Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 29:16

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for suspects uh this is another whodunit murder mystery game um by studio h this one is another one i came across in gen con of 2021 that i knew nothing about um what was actually pretty fantastic is i bought another one of their games and they threw in a demo to this one and i was like oh sure i'll give it a shot i love this genre like almost all these types of games are just so much fun because i have yet and all the sherlock holmes i've played and all the chronicles of crimes detective monochrome vienna connection and this one i've never ran across the same story like it's like which makes these very hard because you see those kinds of movies um i mean this one even mentions you know agatha christie novels you i mean not movies like knives out and things like that is you want to fall into the tropes uh which definitely lead you in the direction that is not the case um so this is another one it utilizes uh a deck like an actual you know deck of cards and i feel like i mean like almost like kind of an escape room kind of style you know the the unlocks where it's like oh we find this card uh and it's a very small footprint there's only three mysteries which i thought was a little less than ideal but we only did the first one

and it was like oh these are long and this is this is hard like this one was very very hard um this had that that movie knives out feel where it's like every one of you is suspicious in some way and which one none of you are good people yeah we're the one person that is absolutely innocent and could never possibly do it was like but maybe maybe yeah the only person that we were like she didn't do it was the kid yeah we never talked it we never there were a few people we didn't talk to no actually we did make fun of her for being the murderer sure yeah um but in in this case and at this point we have played you haven't played detective for modern crime board but you've played vienna connection which is the same system kat and i have played all of them uh what do you guys think of suspects i like it like a lot yeah absolutely falls right into it i think it's really streamlined um it's incredibly engaging like i i at one point i was like okay well i'm ready for it to end because i'm ready to like know who did it but i wasn't just like can we move on like let you get past this like i like it yeah a thrilling game there was kind of a tipping point because i it was getting late like we started this at like 9 30 and ended at midnight so they're very long they are very long cases at least the first one is but it was made it wasn't because i was i was sitting here and i'm just like i

don't know like my brain your glasses literally flew off twice like and i can't break them um yeah brett what do you think out of all the ones that we have played um i i at this point uh i like them all equally yeah um i i enjoy them for all for different reasons this one because the scoring system allows you to maybe you do really well and then you find out more information go ew they need their reinforces what i did or no no we should change and get a lower score but at least we get some of it right yeah you know what this one does that different from all of them you know the questions yeah before you start right every single one of them you're like i don't know what we have to answer so you don't know what is important or not it's true and imagine not finding out that mary was pregnant or something and like one of the questions is like what's the name of mary's baby like yeah i don't know why oh i guess small spoilers for the first one um that should have been said earlier but you bleep it all out because inherently we're probably gonna end up saying something but if you watch the run through then yeah spoilers yeah uh but that is super fascinating that was always a problem i had with sherlock holmes yeah is your life what are we looking for yeah because you're like well it mentioned you know wagon you know brother marks in the mud but who knows if that's relevant and then you get three yeah then you get to the end and because it has most of the time especially if you play a lot of sherlock holmes you do kind of realize oh this is probably a secondary bonus question but then there's times oh who's the leader

of the higgins gang and you're just like who yeah like what the [ __ ] we didn't get anywhere close to that but this one it lets you stay like cat said streamline lets you stay focused like there were a lot of ones in here about you know the head of the manor and it's like oh well okay maybe maybe they did do this maybe they did this and it's like that stuff doesn't matter because we know we're trying to figure out who the killer is yeah not of edward but of mary we want to know as people like we want to know and they cleverly answered it in the thing it's like yeah okay here's the extra but it's all story stuff it's not based off your score it's not none of that it's such a breath of fresh air to just know these are the five questions right now how quickly we answer them yeah is uh going to be pretty pertinent to our score which is also story related hey by the way you [ __ ] failed so this person story wise got off [ __ ] failing and killed you yeah yeah strangled you so it's just it's so nice at how much that makes a difference and other games tweak it like detective modern crime it's like you do have a score but it's not you know a fight it's like you could get like a 15 out of 60 but still get a mission passed because you you figured at least out you know who the murderer was or the main the main answer right um yeah so bret uh keep going what were we saying that was what i was saying uh um i like that um i'm i'm trying to figure

