Skip to main content
Loading video...

Broom Service Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 9:32

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings gener really like to talk a lot of bcks tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a pickup and deliver game designed by Alexander Fister we're going to be talking about brm service and in this game you will be flying around a map trying to deliver potions to different regions it'll give you points that will hopefully win a game set in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules between telling you what we do like we don't like and we'll come back with tell you whether or not broom service is still worth your time and bother today and in the future so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] see you after this bollocks so broom service how you play this game so broom service is a pick up and deliver game designed by alexand Fister to set up each player is going to get a set of identical roll cards you're going to get one potion of each color green purple and red and depending on where you are in the turn order you'll get one or two ones right so the game consists of seven rounds with a variable amount of turns in each round at the beginning of each round each player is going to simultaneously choose four of their 10 roll cards and this will become their hand start and player for each round will choose one of their roll cards and they'll put it face up on the table and you'll see that each of these cards has a strong action and a weak action you start by announcing which of the actions

you will play you play the weak or cowardly action then you get to take the action that's on the card if you announce the strong action player to your left will then announce whether they have the same card in their hand and if they do you don't get to take the action but they do they will do the same thing they Ann outs whether they want to take the Cowardly or brave action if they take the Cowardly action they'll be able to resolve the card if they choose the brave action then the next player on they left will see whether they got that card if they have then they do the same thing if they haven't it goes to the next player and so on and so forth right depend dependent on the player count some of these cards will be set off to the side and this means that if you play these cards there'll be a victory Point penalty if you decide to play them so you can play them but you're going to lose points of doing it so if you play a witch card these will generally allow you to move your witches around the board and then deliver a potion to one of the towers you see there's two different types of towers if you deliver to a square top Tower then you'll stick the potion in the General Supply this is like an infinite sort of thing a magic porridge pot in it where it just keeps on allowing you to deliver stuff you go to a rter then you'll put your potion on top of that Tower to say that it's been used right and nobody else can go there so droids will allow you to deliver potions to Towers to get an extra fre victory points right depending on what action you take so this is a nice way of getting some extra points if you can play the brave action with them you also see there's clouds on the board can't move onto Cloud tiles unless you dispel the clouds right the way you do this is you play the weather fairy card and this will allow you to spend wands to Magic away the clouds I wish I had have [ __ ] w so I could magic away this permanent cloud above my [ __ ] head if

you meure to do this then you will keep the cloud and you'll get fre victory points don't get three victory points for you do you [ __ ] so also at the beginning of the round you'll reveal one of the 10 event cards here these will enact some sort of special ability during the game you might play the black market and black Distillery cards this way a player can decide whether to take the action or event each time the player plays a cowardly role yeah or you might end up playing the works now it's not that shitty album by [ __ ] Queen is it it means that each player can only deliver a maximum of one set of resources this round so these event cards sort of mix a game up they add a nice little bit of unknown [ __ ] to the game yeah there's also a few variants in the game can't be [ __ ] to talk about them because we usually only play the basic game of this but yeah after seven rounds player with the most victory points will be the winner of broom service so do we like about broom service so the first thing that we [ __ ] bag so the first thing that we like about broom service is that it has a nice little tiny little bit of take that in this game right if things go according to plan you can Scupper your opponent's turns by playing the same card that they have couple of problems with this which I'll talk about a bit the central mechanism of pushing you like just that little tiny bit by playing the brave action hoping that somebody else hasn't played it can be a little bit exciting especially not if you're on the receiving end but especially if you're the one who manages to take the action and nobody else has played the same card right sort of borrows a little bit from another fister's design called Royal where you'll be drawing cards until you get a certain number of ships but it sort of twists it on its head somewhat yeah I

think a part of this is It's A Familiar thing and it just adds a little bit of tension to each turn right so second thing we like about broom service is related to the first point right is that the main mechanic adds a nice little bit of deduction fused with a little bit of luck right it is possible to sort of card count know what cards people have already played especially if you're going to go last in the round you're going to be able to see exactly what all of the other players have played so being able to maybe semi deduce what people are doing adds a little bit of skill don't it but you got the luck of doing this after you've Charing your cars you know it's the final thing lot about broom service is it looks [ __ ] Charming don't it it reminds us a little bit of the board of small world maybe it was drawn by the same person the colors are really really nice the artwork on the cards is really really super we couldn't find the English version when we got this so we had to pick out the German version and I found some card scans on a Russian print and play ball game website translated the English and that [ __ ] so that's why our cards look a little bit [ __ ] I mean the pieces are a little bit of a disappointment you know could have done with maybe some better witches rather than those stupid things that look like have come out of a 70s MB Games coffin box but the overall aesthetic is actually quite nice and pleasing to my eye right not my third eye these eyes but don't we like B broom service so the first thing that we don't like about this game is it feels a little bit abstract to us it's a bit weird that you've got bags of personality in the cards know all the little cartoony characters are really

really nice and then when you look at the board you've got those stupid wooden witch things that I think we've seen in the Enchanted Forest or something for a Ravensburger game from years ago so it don't really feel like there's much going on on the board you know maybe it could have done with a more expensive production but then I suppose these Ravensburger games Pride themselves or at least they used to Pride themselves on being reasonable cheap and accessible you know if you think about castles of burgundy in the same sort of vein I mean we picked up for 15 quid way back in the day and now they're selling a deluxe version for [ __ ] 200 quid yeah maybe broom service will get a revamp maybe it'll get a deluxified version that people will spunk 300 quid Kickstarter on right but yeah I feel a little bit lonely playing this know maybe I'll bring my teddy bear next time you know so the second thing that we don't like about broom service and this is the main thing that we don't like about it is that sometimes on your turn you can't do [ __ ] all cuz you're just unlucky enough to choose the cards everybody else has where you are choosing your cards blind you can't really make an informed decision as to which cards you should choose and you need to play those Brave cards in order to win the game right if you keep playing those Cy cards it's going to take you longer to get where you want to go so you're going to have to make a decision as to when you want to play these tough as [ __ ] cards right only problem being is that you don't know what other people have chosen there's no hints on offer unless you do this towards the end of the round where a lot of cards have come out but it's still going to be pissing in the wind and we've played games of this where some people haven't been able to take an action for [ __ ] ages and they end up

getting frustrated and punch a hole in my plaster Ball wall so the final thing that we don't like about broom service is that removal of some cards to the side with a three-point penalty based on player count seems a little bit sloppy and a little bit lazy it's almost as if they designed a game and then came back and went hang on a minute there's too many cards in play for low player accounts what what we do about it I know let's just take some cards out the [ __ ] deck and those cards might be the cards that you really really needed to play this round right not only might you get neutered by other players taking the actions your turns are also nerfed by the fact that the game tells you to remove cards right my advice is don't play this with less than five players that really gets under my nut sack so to summarize is broom service still worth your time and bother 8 years after it was first released in 2015 think it's 2015 yeah 2015 so we're going to say maybe maybe not brm service is an interesting yet flawed pick up and deliver game that is fun but suffers from a sense of plotting and unfair turns right you need to be bold to win but in doing so you may not be able to do anything on your turn and this is a [ __ ] crime that said this is still an okay game if you don't get wrapped up in the uneven nature of its Central mechanism I'm just not convinced broom service is as good as all of the awards has received would have you believe so you go that is broom service remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel hit the like button and all that YouTube

[ __ ] we'll see you next

time

Progress saved