Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 71: Ev Davis on RPGs Beyond D&D

Transcript 58:41

hey gamers quick add break as you probably know by now the beyond solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations and that is a project that i'm super excited about because i believe that learning through play is the best way to do it and the clgs is making it happen in college classrooms and hopefully high school ones part of that initiative is a games press if you want to back their first successful kickstarter project pre-orders for monumental consequence by dr mary beth looney are open now and keep an eye out for rising waters designed by dr scout bloom this is an upcoming game about the mississippi flood of 1927 one of the worst natural disasters in american history and i will be interviewing dr bloom about it on this podcast in the coming weeks thanks so much and let's get started with the show hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and this week on the pot i have a very special guest i have ev davis also known as whistler he is a larper tabletop rpg expert writer and artist how you doing i'm doing great how are you doing i'm doing awesome i'm so happy to have you on here so uh for those of you who are wondering how we met which i will just as we are uh evan i met at a play test of monumental consequence uh by mary beth looney and we'd known each other before that through the yale community but uh ev has great things to say about larps and tabletop rpg things

that i know very little about which is why you're on here to answer my questions but first off you are uh the new author of an upcoming tabletop game yourself you want to tell us about rap scouting uh yeah sure um it is a pbta powered by the apocalypse game uh tabletop game about pirates uh magical pirates on fun adventures and there should be a a preview of the game a free preview online uh sometime in the next month i'm waiting on my publisher for that uh but yeah i'll uh hopefully it'll be out by the time this airs i'll send a link to it awesome so when you say pbta what what does it mean to be powered by the apocalypse that's a great question uh so i think the the bread and butter for a lot of people of tabletop games is obviously dungeons and dragons uh that's the milestone i think the or or maybe the gateway drug depending on who you ask um and dungeons and dragons is a lot of people assume that it's sort of the baseline for rpgs because it's so ubiquitous and that's not necessarily true uh it's it's definitely from a tradition of war gaming and strategy gaming um and in that it creates this really great casual experience but i think a lot of people assume that if they take the mechanical structure of d and d and supplant it

into other systems that say let's like oh let's make an urban fantasy let's make a red wall game let's make you know that kind of thing it'll work just fine and uh it's a dangerous assumption to make because you're supplanting a war game you're making strategy game mechanics um or like what used to be strategy game mechanics um and i would recommend powered by the apocalypse as an alternative to that uh powered by the apocalypse uh originated as a game called apocalypse world by vincent baker who actually i think lives in my area uh and he was generous enough to put the structure of apocalypse world which was originally mad max style you know a game about post-apocalyptic uh scavengers in a desert wasteland environment uh he was generous enough to put it on essentially creative commons so anyone can attempt to supplant that structure into another game and it's become very popular because it's not so much a structure as a vague framework and in fact i would suggest if you want to get into making rpgs making a powered by the apocalypse game is a great place to start because it forces you to think about how to shape the experience of your players what exactly you're trying to get out of um the tabletop rpg that you're making uh and it's specifically a game that tries to

frame the experience as a narrative one as a collaborative story uh so there are like beats that they try to hit uh you still roll dice which is a pretty common mechanic in a lot of tabletops but it's not um uh every minute as it might be with a dnd game comes in some dragons game instead you make moves uh which are triggered by the story so in a pirate game for instance in rapscallion which i'll draw from here since i made it um it's uh a a a common move might be um do use a dirty trick get into a scrap break in or out of something um twist your fate things like that um and those are the basic moves if you if you do one of those things in the narrative that's when you roll a dice to see what happens um and by making and they're essentially like tiny little mini games you could think of them each time you roll it there's like a variety of things that might happen that the game will tell you and uh i think the goal there is to focus the experience of the players into uh specific categories right you're trying to think like a pirate you're trying to make pirate moves if you're not doing pirate moves you don't need to roll the dice that's not what the story is about um and there's a lot more to it than that but i would call that as the sort of the central framework of a pbta or powered by the apocalypse story

um and uh vincent baker's framework oh that's really interesting was dungeons and dragons your first tabletop experience it's the only tabletop experience that i have other than little solo rpgs so i'm just curious i think it was yeah i started very late i didn't really have any friends who were into it until i got to college but yes i think i started with 3.5 edition in college uh and moved to 5e the current edition of dungeons and dragons and uh i think at the same time i also did world of darkness stuff which is its own can of worms for those of you who know world darkness uh similar similar to dnd and the sort of essential structure of it um but it's an urban fantasy about you know vampires and werewolves and so on oh that's really interesting okay so i i want to go back to what you said about how sometimes we think of dungeons and dragons like the base rpg but i mean i actually find it familiar because i play a lot of war games and so those mechanisms for me seem very natural how do you break out you know once you've been sort of conditioned to expect that this is how role-playing works what other kinds of experiences are out there for people who are ready to break that mold that's a great question um in my head anyway i've sort of categorized them into three options um vaguely right like there's obviously many ways in which you can approach an rpg a role-playing experience let's call

