Tier Ranking Our 2024 Game Plays
Transcript
see what's funny is Jamie Jamie always gets uh upset when I'm like not being like I do but then when I do it she's like can you not do it now no that's it's like so I have I have to do it a specific times that doesn't annoy
her oh everyone welcome back to Foster the meele a Channel all about and Bo gam things exactly I had a great idea that great idea was we should tier rank all of the games that we played in 2024 and then I realized that we played like over 600 games and that's crazy so I decide decided that we should tier rank all of the new to us games that we played and does this actually include everything though cuz it doesn't it doesn't it doesn't include Pack's Premiere mhm that's for sure but rank yep for anybody that doesn't know how tier ranking Works basically you have five letter categories this is like a thing in video games apparently not just video games not even just video games apparently other things as well so here's the five tiers we have D which is a dud the game's a dud okay it just wasn't very good we have C which means it's fine m c it's fine yeah I could do without B is it's good this is a this is this a good game good game a is like this a pretty this is a great game I really like this game and S is like this is one of the best games to ever be created ever objectively yeah these These are objective rankings of course of course they are yes we are the voice of reason now I think we're ranking around 288 games which means we're going to go
really quickly we're not going to tell you anything about these games this is just our opinion on where we feel these games should be within this list there are some games that only I objectively of course there are some games that only I have played and there are some games that only Jeff has played but we are going to rip through these and these are the games that are new to us so we're not going to be ranking games that we have replayed this year like Grand Austria Hotel sure we already we played it before okay we don't need to be talking about that so here we go I'm going to record my screen so that you guys can see what we're seeing so this is what it looks like this is called teer.com these are all the games that we're going to be ranking Jeffrey are you ready we're going to stop start from the top and we have you have to populate all those in I did it all by myself yes corre so we are going to start at the top of the list and we have to come to an agreement which we don't always agree I don't know if you knew that about the two of us the first game on the list is River of gold I would agree I would say I really thought she was gonna push for I really thought we were gonna fight right off the Hop there thinking so a river of gold I think is a great game is it a perfect game close but not quite not quite next up we have Maple Valley did you you play Maple Valley that's right I agree I think Maple Valley is an a it's very cute it's a kids game who cares I really like I really like it it's great solo as well arcs
I would put it in a It's s and I will I will like d see I will uh I'll give it to you no that's not give no it's objectively an S tier game do you think I guess like Jeff has played it more I've only played it once so I'll take your word for it undaunted Kalisto 2200 a I would agree that it is an a if this was Normandy it'd be an s correct I agree I prefer the war theme I prefer the war theme too I just sci-fi is like and I know people would flip-flop on that which is fine I'm glad they did kisto because I think it'll get more people here's something that you're probably also going to notice we love board games so if most of them get put into a don't judge me because civil's going in a Jeff hasn't played it it's so good though iron wood I wish it was like an A+ um it can't be it could be I would say I would say it's a I agree that I think it's an a Jeff I think you like it a little bit more than I do yeah I really like it but Seaside seaside's a great little game it is but we have to think is it as good as I think I think it's like a B I give it a B+ which means it's going in B yeah I mean it's great what it is yeah agreed I match slings and arrows I'm doing a for that one but I don't know about you uh it's not my favorite in the series um I would probably be a B on that one
that specific version not in matched as a whole but um yeah I I'll I'll give it to you I think it's probably a b or an a cafe Barz okay here's the thing Cafe bars is really cute and it's really sweet and it's really fun and I really enjoy it objectively because this is an objective list I think it's an S tier I'm just kidding I I could do A or B I I would say b or c and here's why I just any of those restaurant order type games other than diced veggies I'm just not going to resonate with I just they're not my cup of tea so I will let you if you want I'll put it in B yeah that's fine flip seven I think that's an A game A game I was curious if you were going to say s I would agree it's it's it's definitely an a it's one of the best party games that we played all year a guest a g of Robin Hood Gest of Robin Hood I'm thinking that's a B I think you're right and I'll tell you why it might surprise people um tell me I just I'm not I've played it like 15 times and the more I've played it the more I've just noticed a little bit of things that I find a little bit weird about it um in terms of like just things can go one way or the other sure very quickly and there's really not a lot you can do about it it can Cascade against you very quickly uh explorers of
