Skip to main content
Loading video...

How Frosthaven Lets You Build Its World

Transcript 24:36

oh my word the day has finally come we don't have to buy board games anymore what yeah Elaine Frost Haven is here the last board game we will ever need what are you doing looking for a new job one day a board game went to kids board game that promised you a world of fighting monsters and progressing through it however you want it and 13 million dollars in a few years later the board game is here see footnote about the word here what is that board game it's Frost Haven the last board game you will ever need Frost Haven has everything it has Heroes to play like spear person or skeleton friend or an insect hive mind Consciousness that is actually two twin insect hive mind Consciousness this is in one person that in my game I named Antoni it has enemies to fight like rad boys or crabs or skeletons which puts skeleton friend in a tough bind it has tactical combat it has a story a whopping 136 scenarios it has stickers heard Gathering Advent calendars notepads actual calendars timed events Outpost building secret booklets character unlocks it even has Reiner kinesia that's right Ryan is in this game I didn't make that miniature up and within Frost Haven the miniature

Rhino konitzia has also designed over 700 board games so you can play those dear viewer I ask you why would you need any other game in your life what if I didn't like gloomhaven well that's just very silly Elaine very silly there are a lot of cards in Frost Haven but before we get to those cards we need to lay some of our cards on the table when Frost Haven was on Kickstarter amongst the many things that were being announced were guest scenarios by various designers Publishers or board game media people thankfully we weren't amongst that list yes we were no you were look scenario 126 it says design and writing not a peep about me no buyers I can do what I want that's because they forgot to put your name on it oh yeah now that you mention it I do remember designing and writing this scenario and getting paid for it oh bother it seems that we might be coming down with a mild case of bias and when I say mild case what I mean is that we were paid actual money Dash dollary dues for design work in this very board game and if you think that influences us you'd be absolutely right in the strictest terms we did not design this game we designed one 136 of an element of this game because besides scenario

design there's a whole lot more going on in here like character design monster design Outpost buildings and so on but we did do design work for it and got paid for it now not all videos published on NPI are board game reviews we sometimes engage in cultural analysis for example and then people scream at us in the comments with this review is rubbish yeah because it's not a review point being when people come to watch an NPI video they are expecting a board game review so let me take the time to very clearly delineate that this is not a review well what is it then think of it as design analysis will critically untangle the many constituent design parts of frost Haven in the context of what this game is trying to achieve is showing any judgment or verdict on the design as a whole we'll tell you what it does and why it does it but not how well for example we might say things like a lot of early scenarios boil down to kill all monsters because they set up a tactical knowledge foundation in players but we won't say things like if you hated gloomhaven then there's not much in Frost Haven to sway you otherwise or other things of that nature but you just said it well it might or it might not be true who knows I know it is true all right all right no verdict in three two one it is impossible to talk

about Frost Haven without comparing it to its predecessor gloomhaven because they're pretty much the same game but it is precisely in where they differ that we can glean what Frost Haven is trying to achieve both of these games are split into two constituent Parts the scenarios with tactical Dungeon Crawler as combat and outside of that this would gloomhaven called the town phase and what Frost Haven calls The Outpost phase ask an Enthusiast about Callum Haven and they'll say something like great combat but the narrative is a bit rubbish which is not untrue but this oversimplification hides what separates this system from so many other games like gloomhaven is at the top of BGG and what shortcomings the sequel is trying to improve upon so let's start with the part that most people agree is great combat I'm not going to explain gloomhaven combat we've done that in two separate videos already one very old and another one that is actually watchable but let's face it no one ever follows those links so here's the deal if you don't know how gloomhaven works Frost Haven is probably not where you should stop but if you're curious anyway you don't really need to know how it works to understand or enjoy this video right we've covered the old let's talk about what's new which isn't a lot honestly Frost Haven's combat is nearly identical to that of its predecessor

