S.T.A.L.K.E.R: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Stalker the board game, one of the newest games by Awaken Realms. Uh, like I say at the beginning of every discussion for a campaign series that I do. Uh, this is kind of a preliminary pseudo first impressions because we're not we haven't beat the campaign yet. [snorts] Um, so this is going to give our thoughts on the game so I can get a discussion out instead of having to wait, you know, 5 years to get a to get one out. Uh, and then there'll be a second discussion afterwards if we finish the campaign or earlier if we end if we end up not liking it. But this was a game that I took a chance on uh because I know virtually nothing about the IP on it. Um I I've always really liked this theme
with that kind of like alternate universe uh post-apocalyptic kind of like sci-fi area. I know the only games in this kind of genre that I have played are the Metro games, but never played Stalker. tried the first one uh like a couple months ago honestly and it was it was rough.
Yeah, the second one is definitely an upgrade. It's really the story is good.
Um I have half of it, you know.
Yeah, they have like four Stalker games, but then they're like Stalker 2. It was weird. So, uh yeah. So, I basically I I knew it was a a campaign kind of like co- fully cooperative narrative driven campaign game and I just love those. So, Brad, what do you think of Stalker? Um, you know, I did not back this one because some of the preliminary reviews that I was listening with had prototype copies and stuff was talking about how hard of a game it was and how crunchy. Um,
oh, like rules-wise they were saying it was hard
and how there was so much stuff, you know, and it does look like it. Like if you just look at this and look at your dashboard, there's stuff everywhere.
But everything flows really nicely, you know. I' I've actually was surpris I like it more than I thought I would.
Yeah.
Um, even though I like this kind of theme, you know, that was something for sure. Mhm.
Um and it's also one of those that uh cuz it has a solo uh you know type place play play style or whatever that you can do.
But um it really is it's it's what you want in a cooperative game.
Yeah.
Super difficult.
Yep.
Um yeah, I was a little concerned whenever the we played the first mission. I was like, "Oh, these guys are super easy." So that was definitely your your mission.
Yeah, that was the handholding like escape the dungeon type mission. And then it's like all right, time to time to bend you over in mission two.
And you know there's depending on what version of this game you have, there's going to be anywhere from what 6 to 12 missions or whatever.
Um a core game is six missions,
right? So with that, if I'm just taking the core game into a deal,
those kind of campaigns where you just have six deals, I don't mind the reset replay.
That's fair.
You know what I'm saying? Because you do learn like we knew how we would attack it the next time. Plus, it gives you your replay. You're getting your money's worth,
right?
Um in a 12 plus games campaign,
having that kind of sucks sometimes.
Yeah. Um, you know, we've had multiple campaigns that have had their games that were fail forward. Yeah.
And it changed stuff. Um,
I mean, I 100% prefer fail forward. I I definitely see where you're coming from that it's a a manageable thing where it's like, okay, if you only have six games, then yeah, just losing and learning.
Um,
but still, I I really just hate the idea of like, I just redo it. It's like, okay, that took like two and a half hours. like I don't want to redo it. Um, but I I I will say that I I always prefer a brutally hard co-op game versus one that's like, "Oh, we already we beat it. We had no difficulty
cuz we had to really be thinking." And yeah, it's been a it's honestly been a very long time that I have played a cooperative game that I was I had like we were think we spent probably like 45 minutes just like
how the [ __ ] do we get out of this situation like what I like okay what if we tried this what if we and like I last time I can think of where I had that same feeling was like early pandemic legacy where it's like okay if we do all of this then we have to hope that the f that the card we draw is this and not this,
right?
And now grantite we didn't succeed in this in this case. Um, but boy, if we had that would have been really awesome. And there's a couple things. Uh, one I really, even though this is missionbased, it's not they did a lot of uh very small things, but uh nice things that make those missions replayable. Besides the fact you have an abundance of of stalkers to play that all have their unique abilities, which is cool. I I feel completely different from the way
you are. But the two missions that we've done have have said multiple times, oh, grab one of these two cards. Grab one of these three cards at random. So it changes that yeah your objective is the same but the randomization with the random events or like when the ladder fell
and it's like is that just like a gotcha? And then I was and I relooked at the setup and I'm like oh this was one of three cards.
So it's probably like you climb up the ladder no problem it falls or it falls after one use.
Mhm. And I I really like that because lately I I have had a much better time with campaign games that are bite-size.