navor I'm going to put in a b Jeff hasn't played it I think it's a really good game but I would like to play it more before I determine whether or not I like love it or if I just like it trick and snipers uh that's an a for me okay I would yeah I'm not as high on it as you are I think it's an A plus for me for me I put it as a b because it's just too quick I just find like I think that's a benefit of it to Captain flip uh I think Captain Flip's a good solid be I think so yeah I think so for what it is it's great but it's not the game that I'm running to all the time Nova Roma I'm a c or a B oh I'm A B I'm definitely not a c okay I think Nova Roma is a really good game I'm fine with that but it's not quite an a spectacular spectacular is a spectacular game but I think it's a b game I haven't played played it enough Jeff hasn't played it I played it two times with Jeff at packs unplugged it's really good and I don't think you'd like it operation barlay I'm an A on that uh I think an A's yeah I'm good with that it's a great two-player War Style game War themed stamp swap we're goingon to differ stamp swap um I surprised me I really thought it was going to be not great um I'm like a B plus I think I could do B I liked it way more than Jeff I would probably if it was just me I'd put it as like an A minus mhm so B+ is fine even though we can't differentiate between those yep
Star Wars unlimited that's an a for me yeah it's really really good we just don't have a chance to play like same as lorana like if I was to pick one of those games I want to play whether it's magic lorana or this it would be that it I would pick Lor it's like it's like Star rooms um it's very good yeah doughnut shop I really liked but I think it's a b game I don't I don't remember it really remember we were like making donut orders oh yeah yeah yeah yeah again one of those games though order making not my type of thing s and I can't stop him that's not fair as dune Warf for rakus Dune Warfare racus Jeff just says S Bus and stop is an aame for me yeah that's fair bus and stop is super fun card game sashy and sashy rock card 1977 I would put it as a b yep fine with that so far we have no C's or D it was objectively a good year for games I don't you can come at me all you want but yeah for us like these are obviously not all thought all these were great yeah War the ring I just have to believe them Parks rolling hike that's a c for me it's a B for me I prefer I prefer Parks Parks I'm putting it in B try and stop me okay salt and C uh C for me it's a B for me okay well you just got perks so so you want it and C Sal in SE I I know if I play that more it would increase but I'm only basing it off of what my
experience is and I had a great experience with it because I did I know that I like that game more than I'm putting it at now but my experience with that game what I'll sayable salt and sea and why it's to see for me is that if you get behind in currency and you like there's really not a lot of ways that you can get back into the game you have to like this is it's a game that you need to play multiple times to get your strategy and again it's it's punishing game if you don't get things right you are going to fall so far behind that you're going to be out and that's what happened to me uh okay Queen by midnight quarter pass that's an a game for me I I I put it at B but I'll give you an a why you liked it more than I did also you crushed me nocturn is a b game for me c for me really I thought you really liked it it's toall placement it's not a big thing for me I'm fine with you putting in B what's going on here there I got it Jeff sometimes it's hard to grab things magic Maze tower I uh played with o Jeff I played it with Rodney and chrisy and I really liked it I want to get it to play it solo um I'll put it in a B for now Middle Ages remind me is that the one big Tableau like this I like that I really liked it too uh I would say that's an A or a B I do I think it's a B I think it's a b too when you start comparing things you're like H Castle combo is probably a B for me is that the one we played at um with the Discord folks yeah that's a b or re for me I