there are minor quality of life improvements like new conditions such as brittle doubling the damage you take next time or impair which prevents you from using your items or Ward which is the inverse of brittle halving the damage you take or the fact that you draw three battle goals instead of two which is a little mini Achievement System where each scenario you pick a challenge and if you succeed you'll get closer to adding or removing cards from your modifier deck gluehaven's patented customizable dice replacement system but that's sort of it and if you think about it it makes sense most people agree agree that what really works Nate sings is combat so don't fix what isn't broken but play a few scenarios at Frost Haven and you'll recognize that the combat feels different and that's due to the character design that's taken on a new ethos whereas gloomhaven was well glimhaven and jaws of the line was Breezy with easy to execute powerful abilities Frost Haven feels finicky even easy to play characters like the banner spear introduce complications that will rarely present in previous versions the banner spear is a melee force of Reckoning that can make powerful swings and even Target multiple enemies her equivalent in the original was the Inox brute one for one similar cards for the banner spear are more potent for example The Brute could attack two enemies for three damage nice and simple the banner spear can attack three and push them one space but to execute this ability you

have to have an ally adjacent to you and to the enemies in this specific configuration naturally the character is equipped with the ability to summon allies but even then guaranteeing that things will be exactly where they need to be is easier said than done your friends often have their own ideas about where they should stand and what they should whack and enemy turns and more to the point when enemies will take their turn are difficult to predict meaning that Frost Haven is more prone to highs and lows terms where the stars align and you feel like you've been very clever and very good at the cards and turns where none of your cards do anything and you're less of a force of Reckoning and more of a force of basic actions other starting characters take this complexity of actions to unprecedented degrees the aforementioned gem in it has two alternate sets of cards each playable only in a certain state if you are and the melee version of the Gemini you can only play the lighter cards however if you are Tony the ranged version of the geminet only the darker ones the Gemini is a character of ultimate versatility ranged attacks melee attacks healing area attacks a hand size of 14 you name it you can have it but if you are in the wrong State then you can't perform the actions that you need inversely if you're in the right state but want to do an action that transforms you into the wrong State then you are Tony without the chocoloney

I didn't make up Tony chocoloni that is a real chocolate brand I wouldn't necessarily recommend it because it's you know like all right chocolate but uh it's fair trade so that's something to get even a scant amount of experience you'll need access to Elements which you pretty much can't make you're gonna best convert elements but only if you spend a loose guard and you'll need to time being in the right State and have the right card to get the XP Point your area attacks frequently harm allies and your most powerful actions require you to impart negative conditions onto yourself which makes this all very complex but a fun puzzle to solve the bone shaper is a slightly less complicated proposition in that the conundrum of the character is simple brutal but simple the bone shaper can summon things a mechanism that never felt effective in gloomhaven because each summon required you to lose cards and the summons were automated frequently rendering them ineffective well now you have a character that not only controls their Salmons but also doesn't have to lose cards to get them onto the battlefield except each skeleton you summon and we'll deal you to damage and you only have six hit points at level one and whilst you don't lose the cards they're still removed from circulation effectively reducing your hand the trick is that at any point you can deactivate a sum and dropping the card back into the discard reintroducing it into the circulation

which can be an effective way of snatching up a summon that got left behind and re-summon it right into where the action is except that will once again cost two hit points conundrums imagine gloomhaven like a toasted cheese sandwich it's Rich indulgent and good enough for you to ignore that this is a food analogy if you want to make that same sandwich in Frost Haven well it comes with a much better grater but gives you no cheese so if you want a toasty you will have to improvise and sometimes that does mean scraping your knuckles against it this system always excelled at pulling you into opposing directions with loot that makes you go out of your way bathroom goals that are at odds with winning the scenario and personal quests that make your intentions suspect so this new ethos pushes you even further and asks you for more sacrifices and more concessions if you want more evidence how about masteries each character comes with only two and you get to complete them only once if you do you will get an immediate perk that's where you get to change up your modifier deck for example with the Gemini all you have to do is swap States every single turn which means you're restricted to very specific card play combinations my attempts to achieve this master return by insect hive mind intellect into a Daft fly