Mhm.
And these feel bite-siz. Even if it's like I have I have everything for the game. That's tw 15 missions.
Yeah, I think it was like Yeah. 12
cuz there's three in the duty and freedom um six in in the the um
box
in oh six in the core box six in the stretch goal so 15 total missions
and depending on the outcome uh well this is if we fail but see I think there's multiple different ways to succeed
that's going to give you different uh different uh you know things that are going to help you going forward so Yeah, I I think that they did a fantastic job with the way this mission is. And like you said, it this this is a tablehog. Like there's a bunch of [ __ ] here. They did this stupid thing with like the the campaign binder. There's like two things that go in here. So it's like why do you even do this? So I just bought like my own binder for like four bucks. Um and just kind of shove stuff in it. But they I mean that those campaign things just walk you through literally, okay, zone exploration, do all this now. Do all this. Okay, now go into the mission book and set it up and you're ready to go.
And it's it looks like a lot, but it is incredibly streamlined.
Yeah.
Uh which Awakenes is not necessarily known for. I don't think they're as bloaty as as other other companies. Um, I think their games usually are actually really well put together, but but yeah, you would expect a game like this to have a bunch of little weird rules. Um, now the line of sight rules.
Yeah, those are kind of strange.
I'd rather have it be this though than weird convoluted get out the laser pointer. um like oh it take two dots of one area and draw them to a it's like h so at least yeah it might not be the most thematic thing in the world where it's like okay for some reason I'm here and there's an enemy here and I can't see him [snorts] but the way that it's kind of like for like function at that point it's just super easy to know what who could see you and who Right.
Um, so yeah, like I I mean I'm actually incredibly impressed. Like the way they have you manage ammo, like that's not fiddly,
right?
Uh, the fact that other enemies if they're in a different group can attack each other is also something that's never done anywhere. I think that's cool. Now, we haven't actually seen that, but it is possible. Um,
yeah, cuz the first mission was all humans and this one was all mutants. So,
I didn't think they were going to throw a boss in like right off ripe, but I guess if like if you're following an a story line and there's only three in that in that section, then they kind of have to ramp things up pretty quick. Uh, and yeah, just the sheer amount of strategy that you that you go in trying to overcome the or meet with the uh the mission objective is insanely good.
Yeah.
Um, and then the fact that it's like you don't just have like a health pool of something. It's like, oh, you hit zero, you die. It's like, oh, you take your critical injury and then, oh, hey, you get rid of all of them if you heal. Oh, cool. So, I think they did a lot of really really nice um quality of life things for this game.
Um are there any any negatives for you?
I mean, big one for me is fail forward. There's no there's no fail forward. I I find that kind of annoying.
Um I mean, there's little things like the paper money. Yeah, the paper money is stupid.
That's out outdated type stuff.
Yeah. And even if you try to do it like cool, like rock hard does it, it's like it's still paper money. Like I'd rather at this point I'd rather just pull out a calculator or a pen and then just write it out.
Yeah. Um but other than that, I don't know if there's really a a ton, you know? I mean,
there's a lot of stuff you have to manage.
Yeah.
But I mean, it's not overly overly done. Um, I was a fan of the uh I like the action trackers.
Yep.
Those are handy. But, um, as far as stuff I don't like, I just don't really know. I mean, other than the line of sight, the line of sight thing kind of bugged me a little bit, but
yeah,
I mean, that's not a dealbreaker by any means. Every game does it differently and and stuff, you know.
Yeah. I mean, line of sight's not a negative for me. I can see where some people could get hung up on it. I think I kind of like I like the simplicity of it. Makes it a lot easier. Um I love the fact that enemies actually have facing. So that is actually incredibly important on how you're going to maneuver and what they because it feels I feel like they actually kind of managed to take a board game and implement video game
systems. Yeah, they did a good job. Um, and they did a lot of simplistic work with the your attention token being like it's either low or high. And oh, these are the hard rules. Like when you're moving, if you're moving your three spaces, it's going to pop the low one in your spot. If you run past their line of sight, uh, then the the heavy one or the heavy one, the uh the high one is going to go in the spot that you like past the corner. So, they're going to go check it out. I think that they found a really good way to make the AI, like the enemies, not [ __ ] stupid,
right?
Where they're just kind of like, "Huh, must have been the wind." It's like, "I'm standing right here." Like, it's like, "Nope, they'll see you." And if you tend to [ __ ] up, you make a mistake, you're kind of going to eat it.