didn't I didn't really enjoy that I've been playing a lot on BGA cortis that was that's one that was almost like biblos do you remember where it's like yeah yeah I would say that's a c for me I liked it more than you but I'll I'll get okay ship rights of the North Sea Redux is probably a b c for me really yeah I like I'm putting a b kfire delve scorns stock I think all of the delves are an a for me I agree they're like basically all the exact same but they just have different characters fishing fishing's an a with the opportunity to be an S okay Jeff loves fish I would agree yeah see I prefer fishing to trick and snipers for trick Tak yeah that I just said I I I just said Jamie fishing could be an S why do you always have to try and argue cities I really like cities yeah you me a I would put it in a b but I'll give no go B then just know I like to VI games more than Jamie Okay suan C right chill uh Contra banter you never got to play it but I did oh we kind of played it a little bit yeah and I hated it yeah it's not a Jeff game I would oh no I'm putting in C it's it's a very specific type of group that you have to play but I thought it was really good compile Jeff didn't play it I would probably go B for now I'd like to play it more I did think it was really good though I saw people playing it it looks incredible I want to play it so badly
yeah I played with Max and we had a really good time but I just think it needs more plays for me uh Cascadia Rolling Hills SL rolling Rivers which is the Rolland right version I'd give it a b b for me as well yeah I I often find it's same as Parks rolling hike when you do a rolling right version of a beloved game I'm not going to like it as much I'd rather just yeah agreed Walking Dead surrounded we probably not the target Mar there walking dead surrounded is a b really it's a button shy it's really oh that's not the dice one I was like what s uh skyrise I think skyrise is an a for me I think so for me too it's a great game it's just not one we've gotten a chance it you put it what do you mean I didn't put it anywhere oops yes I did okay lore I love Lost That Fish game somewhere my computer's like I can't we didn't even talk about it you just put it in B I really like it it's B okay lur is the B I I don't know if I can do this we have so stressing we have so many left I'm just trying to go quickly uh so I have cascadero cascad I'm just combining them as one I think they're both be's they're c's for me I we'll put them in B why am I even here okay Expeditions Gears of corruption the first time I played it B second time I played it a third time I played it C third time I played time I played it s no I think it's a B+ game so I think
okay so Expeditions Gears of corruption is the expansion for expeditions it significantly increased my enjoyment of the game agreed so in case you're curious Aqua is a tile placement game yeah I think it's B for me okay I would agree the gang uh I know you don't like this game I it's gone up for me yeah yeah I put it at an a I I wait I I think I'm starting to understand yeah it's an a game for me too I really it depends on who you're playing it with and it's Co-op and I normally don't like Co-op no h I had a great time playing with Sam from Lord of the board because it made me feel just like I wasn't alone and not knowing what was going on things in rings is that's a that's a d game for me I would put it in C it's it's just not my thing I think here's the thing it's fun but it's almost impossible like know what I mean I find it subjectivity yeah it's an impossible game but I like it botney oh you really like B I really liked botney oh I was gonna put it at a B I'm fine with a B but I'm Asing probably an a I think botney would go up if we played it at a higher player there is some is there is some inherent issues with botney that I think is going to prevent specifically at two players yeah at at two players yeah message from the St I really liked it I'm going again another one that's just not my cup of tea I'm going to put it at a B sure I'm fine with that production this is going to be our balance search for uaps I'm putting at a c I didn't really like it
that much I liked it I liked it but like after playing search for lost species I just don't care about I just also I made a mistake really early maybe if I played it again it would go up Nick says it's better solo Pixies Pixies is a c for me yeah I think I agree I played it a couple times on BGA I'm like yeah this is fine it's trying to be sea salt and paper guess what it's not that's exactly what I was just gonna say the problem isn't necessarily the game it's what it's trying to compete with yeah good luck uh and SE papers might be an S game Expressions we played with uh Danielle and Max when they came it's little card game I don't remember it either let's put it at a c that's a C or D game then I think I remember liking it but I don't remember rainbow I do remember that um I think we also played that with them maybe I think that's probably a c game for me yeah I think so uh fugo