out um if i like the the exclusive card format yeah versus the book okay um this is much easier to reference again which is critical yeah in doing all the stuff rather than detective modern crime does this too okay or fanta connection because we have all those cards that come out yeah right um um so that's not but versus the um sorry the sherlock holmes ones where it's all in the book so you kind of have to remember and it's hard to go back there are different ways to organize what we've learned over sherlock holmes was okay the lead was 54w and so we put that and then we kind of do a little like a line a sentence of what we found there or whatever was pertinent to that um but what's fantastic about these especially because these are newer sherlock holmes basically you kind of know when you turn to it oh short paragraph not gonna be any information long one great we're on the right track here everything is fair game when talking to everyone it's like okay they're gonna say something but what makes this one so hard like the other ones is you don't know there's nothing in this that ever is definitive right like at least per to the case like we guessed at the uh i think the first the first guest the first person we i was like it's her but it's not for the reason that we thought it was yeah

no um we thought it was she loved your brother and so um and i feel like and i've seen this happen whenever i did the demo the first time if you get so focused on the score yeah you're gonna i think you will have a bad time because for some reason tying a score and actually being able to visibly track your score and have a timer like oh i only want to do max 30. answer all these questions and see what the result is you're most likely going to be wrong yeah well in the point of these games too is is it's the journey yeah as well like like the fun is to be had when you're collecting cards and going around and seeing what like what you can find what you can uncover yeah and for me it's like these games do both the journey and the destination so well because you get to be involved you get to at least feel like you were on the right track and then if you're wrong and you read it at least you still get the story what i don't like is is bum rushing these games because when you do that then you didn't get the story right you didn't get to play the game and then you're unsatisfied because you got all the questions wrong so this is kind of a double-edged sword if you you're not necessarily in a time constraint if you don't give a [ __ ] about the score at all yeah then just play the game yeah and then answer the questions but it's nice to have a stopping point it says okay with what the information we have if this were the end of it what would we think yeah and then later on we go don't think so yeah i mean exactly like

we could have and there's no reason why you can't it's not like a one-and-done answer exactly uh you and you you and they even mention it in the uh in the rulebook it's kind of like hey here's here's maybe some break points 1-30 okay we're at 30 cards let's calm down let's not over talk to anyone let's not look at any more locations let's try to answer these and then we answer them oh i think it's jimmy dean because of his bagels his morning bagels he's the killer uh and then you answer those questions then you keep going and then you get you answer more cards you get to in this case 45 and you're like nope i still think it's him and you so you don't have to answer it again but you get more information you're like okay now we think it's this person yeah and i like that i like the fact that you're able to answer them potentially get max points and if not you can just change it and then if you get more questions then you can go back you know it's i love this system the the the answer having the questions up front is i think superior having a focus for all of your thinking especially because it is a lot of cards like there's a lot of cards there's a lot of little things to be like okay like whenever you point that's like well the fact that that's an option makes me think that it's important and or it's a red herring or it's a red herring and so and and that's the thing is you don't know sometimes it's like okay well yeah they did point that out but are they smart enough as designers to to make me they know that i know that

they you know so you just kind of have to take your guess yeah now in terms of mechanics um like it is still your bog standard who done it uh if you have i mean i wouldn't say get this one over any of the other ones right honestly um i just like owning them all because i love these kinds of genres they're so much fun for me yeah like you said earlier like we haven't run across a similar story yeah like they're all incredibly unique which i think is fantastic because it just blows my mind how like they don't start repeating the same crimes or like yeah cause it's like yeah you would think oh man that's a lot so well i will say in the season one of detective modern crime they do have a knives out um uh case uh but they even say because like i have a designer's journal they're like hey yeah we were inspired by knives out and but still the method and everything is still different yeah this is in a manner there's a manner uh case and sherlock holmes so the settings are going to be relatively similar now but how they go about it it's not like what's going on and who's doing it and why they're doing it and ancillary stuff like here's a whole other possible murder that really has nothing to do with it yeah but is it indirectly related it might be yeah this one oh my god they just get because you get inside your own head well i was telling my my friend devin when we did the demo for this i was like these games are so hard because you don't know how