it um obviously one of them is a word competitive style game where there is an assumed enemy right and as a result the dungeon master the game master uh will uh roll their own dice for the enemy and you have to beat them um is the baseline assumption there obviously that's where d and d comes from um and then there's more narrative style games and pbta isn't the only one obviously but it's a sort of typical version of the genre um and then there are games that i would describe as attempting a form of group therapy or a cathartic experience they're aiming for an emotional cathartic experience in a safe space and among those i would maybe a good example would be the uh no dice no masters game which does not include dice rolling at all um an example might be wander home uh which i on the copy of it's a great game um where winning and losing are is not even remotely close to the point um and like i think there are traps that one can go into if you don't frame your experience from that way both as a player and as a creator of games so if you have a um for instance uh if you come into dungeons and dragons and say oh i love to tell stories and i really

want to like make this cool character and then you happen to be in a group that doesn't really focus on that and focuses on in fact the things that dungeons and dragons is good at uh the combat and the uh the sort of dungeon crawling aspect um you might end up being disappointed in not knowing why and um i think i'm not going to call it out by name because i feel like that would be a little rude but there was this game that i that i stumbled upon that touted itself and had amazing art along the lines of this exploration game you know there's this deep fey jungle um that resists all attempts uh of civilization to encroach it right and um the the game told cells of that as its main aspect of you exploring this jungle it's like far too dangerous for any like mere mortal but you're still like going into it trying to discover secrets and i was like oh that's amazing right like that's something that i think dungeons and dragons doesn't do very well uh it sometimes frames itself as an exploration game but i've like gm professionally for a long time for dungeons and dragons and it's not there's not very many mechanics that do well for that anyone who plays the ranger will will know that's the case and um i think uh i i sort of saw this game as an outlet you know like a something i

could i could i could use because i love exploration anytime i play a video game that's those are the ones i gravitate towards you know hollow knight uh things like that and unfortunately i was very disappointed to find that it the only mechanics it offered were combat ones it was very similar to d d it used a very similar dice system even um and it had a very strict win-loss mechanic which is another thing that typifies strategy games you know um what i would call the neutral fail state you are punished with boredom um and that was really disappointing to me and honestly spite can be just as strong a fuel as exciting optimism uh because i would love to make a game that is actually about exploration and not in a colonialist way like it often is with board games i think um but in a in a truly like exciting like the feeling of going into your backyard and and finding like this patch of woods and something like that i would love to do something that actually attempts that uh in a way that is non-combative you know uh but that's like a good example of of maybe a game that is trying to it had amazing art too like this mysterious forest with these huge hulking figures in the background but again a game that was trying to do something but getting way laid perhaps by um the mechanics that d has sort of typified and codified in the genre

interesting so when you uh when you were designing rap scouting what did you want players to experience as pirates because we think about the swashbuckle part right with i mean you we're talking about combat but there are a lot of other aspects of being a pirates how how do you choose to structure that for yourself to create your own i'm assuming it's some sort of ideal experience that you wrote it yeah absolutely that's a great question um i think so one of the one of the baseline assumptions dmd offers is that death is the final option it's a final failure right that is the stakes that you die um and i don't necessarily think that's true for pirates you know pirates only die when it's sufficiently dramatic to do so uh so that's what we did with the game and i think that's true of a lot of pvta people powered by the apocalypse games are often death is not really the arbiter of things like if you're playing a high school drama death is like a weird anomaly right um for instance and um i think for rapscallion what we wanted was for there to be stakes obviously but the stakes are often you give in to your vices as a pirate you uh oh you start you start to uh get that greedy treasure lust again or uh oh you fall in love with your opponent oh no the romance the swashbuckling etc etc um so that's the kind of uh story i wanted to tell so a lot of the time um you know you

