things just revert back to the way they were and now you're you're one year older and that's just kind of how rounds in this game go you can't really choose what you're doing a lot of the time at least in the first console age the emperor age is where my choices actually started to feel like they mattered you can maneuver yourself in positions where different campaigns are forced to happen you can break treaties to make sure you go to war with Austria and with the end so close in sight all of the sacrifices of glories you have to make begin feeling much more important there's a game mode where you jump straight to the emperor era and I think that's pretty good first of all it cuts the play time down my first playthrough from start to finish took about 6 hours total the game box estimates between 1 and 4 hours though I think without an early death you're more likely to end up closer to the ladder when I played the imperor scenario that wrapped up in about 90 minutes or so it puts you at more of a disadvantage than you otherwise would be as the game state is worse than if I played through the commander and first console era on my own but that was a trade I was willing to make to get to the more interesting parts of the game the game can end in a handful of ways a card might tell you the game ends likely with Napoleon dying or abdication is another way where you voluntarily
with quotation marks around that step down from the throne or you could get the Holy Grail reaching the limits of glory and enacting peace across Europe with an air on the throne afterwards you check a little table in the rule book and it tells you basic on how your game ended and what what the board state was how good of a job you did and then after you read that you say Thank you Mr rulebook I also think I am the greatest leader since Augustus and then you pack the board game away it's not the most climactic ending to a 4our long board game but at the same time I do kind of appreciate it in the sense that all of the marks uh that you can reach in that table are really hardfought victories that you have to claw your way to it is difficult to get some of those achievements just based on how the game naturally develops and I appreciate that there was something to reward me even when I felt like I didn't do that great of a job and likewise you can die very early on in this game and so just reaching any of those Laurels is an accomplishment in and of itself and now I'm going to return to a discussion that I brought up at the beginning which is the magic circle versus having fun now the magic circle
is a concept that I've adapted from uh the rules of play which is a textbook on board game design that I really love in my version of it uh the way that I apply it at least is how much does a game make me feel like I am the person I'm playing as such as in Dune Imperium I do feel like I am a conniving Supernatural space politician most of the time when I play that game there has been so much work done in this game to make you feel like Napoleon you can tell how much passion went into creating this there is a reference book that is just the historical context for every single car in this game and there are a lot of cards in this game and it just goes to show how much was thought about when they made this game and I think it kind of gets in the way of the fun a little bit um there are a lot of cards in here that either the choice is obvious or the choice is made for you in a way that really takes away some of the agency kind of like how Napoleon's you know Bo boot on the ground agency was taken away when he became first console and Emperor and also like you know the domestic policy and foreign policy phases in this game are a headache and I sympathize with Napoleon because I had
to live through that as well I got glimpses of how interesting this game could be but there was just so much noise around it that I found it hard to filter through to the juicy decisions I have other solo games so when I compare this to the ones I already have I just don't think you will end up on my shelf that's not to say this game isn't for you there's a lot of neat things in here living through different timelines of Napoleon's life is a really cool concept and as a history nerd that peaked my interest big time I also loved how simple it was all the cards tell you what they do the only confusing part is the setup which really isn't that bad because all the cards tell you where they go it might not be for me but I am positive there's an audience out there that is going to love this game people who are maybe more into history than me people who kind of want a 4H hour long light role playing game that they can kind of turn their brain off for or people who are willing to look at a board and find the very small ways that they can optimize this and get as many points as they possibly can ring out of their army this game is going to be right at the rally and I think that if that sounds like you you should check this out for me though I'm probably just going to play a few rounds of Imperium Legends Classics or Horizons in the same amount of time it would take me to play a round of I Napoleon if I'm looking to
get a semi-historical solo board game fix that is my review let me know your thoughts down in the comments do you tend to lean more towards thematic engagement or have having fun thank you so much for watching thanks for being an awesome Community I am Eric with the cardboard Herold