Wingspan Pocket Review: A Bird in the Hand is Worth Two in the Pocket
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal.
I'm Chris Yee.
I'm Mike Delisio.
The new trend in board gaming is no longer dual games,
No.
but it is shortened versions of popular games as evidenced here by Wingspan Pocket, which I know for sure doesn't fit in the pocket.
You If you wear
And I have big pockets.
trendy cargo shorts like me, you can have a big bulbous box sticking out the side of your leg.
Maybe with those old Janco jeans or whatever they were called way, way back. I never owned a pair of them.
It is a pretty small game though compared to Wingspan. It says it's called a lighter, swifter version of the award-winning Wingspan. 25 to 35 minutes, which cracks me up on the back of the box they couldn't just put 30 minutes. But they want that that range in there.
think with player count, I think that's actually smart.
I don't know. I just want to say 30 minutes, I guess. But [clears throat] um let's take a look at how it plays. You don't need to know anything about Wingspan. I'll explain how to play the game and we'll be right back. At the beginning of the game, each player starts with a nest card. You also start with six cards. Now, every card in this game is double-sided. There's food on one side and a bird on the other side. So, you're going to be flipping two of these up and this is sort of it's face up, but it is your hand. You'll have two birds and you have four cards, which are essentially food. Now, if you're playing the advanced game, you can pick which of your two birds, which your six cards are birds and which four are food. And then you'll start the game. On a player's turn, it tells you right here on your nest card, you have three different actions. You can play a bird, draw two cards, or lay up to three eggs on different cards.
So, let's talk about drawing cards first. There's going to be three piles of cards in the middle that are food with the top card flipped up that are birds, you will just draw these into your hand, which is in front of you. So, I can draw a bird and then the top card from here. Cards aren't replaced till the end of your turn. And then these cards just come to your hand. You can draw two food, two birds, or one of each. You can also play a bird. So, when you play a bird, you will look at the bird. The bird will have a cost. Now, fortunately, uh you're going to be starting with an egg. So, this one here costs an egg, a berry, and a worm. So, I would just discard both of these for the berry and the worm. Discard an egg. And I would play this card here from the nest from left to right. And then that final action, which is laying eggs, is just putting egg on different cards. Your nest can hold three eggs.
And birds that are in front of you can also hold a certain amount of eggs, whatever it shows on the bird. Now, here's the thing. Every time you take an action, there are these three actions to take, you are also going to activate your flock. When you activate your flock, you'll start with your left-hand card and just go over activating any brown powers that are there. So, for example, this one here says, "I can draw a food card and I can draw any food card." It might be more specific or might even be more vague. Well, this one says I can draw a food card or a bird card. While this one here says, "I can draw a food card as long as it has uh the grain on it." And there's all kinds of cards and you're going to activate them. There are many different brown effects. Some of them allow you to tuck cards under your card. Some allow you This one copies the right-most brown bird power to the player to your left.
Sometimes they do things like this. With this one gives an egg to you and an egg to everybody, including you. Sometimes there You know, there's all sorts of things that are in here. Some cards are green powers like this one or this one here. These don't activate when you run through your cards. Rather, instead, they give you something that a special ability. Like this one you can use fish as wild when playing birds. Or this one lets you ignore a worm in bird costs. So, this is the game. You will take your turn and you will go on activating your brown powers. And when somebody puts out their sixth bird in a line, that's going to trigger the end of the game. Make sure everyone has an equal number of turns. And there you go. I should mention this says feathers in it. This is just to keep track of when you go through all your different powers. Points in the game come from birds themselves are worth a certain number of points, these feathers on them.
Each egg is going to be worth one. Tucked cards are going to be worth them. And at the end of the game, you're going to look at the gold display. So, at the beginning of the game, you're going to put two cards uh on top of this. So, this one would say beak pointing left and at least one card tucked behind it. These are going to give you extra points for each egg on a bird with a beak pointed left. Or bird has at least one card tucked behind it. And there's all sorts of cards worth two They're two-sided cards, so you're going to have lots of options, but you'll be playing with two of them per game. You'll add up all your points. Whoever has the most points is the winner.
One thing I did not do is I did not compare the birds to see if they were from all sets or from one set, if they're from the original set.