Fuego uh Fuego is very good I would say it's an a uh a game okay I'll put it in a a two-player trick taker is not easy to yeah um produce no not that this is solely two-player but it's very good at two-player mid summer night fair I would also agree it's a c I think this game has its place but we are not the target intro game for kids yes and it it nails that three of a kind we played that at packs with remember like uh Monique naine Michelle Jenna Tyler Ilia you and me at the end of the night where we were oh yeah it was fun um I would say it's a b or a c for me yeah I'll do B I think it was a fun little party game survive until daylight I liked it more than you did yeah I'm a d or a c on that one oh I was going to be a b where do we put it Jeff oh I dropped in B oops okay Corridor Pac-Man uh that's probably an aame for me I very much like the Q series of games yeah uh so I probably am I'll put it in a I'm yeah I'm a little bit probably biased I also love retro video games so applying the Pac-Man theme to that game I like I like original Corridor so like adding a retro video game theme to that is just it amplifies it it's fun and corridors on BGA if you want try it and I would just say like again if you're not into that kind those abstract type puzzle games this is not going to be for you but I very much enjoy those uh Stock Exchange I think is
a b game for me yeah it's it's a higher be I really like I really liked it as well yeah paper app dungeon Jeff hasn't played I probably put it at a c for right now but if I played it more I think I'd like it more uh Ticket to Ride Paris was the one with a small tiny board yeah and it had the uh yes I remember that it was almost like I was I remember playing it being like this is just what you should play if you're learning Ticket to Ride yeah I I would say it's probably a b there's other ticket to rides that I I like Pand way more um Nordic countries Nordic countries yeah yeah uh flip circus you remember that one with the little like tokens and you're trying to flip over right we really liked that actually probably a be yeah that was a really fun little travel game word traveler it just wasn't really for us I think he need to play it more than two I agree I would probably see it yeah will any games get into the D category no I can see one right now oh yeah uh let's go to Japan I played it in yeah that's a you thing I still don't know how to play this game I've played it but on BJ but I don't know how to play it I I'm going to put it in B only because I had a great time playing it and then I played it again on BGA and I got really confused and I was like oh no so if I played it again in person I think it'd go up to an a stifling dark it's probably a d or c for me I think it's a d I did not like it it it's it's competing with some freaking Banger hidden movement games it was just too much to manage that's that had like
the flashlight thing and I just didn't I'm like no too many components uh Star Wars Bounty easy D for me yeah it's probably the it's I think the worst game I played last year okay uh life of the Amazon an a yeah teetering on S tier I agree distilled an s s yeah agreed there we go happy home is a d for me yeah agreed I just didn't really it I really wanted to like it but it was almost too simple weirdwood manner it's a d for me it's a d for me too sorry uh Sears catalog it's a c for me it's a c for me yeah um actually since we're here I'm just going to scroll down because I know of what's left is down here somewhere and let's just go up cuz of what's left in Sear's catalog are the same game got it uh okay fairy you didn't get to play fairy got it I just spent the whole game doing this got it I don't know I also didn't really understand it so that's probably part dice sounds an S tier for me yeah dice to freaking best game prodigal club's an S tier for me agreed thank you Nick yes thank you Nick uh Romy Romy I really like I do also really like Romy Romy I think it's a I think it's a high B yeah I agree uh search for lost species Jeff hasn't played but I have and that is an
easy a A+ Millie fiori I ver so first play I was kind of like same and then we played it again again I was like wow I really like this because I think we understood better what we were trying to do I think it's a I honestly think it's an aame I think so too um I very much enjoyed it and it's also just beautiful yeah okay Tinder blocks Tinder blocks a I don't know I think it's probably a b fine I I can concede to that yeah it's fun though it's fun for what it is but it's you're just stacking cubes raising robots uh that's an a tier game I agree that's very much inner wheelhouse I really want to play it again very much so Aquatica is an a for me yeah I'm fine with that I of those types of games I think that's the one I like the mosta is great um tangram city is an a for me but probably not for you I could go with B yeah I'm fine cuz I'd probably put that as a c it's just again that's not my type of thing it's totally my type of thing flip ships a easa easa that's the name of a movie F girkin I think it's a B I think so too it's fun and we like it but like I know people are GNA Max bounced off that game so hard yeah and I understand the flaws of that game same Nar I really like Nar I do too I think it's probably a B+ I put it in B too it's not quite an a for me even though I really like it