uh uh what adequate the creators are it's like are they just trying to make a game like this and fail miserably so it's like how much credit do you give them for having in-depth writing and and you know misdirection and actual cases and leads and things like that or you just chalk it up as like well okay it seems like it's the boyfriend so i guess we'll go with him and they're like yep did you get it you know no this one they they put some effort they went over quality over quantity yeah now in retrospect i'm noticing things like one of them says okay this is the murder weapon yeah another one says uh this matches this person but is it possible yeah the only thing about the gloves is it was it was much much less certain yeah which opened up the possibility yeah cause cat was like well you can wear gloves that are bigger and that's like and that that's where because that because that came with a cat's more of the um the subjective one about like well yeah you can do that but i'm more like no the game has to have a mechanic that lets us figure out who the [ __ ] did i'm like the game knows that we're smart and it did yeah and it absolutely did and that's brilliant but it is also i will say equally frustrating because you spend a lot of especially in this first case flailing yeah talking to everyone and it's like i don't want to talk to everyone because that's too much information for me to try and oh he said

this but did he mean because you you never know if they're lying do you remember when i was like didn't somebody say something about herbs and i was like did i hallucinate that lately and it did and we totally blew it off yeah and it and it was like because i was sitting here i'm like we're going to talk to a person we're going to get a certain card that is going to be footprint gloves boom got them answer it yep rope which was so obvious as the murder weapon oh by the way not the murder weapon because you walk through it you walk through the case the fact that they i love the tangible stuff i mean sherlock holmes has it too with the map of london i love physically having something um of course detective has the laptop like and that one has the more intricate system because in a lot of these you have to take what they say for face value because you can't ever tell if they're lying in detective when you interview them they have what's a stress level so if they say something it'll say hi stress level and it's like okay that we can deduces he's lying about that or something about that um and then chronicles of crime yeah that the characters move around the map and then you have a qr code you can ask them you can ask someone about an item they might not know you can find information you can go back to them so it actually has an interactive real world feel they all do something different this one really heavily relies on like your ability to cross-reference as well um which is why note-taking was because i was i was writing down like the specifics like i also gave you the tiniest book imaginable really truly dead and that's the round but boy i love it yeah yeah little detective notebook

it was yeah and that was my thought when i wanted to collect scotch yep get divorced lose the dog shooter gun three o'clock every day i'll see you tomorrow at three o'clock click all right see you tomorrow oh my but it really relies on like your actual deduction skills and like what you can pick up on which is really uh nice i mean because you look at you look at the item like the tangible item like the map i mean hell the the um family tree was super intricate we were constantly in that trying to figure out how it gave me an ulcer yeah it's like okay how old are they when were they taken you know who were they related to why would this person have a motive you know how are they what's i love the fact that this also tells you what people's thoughts are on others and that allows you to cross-reference okay everyone said this character everyone's saying the same thing about this character yeah they can't possibly do it which at least were right about that or everyone's saying this about this character like which means that their opinions aren't formed by like jealousy or something like that like because someone said obviously someone said something a good example would be like oh well she was a stupid [ __ ] but everyone else is like she was just the greatest gal we like yes seven out of eight people are like i wish she was just so nice it's like okay well that one person really hates her but then you find the story reasons why or in the demo which i guess we can spoil that there was one person who said