there's uh first of all for powered by the apocalypse games losing uh or failing a dice roll is uh framed differently as with many other games um there's a sort of uh hit or miss aspect where if you miss a dice roll in the parlance you uh instead the the story keeps going something happens um it's just something that might be outside of the player's control as opposed to inside it right there is sort of like the basic level of how much how much say do i have and what happens how good is that aspect related to me um so let's take one of the moves i mentioned earlier uh of getting into a scrap if you hit getting into a scrap that means that you get to you know that's like the combat move right that's the move where you fight people um and hitting that means not only that you might get to harm them or get into an advantageous position but that maybe you take their stuff if you're really good or um you kind of get a scimitar to their throat and and can tell everyone to back off or even that you gain sort of bond with them which in this game means that you have some kind of connection that you can leverage um and if you miss you don't die necessarily it just means that they get to do something to you maybe they kidnap you maybe they uh without a flamethrower and uh start

toasting your ship and you kind of are are desperately trying to get there um but whatever happens the narrative continues and the narrative becomes interesting as a result of it and that's sort of the biggest if i had to describe like one difference between pbta and like a dungeons and dragon system uh that would be it uh and for me that's kind of great for a pirate story because you can typify losing as uh anything you want essentially oh that's really interesting i love this idea of thinking about winning and losing and i guess conflict differently because i think conflict doesn't always have to be fighting but i i mean i think most games have conflict except maybe things in that third category of role-playing where you're having a cathartic but even then like like wander home has this amazing section it's probably the best section of the book i mean the whole book is great so by wandering etc um but it has this that has this one section that's like um uh like losing is an invention made by games you don't lose in real life that never happens maybe you maybe you miss a step maybe you feel embarrassed maybe you feel like you're a failure and no one's supporting you in this but let's talk about that and let's not talk let's not frame it in sort of such

strict terms and i think for that kind of therapeutic type of game um that is is one of the most interesting aspects to it yeah absolutely what i'm hearing too is as you talk about your own game and as you talk about these you know like wonder home these are experiences that i think in some ways it's also easier to just set up a combat and roll and see who wins or loses it seems to me that in order to have a narrative that's consistently interesting you have a story you want to tell but because it's a game it's also a highly interactive experience where the other person the person playing the game has to reach back and make it come alive and i mean i'm i'm personally down for most things right but you know people are shy i can be shy how do you draw people into a game like this they're going to get the maximum best experience possible because i feel like with a with a with a game of this nature you have to give a lot to get a lot yes for sure and i think that's what i was talking about earlier about knowing what experience you want from a game from a role-playing game is really important because role-playing games represent a sort of intimacy not necessarily encouraged by adults of a certain age and um that is uh sometimes difficult to get people into i i work with kids i do dnd for kids and something i've noticed uh obviously they get into it they love it

but um the fact that when you fail nothing happens is very difficult for them there's a sort of frustration tolerance that you learn as an adult that kids don't yet have access to where it feels it it feels um yeah again like they're being punished with boredom which is the worst punishment of all you're playing a game you want to have fun and when you uh you know have to spend half an hour waiting for your turn in your initiative order and you attack twice and you miss both times it's as if you did nothing at all and that's oh that's that's punishing um and in that way for people who think like that people who who uh find that increasingly frustrating um i think there's very little obstacle to getting into a game like pbta it's um it feels more like suddenly everything you do has consequence every time you roll a die the narrative hinges on that moment um but for some people that can be a little alarming you know there's uh there's a comfort in the repetitive you know um us versus them if i fail nothing bad is gonna happen to me you know like it's okay um and uh there's also a sense of um increased intimacy with the expectation that you need to be role-playing at least in some aspect um more so than in d and d perhaps

in at least mechanically and i don't know it's a good question i think there's an increasing focus in tabletop games and in larps from certain aspects of the community to increase the amount of safety tools and other such mechanized ways in which to modulate experience for people that i really want to encourage i think monster hearts which is another pbta game i highly recommend it um it's about uh teenagers it's like a teen drama but urban teen drama right so uh you you're struggling with anger as a teen but that also means that you're a werewolf you know and uh it's great it's a great game it actively talks about like sex and and drama and and bullying and uh other very touchy subjects about youth and you're playing as a kid so i think that game has one of the best um if you ever want like a good example of how to frame something in a way that makes the players feel safe and tries to as much as possible to to get it to um be a consensual experience that is the game i would uh i would recommend most highly um and i think those uh more cathartic