quadropolis same deal yeah B yeah yeah for now I think it would be here's the thing about quadropolis we played it loved it couldn't tell you a thing about it could not tell you a thing about it yeah don't remember it yeah just remember I do we bought it I know we bought it power an a I agree powerin an a uh Full Throttle is that an a for you I'm fine if you want to give it an a I love it for what it is it's silly little mop yeah neima is probably I think it's a it's it's in the similar vein as Tinder blocks for me so B yeah I think any of those dexterity games are going to be a B for me yeah uh Mex versus minions have we played it enough no I think it's a yeah it's fair when we do our uh campaign game this year that's one of the options that we're going to let people vote on for our Kickstarter backers hemon is an uh an a I agree aony sorry yeah Jeff get it right would you uh Dogs of War is an a for me agreed very excited for the new one to come out witchcraft is an a for me Jeff hasn't played it so he can't say nothing about it 20 strong I'm going to do for now I bet you it goes to an a when uh yeah when the Tanglewood one come out because of the theme and everything I just think it's it's it's so challenging that it's like I never win ethnos ethnos is an a for me I agree and we have played the
updated version for anybody that's curious and it's very good oceans is probably a fine that yep really like it though uh acquire is an a yeah acire was is Aire an s shockingly good I think we play Aire more it could end up in an S I agree I really liked acquire mind space probably a B I don't remember mind space you loved it Jeff remember the conveyor belt of cards and then you're drawing your little polyomino Tetris shape yeah I really like that that's an a game for me okay well let's put it into a last two times I mentioned you're like I don't remember I like anything that's got Tetris e pieces in it which is interesting yeah pagan Pagan an a easy have you played push this push card game we got to play it it's so good it's like a bee but it's it's really good um fluff I really like that I did too we had a good time yeah uh I would say B I agree I'd like to play it again panda panda panda panda is an a for me I really like P I did too it's also the artwork is the same that doana which is great get bit get bits in a I agree get bits so good the taable nuts crew can get bit if you're listening to the table knot crew they played it incorrectly so don't listen to their T I really like T same uh I think
it's probably a B+ right now just because we've only played it like a couple times and we don't know the strategies and stuff totally penguin party was cute but it's probably a b yeah Fair um High season the Grand ustra Hotel Rolland right I think it's probably a B I think so because I I I I'd rather just play Grand ustra Hotel circus flati I think it's a it's probably a b yeah hi B uh espania 1936 it's a b yeah I'd love to Play It Again y a very very good battle flow chart in that one Coffee Rush see for me B for me oops I dropped it in B I just want to note every time it's been C foram she's put it in yeah but I've been giving you A's that I think are B's mountain goats is that's an a an a thank God God you said that Jeff because I agree I love that game a gentle rain I think is a bee for me it's very it's just a very like chill whatever game sausage Sizzle is an a for me thank God I love that game I don't know what it is about it but I love a little dice push your luck game same uh melium is an a melium is an a for me I don't know where it falls for you but I I like it I think I'd really love to Play It Again medich Jeff didn't play I got to play the new version of Michi it was really good I'll put it at a B and I think you'd love it even fall I would do B I thought it was really good lunar probably a b uh not for me I
would say it's C oh okay uh gingerbread house Jeff didn't play so I'm going to put it in a B I thought it was really good surfacea orus Max easy easy a can't believe they changed it from dinosaurs to freaking fruit yeah Septima I'll do a B for now I still haven't played it I'd really like to play it again art Society is probably a b ah I don't know man that I would probably put a B plus a I liked it a lot I'm fine with it in B okay I like to play it again what game are you banish the snakes oh that's just for what it is I think it's a b really okay yeah I would have put it an A but I'll give you the No No we can go a I'm fine with that it's my favorite of that like pandemic system same I just love the theme I think it's crazy fiction we're gonna differ I would put it in a b I'd put it in C so we'll put it in B There It Is this is just I I just gave you this whole video is just us putting games in B that's all it is B is the safest spot rice rice is an a for me I agree uh Sky Team you haven't played I would probably do a b but if I played it more it probably be an A comprom C I think so too I really like it but it's got it's got its place it I also think it has a shelf life yeah I agree a very short shelf life I love line it I do love line it I'm putting it in a yeah I'm fine