oh this was written certainly by this guy and then that guy was like oh no she wrote it and it's like okay well they're both they both have conflicting information can't both have written it right it's like so someone's lying or it's a third party yeah yeah i thought you were gonna say something i was oh okay keep going no damn it was it was weeks ago oh i gotcha um so with the tangible stuff it's it's always nice to be like okay well this is right next to this and then you so you try your own conclusions and it it's at least reassuring to know that you are gonna be we were at least somewhere on the right track at least at one point at one point we kind of had it then we kind of mixed it around and oh it's just so this one was this one was so hard this one had so many avenues because you also do throw away lines ah she's pregnant oh okay well we have no definitive thing like that but then it's like then you brought it back it's like okay well that definitely would be a motive it's like yeah it's so what does this play up to how many people does this play up 26 three six one to six yeah yeah um i never liked these at large people because of that very reason too many yeah too many hands in the cookie jar where it's like too many cooks yeah there's no reason like 20 couldn't actually sure just the logistics of everyone everyone everyone gets a card yeah everyone wants to see something you someone's always getting

like overshadowed by someone else who wants to you know talk and have their theories heard i did feel bad during the game because i was like stop like because i like it's like you need to be heard so yeah i couldn't imagine it with honestly more than like three four people yeah it would slow down even more yeah well it's also really cool that they do in this and i've seen it in this and then the demo is they have like a symbol thing where it's like okay if you find these key because it's all i mean they're so hard to narrow down and figure out it's like oh if you find these key piece these key cards you get to now look at this special card that's most likely gonna help you a lot at this point to help define your uh you know your theory yeah or retract uh we had it narrowed down to one of two people um but we we backtracked um because we thought that um it's our fault didn't i look like a vampire we're the right wrong person for the right reasons yeah pretty much pretty much by the way that these were answered all these questions were essentially subjective or uh you know uh sub questions to the main one who's the killer okay why'd they do it you know boom and depending on who we answered as the killer it gave us different reasons yeah um but yeah it's it feels so close to detective work as close as you can because one key piece of evidence we did not look at yeah it was and in this case we had it available to look at but i was like that's not relevant yeah so yeah okay why would we well because they say yeah you can look at this if you want to yeah but that's where you kind of want

to still kind of keep it within the cards yeah it's like okay well we'd much rather use we have like two cards left we can look at we think these two are more important than this one and god it's it's just it's so rough this one this one was very difficult one of the hardest ones i've done in in a long time this was this is tough like this was a brain burner so good story though yeah it was still incredibly fascinating and so the other two the final act and the wings of vengeance they say they're um in chronological order so i don't know if they're gonna be one of those things where it's kind of like the final act is not the last thing yes not interesting it was someone's final they are all written by different people though this one is by gualam i guess the game the the the designer wrote the first one okay and then we have sebastian duverger nedelek sorry to chapter two and then paul halter i was gonna say halter and i'm like dude that's a little close to hitler oh man he's like thanks yeah no paul paul halter so uh yeah this one is fantastic i'm definitely gonna be keeping an eye out for um like for for this because what they can also do yeah they have claire harper so she's like in the 1930s so they they kind of if they're going with this as an actual character that's who we play as uh they've kind of limited themselves to a time period yeah uh

so you can't be as free as like chronicles of crime who they have you know the 1400s and then they have the 2100s yeah um yes you can just beat the daughter a little bit i guess i bet there will be more boxes featuring other investigators in different time frames oh that's true yeah that's true and i hope they do this is uh these these are awesome i i am not displeased at all and now i know what to expect actually i knew what to expect after playing the first demo yeah and that was just more yeah that was about an hour and a half of that one and it's like oh my god yep yep that all makes sense reading that solution and then here it's like oh no that's a lot of people to talk to that's a lot of stuff they can give us so i was like thank god like seven of them are dead oh i know and i mean at least there were a couple that we could have just rode off it's like there's no way a 10 year old is doing this well yeah but but you know what if she was being silly cooper she was yep whether she was been and