experiments um no dice no masters um also do that very well in a different way of course um like the x card is a great example the um uh the the hard lines and the soft lines um system is also very good like all of those i think um they weren't invented by these games but they were uh they those games took them and and tried to give them a wider audience which i really like one thing that's very interesting to me about this conversation is that it's also clear you've played a whole bunch of different role-playing games and okay so just from my experience with d rolling a character even starting to get into an adventure with all the books and all the information it's kind of exhausting and i say that as somebody who like loves games with multiple rulebooks right and so i think of all the games that that is that is the closest maybe to a to a uh uh a a board game experience there are board games that actually try for that kind of experience where you roll a character and stuff which i think is really interesting yeah but it leads me to ask so when we're talking about these you know power by the apocalypse experiences or these you know other ways of role-playing are they also easier to just pick up and play i mean are there role-playing games out there with just lower overhead or people who are really into tabletop just just going through this startup process again and again for games because they're just that interested yeah i think i think there's this really interesting

fascinating phenomenon where um a lot of people are are a little shy about leaving d d because that's where they were first introduced there's a large community that supports them you know dnd beyond is an amazing resource um uh and yet you're totally correct in assuming that d and d and strategy games in general sort of games with for instance um expect you to have like miniatures and a map prepared for some combats you know not everyone does this i love that kind of part of d d you know i love painting minis and like using them on my players and stuff um but it's a lot of like stuff you have to do to get the true d experience uh and for monster hearts for instance you just buy the book what's like thirty dollars that's it you know it's all theater of the mind right because you don't need to have the strategic aspect that's not what the game is about um yeah absolutely it's it's uh most most of the games i've been talking about here are far less far less intense in terms of the amount of stuff you need to get before you before you enter them that being said it is a big transition i've seen a lot of people struggle with going from the assumption the neutral fail-state assumption to oh these roles aren't do you succeed or fail they are what happens in this story and how can we make it interesting um so i'm not going to they say that that's absolutely something that people can struggle with if they're used to for instance d um

but yeah it's way less with less overhead uh how so this is so when you say theater of the mind i'm assuming that means you know for example to play rapscallion you don't actually need a fake ocean with a grid on it and a pirate ship yeah a pirate and um hats i mean that might be fun actually but rap scouting actually uh rap scout actually does uh uh ask you to make a map um but it's sort of an overall map where you can like put x marks the spot and things like that um and it has specific instructions for like just doing it on a piece of paper right um so that is like an overhead i suppose uh you need a piece of paper um but uh yes you're correct in assuming that they don't need uh miniatures and things like that um for sure so we talked a lot about tabletop you know role-playing that you can kind of do just in your living room uh but you are also uh fairly heavily involved at least from my perspective in larping how interconnected are those two things and also do you want to just tell people what a larp is just in case they don't know right yes larp is a live action role play game um i think the thing that differentiates it from a tabletop game is that it attempts at some kind of immersion as much as possible it you know larps have mechanics just as any game does but it it as much as possible it attempts to disguise those mechanics

under a veneer of reality um and i think a lot of people have done larping without realizing it i think like those um fun party games that are like murder mystery and you get your own little part um like little parlor games like that those are for sure larps that's what a larp is um and uh they're not to say there aren't very mechanically heavy larping um but for the most part a lot of larps especially parlor larps which are smaller scale like room what like room sized larps um uh definitely attempt to lower the amount of mechanical overhead that you need to that you need to learn because the idea is that it's an immersive experience um you come in and maybe a good parlor larp uh again i the ones i know best are the ones i've run so i'm so sorry but i ran this uh this parlor larp game that was a spoof on what we do in the shadows which is a great um a great movie and series um highly recommended silly vampire stuff uh foolish foolish vampires vampire is not taken seriously is what i would call it um and the idea is that like it's set in boston in the same sort of universe and all of the vampires are coming together uh and they're gonna have to figure out like you know their their the leader of their cabal just died and they're all trying to like in fight vote on who's who's gonna go next um uh and uh that's the

parlor larp right it's set in a room and maybe you have some props like ooh there's they're doing it in the back back room of like a a bar so let's like put some like coffee on the side or something but it can be very theater of the mind which um does mean uh essentially like and it's used in dnd as well like if you say i'm running dnd as theater of the mind that means that uh you're not using a board you're not using miniatures you're just imagining it in your head and that is sort of the default assumption of most most other games and for larping theater of the mind i think would describe or black box larping i think it's i've also heard it called freeform larping uh where uh relatively few props um a little bit more imagination required versus sort of a 360 fully immersive experience you know you get to like they're called i think they're called castle larping or like uh uh yeah like like because you know in europe they would do it in cast they would rent out a castle and then you would pretend to be people in the castle and you full dress you know like it's all almost like historical reenactment i would say is sort of adjacent to that almost um uh yeah there's a there's a wide variety of things you can do with larping um but the typical example is um you you you have to be getting up and role playing and acting essentially um in a way that you don't

necessarily tabletops where you still you know it's still um within a mechanical framework um where many of those elements that would be replaced and larping with real life props and uh role play um and a tabletop is simulated through dice and other mechanics oh that's super interesting i will confess my first uh my first experience of seeing someone larp was the fear of girls series on youtube about like two lonely guys who play dungeons and dragons together by themselves and i'm pretty sure the humor has not aged well a lot of it's kind of sexist and homophobic sure sure sure yeah i don't know i remember and i remember just watching some guy yelling magic myself and like throwing something in someone and like that's it so uh it sounds like actual larping is very very different from what people are kind of joking about okay i'm gonna so so like my experience yeah there is there i think there's like this video that circulates whenever some talks about larping with which is a guy who has like little packets and he throws it someone goes fireball fireball fireball and that is you know that's the vision um and i i was i i i also started larping when i was in college and when i

started it was like a college-run larp so it was very low-tech right i ended up running that larp for several years and it was i was very nervous to get into it you know it has a reputation for being like the ultimate nerdy activity um but it also i was like very skeptical that college students could act like i felt like oh this is going to be like this is going to be kind of embarrassing you know i feel like i'm not gonna i'm just gonna be around a bunch of people who are like trying really hard and it wasn't true like these college students that most of them were were quite nerdy and and fairly socially awkward but being put in a larping like you know if if you're entering a larping scenario it's amazing what people can do um a lot of the time people won't necessarily act too much they'll act within their the realm of their willingness and experience they'll they might get into some sort of exaggerated version of themselves that's often pretty pretty much the case and uh like people can do that very well and i was surprised by how like just genuine and uh cheerful and uh uh how about how much of a good community it ended up being and that has remained true for even the stuff that i've done outside i've done a few buffing warps which buffing buffing is the descriptor for uh when you attempt to facilitate combat through fake weapons phone okay usually so uh boffing a buffing weapon would be

like a a special foam sword and there are very specific rules for this um of a variety of qualities to make sure it's safe you know you have to have a specific kind of thickness of the foam it has to be a specific length with like the pva pipe underneath has to be like uh you know a specific brand and stuff like that um so it's very it's very codified already it's a it's a pretty uh common thing and buffing larps are the ones that you see often on the media right like you go out to the woods and you find a cabin or some such and then you have some you know you have like a nerf gun or a stick that is foamy you know so that you don't hurt people and then you go out and you and you hit people with sticks um that's buffing so actually you stumbled on earlier what i was kind of hoping we would talk about too which is so a lot of the language even though we're using to talk people are you know black box theater of the mind props acting yeah you know this is this is very much you know um i think that we all think about like you know drama kids and how they love to act sure they like they like to be this so but the other things that you say indicate that you know larping is really not necessarily about being a great actor as much as it is about being willing to be in the moment so how good do you really have to be getting into a character and acting and performing to be a good larper well i think the main difference between acting and larping is that larping is making it easy for you they're immersing

you in this emotional experience there's a there's a term that you will often hear uh larpers use called bleed larp bleed which refers to the phenomenon where the uh the emotions of your character become your own um and then you have uh i think i've heard different terms for it fall uh larp uh larpfall where after you and leave a larp and go back into the normal world there is this mixture of emotions where you had all of these major emotions that had an effect on your life you were fully immersed like in a buffing log for instance you are fully immersed in this world and it becomes real for you for a while um in a way that i think for an actor obviously surrounded by cameras or on a stage it can't be the actor has to make that moment and in larping the moment is made for you and in concert with many other people's moments and that can be a beautiful thing it can be very powerful many people come into larps wanting to bleed they want to there's a specific kind of larp um uh that that that aims for that sort of thing i think it's sometimes called uh you know crying in the mud larp because you know that's that's the emotion they're going for you know uh but uh not everyone wants that obviously some people just want the hit with sticks um but that is an

essential part of larping that that exists for a lot of people and i think that's really fascinating you know the the interplay between having to leave this experience that was exceptionally real except that it wasn't the only the only thing that wasn't real about it was the fact that it was not real um everything else was very real and then you have to go back to your life and be like how do i reconcile these emotions that were exceptionally real to me um but that have no bearing on my life right now um i think people like that for the therapeutic quality of it i have an experience much largely myself but um i kind of wish that i did it more because it feels sort of like a cathartic release almost for a lot of people oh that's super interesting i also think we're touching on a lot of things where you know i think people see larp especially as a very vulnerable thing to do and i i think a lot about how you know even with games right i'll have people look at me funny not not so much anymore board games are hot now uh but you know that's what you do for fun you just go play board games with other people like as if playing a game is somehow trivial right and i think that we also see pretend as something that's for kids and that can't be really really moving yeah how do you you know i mean i'm assuming if you're willing to try a larp you're already past that barrier but like how do you push people you know further into being willing to do this and you know what would you say the benefits are for somebody who's skeptical it sounds like catharsis is a