There are hummingbirds in there, right? So,
Yeah, I don't know.
That's a recent thing.
So, one of the groups I played this with actually just when I played it someone walked by the table and said, "I own all of Wingspan. I just kind of want to see Oh, there's African birds." I mean, it was It's amazing how
Yeah.
knowledgeable people are about even just like, "Oh, that bird's new." I'm like, "Why do you have every single bird memorized?" So, yeah, there This is going to be just kind of a melange of birds.
A melange.
Yeah.
A menagerie.
I will say one thing, they did not lie about the time. It is a quick game and it is going back to components like all Stonemaier games, very well put together. The cards I had no questions on anything other than, you know, like what does a symbol mean? The biggest thing people ask is which symbol means draw a resource card, which one is draw any card, but I found it to be pretty easy and everyone has their own little thing that explains all the icons and everything in the game and it even tells you your actions on your turn. It's like really if if you can't you almost don't need the rules to figure out the game.
It's well, especially if you've played Wingspan. If you haven't played Wingspan, well, no, I think it really gives you a boost because the icons are kind of consistent. Like, you know, what a wild icon is is consistent throughout. So, but if you haven't played Wingspan, I agree. I mean, everything you need is right there. It tells you you what the three actions you can take on your little nest card. The rules are well done. Good solid package, good user interface.
I agree. I agree on all accounts. I really enjoy the the double-sided nature of the cards. It's a little bit of that like point salad type of thing where there's face-up and there's face-down stacks and then the face-down has one purpose and the face-up have the other. I think that's great because it naturally just creates variety cuz some birds you're just never going to see because I took them as a cherry as a berry. You know what I mean? And and it's also just economy of stuff in the box. You don't need lots of different resources. Also, I like the food market mechanically in gameplay in this one way more than the original Wingspan.
I think everyone's going to like it better though in the sense. The only disadvantage that the new food market has is occasionally you need a resource and you're like, it is not on the top. You can use any two as a wild, but I might go, "Man, I love that there was a cherry on top. Do I draw a card hope oh, it's still not there." Sometimes that happens where you might get stuck. That two-for-one kind of solves that.
Yeah, I felt way more stuck in in basic Wingspan.
Oh, for sure. Sure. I would say here's how I would put it. Um, I like it better than basic Wingspan. I still think it does have the issue that pops up that you mentioned. I still like most how how the the kind of the feeding happens in almost every other span game still over this.
Oh, like just like the newest Wingspan, it's just cards.
Yeah, exactly. Exactly. So, it's not I don't think it's as as elegant as some of the later span games, but it's better than Wingspan.
It's also shorter, and so I'm okay with a little bit of that. Oh, maybe I can get something from the market, you know, hopefully I'll reveal some cards. Okay, next turn. Uh, it does definitely get a little bit obnoxious though if you have a if if the the by the way, the birds you fire off every single turn
Yes.
is unbelievably cool.
Mhm.
But, I have seen people get shut out a lot when it says grab a fish is one of your powers you get to activate. And when five turns in a row there's no fish in the market, that's where it stings a little bit more.
I agree.
Well, to that point, so that's something we've been mentioning Wingspan a lot, but this game is fairly different. And the main difference is the fact that you are firing off the same row of birds every single turn. If you're someone who likes that engine, hey, this card goes off every single turn. And the first two couple turns you may not have one. Although, most people can usually build a bird on the first turn or whatever. And then it goes off over and over and over and over again. And some of the birds are clearly better than other birds going off every turn. You know, if there's one that gives me an egg every turn, that's fantastic. If there's one that lets me draw a card every turn, that's fantastic. And I want to get those earlier. If there's one that says tuck a cherry card from your hand underneath, that's possibly good. And I might even set up a if I have one that says draw a cherry card right before that, that's pretty awesome.
But, you're building this engine that goes off a a but also is small. It's a six-card engine and you're only going to run six cards once. And they may not all be brown powers. They may be the things that that make things cheaper, too. So, yeah. I I think that that's an interesting thing they pull off. It feels a little bit to me like a mixture of Wingspan, right? Where you've got your your birds on display and the idea of that is in both Wormspan and Finspan of firing off like moving your guy across the the the cave there in in in Wormspan. So, that kind of that satisfaction, it happens more often here and that's why I feel like this is this is a game that in its amount of time, which is short, gives you a lot of dopamine hits.
