Skip to main content
Loading video...

Football U - Kickstarter Game Review

Transcript 12:05

Just in time for the American football season, we have a brand new Kickstarter for an American football board game. A surprisingly rare genre in the board game sphere over here in England anyway, outside of Blood Bowl, of course. But Scholander Games have tossed a Hail Mary from across the pond in midirection. And I have to say that this one, Football U, just about gets a score, even if it was a bit of a scramble in the end zone, as it's a halfdeent solo flip and roll style game where you act as the head recruiter for a college. and you're tasked with recruiting your players during the offseason, playing games against multiple clubs with a simple solo mode, and you win by becoming the best college after completing three full seasons. Now, full disclaimers, I have been sent this by the company for review, and it's just a prototype, so none of these components will be final versions. And now the opening spiel's out the way. Let's show you a quick round of solo gameplay. So this is essentially what the board looks like.

You have the main draft section. You have your college player board that just has two basic players on it. We have our head coach on his default side. Our tokens on the board and team chemistry cards to the side next to the drafted players. During the start of the off season in solo, you place two random players from the top of the draft pile into your college recruitment area. And these guys can be purchased for minus one cost. The cost being on the card and that cost equates to the time track on the right of the player board. You have 15 weeks or 15 cost to buy main players or basic ones. train your players, basically flipping over your rostered players to hopefully be a bit better during the season. You can buy gameplay tokens to give you rerolls or use offseason abilities on your cards. So, essentially, you spend 15 points. So, what I'm going to do now is just buy some players, buy a reroll token, and train up a guy. Spending all my 15 points, and that's essentially it for the off season.

Heat.

Heat. Heat. Heat.

Now comes the main season where we play our games. And in the solo mode, essentially, you play three main games and one bowl game per season. All of which are predetermined so far on this handy little sheet depending on player count. And the cards themselves have the teams your play on them with all the dice they need for you to roll. So, what we do is we grab all our dice for our team. These dice are located on the players and different color dice are better than the others. So, it's always good to look out for the top players with the best dice. And we grab the opposition dice that's on the card. Essentially rolling them both like so.

Now we compare both sets with both of you can canceling out the top scored dice on the opposing team so long as your defense is rolled x's that is. And we see who won the game by tallying up all the remaining points scored. The winner of that week being the one who scored the most. It's at this point also that you can use your player abilities and any in-game team cohesion abilities that you acquired just by putting one of your little markers on and doing what it says, like re-rolling dice. And pretty much that's it. Keep going until you've played all four opponents. keep track of your wins and depending on the amount you got each season, you will go up on the national ranking with your first season granting one, second season granting two, and the third season granting three points. And then all you do is you go back to the off season where you do it all over again. Your head coach gets flipped if you won only one of the four games. And so then you get bonuses going into the next off season along with you getting first dibs on players if you're playing more with multiple opponents. But in solo, you just reset the board and go again where after three completed seasons, you win if you've earned a top five national ranking. And that's pretty much it for

the game play. As you could hopefully tell, it plays pretty fast along with fast setup and tear down. Everything beneficial for a good early or late night filler game, which realistically this one is something you can play in half an hour on your own with kids or a group of mates as it's one to four players. I really enjoyed this one in parts myself because it's an American football game that's solo and it's also pretty fast and I enjoy the tactical variation during the off season. Do you go offense heavy to roll stronger pointc scoring dice? Do you have a small but elite unit that you've trained up? Do you go heavy on the defense and try to get white pick six dice to score? or even go heavy player chemistry to get lots of bonus cards to use in matches.

There's lots of options for team building and plenty players on offer from the market draft to make this a great little experience on your game night. It's especially annoying when someone drafts the player you were hoping to get and it creates this nice little interactive back and forth where they are now your rival for the entire game and you want to beat them for stealing your man or when the clock is ticking down on your draft and you're in two minds about training the players you already have to make them better. or do you spend that last four clock to grab another player to get more dice? The game for me is at its best during that offseason phase. But alas, no game is perfect, and this one won't be for you if you don't like rolling tons and tons of dice, as that is basically the entirety of the game section in the season. If you're playing solo, you roll all your dice and then you roll all the bots dice and eventually you'll be rolling as many dice as a 40k orc player. And that is essentially it. Even the game changing cohesion cards either add dice, change dice, or give rrolls.

So, you need to go into this game liking rolling dice to get the most out of this one. And I don't mind it myself as a former Imperial Guard player in 40k, but as I've said to the designer, my one big complaint is the amount of rolling and especially when you have a tie game because sudden death rolls with two pretty weak dice can mean the game can go on forever. I've had anything from three rolls on my dice to 34 the ones where it took that long to get a determined winner of the match. It was mind-numbing in basically the end of my 34 one because I was just sick to death of rolling seven points or a zero along with a block only to see the opposing dice roll exactly the same. Maybe I was just unlucky, but from the multiple times I've played this now, I have to say that I dread a tie game and wish there was instead a draw mechanism for say after three rolls and there's no winner cuz it really does disrupt the flow of this game. And of course, with rolling dice comes a lot of luck factor.

I've had games where I've rolled all sevens. I've had games where I can't roll anything but blanks, even with extra dice and rerolls, and your overall enjoyment will be stuck behind the luck wall, I'm afraid. Yes, you can mitigate it by having the better players with the better dice and abilities, but your chances of blanks just go from half to one in six. And if lady looks not with you at that roll, then that expensive six seven cost player might end up being a bust. and you lose to factors basically out of your control. I've had multiple games now where I've grabbed the top guys over three seasons and I've just whiffed when it comes to the dice rolling half of the overall games. I ain't going to lie, it's deeply frustrating seeing all your offseason plans blow up in your face. And I know that happens a lot in real life NFL.

There's always one so-called generational talent that busts. Usually they play for the Browns, but realistically that is all I have to moan about in this game of two halves. I myself absolutely adore the offseason part of this game. It's sensational. I love the drafting mechanic. love building up my teams, working on the clock and making the tough decisions. But I am a little let down by the actual season and just roll my dice as fast as possible to get it out the way, hoping I don't end up with a draw so as I can get to that next off season and begin to love this one again. Others will prefer the rolling of lots of dice. Some will love everything about this one. And it's definitely great for families and solo players like me who just want to skip most of the game section here cuz there's no upkeep on the solo bots. Just roll their dice and see if they win or lose. I like it for that. If I'd have to draft for the opposition or done more upkeep in matches, I really don't think I would have enjoyed this one, but it can be over in no time at all. I've been finishing entire games of this in like 15 20 minutes now as long as there's no draws. And I'm sure there will be something here you can enjoy. I do recommend it. It's a basic 7 out of 10 quick early or end of night game that anyone can pick up and play no time. So pledge for your family or group if you enjoy quick drafting flip and roll games

with lots of dice. And thanks for watching.

Progress saved