Skip to main content
Loading video...

Two simple card games from Zoch: All in All & Mana Mana *Board Game Review*

Transcript 12:42

I was sent copies of mana mana and all in all by the publisher for this review so thanks to zoc verlag select colored cards from a central display and build sets to earn Mana tokens which can be spent to gain extra cards on subsequent turns adding cards to your opponent's existing sets will give you more tokens to spend but think carefully because giving your opponents cards might just win them the game mana mana features simple open card drafting with some positive player interaction that's the hook competing space captains explore space portals to gather rare space relics make sure you land your spaceship before a sub Auto crosses your flight path bringing you crashing back down to earth all in all is a game of push your luck card play with an Intergalactic flavor and that's the hook I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe comment and share the video mana mana and all in all are two recent small box card games from German publisher zoc verlag and I thought it'd be interesting to contrast the two products because they're comparable in terms of their very simple accessible card play but they differ enormously in their presentation designed by Peter Jurgensen mana mana is packaged in a black box with gold lettering the cards are simple colors with Maori symbology but essentially the game is entirely abstract there's no narrative and the chosen images are purely decorative Torsten Lance Fox all in all has an elaborate plot with each player

represented by a different Intergalactic traveler and each controlling their own spacecraft the different locations on the tabletop are Illustrated with Cosmic portals and the sets collected by players represent space relics the production team have clearly enjoyed immersing himself in the narrative so much so that the rulebook features a detailed humorous description of the eight relics found in the game from outward appearances Mana Manor declares itself as a somewhat sophisticated game of abstract card play but all in all looks fun perhaps even funny and it promises a more thematic experience in mana mana players aim to gather Cards into sets on the table in front of them at the end of the game these cards plus any Mana tokens collected will be counted and the highest scorer wins on your turn you can select a single card from the central display for free or spend Mana tokens to take multiple cards of the same color alternatively you could choose to play a set of matching cards in front of yourself or add cards to a set which is in front of another player when you play sets of cards you earn Mana tokens based on the number of cards in the set so adding cards to an opponent's display is very helpful because it generally amounts to a larger set and more Mana tokens for you but it does come at a cost because not only are you losing cards you're actually gifting them to your opponent so the game is a constant Balancing Act of building your own sets but carefully gifting cards to opponents to a massive tokens which allow you to maximize your card draws on later turns in all in all you start your

term by selecting an unseen card from an opponent's hand if it's a relic or an alien it's placed at one of the space portals at the center of the table all players then select whether they're going to remain in the round or bow out by Landing their ship at that portal assuming they haven't landed their ship the next player then does the same if you ever draw a Sab Auto card all players who haven't yet landed a bust and they won't ever get to land or gather relics so each turn that you choose not to land your ship is at risk ultimately when every player has either landed their ship or a sabbortle has been revealed all players who landed gather cards and play sets of cards onto the table the longer you remained in the round the more cards you can gather and the game ends when one player has completed three sets of three matching cards winning the game so why have zoc verlag opted for such wildly different approaches to the presentation for two games which both feature minimal components and Rule sets of comparable simplicity the answer probably lies in the Dynamics of the gameplay mana mana is a fairly predictable game the pattern of play does not vary much from turn to turn there is a strong sense of progression for wood momentum as players amass more and more Mana tokens allowing them to take larger groups of cards from the display as the game progresses unfinished sets become more readily available throughout the game providing more opportunities to step in and complete an opponent's display earning Mana for yourself but gifting them points it's an elegant system and the modest packaging reflects this

all in all is anything but predictable it's a wild ride full of highs and lows when you pull the card from your opponent's hand you have no idea what it is and the moment of reveal is exciting a round could end very quickly or it could be extended over many turns with each subsequent card draw becoming more and more tense the inclusion of Three Special action alien cards which can be played instead of taking your usual turn spices things up a little allowing opportunities for players to snatch Relic cards from the display or even in front of the other players the game is chaotic and silly something which soccer do well I'm sure this is the thinking behind the humorous artwork and setting certainly doesn't feel thematic and indeed The Narrative makes no sense but it is a fun backdrop for a wacky half hour the outward presentation of a game is the very first step in onboarding potential players the next step is the rule book and once again the contrast between the two games is Stark the mana mana rulebook is really simple to follow the gameplay is slick and easy to get across in text with minimal examples required I was up and running in no time the rule book for all in all on the other hand is bogged down with thematic terms and references to the confusing narrative cards are called relics special action cards are aliens a round of play is called a mission sticking is described as Landing card locations are portals your personal display of cards is your home planet and none of these terms is confusing in isolation but when