main one yeah it's an amazing question um the thing is i i wouldn't want to push people into it because it is it should be opt-in and like i said there are larping things that have become more and more popular to my great uh uh joy that try to make it safer for people people who may not want that fully immersive experience people who may want to be like okay our characters are getting into a romance but we need to go out of character to talk about that right um how how do we do that in this in this larp that like what you see is what you get is a term used in larvae like what you see is what you get meaning everything need should feel as realistic as possible how do you do how do you facilitate that if you're not comfortable with certain things like right you just become comfortable by lieu of acting no that's not how it works so um they're that's becoming more popular it wasn't always i think for buffing larp specifically it's sometimes something people aren't used to because they're like oh this is just combat combat you know and for those people it might not be safety rules become a question of like okay you know no rhino hiding which is like pretending you don't get hit by blows or whatever um and i i think that in order for it to work for people you need to be into it i i don't want to pressure anyone into doing it because it can be very um

it can be intense like i i am a very easily overstimulated person and larping can be a lot you know it's like uh at its height for me anyway like people do it much more like frequently but you know a buffing larp is often a full weekend you come in on friday and you stay in character until sunday afternoon and that's like so much for a lot of people and that's understandable um and uh but what i would say to people who are even tentatively amused or interested is that it's you know it's it's much just because it's silly does not mean that it is uh not fulfilling and wonderful in fact it can be fulfilling and wonderful because it is silly um yes on this we both very much agree so it sounds like you both love to play and you like to run events as dm as you know are you still the dm or gm for larp is that still the title um not right now um i am the larp i'm i'm helping to create is not yet obviously larping there's a whole debate right now about whether you can in fact larp in a pandemic safe environment and i think the assumption i've heard most people go is like yes larping online is fine but as long as it's you know it the the format of the story

has to be online so like maybe you're a bunch of scientists who are talking to each other on the comms as you attempt to fix the spaceship um i've seen that happen that works pretty well uh that's but obviously we don't want to do like a buffing larp is not safe in the pandemic environment so no no one wants to do that um so instead we are we're creating the system for it in preparation for it to be um for it to be run at a later safer date awesome what i was going to ask is do you feel more comfortable in the game runner role or in the player role like do you have a preference at this time or is it important to do both to get the most out of it this sort of delves into psychology doesn't it well yes actually i do i actually find i've played quite a bit obviously but i actually find that um running a game is much easier for me um my skill set is more catered towards it and i will say for anyone who does tabletop rpgs for anyone who does larping uh being one of the players is a talent in and of itself uh there is a sort of improvisational ability a sort of wonder a sort of willingness to wait uh a willingness to let go of certain control um that is essential to any like really really good player and you can be a good player it's not just you know the gm's

role for everything there are some games that don't have gm's in them um and i think that that's something that i i would love people to take away is like you can be a good player it's okay to be a player and you can be a really good one uh you can you can yes and you can improvise you can uh bring snacks it's always an important one uh you can uh have this you can you can help create this experience uh in many ways i think the players are just as responsible for any of the game runners or gm's or whatever you might call them for making the experience happen um and that is more or less true with different games but all games have that balance that inherent quality of their there is a large part of this that no one is in control over it is up to the whim of this conglomerate mass uh so yes i i'm not very i'm not as good at that part because when i come into when i come in and be a character my natural assumption is like okay you have to make a role for yourself you have to decide what your tiny piece of the story is and what i end up wanting to do is being like okay gm what's your goals here just tell me what they are and i'll help them i'll make a character for them you know and that's just that's just casting for a larp this is what i'm doing that's not what being a player is so oh interesting uh do you find that you

