Skip to main content
Loading video...

Spirit Island: Jagged Earth Expansion Review

Transcript 7:58

blighted and scarred at the hands of the invaders this once peaceful and verdant land was torn asunder but when nearly all hope was lost new spiritual protectors came to the island's aid fearsome mighty and adorable jagged earth is the kind of big box expansion that other big box expansions tremble in fear of pretty much doubling the content of the original spirit island it adds in 10 new spirits whole kits to support two additional players elemental tokens to keep track of well elements and more minor powers major powers events blight cards fear cards adversaries and scenarios then you can shake a stick at this beast has it all what's really striking about jagged earth for all its lovely girth is that it's really just a more stuff expansion i mean sure there are some new rules like isolation which effectively cuts off a land from adjacency to all other lands or there's badlands tokens which amplify the damage both to and from invaders in that land and some really wild ways of building separated islands from one another but it doesn't really change the fundamental avenues through which you're interacting with the game it just really adds on to what the base game and branching claw brought before though it takes care to include enough events and terrain tokens so that you don't actually need branch and claw to sit this baby on the table

but what's most impressive is the continued creativity through which eric royce has taken this same framework harnessed it in order to come up with even more absolutely wild and fascinatingly unique spirits which is a big part of what makes this game so special in the first place jagged earth's new spirits are every bit as compelling if not more so than the original eight all ranging from moderate to the new very high complexity rating you have spirit after spirit that continues to convey the unique blend of mechanical function and thematic translation that is oh so potent in this game you have everything from spirits who bend time and space to ghostly apparitions haunting the board with persistent damage to a specialist who cashes elements to spend on big powers each new spirit has been a joy to play finding how they integrate with one another how they match up with old spirits strengths and weaknesses with new and old adversaries surprisingly though of all the new spirits my favorites have been three of the moderate complexity ones and one high complexity many minds move as one is a flock of birds gathering and pushing animal tokens and long stretches across the island offering some of the best tactical control and support seen to date volcano looming high represents peak spirit island forcing players to approach problems in creative ways based on capabilities and limitations all reinforcing a theme because this dude just

builds and builds a literal tower of tokens then destroys them all to reign destruction around surrounding areas then we get to my lizard boys my two new favorite spirits in the game period vengeance as a burning plague and lure of the deep wilderness not only do i adore their artistic designs both have slower but consuming effects that unfold beautifully upon the island vengeance builds up plague tokens after plague tokens sickening the land to the point of inhospitality whereas lure is an angler fish lizard thing sort of an anti-hungry hungry ocean who breaks down cities and towns into their lesser parts lures the days the explorers into inland territories then how brutal wonderful perfect look if i'm being honest and you love spirit island which most people who at least like it tend to love it then this expansion is a no-brainer it has more of what's best about spirit island providing more intricacy and customization options while preserving the beating heart of the game and in a cooperative game where the most fun comes out of seeing the overlap of different spirits at difficulty levels and facing different obstacles then that's a good thing but even if i love it and recommend it that doesn't mean that i love everything about it i mean i hardly ever want to play spirit island at four players in the first place the thought of

playing with six players with all of the compounding possibilities of what players should and could do is absolutely mind-numbing and truth be told that kinda goes for the high complexity spirits too don't get me wrong they're impressive conceptual and bend the parameters of the game in some of the most buckwild ways but when i get to such a high complexity level that i'm having to see through the matrix so to speak where it feels more like i'm playing spreadsheet island it takes me a little out of it though i have some people in my group that love this stuff but it's a good thing that there are plenty of other spirits that feel robust and intricate but are the right level of complexity for me but that's kind of the point right this expansion offers new ways to keep the island feeling alive and wild and it's impressive that the relatively simple framework continues to support such variety while none of it is exactly beginner friendly as the expansion lacks low complexity spirits even going so far as to offer supplemental augmentations to the original four low complexity jabronis elevating them to meteor distinction this expansion offers a bit for everyone and i'd be remiss if i weren't mentioning the new power cards which low key may be the most intriguing mix-up that can happen to the game with great artwork thoughtful interactions devastatingly powerful cinematic moments and great new

synergies even if the new spirits dropped off the planet the use would keep the originals feeling fresh and new and of course this expansion introduced some add-ons with a new promo pack essentially acting as an expansion to this expansion including a couple more spirits and an adversary it's hard to not lump them in together mr bird at duplicity is fantastic and pretty much the best team player ever multiplying power effects and of all the very high complexity spirits secret paths unseen who creates and removes adjacency from completely different areas on the island as she damn well pleases is probably my favorite and if you need to go the premium angle the premium token pack adds some verticality to the game through screen printed wooden island tokens energy and fear and since there's a lot of information being communicated in spirit island at any given time and the whole shtick is kind of the battle of the natural wood tokens versus the invasive plastic yes i find this premium token package to be a very welcome addition so jagged earth is it necessary no is it going to change the minds of someone who didn't like the base game in the first place absolutely not but if you love spirit island which i do then this is everything that you love about the base game and then some and some more and a little bit more on top and that is our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack

for the cardboard harold

you

Progress saved