the rulebook tells me to take a relic not an alien from my hand and place it onto my home planet there's a couple of cognitive hurdles which I need to LEAP before I grasp exactly what I'm supposed to be doing and when the rules for the schema tell me to take any Relic from a portal of my choice and place it in front of me I'm left wondering if this is on my home planet or is this some other area that I've overlooked it took two or three reads for me to fully grasp the flow of the game and it didn't need to be this difficult because all in all it's really simple to play Heavy use of thematic text and imagery might lift the aesthetic appeal of a product but it comes at a cost when it obscures simple mechanisms above anything else casual players are looking for accessible games with minimal rules and anything which hinders comprehension is potentially a problem now I'm overstating it we're not in Android Netrunner or race for the Galaxy territory here don't let my little rant put you off if you've played a few modern board or card games you'll be fine it's the newcomers who might be left scratching their heads I rate games using my own ladder engagement system a game is awarded zero to three points in five categories and each point climbs the game one rung up the engagement ladder a score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me for thematic immersion both games score zero despite Alexander Jung's attractive overlay all in all is essentially an abstract exercise in pushing your luck and mana mana likewise it's nicely illustrated by Matthias Hollander but it doesn't really have a

theme for interaction both games do really well I enjoy the positive interaction in mana mana it's a nice change of pace you're never doing your opponents down in this game your actions lift the other players Up All In All is a game where every player is invested in every turn when you select a card from another player's hand every player who hasn't yet landed their ship is on tinterhooks waiting to see if they're progressing towards greater Rewards or crashing back down to earth the game is similar to Diamond or Celestia in that regard the alien cards add a small Touch of take that or destructive player interaction but it's certainly a game where we're all engaged at every step and one player's decisions impact on everybody else at the table mana mana is light on tension there are moments where you're willing your opponents to complete your tempting colored sets gifting you points and there are times where you're willing your opponents not to complete a set in front of a player before you can get to it and claim those valuable Mana tokens but in general the game is stress-free as with most push your luck games all in all is full of tension and stress which always engages players when I describe feedback in games I'm talking about the way that the game itself responds to the player's input the rewards the penalties and new possibilities which open up as a result of a player's decision mana mana has two currencies cards and tokens and these accumulate throughout the game with a satisfying sense of momentum so that players are achieving more on later

turns than they did at the start of the game all in all could have been called All or nothing because that's the way the game feels when you have a good round pushing your luck over multiple turns and never going bust the game rewards you generously but a bad round where you go bust early leaves you with nothing The Game responds harshly to the player's choices no losing half your actions as you would in other push your luck games like cracks of quedlinburg or living forest in all in all you're playing without a safety net for Meaningful choices mana mana wins out the decisions are subtle all players will score well at game end amassing points from cards and tokens but the winner will be the player who made the best use of those cards and tokens it's essential to gift cards to your opponents to gather enough tokens to maximize your card draws but if you do this too much your opponent will win it's a game of balance not the deepest game in the world but good for a simple quick stress-free session all in all essentially has one decision stick or twist it's a fun decision it's one which has been utilized in many different forms in hundreds of games over many centuries but it doesn't have a huge amount of depth chance plays a massive part in determining the winner of the game the overall scores are eight for mana mana and nine for all in all but I'm deducting two points from all in all for the tricky rule book and the fragmented turn sequence it just doesn't flow as smoothly as it should nonetheless eight points for mana mana and seven for all in all are very respectable scores and while they don't

reach the highest rung of my engagement ladder they do offer up some really enjoyable gameplay so moving on to my product design checklist are the games innovative well no I can't honestly say that there's any huge Innovation on display here and that leads me on to my next question is there a need which these products will fill a problem that they solve or a gap which they fill honestly there are many many games which resemble mana mana and all in all but the positive interaction featured in mana mana is refreshing while all in all shares similar mechanisms with diamond and Celestia in this product the push your luck experience is offered up in a particularly portable affordable package best-selling products marry a fantastic core concept with outstanding execution by both designer and Publishing team on my idea execution Matrix the most successful products sit in the orange or red portion of the grid with the weak products lingering in the blue section push your luck is a well-loved mechanism it's the core of blackjack poker and most other casino games it follows the all in all is really engaging but it's hard to pinpoint a new groundbreaking idea here the idea in mana mana is neat it has a clever mechanism at its core but the gameplay does feel slight the execution of all in all is a mixed bag with amusing artwork and a portable affordable package but the rulebook is a barrier and the gameplay feels disjointed Nana Mana is a smoother experience it's nicely presented with a rule book that's easy to follow now both

games are held back a little bit by the lack of a two-player mode and while all in all is playable by three to six players mana mana can only be played by three or four and that feels restrictive ultimately both games sit in the green mid section of the Matrix representing very solid entries in zox catalog while falling short of the heights of their greatest titles picomino or sushi go go splits or potato man if you'd like to hear more about my favorite zoc products follow the link

Progress saved