are when you're running the game yourself are you more delighted when players surprise you or does it stress you out because you have to then roll with their punches oh it delights me it delights me i think there's a lot of um there's a bit there's a sort of a culture in tabletop rpgs of like i'm the evil dm ooh i'm evil ooh i like to punish my players don't cross me otherwise something might happen to you and i hate that i hate it like obviously it's mostly in good fun but a lot of a lot of gm's take it seriously uh and that's absolutely not what the role is in my opinion your role is to make the players lives really cool and fun and interesting and that's why i really like pbta uh for that strength specifically there is uh this beautiful sensation of like freedom where i don't like for d d i need to prep at least two hours before i enter a session usually unless i've already pre-prepped you know yeah for for rap scallion i've been doing a play test for rapscallion for the last more than a year now year and a half and i prep nothing i come in completely completely barren uh and just let it happen and and my players are always like oh you're doing great this is amazing thank you so much and i'm like this is this is not me this is all you guys this is all you guys because it's this beautiful little flower everyone's gently tending to at the same time um that's what that's what good uh a good

role-playing experience feels like it feels like uh this is not mine and it is not yours it is some someone else's and it's probably ours in a sort of characterized way so i think about this because i'm a teacher right i run a classroom and you know there's students who kind of hog a lot of the space and then there's students who you have to kind of encourage to participate even when you can tell they have something to say is that ever part of your role as the gm like do you ever tweak what's happening in the game or kind of insert yourself in order to help with balance among the players if you've got an alpha or if somebody's really sucking up all the air yeah that's absolutely part of it so um there's a balance there right so the the first situation is is that does that player want to contribute um there are different kinds of players and certain players i would call audience members not in a judgmental way they like to hang out with their friends and they like to watch the situation go down and they find that really fun and they can contribute themselves but it's not necessarily what they came here to do um right and just and figuring out whether that kind of person is is willing and in fact finds it engaging to listen and and be engaged in the spectacle from the sidelines um is probably the first step if however they appear there are many cases in which in order to find that out i will attempt

to uh tempt the player right give them something to do and see how they react so in a role-playing scenario that would mean um ask them what their backstory is ask them what they like about the game ask them uh you know whether they want a cool little magic item in d d terms or uh what they think about this uh npc in their backstory and you know press and check you know everyone engages in the game differently some some players don't want to role play because they find it kind of a little bit jolting um and for those people you know you get them out of their comfort zone but only a little bit and instead you ask them like okay what do you make you're like you're a tinkerer right what do you make and they'll be like oh yeah absolutely and they'll get into it you just have to find the in everyone comes into the game with an expectation and it's usually unspoken um just like i'm sure everyone comes into a classroom with an expectation that's unspoken and you have to figure out what that is um i'm sure it's much easier when you have say five players instead of a large classroom full of people um well this is the assumption the five players wanted to be there yeah yeah exactly that is a major difference um uh but like i think everyone has an engagement point an engagement facet of themselves that makes them excited without maybe without them really notice it um yeah the other thing i'm hearing you saying that's interesting and i think that when people think about how to role

play good right they might forget this is that it seems like it's also okay to kind of talk about your character while not being your character for sure that makes sense like oh i want my character to do xyz it's just as legitimately a way to play as i go up to the other pirates and i punch them in the face and say my parrot is better yeah yeah absolutely i think there needs to be that kind of flexibility um i think a lot of people let's do a dnd thing again because that's what everyone knows um you uh you are asked uh a lot of people will wait uh for someone to make a persuasion check on an npc they're trying to persuade they'll wait until you say something persuasive enough first which is not how any of the other game mechanics work right if you want to chop down a tree they don't go like okay get up try to chop this table in half let me see how that works oh now you can make an athletics check okay you've convinced me you know like that's not how it works but with role-playing somehow the situation is often reversed which i find really interesting because that's how pbta works right the role play triggers the dice as opposed to the other way right um however that can be because record it you're courting a certain type of player by doing that because some players will be like can i just my player is really charismatic can i just you know is it okay if and then they get really nervous because they're expected to come up with something really persuasive off the bat uh and that can be a deal breaker for a lot of people if they have a

gm who expects them to do that and thinks that's the fun part of game when in fact it's the most anxiety inducing so yes absolutely i would if a player were to be uncomfortable i could say like um okay i would i would remove myself several steps from the situation and say like what's uh what what what are you trying to get them to do okay um what are you offering them in return are you offering them anything uh maybe and that can just be like you're trying to seduce them or you're uh trying to be friendly really friendly like what are you what are you giving them in return for this service and framing it that way can be easier for people because they don't have to like come up with a fun way to say it right like as someone who's a little nerd diversion myself i can understand the uh insane amount of effort that would put in if for certain people you know yeah absolutely and so uh just i guess one more serious question before we just go to the fun stuff um so how do you think so you've you've been a player you've been a game master and now you're an author of an rpg how do you think that writing your own has changed the way that you experience role-playing certainly i think there is a privilege uh of knowing exactly what the game that you wrote expects you to do so if i were to apply that to rapscallion specifically i could give you all kinds of answers like

