Manaforge Review
Transcript
so there you are you're reading a book or watching a movie and the hero is just about to save the day with some magical doodad that is going to fix everything and they all of a sudden lob off some Dark Lord's hand and claim some ring and suddenly they are the person who gets all the fame fortune and glory of being the hero and you're wondering what about the person who actually made that don't they deserve a cut of the cred and that is exactly what mana forged by mystic Tiger games is all about in this dice rolling resource allocation game you are competing with your friends to have the most prestigious smithery where you are creating these artifacts for all the heroes to use in mana forge players use their beautiful pastel dice to generate mana and purchase items from the supply these items are either one-time effects resolved and chucked straight into your storage or powerful workshop cards that can be exhausted every turn for a variety of effects usually having to do with getting more points or generating even more mana furthermore through dice cards or asymmetric powers in the form of talents you can also earn mana gems which are like stored mana that can be carried over from turn to turn or permanently slotted into your items in your workshop making them even more powerful and mighty which is probably the aspect of the game that feels most in sync with the theme on a player's turn in any order that they choose they can resolve up to four the rolled dice
perform any number of actions and purchase one card from this supply now these beautiful dice correspond to the four primary elements in the game and are the cornerstone of your magical forgery not only do they produce mana of the affiliated dice type but also they produce mana gems which are super handy beyond that they can also produce mana for the affiliated elements to their dice color and each color or mana type has a different special ability that can be rolled when activated you can resolve them for example the wind one can be activated in order to straighten already exhausted card allowing you to use it another time let's turn all of these are handy oh yeah then there are the super rad pink dice they are pretty they are pink and they are arcane they show two symbols on every side and you get to choose which one of those symbols you resolve when you use this dice as play continues the cards you buy become more fearsome and expensive due to the arrangement of the deck $18.00 followed by 18 noon than 18 dusk after nine rounds the deck is empty the remaining supply is discarded and you meet up with your smithing buddies to count up points and brag about who has the biggest long swords and most beautiful breastplates of the day but wait no Smith is an island unto themselves no you need helpers and as I said earlier asymmetry in mana Forge comes in the form of talents a crew of helpers that you draft
at the beginning of the game and then of the four that you keep you decide which two you're going discard so long suckers and begin play with the two remaining not only do they have some sort of special powers that will give you a little bit of a nudge out the door and a little bit of direction to focus in the game but they also add corresponding dice to your pool of the four basic dice so that way you have an extra bit of capabilities I really dig this system of crafting your asymmetric powers to start out the game here's the thing about mana forge every turn is a puzzle about what you can do on that specific turn and yeah sure your mana gems can carry over from turn to turn you'll get to roll the same dice next turn and your items in your workshop can be used every turn but you don't know what you're going roll next turn you don't know what items are going to be in the marketplace or even if you'll be able to afford them or that your gems will even correspond to the type of items that are in the workshop so instead you are focused on the here and now you start looking at your workshop items your dice your your talents and then your gems and you start figuring out this labyrinthian maze on what specific four dice you're going to use and what items are going to use in what sequence and then acquire an item that is the best possible item with the best possible ability that you might even activate this turn in order to trigger
more additional stuff all to get either more resource production or more points right now so this is what a typical turn might look like in mana forge or then I convert this water gem I put this here the Hopi six get me the tribe but the portal staff is worth more what I could do I could spend to put this on here and that'll be - wind and I could get the portal then I have nothing left over oh but I can flip this over to a water side get a water gem and then I can buy the portal staff for seven points and I get a man that said I really do find the puzzle solving element of the game fun and it is really enjoyable there are a lot of aha moments where you're like I'm brilliant of course if I just do this then resolve this die and then choose to do this and then buy this item I can combine that with the item that I already had in order to get this amount of points and produce this amount of gems and I'll be all set up hopefully for next turn and that's great I really love that but I will say that by the end of the game with a bunch of different items with excessive amounts of production or point values it tied to them the amount of
computation of capabilities is going to be a little bit dense and it's going to rely on some analysis that might be a little too opaque for some people and a little too paralyzing for others let's talk about the theme for a second while it's true that each of the game's elements essentially boiled down to different colors of currency there are some moments where the theme of the game really shines first off it feels awesome slotting gems into your workshop forever making them more powerful then the gorgeous art really cements he Civ and imaginative world kind of like a middle-eastern Old Testament II take on classic fantasy lastly some really solid components like the supply board and the dice reflecting the weird yet wonderful color palette Amana Forge help infuse the game with some mystery and wonder oh and the first player anvil is super rad there is a lot I really like about mana forge the way that you draft and combine talents the awesome sturdy components the whole theme of forging these mystical objects in a really kind of exotic and unique take on fantasy and the puzzle alone feels thrilling when you get to do some awesome combination of like 10 steps in order to get the best possible resource production and a whole lot of gems that can slot into your artifacts and then you buy an item and add it into your workshop in order to get some more points it feels really satisfying and
like you're a genius which is awesome but that said it does feel kind of shallow when the end result of this big giant expansive turn is that you get to buy one card and one card only and that card is ultimately going to result in either producing more resources giving you points or giving you a way of converting resources into points ultimately I do wish mana Forge offered a little bit more some other tracks some other investments something that made it as dynamic and thrilling as I'd hoped it would be but as it stands I do think that it's probably going to fall flat for people who want multiple paths to victory or a lot of player interaction or a lot of deep systems to explore but if you're looking for a great entry point into resource allocation or maybe you just really love custom dice and dice games where you get to make decisions based off of what you roll or you really dig the theme and you want to step up your lightweight gaming into something a little bit more crunchy to contend with then there is a well balanced totally solid approachable and fun albeit straightforward game in manna Forge so that is the cardboard Harold's review of manna forged by mystic Tiger games what do you think of the game and what did you think of the review let us know in the comments below if you enjoy to this type of criticism then please let us know and I would love it if you chose to subscribe so thank you so much for watching
I've been jack for the cardboard Herald