Yeah. Another tiny little nitpick would be how it's kind sometimes difficult to find where the overlays go. Um,
oh yeah, that one is actually kind of uh really annoying
because you you really have to scour sometimes like I have no clue. They didn't like a lot of like uh Agamonia
gives the outer deal so you can kind of see more of the world and there's just what's on the you know.
Yeah. And I mean I'll say that like the the map tiles don't look great like they're not it's not the most detailed uh be it's like these feel like old Gloom Haven tiles a little bit. Um, the other thing that I think could be annoying for a lot of people is you can run into situations like what we did in episode two where you just if you're playing it for the first time, you don't know the outcome. So, it's like if you if you are spending a lot of time strategizing and then you finally get to your destination and it's just like, "Oh, nope. Actually, it's not here."
Yeah. It's like
that happened in the first one actually too cuz I had that key thinking it was
oh for him
the cell key and I and then it ended up being
on clear on the other side
and I hope they don't do that. I hope it's not like always all the time you're just kind of getting [ __ ] It's like, ah, you thought it was here. It's not. Uh, like thinking back, I think it's cool because it's very thematic of like we're in this situation because we thought the ladder would work and this it feels very kind of spec ops of like, oh [ __ ] we're in this horrible situation in this horrible alternate universe. We just need to get in there to get this anomaly and get out. The ladder didn't work. We put all our eggs in that basket. Didn't kill anyone. Now they're all rushing us into this horrible basically bottleneck. So out of a lot of games, you can see the consequences of your actions. But I will say that can still be very annoying when it's like we made it out of the situation and oh cool. They overrate it.
Neat, neat, neat, neat. He has 30 health. We've done eight and we're stuck in the [ __ ]
uh in the building where you just kind of
you can see the writing on the wall. Yeah.
So, I can see and who knows? I mean, we we didn't kill enough of like the sto the snorks. So, the card said he ate it, but then it's like maybe it's in one of these stashes. And who knows, maybe a stash does give you a rocket launcher that you could shoot him and it does 30 damage.
Yeah, it does some big damage [ __ ] Yeah,
with mines. Yeah, like just something uh that could actually help you cuz it's like, okay, there's no way they expect you to use tier one guns to try and deal 30 damage. Like, that's insane.
Uh so I don't know. Like um I I imagine I don't know if I would want to record us redoing it, but just play it again,
right? uh like in our own time and then you know deal with and then just kind of bring everyone up to speed in the next episode.
Yeah, because this specific [clears throat] scenario all the enemies were on the board except for there was going to be three more come out.
Yeah.
You know, cuz one of them was an X, three more came out. So you just deal with those snorks first.
Yeah. It's going to take several turns for him to move out and very slow. Yeah. unless the card specifically says he he moves again. But
I I I can't remember if there was a rule that said if there's none to activate then the ones that are on the board activate uh those those mis those mystery I I can't remember.
But I mean I only read like the rule book once and once to how to play and I was like I think I got it.
Yeah.
Which is awesome. Like that's a great feeling. I also love the fact that when you're shooting, you actually have like body parts to hit.
I think that's really cool. I mean,
Fallout action there.
Exactly. Not quite to that extreme where it's like, I'm going to shoot his hand, but it it's still like, oh, you want to go after the head for to instant damage or the torso or depending on who you're fight like the the head for the giant in this case gives you more options than the torso.
I I just think that's really cool. I think they do a lot of really cool stuff that s that other games would make incredibly fiddly and not fun. Uh but here they managed to make it like really like really indepth. So I mean yeah like I'm I'm very excited. The one thing that I think that is kind of like a it's not amazing. I don't think the writing's that great.
Yeah. Like it's there's not a lot of it. Uh, which is it's not like it's not heavy on narration where you're sitting here for 45 minutes listening to dog [ __ ] primal writing.
Yeah. [snorts]
Um, but it's it's not like so far it's just not it's not really that engaging.
Well, in the game's defense, the the video game didn't have great writing either.
Exactly. Yeah. So, I don't know how much that they took from the video games in terms of like story. I don't know if this is like, hey, this is a story of stalker this game, but in a board game. I don't know. Uh, but yeah, they also have some pseudo legacy elements.