flailing in a spider web of ineptitude but maybe you can do better let me know how it goes so you have a system that remains largely unchanged but at the same time there's new puzzles new complexity new levers to pull but Frost Haven's second half is a dramatic transformation I'm gonna put the hat back on the thing people often say about gloomhaven is that with the PC Port there's no point in playing the tabletop version because it takes care of the faffey admin and I'm like no the fact is the point and I'm just kidding faff is awful in anything that trims it is good but removing gloomhaven's tabletop presence also diminishes that sense of an evolving narrative after four or five play sessions you probably have about four different quest lines with the side quest or two spicing things up the world is growing and don't get me wrong that's also something that's in the PC version it's just that if you're playing with your friends on a physical surface it introduces a shared sense of Discovery and evolution by applying stickers opening envelopes in short manipulating this play space with your hands and making choices together you're engaging in collaborative World building that evolves depending on those choices if I was allowed to be critical I'd say that this was gloomhaven's least develop aspect it's not that it wasn't there it's just that it was unfocused and

Pokey it's only natural that the biggest change comes to this part this is gloomhaven's party sheet the same size as the character sheet and I don't have enough hand or feet fingers to count the amount of times it got lost somewhere in the Box because it wasn't particularly interesting or useful this by contrast is Frost Haven's party sheet and I think you can tell there's a lot more going on Frost Haven is not a big bustling Metropolis like Gloom Haven it's an outpost set up in the inhospitable fringes of the continent by Mercantile organizations and then almost entirely forgotten about I wonder how that happens I say almost because your party is basically a gang of mercenaries hired to check in on corporate property after one optional and one mandatory introductory scenario you'll arrive to find The Outpost and its mayor sather barely holding together you'll also find a community that deemed itself independent from these companies a long time ago and whilst you're here you might as well help cute buildings that's right Frost Haven has a building's minigame where each Outpost phase you get the chance to stick some new artwork onto your Outpost map either upgrading existing buildings or hammering out entirely new ones buildings are the heart of the Outpost phase not because of what they do because frankly for the first 10 scenarios they'll just let you make some resources or Brew some potions or make some new gear but because the rules

spreading out from them Reach every crevice of frost Haven for example how do you build a building you need resources how do you get resources you go and fight things in scenarios in previous versions every time you killed a monster it dropped a coin if you light it for Loop you got some money out of it now dead monsters drop loot tokens which can be coins or material resources like wood metal and Hyde or herb resources which are fantasy Roots berries and I kid you not something called an Axner which coincidentally is a name I used to dance under slowly but surely you'll collect a menagerie of rocks and planks that you can lay to convert into a boat or a fantasy Etsy right but notice that this mechanism that lets you gather materials also gathers herbs and whilst you can't build a house made entirely out of ax nuts disappointing I know you can do something even better maybe because it's the holidays but I'm really feeling the love for Advent calendars lately and Frosty Boy did a Santa and gave me the present of potion brewing during The Outpost phase you can combine any two herbs on this Matrix and then brew a potion you can combine even more herbs later if you upgrade The Alchemist building and then once you've combine the two herbs you open the door and see what potion it is that you've brewed fun and unexpected results guaranteed but then once you know you know which also

sort of makes sense talking of Advent calendars Frost Haven lets you open scenarios in that same way as in there is an advent calendar that depicts all the scenarios and these arrows sort of show the progression I don't want to say a lot got here and by the way there's like five of these throughout I'm only showing you one where we haven't opened any doors so I don't accidentally spoil scenarios for you but what's nice about this is that it once again adds to this cohesive sense of the world because different scenario trees have different color coding so at a glance you know exactly how much you've progressed through each quest line all right but what about more interesting buildings the standard array don't seem particularly exciting well they're coming but first you have to unlock them by retiring characters bloomhaven players will remember this mechanism as I have all these cool characters in my big box but I can't touch them or even know what they are until I complete an arbitrary number of tasks well that's still here except you don't unlock classes you unlock new buildings which leaves the question how do you unlock new classes the simple answer is that you just do we got to open some of these types of things really early earlier than you might think now they unlock just sort of based on things that you do places you visit choices you make they're logical falling in line with the narrative you create with your friends further reinforcing the sense of a tangible web of events that orchestrate