there is actually one complaint that i have you in in this one and in the demo we never get to actually inspect the body it just kind of loosely tells us and both of them we never it was like ah this is what's around them and it's like no i want to look at the body in the corners like [ __ ] you yeah yeah it took it took it it took place in several different places yeah we did but not just not by going there and examining them poke the actual thing and it makes sense we're not trusting the experts yeah i mean yeah we're not coroners we're not anything that we're detectives so it makes sense that we would look around them and not entrust yeah the experts sherlock holmes does have that you can go to the corner and they tell you exactly oh and here's what was on them and all that is just a face-to-face meeting really it is yeah yeah but you get a lot of detail you do get a lot of detail that helps i mean hell even in this one there were there was like four different red herrings on the murder weapon it's like ah she was wearing a scarf oh strangled okay so that's what was used and then oh my god yeah but luckily we happen to stumble across that's true because i was like actually we probably i don't know how seriously would have taken it if they hadn't had the card matching that's what i was about to say yeah the card matching is so neat and it's such a simple um mechanism to have in this game yeah so the fact that yes there there is a way for you to be like to figure out for sure something because otherwise if it was just all based off speculation um you

would never get an answer correct but to be honest i would not expect to get that piece of information from going to the great hall true yeah yeah because you have no you have i mean i i don't know if you're allowed to look through these i don't know if you're allowed to be like oh what does the great hall look like you know i don't know if you're if or if you have to keep it all secret and then say you're going to go there um because like i i mean this is all you're playing either because because one side of the card doesn't give away anything yeah it shows the picture except some clues yeah like this one would be like oh there's a telephone maybe we can call someone okay i this is once again in hindsight i would not have thought of that yeah no but there's no more actually if i've seen that i probably would have skipped it because there's no sub specific places within there yeah so i probably wouldn't have bothered going yeah i guess it doesn't hurt you like because if you can look at the library like yeah they're all pretty vague like you don't know what to what to look at in here you just be like okay there's a lot of books it's a library that's true you do have to actually commit and then you find out well there's three other options yeah i can definitively say though and i love all of these for it this one sherlock holmes detective chronicles the crime none of these hold your hand like this one in particular it's almost yeah you don't need a little detective piss book it's like you're gonna need like sheets and you're gonna have to be like a chronologically okay who could

have done it and and actually like work it all out so it takes time like a real detective like a real detective uh yeah this one's fantastic a little i can't think of anything else um to to bring up i definitely wanted to hearken on the major differences uh i guess the big question is should you own this if you own any of the other ones absolutely yeah i think so if you enjoy them yeah because these are these are one of those things yeah they're gonna keep uh i mean hopefully they keep supporting this uh there's three big sherlock holmes things uh detective keep getting supported so and there's a key so here's a key question then um among the ones that you mentioned yeah if someone didn't know any of them and wanted to start out would you have a particular recommendation chronicles of crime okay probably because there's difficulty levels based off your cases um and there's a lot of them out now and it's i mean that's assuming people love apps and i'm not one of those people that throws a fit if apps are in my board games like you know but that would be the first one i would go to uh because yeah because there's difficulty levels um and you just need your phone sherlock holmes is continuously going down compared to all of those just because all of them are so innovative and they do what it did better it's the predecessor set the bar relatively high for this genre but it's in all the newest expansions yeah and all the newest expansions especially one came

out a couple years ago yeah it's ten new cases and i love the sherlock holmes genre but it is still a book yeah yeah i mean they have a map and then there's one where there's a manor and so they are bringing in extra elements but it is still the book yeah um but out of all all of them i would say get chronicles of crime first just for variety uh now which one's my favorite it's still detective modern crime board game just because i love the laptop like that aspect that one uh the way it's written the settings that they've included and the laptop all make me feel like i'm actually in an office typing and stuff gathering evidence yes but this one is really up there oh yeah uh yeah so on a scale of one to ten uh brett nine nine nine yeah i'm gonna give it a nine as well uh it's yeah it's so good so here's two hopefully yeah like you said more more you know three boxes i mean because this this probably isn't super expensive time consuming to write the stories yeah um but yeah you're gonna be like oh here's a new box set in 1980 it's in the 80s you know here's one all three cases about the satanic panic it was the goth every single time golf kids it was uh what's his face it was the other one it was something i was born no what was his name from the west memphis three there's all them uh but so so yeah i guess we'll we'll just

see but that's our thoughts on suspects uh less than what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved