Orleans Stories: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we're doing a no run through review for orleans stories uh which is a slog um no so this game whenever it was initially announced like because i think i can i think you were the one who told me about it yeah and i was like oh [ __ ] early on stories like a campaign of orleans that doesn't sound boring um no but i was i was initially extremely excited for it because of the uh i mean the potential that i mean we both love uh early on the way it was marketed the way it was marketed my number one game of all time yeah it's your favorite game of all time so yeah orleans is is great like the epitome of what every bag builder wants like aspires to be um so uh essentially making a campaign a somewhat historical kind of a civilization kind of game center around that sounds like a pretty good idea and oh boy the tmg just open up this box and take a giant [ __ ] in it um that's not entirely true um this game isn't horrible but as we were talking when you when you left the room brad and i were
actually talking about a little bit and i felt like at the more we started really looking at it the more it seemed to unravel it's kind of like it's like a it's like a like like a rope like you pull one string and it just like all just then you're like great now i got now i got nothing here um oh you got what do you guys think what do you guys think of early on it is okay it is not so okay that i want to play it for four hours it see here's the thing it is um long and no matter how much you love orleans i can't imagine you love it so much that you would play one game for hours right like there is not enough substance to warrant a long long game so we're gonna dive into that a little bit more but brad what's your initial your initial thought my initial thought is kind of goes around along the lines what you're saying you know it's it's it's longer than it needs to be yeah um it's it's or the base is orally armed you know yeah and everything which is great right the game itself isn't bad it's just it's like it's cool like i kind of like some of the decisions that they made but they executed it in such a horrible way essentially in orleans you you're gathering victory points and at the end of the game you have essentially like checklists of like okay here's how and then you add up all your points and your
most points wins uh and that that's it that's not the same that's not the case here you everyone gets a checklist that's exactly the same um that's exactly the same that's that's not really a problem for me uh because you can you can tackle them in a different order it is a race for a reason yeah yeah so you essentially have have this which is a race to complete a bunch of different objectives and you have to complete them all uh to win the game you have to build a well do something with a monk and and cloth and a harbor build a church get 20 citizens um i don't remember what the two people one was uh i just do something with a monk yeah but you have all of this and the problem isn't so much that this i actually like this i kind of like this almost a little bit better than the victory point thing because like i mentioned in early ons there's sometimes not every game but some games where it's like this is the definitive way to win oh there's a lot of silk in the in the market race to get that silk technology or or tile and then just ramp to that because unless you're playing with the the [ __ ] market that you can [ __ ] with other people uh then no no one can stop you so you can visibly see my mountain of silk that's oh look this is 60 points right here uh like i said not every game because sometimes a bunch of silk can go out on the board and then there's not much there it's not that viable um but my problem with this is it's a race
like imagine if you were doing a marathon and like never mind my analogy is not going to work the variability is what is what differs between the two i think this this is static yeah it's the same every single time um yes it's true static it's the same every time so you can almost take the same steps i mean i know it's going to be different because people are going to build build technology or build these in different yeah depending on player order and how that happens to happen right but in orleans you know with all the events that pop up you you have um that turn to prep for it yeah this i mean we were sitting here multiple times but okay famine's coming they're at three so we need to stay here at eric too and get everything prepped right before we move up and they they you know i think they tried to fix that a little bit where we know we know for a fact famine is coming up but they give at least a thematic reason like why we know that like some some people that came into our village they told us hey we left there because they're getting [ __ ] so we can prep um and it's an era i don't know how long an era is supposed to be in like generation i thought or a couple generations yeah so so i mean at least it was thematically tied in which i like yeah but yeah that's that's that's kind of my problem is that you can like you can't even complete some of these until era like you you cannot theoretically complete the the monk one