with that I do be playing line it on BGA all the time yo-kai sketch we really liked do you remember that one I probably do B I'm fine with B Potato Man potato man's a bee potato man's so it's so ridiculous f f I really enjoyed I did too uh I still think it's a B+ though no it's an a no it's B+ okay B+ I think it's a B+ too dog park I've been playing it on BGA and I kind of like it I don't there's nothing about it that is overly like crazy memorable I don't remember any of it okay well I'm going to put it in a b because I do really like it now that I've been playing it more um on BGA general orders general orders is probably a c or B for me yeah it's just like I think it's c yeah for us and I'll explain why I like more robust war games but a lot of people don't and I think general orders fits more for those types of folk than necessarily for us Robo trick uh that's probably a b um possibly being an a um we need to play more dandelion dandelion I don't remember it oh yes I yeah probably a c for me I'll give it to you but I would put it in B uh monstrous Jeff freaking loved this game remember it's kind of like that Lane Battle almost with like the Monster cards you L
it yeah that's an a that's an a I'll give it to you I would have put it in B see how generous uh Barcelona I really liked yeah it's probably an A or a B for me I'm gonna put it a because I really liked it I like to play it again uh Island something shiny I'm gonna go B I wanted it to be an a Disney dicks it I like dick it but it's like a b yeah uh Rebel princess I really liked it but I'd probably do a b yeah I know people freaking out about that game but people hyped it up a little bit too much don't do that mhm far away what do that we do that on do that don't be like us far away is probably I still don't know how to play that game so you can go ahead don't know how to play it you're funny CU you are playing it I know I still leeping lemons easy a objective a objective a that SN hit it's fine I'm gonna put it in yeah I think it's fine okay this haunted pinball game I want to put it in D okay even though okay even though I think it's a fun game I played it again with Matt and I'm like if you do not have a bunch of players playing this it was so boring sure but with that being said I think it's excellent if you have kids if you like dexterity games but I would pick tumble and dice over this
every day yeah but tumble and dice is like that's a billion doar pick a pen I'm going to put in B Jeff didn't play it uh wandering Towers Jeff ALS didn't play probably C in that I think it's fine AWA I think it's a d or a c I'll put it C I think it's fine um Robo rally I'd probably do B I'm fine with B I would like to do the Transformers one personally walking to the dice game that's s tier right there I'm just kidding it's probably technically a b it's probably technically a d b is a good compromise because I love it uh Cosmic fro an a game for me but I it was not for you I'd put it in B but I'm fine with a I've only played it once pray another day I liked a it was a B I like to play it again Halloween I actually really liked that I did too do we want to do B+ I think it's B+ yeah it's it's a good it's a great intro to H movement definitely uh tribes of the wind I'd put out a b but I think it could be an a yeah I think it would be an a if we' played it more but I agree with with you Bark Avenue I'm doing B uh agreed I do like the root building stuff yeah uh cabanga that was so fun yeah I'd say it's probably a a B+ right now B+ mama I don't remember that the pizza card game we're making the toppings but like you can get rid of people's it's really good
you really liked it we'll put it in B we play Rodney and Christie um pollen is probably a b game for me sure you crushed me in it it' probably be an a if Jeff didn't crush me remember Phantom Inc yeah Phantom Ink's great could be an s m trash talk we played that Rodney and Chris you remember we had like the thing we each had like a and you have a bunch of like random crap and then you're like describing it no okay well it was fine so we'll put it in C okay vampire queen I could do c sure I thought that it was it's good if you have a big group of people sale sale's a c for me just because it's for too impossible I just I don't think hard I don't think I understood it very well piles you didn't play it was really it was just chaotic fun I'll put that at B the same game the first time we played it we hated it the second time we liked it but where does it fall a bee the safest space Just Desserts I played it solo on BGA and I loved it I played it six times in a row I invited Jeff and he's like this game's stupid I'll go see sure but it's really fun Zub ball Zub ball might be a d I think Zub ball is a d I was gonna see where you put it but I'm like it's it's fun I don't know how to describe Zub me either it's it's a dgame but it's a fun d game yeah I don't know it's a dumb baby game but it's a dumb baby game uh key Forge I didn't play it I played it I think I put