Hey, god. Uh, you actually have a map, like a a stalker map that you actually place stickers on and you'll mark out locations uh if you whenever you finish them or you've gone to them. And there's like a few few things you can do. You can do go talk to your contacts that you have now. you can uh you know go to location, get like a item or something. It's very quick and manageable. So, I like all that, too. There's really actually a lot of things about this game that I like and very little things that I don't like.
Oh, yeah. For sure. It's It's a good game. For sure.
And I'm pleasantly surprised at honestly how good it is. If you love brutal co-ops and and this game, this game is brutal. Even a game with dice resolution for your combat. Like I feel like you you could see the riskreward. I'm going for the head. That has a higher that has a higher star value. I didn't get it. Well, I missed.
Yeah,
that sucks. Uh but I could have just gone for the torso and dealt with it. Um and I will say surprisingly I think this game balances really well with two.
Mhm. Uh, I was kind of worried that the missions were going to be like too big that it's like [ __ ] two of us can't really can't really deal with it.
Yeah.
Um, but looking back, it's like we felt overwhelmed by the enemies because we let them sneak up on us.
Well, and like the I think the change with solo is you get uh four action cuz it's a different one of these.
Yeah, it's just a tempo. get three actions per turn, right?
So, you essentially get six actions,
right? So, I mean, but but everything else stays the same.
Yep.
So, I mean, it's
I mean, the number of event cards uh you have changed. There's a there's a little icon that says, you know, number of players minus this.
If I was to have this game and own it, I would and play it solo. I still run two characters, though.
Oh, you would? Oh,
I pretty much I pretty much want to run two characters because I think you can
kind of like what we were talking about possibly doing at one point was lure away and do stuff, you know, like I I like having that option of having a second person be kind of like a
Yeah.
diversion. Um certain things
they do say it's like a it's one page. It's single stalker mode. Real stalkers seldom go out in groups. Too many guys to divide the loot. Real professionals go into the zone alone. So, and then they also mention um like there's a lost territories thing. There is also uh you don't have to play this as a campaign. You can play it as a oneshot and they have rules for how to do that. I didn't read those cuz I was like I'm playing this as a campaign.
But yeah, no, I'm I'm very intrigued. I'm very excited to continue. I'm honestly kind of excited to try this mission again. uh and and see how that outcome goes. He's probably going to eat it again.
I just think I cuz those were what ended up killing us.
Uh the snors. I mean, you get rid of those why they're spread out and stuff and just get we just hunker down and just take them out.
Yeah.
I think that's that's the way
that's the thing though is like this this map layout is so jank like line of sight. It was hard. It was hard for me.
Yeah. like because I was like I need I I'm best at range four or more and there wasn't a lot of like straight shot. There was like a lot of walls, a lot of corners and stuff that I'm like I can't really That was the best shot. That was my best opportunity. I shot twice this whole mission.
I shot three times.
Yeah. So, so yeah. I mean, which again I think is just highly thematic. I'm a sniper and it's like well I need clear line of sight to do well.
So yeah. Uh I guess we'll see. Um do you have anything else? I think so.
Cool. On a scale of 1 to 10, would you give me stalker the board game
at this point because we're a couple games into the campaign and I know like you said this is a preliminary deal. I would probably go with like an eight right now.
Yeah. Um, yeah, there's gives it room for me to,
you know, move up if it if it ends up panning up and getting even better the deeper you get into it.
But it it's not going to get wor. I guess it could get worse because I've had games like that where it's gotten,
but uh but yeah, I'd say an eight solid. No, that's exactly where I'm at as well. I I completely agree. I think this is a very good game. I'm excited to see how it goes, but I could see how it could get worse if every mission just kind of is a big middle finger for everything you do. Yeah.
Or if you constantly are getting swarmed and it's like you just kind of have that fine balance like this second mission where we lost. It's like
you see the mistakes you made so you're not upset, but then it's like I don't want There could be missions where it's like I don't know what we could have done different to to try and beat this besides RNG. So, that's a possibility. But, yeah, I I also just love the fact that it's there's not like a million missions to do.
Yep.
Which I guess Awaken Robes doesn't really like Dragon Eclipse was very bite-sized. Um, I guess is Vanguard and Tang Grail are massive, massive campaigns, but
I don't know about uh cuz I haven't looked to see how how many sessions the new Asylum game by is going to be.
Or Grim Coven.
Yeah. But yeah, so that's our thoughts on Stalker the board game. Uh, let us know what you think of the game in the comments below and stick around for the rest of the series. Like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever day it is for you.