until you can actually get a monk which is in era seven yeah um but then there's there's these things that you pass on on the fame track that just lets you cross off something so every every single time you play this game you're gonna cross off the monk yeah just to get it going yeah because why wouldn't you that that's my thing it's like that's why i like the victory point version better yeah because i know there's there's ways that are more beneficial than others and you can choose which path you want to take right you can be like i'm going to try the the the fisherman with the money i'm going to try to do i'm going to try one with money this time and yeah or do whatever yeah this one you have you you are on a rail yep for the most part you you know you're gonna have to get that have to get that and for the record the story is subpar at best like it's not invigorating or anything yeah it's more like loose history right it's just like it's really it's like it's mechanical stories it's just like it's telling you why the monks aren't there like already it's like there's no enveloping like overarching reason why we're doing what we're doing i was confused because at the very beginning of like the actual when you were explaining everything to us i was like oh so one game isn't just one era this is gonna be yeah this is a whole thing yeah um so yeah you're right you're like this is extremely railroaded and even then because the game says 60 to 90 minutes it does not say per player so [ __ ] tmg for not actually putting that on there yeah that is an absolute [ __ ] lie yeah um imagine unpacking this and being like okay yeah
cool got some time to learn and there's no safe system like um unlike the colonists that we played uh with josh that has to say it's not the best but you you can save it and it's a um it's it's a civ game like it's a long saved game but actually you can be like all right that's enough here we'll we'll bag it everything up and we'll save it for whenever we come back you have to take a few pictures but there's no you could pictures like you were saying but you'd have to really god right okay well let's see okay write down every single thing that you have and no no keep it in your bag um just as a deal bgg has it as 60 to 180 minutes like but here's the thing um because the main thing is that it's long and there's not enough to do um we there was a point when we were playing that unless the fame counter stops at 69. uh or 70 like if this is where you have to end i had an engine that if i had bill to the uh what was it the tax collector yeah it was the tax collector yeah it's the uh battery office notaries no re-office that gives me three coins so i had an engine that's like okay i can get three coins i can go to the pub get rid of three coins for three points so there is almost zero reason for me to advance because if i can just circle this fame track and then just race oh citizen boom oh okay gonna get the drawback boom check it out and then i'll just keep checking off the only thing that prevents me from doing that
is the the church you have to actually build the church and you can only build the church whenever you get the church in seven an era in era seven yeah so here's the problem with that is that okay because there's no events that come in i can look okay so to get out of the famine you need to pay a coin for each village on the board um and that's not even each of your villages just each village on the board it's like okay well i'm accumulating a [ __ ] ton of money anyway i just won't go to the pub so all right so i'll be in famine for one turn okay to get out of attack uh your harbor is complete well you can actually complete the harbor uh before era era four so okay i'll just aim to do that uh so i'll probably be in there i'll preemptively do that you can just plan so far ahead that it's like i can just be an era too while you guys are trying to go in four or five or whatever and i can just lap the board and then just race to seven and then be like okay boom done well and i think they could have they could have made it a little more intriguing if there would have been these eight and they were randomized yeah that way you couldn't look up they were all face down it's like you'd flip like maybe if one person was getting ready to go you then you'd have those two out yeah oh yeah there's some actual consequence today because that would be a ketchup thing because the people that were like we were if we were behind and we'd be like okay well he's on this one we can kind of see it a little bit that's true yeah that's kind of a ketchup thing yeah that actually wouldn't have been that bad right but they wanted it to be
so ingrained in like the theme and the story which that it's not even that good anyway that you you can't do that like you have to be like okay because then like i mean but this still could have worked because if i go into era like let's say it was random and it's like let's say um era 7 uh which is the plague that comes up uh it's like oh [ __ ] okay i then plan for that but now i have availability for my monks but you guys now know okay well if we get there we can get monks hm should we do that because like nothing mechanically is any reason why we we couldn't do that why why that that wasn't a thing yeah it it's uh i like the mechanics overall well yeah because it's like if you like early ons but i mean so really i guess it just boils down to this yeah i mean this is what makes it a three to four hour game yeah and i mean it's not even it's not like it's not like it wasn't fun uh because we were playing early ons right yeah because it just got a good stale we played like two games of early on yeah yeah yeah yeah i mean essentially it's like watching a three-hour movie and you like realize you're like there were scenes in that movie that could have didn't have to be in there like because put it this way by the time we quit i had actually already completed one of my sections yeah and i had double the amount of citizens not by really putting in any more work i just had a i just had an engine you had a really good engine yeah because we played for what two hours yeah we played two hours there's eight errors we're on air at two