Did you uh did you play Jump Drive, the quicker version of Race for the Galaxy
I don't believe I did.
exactly the same analogy there. Yeah. I and I think that this is a little bit more robust of a game than Jump Drive compared to Race for the Galaxy. Uh or sorry, or comparing this to Jump Drive. Anyway, I I think that it just that constant idea of like firing off engine. Every card that you build, you're just going to keep seeing it happen and happen. It's great. I think it condenses a lot into a little.
I think it's a lot One last thing, I think it's also really smart that a lot of the cards will affect other people on your turn, too. So, you're always feeling like something's happening.
Yeah, as although I will briefly to that point, I know that those cards that say do the person's action to your left or right, that's kind of cool and it promotes interaction. I found them kind of annoying because I like, "What does your card do again?" Okay, what does your card Oh, it changed. I I It just wasn't as smooth as I would like that to have been. I I'm waffling on this one a lot. I played it several times because this engine going off First of all, I think it's almost imperative that maybe not for your first game, but every game after that, you have to play the advanced rules.
Yeah, 100%.
to play where you're picking your two starting birds yes because that first bird you play out is so critical cuz you're going to activate it like 20 times or I don't know. I'm making up numbers. I don't know how many but you're definitely activating it a lot.
of any of your
So you want a really good one out there or one that's going to be useful to you. I played one game I played one guy his first card was he got a an egg and then everyone got an egg including him and then we were like, "We're never taking the egg action." because you're giving us eggs. Now you he can choose not to do that and you don't have to do them as you go through them. But then he's hurting himself just to hurt us cuz he's getting two eggs out of the deal.
Yeah.
But there comes a point where, you know, you're full on eggs and everything. And so if I get the card out there first that lets me draw a card, any card, as my first bird out, that's pretty powerful. As opposed to take a weak card or tuck a card or or draw a card off the top of the deck and hope it's the right one. So I I it's an interesting idea but I feel like the game feels very lucky to me which I think might be satisfying to people because it's 30 minutes but if someone gets a nice little engine running halfway through I can go "They're going to win."
You know, they draw a cherry card. They then tuck that card. Um they then have a card or whatever, you know, then they get these cards for a discount. I don't even need to spend cherries or whatever. You can get a little combo going which feels great when you have it less so when you don't. Um and the other thing I don't love about the game and I really don't like this. I just I think the bonuses are for for a game that's so easy to teach people teaching those bonus cards every time I'm like, "Okay, listen. Each egg that you have on that bird will be worth two points which they could have just said, you know, for if you match these characteristics or three I guess if you match both characteristics with that bird." And almost every time someone at the table goes "Oh, at the end." "It's the eggs. I thought it was every bird facing to the left." and I I thought we explained it.
Yeah.
You know, um because after the first game I played I was like, oh, I better be really clear and that and still people forgot. That rule for some reason feels a little janky. I don't know a better way around I would almost rather they just gave you points rather than doubling the eggs.
Yeah, that that is also technically the advanced game, Tom, but also you should play it immediately. You should play it you should play it immediately, I think. Maybe at least you're by your second game.
Especially if you've played Wingspan. 100% yeah.
Yeah, um I think I agree with you on the luck. I think this feels significantly luckier than Wingspan and I think that that is the trade-off for getting it this quick.
Sure.
I don't think you could have done both really realistically and so I think that that's going to be one of the decision points you make. What is your tolerance for luck? Is it a higher tolerance if it's in a shorter game? For many people it is, for some people it's not. But I 100% agree, this definitely has a a luckier feel and for me where it hits me strangely is less with um the combos and more with the food. Like I feel it more with the food even here than I did in regular Wingspan where it's just like and it's mostly what you're talking about is like there are several times that you would be able to trigger a bonus if the card was out there and you just can't and it feels bad every single time. So.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's funny, right? Because I agree I agree with the shortcomings here.
Uh we haven't said scores or anything have we?
No, no, I was waiting to talk through it.
Yeah.
For for me Yeah, I really waffle on this. I I disagree with you. I I like Wingspan better especially with an expansion.