themselves based on your agency and hey I'm going to let you into a little secret there's nothing that stops you opening one whenever you want in fact I'm going to open this one from gloomhaven right now because I've always wanted to know what was inside it foreign

quests seem to move as a brisker pace we're just scratching the surface of this campaign 12 games in or so and I'm already retiring my character point being there's a more purposeful sense to this progression your world is open do what you like but at the back of your neck there's this feeling of guided curation it's clear that a lot of time was spent thinking about how you progress not just through scenarios but also outside of scenarios Frost Haven added Seasons meaning there's a calendar meaning when you reach certain time points you'll trigger events either pre-printed on your campaign sheet or ones you wrote in as you progress through the campaign and of course there's still the road and outpost events the little narrative doobly-doos with multiple choice outcomes which get more dangerous during winter which can potentially lead to attacks which can destroy that's right you guessed it buildings looping back on this one design focal point Frost Haven understands that it isn't enough to just have many things in your game those things especially with two disparate Parts have to inform each other in other words I want to fight because that will give me resources so that I can use them to build buildings and I want to build buildings so that I can craft items there'll be potions so I can get better at fighting like we said before buildings reach their invisible hands into every rule of frost Haven every element and connects it with meaning

would Frost Haven work without them of course that game already exists it's called gloomhaven and I hear one or two people like it but by having this focal point Frost Haven lets you feel like you are progressing through this campaign how you want to like you are the one building this world rather than how the game wants you to do it when people talk about gloomhaven or Frost Haven the big talking point is the size of the campaign 96 scenarios 137 scenarios so much content in fact progressively our hobby is leaning into evaluating games based on Content Volume rather than content quality 700 cards in tractor forming Mars oh my God value what's on the those cards tracked us why are those cops 700 which is where we arrive at the purpose of this video we've bought ourselves from critiquing Frost statement by accepting the chance to add our little Mark to it but we did sort of want to raise a talking point Frost Haven is obviously what some people will call Value but I'd like to invite you to ask why are there so many of a thing in a game if you design 137 scenarios even if you split the design duties between multiple co-design as guest designers AI algorithms it's never going to be as good as say a game

that has 15 scenarios but really focuses on them so if you have 137 scenarios what do you get as a trade-off we think the answer in Frost Haven is this code and architecture of the campaign in Gloom Haven you place stickers when you unlock new scenarios marked game States when you made important narrative choices and the city itself was present on the map but it frequently felt intangible Frost Haven's map devotes nearly half of itself just to The Outpost and this increase in size isn't just here to Big itself up it feels palpable there's a structure to The Outpost phase that codifies it as a real place you mark off the calendar to show that time has passed then you draw an outpost event then you activate your buildings then you have some downtime activities like brewing potions leveling up your character crafting gear and then you can build a new building or upgrade an existing one there's a logical sense to this flow if the Outpost event you drew caused an attack which wrecks the logging Camp no longer for you this Outpost phase but in step five you get to repair it and then in the next Outpost phase it can get wrecked again this structure makes Frost Haven feel less like a glorified Quest Hub and more like an actual Hub it's the place that you care about and maintain it's the place that you want to go back to after a hard encounter because there's always something to unlock build Brew explore before you go on one of the many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many

many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many many other scenarios yes a lot of early scenarios boil down to kill all monsters because they set up a tactical knowledge foundation in players yes some of the experimental scenarios can feel a bit wonky but together the volume frames that structure the campaign rests on it enables that sense that you together with your friends are sharing an evolving setting the little downtrodden Outpost of frost Haven surviving in a place the world forgot about whether it uses the tools we dissected well that's not for us to decide I'm looking forward to seeing what other reviewers think of how this mod on trusty handles that nearly impossible Balancing Act having said that we are aware as people who make videos we can inadvertently get people excited about things and drive them towards a purchase so allow me this one small point of critique to avoid influencing an expensive mistake if you never played gloomhaven then Frost Haven isn't the place to start check out our video on glue Maven jaws of the line for a much better entry point into the system and if you hated gloomhaven then there's not much in Frost Haven to sway you otherwise

Progress saved