yeah he could have went to three yeah i could have gone to three um but i'm like why because there's a famine i don't i don't want to deal with that it's not like it's the first game thing yeah because we know how to play early oh yeah wasn't that much added it was just they really okay essentially what they did they took orleans and they're like how can we how can we exploit the fans of orleans okay here's what we'll do we'll take the game and we'll just we'll just chunk it out and we'll just make some half-assed story uh to uh to make the game longer i just think calling it stories is incorrect it should have been like errors no it's it's actually it's stories because there's two stories there so it it'd be funny if it was the story because i wish it would have had been more campaign it should have been where there were stopping points yeah and you know like and actually put in some effort into each era like to where because in my mind when i heard early on stories was the fact that it was going to be not legacy but campaign where maybe the way that you built or how you did certain things in your era it could like expand into where this is mine like this is like this is my whole village or uh whatever yeah and it's not it's not that it's not that at all um it's it's a race i just feel like i don't even remember how uh how much this was i don't know but it was just through pre-orders through their stats when you go to kickstarter which is what's weird to me because tmg's a kickstarter i mean they do everything almost kickstarter yeah and i
didn't do this kickstarter i think it was just kind of like yeah um one thing i an idea i was thinking with this would almost be like if they broke it since it's stories if they broke these into eight games yeah and had either the theme was there was the famine theme and yeah you had like almost like you had a different starting starting yeah and you played that out and you have to deal with it yeah maybe if you won then you had a little advantage in the next yeah kind of like what arcadia quest does is like each thing it's like okay well i won this one so now the famine is not going to affect me as much right um and that way you you had a saving point it was a whole new setup to start off the next game yeah so you didn't have the same bag you know you hit the same six or seven yeah yeah but it would be different depending on the theme of the yeah there'd be the attacks and then that's when the fortresses are coming forward and we have to fight each other you have the knights and all that i think that if you just broke it up into little segments yeah it's so much better yeah that's a good idea that is a good idea um tmg it's a yeah yeah if you want to work for them um because apparently they had no idea what to do they it just it seems like i don't even know how this came up it just it boggles my mind at how the mechanic i mean that's the thing we can't even give this game any praise on how the mechanics work because it's already a game that they've made it's like it's early on and everything new is not bad but it's not good yeah it's just not really needed like they didn't really need to make this that's true yeah they they really didn't
yeah because the the invasion expansion added all those events and the events yeah into the game right i mean because the fact that what makes early on is great is the fact that you do flip over an event and it's like oh this is gonna be good or it's gonna be bad for and like it's actually based on player like sometimes an event could be good for me but bad for you right but you have that whatever you have your actions whenever you draw you have your actions to place out and be like to try and plan for it like we mentioned before i can sit here and and be like all right figure out my strat and then i can have that same exact thing the entire game and nothing you guys do unless i mean they tried to seem to fix that by trying to conquer one another but it's like okay like you can't do that oh no you took that from me so it goes back all right i guess i'll just go somewhere else well and you said that that the the knights and you need to for attacking didn't start till age four five or five yeah whatever so no aerofork we only had four more eras there are places for territory and then that one this would have been worthless right yeah until somebody got until and then and then it it forces conflict um in a game where there was never any conflict like the only the only conflict in early ons was the very passive like oh you have it you have a mill okay i'm gonna try and take as much to stop you from ending which isn't even that's not even that bad like that's not any like personal slight but here it's like okay well now you get nights so yep we ran out of spaces on the board so now you have to fight each other for any
semblance of territory control which like i'm never a big fan if it's not like a like like meant to be super territory like control game i'm not always a fan of just throwing that in there because it's like i have other [ __ ] that i want to do i don't want to [ __ ] fend off right like right and then they even by even forcing conflict then they also have where you can just build fortresses and be like okay well you can't take these for me so it's like yeah so the conflict that they that they force on you they also put in another way to to prevent that it's kind of like the here's here's a good analogy assassin's creed odyssey when that came out was such a grind that there was uh microtransactions that you could pay like 20 bucks for an xp doubler or or money doubler so essentially it made the grind that they implemented in that game non-existent but you had to pay to do that it's like okay so you're paying me really to not play play your game here it's the exact same thing it's like hey we're gonna put in you here to have you attack each other okay but we're also gonna put in something to where you don't have to attack each other it's like then why'd you throw that in there like your example like replacing or or randomizing these that would work if we wanted to make this game work but your idea for eight separate stories that are centered around each other each theme with different mechanics would have been fantastic they would have had to actually put in some [ __ ] effort but uh yeah not just copy and paste and um yeah they just they missed the