Oh, I didn't Did I didn't say Did I say I like Wing this better than Wingspan?
said that it was better than Wingspan or they liked it better than Wingspan. Maybe you said you liked the
I I like the food the way the food works better.
I like Wingspan better because it's a very robust game and I don't mind that I know going in especially with an expansion which is my preferred way to play it with especially with the new Americas expansion, but I get that that's a longer game. I get what this is doing. This is the I don't think this is unnecessary. I just didn't love it, but I also didn't dislike. This is 6.5. It's really close. I I I played it several times. It's kind of enjoyable, but sometimes I would be like, "Yeah." And other times I'd go, "Maybe next game." And again, it's 30 minutes, so maybe that's not a thing. The my the the city game or Jump Drive that you mentioned earlier, I think that's 15 minutes or something. And even then, I like Race for the Galaxy better cuz I kind of like that robustness. It's not always the case. So, when I was talking to someone about this, they're like, "Are you a gamer?" No, I just played that Catan on the go, and I like that better than Catan.
Sometimes shorter is better for me, but in this case, I admire it. I think it's good. I I almost want to say at taking my recommendation aside for a lot of people, I'd be like, "Oh, I recommend you play this for sure." Just for me, it's a 6.5.
I'll go next if you don't mind cuz I have a feeling it's going to go boop boop boop. Just a guess, but I'm at a a 7.5. I do recommend it, but I don't know I I don't even know that I could say I like it better than Wingspan. To me, they're fulfilling very different purposes with the same kind of like playground you're playing in. Basically, collecting birds and and, you know, doing a bit of a resource economy and things along those lines. And so, I think that they both do that, but they're they're serving very different purposes. It's tricky for me because now I don't even think about Wingspan. I think about the other spans, which I like better, right? But, that being said, I still think that if you want this kind of an experience where you like birds and you like this I some of the the the hallmarks of Wingspan, and you just want to play it more quickly and and set it up in minutes, right? Then this is a good this is a good option for you. I don't think it replaces Wingspan by any means. I think it's two very different things happening.
It might It might though. If you think Wingspan's too long, but you like the idea, this might be the replacement for you.
I don't think it's as robust. I don't think that you know, I I think inevitably this will come out with expansions, and I think that's dangerous to an extent because when you add expansions to a pocket game, is it really a pocket game anymore? So, I That's
realm.
That's another whole thing. I think that this is a little too slight to ever replace Wingspan in my mind, but it serves a different purpose, and for the purpose it think it's trying to serve, I think it's a 7.5.
I'm And I'm You're correct. I'm just a scooch higher at an eight. I really enjoy this even though I have had some dud games. I have. Uh but they're not terrible duds. They're just kind of Oh, I didn't get things fired off as as well as I was hoping to. And it leaves me with that desire to play it again, whereas sometimes some games uh do have that fragility or that unevenness where you have a bad game you go, That was just a bad feeling game. I haven't felt that with this. I've had bad games where I didn't play well, and I go, Ooh, let me take another crack at it, which is a good sign to me. I really enjoy this. I personally enjoy it more than Wingspan because I don't I do think that that game drags a little bit, especially at the higher player counts. I would sooner play this at the four and five player count
Absolutely.
than classic Wingspan.
That's hard to argue.
Yeah, yeah, you're right.
But I know that I'm biased. I just don't like the classic Wingspan as much, but the other iterations, Finspanned particularly, I think is really smooth. And so, this one kind of fits in line with some of the modernized changes I think that they've made since the original. I I do recommend it. I think that if you particularly have that proclivity towards small, quick engine-building games, I think that there's going to be a lot for you to enjoy in this one. And when things don't fire off, you know, it's it do- it doesn't it I've never seen someone get blown out of the water cuz they weren't able to get that fish and tuck it under the penguin. Uh penguin's my favorite card. So, uh yeah, I like this one a lot. It's an eight for me.
Also, if this is successful, I imagine, and I know I have no knowledge, you'll see a Finspanned pocket at some point.
Yeah, which would be interesting because Finspanned is closest in time to this game than any the other span games.
It's still at least twice, but yeah.
Yeah.
Anyway, there you go folks. That's Wingspan Pocket from Stonemaier Games. I'm Tom.
I'm Chris.
I'm Mike.
Tweet, tweet.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Yeah, we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.