uh i know exactly how ppta works now magpie games my publisher is very is very it's like specializes essentially in pbt games and their editors have been able to uh coach me through some of the weirder or uh less well-known aspects of that system and they have like tons of play testing experience where they like okay yeah we know often it is the question of of a period right a question of formatting a question of word choice because it's a narrative game so it must be framed narratively so right how do you how do you frame this specific sentence to make it sound correct for a player you know like on the get into a scrap how do you frame the good part narratively in a way that encompasses all scenarios you know like that kind of like tiny quibbles you know that really make the difference and having been through all that it gives me a higher appreciation of pvta games um as well as how they differentiate themselves from other games you know i would not be able to talk about the expectations that i've been saying and the specific small uh changes between that and say d and d that make all the difference i don't think i would be able to pinpoint that so specifically um so if anything the the the writing gave me the ability to be like okay let me pick the players i want

let me pick the players because i know what the players want from this game and i know that the game can offer them to them um so so now when i when i look at a game i i'm thinking like okay what do these players want out of this game and how can i provide that to them instead of okay which players might like the story i came up with i guess you know like that kind of the kind of like higher level structural thinking um yeah i think that's the biggest the biggest uh lesson to be learned um that i can take to other systems that aren't just this pirate game that i made up oh man that's super interesting okay so just fun fun little question uh what's a what role-playing game other than your own of course everyone should play rough scouting once available obviously would you recommend that people try if they're looking for something that's beyond just the sort of d d pathfinder oh good question can i list multiple options yes there are no rules on here except yeah well you know you must ask um well if you like d if you think dnd is fun and you like the feeling of like the strategy aspect and the um uh the uh feeling of like righteous defeat of evil you know that kind of thing i i i would recommend uh systems that are like it um you don't have to go into

like powered by the apocalypse games for instance if you don't want to um but if you've ever been frustrated by it um a good you still like dod perhaps but maybe you want to try something different there is a d equivalent for ppta called dungeon world which you can try uh i wouldn't recommend it as like the best pbta game but it is essentially d and d but in pbta form so if you want to see if you want to have that uh slow transition that's a good gateway drug i suppose um and i've also seen monster of the week that another pbta game uh also be a good a good version of that for some people um so uh and monster of the week is um very uh buffy you know very uh like like every time you get a mystery to solve you your team of monster hunters and you have to figure out where the like what's happening and eventually defeat the monster with the power of your like wit and also maybe you know kicking kicking their ass a little bit uh so that's that's it those two uh i i can see some flaws with those systems but they're great ways of introducing someone who is used to a certain combative play into ppta games um for really really good ppta games uh monster hearts is still amazing uh very very good masks

is a game about teenage superheroes um sort of uh and though i think it's also published by magpie games and that one's a very very good um for those of you who like root the board game there is a rpg for that also by games um so that's a way to if you if you're interested in root as like a system of like all these different factions coming together in this woodland and like what that looks like you can now do that in role-playing form um also a ppta game and i'm trying i'm like focusing on ppta here because that's what i've been talking about wander home is the one i mentioned earlier that was a no dice no masters game so if you're interested in a game that is not not uh that is much more an improvisational exercise framed in mechanical terms more than a strategic attempt at simulation of war strategy story etc uh highly recommend that one it's about um you're a bunch of animal people who are making a journey and once you reach home you are out of the story because the story is about the wandering and not the coming home um and uh it's it's a great game to do with like people you really trust like a solid group of friends that you really that you really like uh yeah i would say there's urban shadows which is an urban

fantasy game set in the city environment that's a pbta game um oh there's so many options those are the ones that immediately come to mind but i'll think of a billion others by the time you you cut the you cut the feed that is awesome i'm actually curious now i need to like get some people together to humor me uh but also where can you be found online so people want to follow the progress of rap scallion or talk to you about games or you know where where where can you be contacted my goodness uh i have a a website um that has like a contact me page it's evanly davis.format.com that's mostly for art though if you want to contact me more specifically or look at what i've been doing lately i do have a twitter reluctantly um it's i believe art of whistler all one word uh art of whistler on twitter i also have a tumblr but that's more for fun uh those of you who are listening know i can be found anywhere on the internet it is beyond solitaire thank you so much for coming on here this was awesome i learned a lot hopefully everybody else did too and this is fantastic thanks so much for having me it was super fun to talk about what i like alright everybody out there please like subscribe leave a nice comment a question and most of all happy gaming

so

you

Progress saved