it at be going hurt Rod's feelings no I really liked it uh kitten Kitt like Tinder blocks but with cats and speed yeah I would say it's a c I agree it's not as fun as Tinder blocks crisis I very much like Crisis it was really we didn't manage our crisis very well do we want to do a I I would say it's an a game yeah uh Boba maang I'm good it's probably a it fine uh Blitz bow season two blit Bowl's probably a c for me right now yeah but I think that would go up we need to play it more yeah uh Sushi go spin some for dim some I freaking loved that you did yes oh okay where would you like to put it you don't I remember freaking out with that game yeah a lot of people a lot of people hated it Jamie's memory of some things I I think is zero I think sometimes Jeff thinks he loves things where do you want to put a Jeffy it's a B+ okay uh My Favorite Things actually really we played it at p with uh the Discord people Ben Sarah Daniel remember we had to like write on it and then pass it and then try to put it into order oh yeah I mean it was a little bit more in-depth uh fun facts I do see yeah uh Rolland bump Jeff didn't play I played it I loved it I'll put it in be Fisheries of gloss glosser glosser with the little yeah you did we played it together with the little fishermen that
are going and they're catching fish oh I I actually like that a lot that's an a I think yeah I didn't play Jamie I about Jamie doing this but then I actually do need her to explain because I don't remember things based off of name or cover I I remember things based off of mechanisms which is weird switchbacks we played this and I don't remember it yeah though that that's got to be a d then right oh I feel like I liked it more than a d FTW that's a B for me b y all the way um planet fall is probably a c for me it's it's probably a C or D for me too yeah um Skyrocket not our cup of tea we can't and just while we're here the real time ones quicksand is going there as well yeah because we just can't do real time it's just not an enjoyable experience cacao caca is an a for me Cacao is really fun I'd like to play it and we've only played on BGA that's not true I played it in person with Charlie Mike and uh ex me for not for not having an invitation stranger thing D oh Jamie we got pumped yeah but I still like uh Atari S I really liked it it's a b game for me but that's based off of the theme for me yeah neotopia I I really like neotopia a lot so are we doing B I think it's a B I think so Prosperity T Jeff didn't play I'll put it at a c it's really pretty it's kind
of mean it was fine ancient actually really enjoyed think it's a b game for I think it's a b game too crisps e f f f f plus F negative f f it's not on it's not on the list super fight Jeff didn't play it's a Dame it's kind of like a Cards Against Humanity Style game where you're like hitting two things against each other dubious I'd probably do c yeah it wasn't really my thing we played dubious and Phantom Inc in the same like weekend just play just play Phantom ink uh rolling Japan de did deaf deaf didn't play Jeff didn't play I did with Rodney and Christie and I really liked it it's a complicated rle in right though complicated stickum don't remember remember we played it with Charlie I don't remember remember play with Charlie at BGG and it's the one where like you have a certain color that is negative points um yeah I would probably do B yeah I played it again at packs but you didn't myth wind D we didn't like it we're sorry ALU Jaris is a c for me but I did I did like it but it just uh see look bayonets and tomahawks that's a an a game for me okay we're almost done Jeff redwood's a d for me uh that's no it's not a d game it's it's for sure CB c i I thought I just cuz you got
freaking dummy yeah I'm going to put Doom Lings in C I like doings maybe we should put it in B yeah I think Doom Lings is like a game that you want to have in your collection to introduce people into here's what I think about games like Doom Lings I think people knock them off because they're Mass Market immediately yeah they're just like it's Mass Market I wanton to play it yeah and that's not fair no because it is a it's a for what it is it's a very good game yeah and I could pull that out and play with like my parents and kids and whatever I think I liked it I oh oh sorry uh Redwood put in D I got it confused with the next game that you're about to pull out okay thank you redwood's when we like taking a picture but I can only it's it's it has the same issues as stifling dark it's just trying to do two match and sorry I got it confused with this one which is Bonsai uh which I very much enjoyed I would have put Bonsai in a c but where would you like it a b uh I'm fine with C I think it I think I'd put it in B but I'm fine that you want to put it in C zuus B US is an a game for me the game for me I'm trumping you you've gotten so many zuus is an aame I don't care what you say I'm taking it fine pipe mates uh I played on BGA I might do actually I think it's probably a b we play that in person didn't we no we own it but we haven't played it vampire Village is a d a d for me good Omens is a d yeah and here's the the caveat with that if we had watched the show or knew anything
about it sure proba maybe it would go up Halls of hegra uh a A or S I mean I think it's very good we'll put it an a because all of your games are an S arcs Dune Waring um trick draw is probably a d yeah agreed I think it's fine last light's a d for me yeah same did I did not like it maps of Mya is a d for me it could be a c it's probably a c okay it's probably a C I'm get Ruiz see of theves yeah I did yep we played it at a review of paloa remember oh yeah yeah yeah yeah I think that's a c I think it's a c listen you need to explain to me what we did junk drawer is probably a c I like junk drawer but yeah I think it's a c it's just very like simple yeah um Donuts that one's increasing for me the more I play I probably do it a b now that you told me what the objective is I think I'm doing better yeah uh video game Champions is a c for me I think yeah uh okay dungeon date Jeff didn't play I'd put it at a c it was cute Lord of the Rings journey to Mount Doom I'm putting this in a d it was terrible it's Candy Land it was I did not like it uh bat flip that's a c yeah I think so Grove you didn't play but I would put it at a B it's just solo game X code Jeff didn't play this game is objectively a
but based on my experience we had so much fun playing this I played it at Canada Place uh Dimension I'm going to put at a B it's another little solo game that I take traveling pass pass I like pass pass the only thing I remember about pass pass is J saying pass pass pass pass I just kept the whole game I was like pass pass a be it's like a fun little Card Game Pass pass Ticket to Ride Europe it's probably like a be and a I really like Ticket to Ride I think all ticket ride ticket to rides are great bino is probably a see so here's the thing though we've been playing BHO wrong remember what I told you about the yellow cards and you're supposed to remove it yeah okay I think it's probably a b we'll put in B we we've been playing BHO wrong yeah it hurts my fingers and I'm also bad at it aula summer Pavilion you didn't get to play this one I did I thought it was great so I will say we did not include any prototypes we did not include any like games releasing next year like anything like that so and I definitely left some up the list but this my friends this is the ranking and we have five six in s tier and all of them belong I mean I don't know aboute two of them because I haven't played them that is our tier ranking of the new games that we played in the year of 2024 the year sound like some sort of like fantasy movie The Year of nandor the year of nandor Cu he was born in the year of nandor is 2025 though well his up and coming for sure he's a
rising star that one anyways we would love to know what do you think do we put any in D or s that you're like what are you doing you could tell us but it's not going to change our opinions because this is an objective list objective it's been vetted yep by um uve Rosenberg sure and why would you pick up why would you pick out U I don't know the first one that came he's the Freeman freeze it's been vetted by both of them okay even though some of Freeman frees games are on the a or the S yeah doesn't matter let us know what you think in the comments below we are going to have more videos coming of our top 10 top 20 all that good stuff but those are the games for 2024 and that is what we have for you today so now let's talk about something if you're interested in buying board games like any of the 288 that we mentioned today I might like to recommend that you check your friendly local gaming store and for us that is boardroom Game Cafe if you like what you see Please Subscribe we hope to see you again soon and now we say goodbye goodbye later days sometimes a nice face rub maybe I wonder if the massage gr will do your face you can get facials can you get out are you freaking ready yes how it's just the problem with Star Wars unlimited is
it's oops sorry I've gone too far H okay get rid of that ad I can't it's there's an X right there no hey you want to get rid of ads send me your feedback no thank you stupid what the I don't know Jamie but I'm going to lose my mind that may have been one of the worst games we played last year and unfortunately we had to do it on camera