mark and the rule books it wasn't that good oh the rule book is is horrendously stinky bad um not not only in just kind of organization where it's like the first page is like hey do you know how to play orleans great you don't have to read this i like how it's color-coded right because that's pretty nice but here's the other problem that i have this is very slight there's two stories like i said in this book or in this game uh first kingdom and king's favor the first kingdom is green and i was like okay great and i couldn't find the second one because it's also green oh so i didn't even see that until later i'm like oh yeah it could have just been a different color of green so we're running out of colors because we had to go to bgg just to find the definition of what all costumes were food which which thematically makes sense it's all in the food depot but they didn't say it yeah and if they don't say it like you have to assume it's like well wouldn't they have said it like yeah you would think so again that's what makes it bad is like there's no clarification um for anything so once again all the new stuff that they put in they don't even really tell you how to implement that new stuff so once again that that also makes it bad bonus oh this this is a positive yeah even though we didn't use it we were just asking you the whole time
the building tiles do and it kind of answers any questions so people can look and not instead of like everyone passing on the same rulebook or like some companies they only print like one player right it's like this this was a positive it is nice i i do i do like how the errors are sectioned out um and this i mean it seems like what they omitted in the rulebook they put in here um right which i don't like i think it's like once again they just who's the designers for this it's not random friendly stockholders all right pull up right here that's just that's it's it's like it's like yeah uh designers reiner stockhouse dlp games which is a european companies who created who makes it and then tmg who imports it to the us gotcha so they're there so dlp is actually ones who made
or like they i i'm really meeting the designers of the game so if tmg is so if they're the ones who just brought it over to the states and it's not their fault they're probably sitting there and they're like oh great you guys have a new orleans game that's fantastic like well because remember when i sent you that pre-order yeah the thing for the pre-order i was like i'm gonna wait because i just said dlp version and i was like i want to write for the tmg because i don't want it to match my that's right that's right i didn't do it but then i realized it's all tmg anyway so yeah that was my yeah my mistake but i mean saving money yeah i'm really trying to think of other positives like i i like i in in terms of the game not what it could be because that obviously doesn't exist i like i do like the progression of like okay what food is on the market you know what uh like what tiles you can get to um i do like that but very loosely like it's not it's like okay like it's very superficial likes i'm i'm really stretching to find some things i like just an okay game yeah i'll tell you these up here were kind of cool um like those because you know like you know the benefits of boards you know we they had the different boards where you could call your bag by putting stuff out there and get benefits right these are the same way but once they're filled they flip over yeah and they're so like different yeah so like the wine press yeah you send wine and then three three people and you get five five uh money uh the next one is the weaving loom which is wool and and uh silk and you get five points uh the
the three field crop rotation you get three points the back is right of succession which is five points five money and stuff like that barter that was like the only conflict one you can trade something for another person but you only do that three times and it goes to knight's allegiance yeah uh alchemy is alchemy yeah it's just there was it was create a little bit more creative yeah i did like that last part because at first i saw those up there and i was like i don't know how much i'm going to use those i actually wound up being the only one uh i did i did like one i put one out there when i was when i was moving the air because i know i put two so i guess i didn't do a significant amount more but um i don't care for the semi-co-op part yeah the food depot it does it didn't make any thematic sense it's like yes technically a famine affects everybody but it only affects the people who are in that era and if they have enough money it'll only affect you one turn yeah yeah yeah yeah that's true you're like oh well that day sucked let's move on and i have money right you think i'm yeah i just throw it at the ground make food that's how that works um honestly i can't really think of anything else the rest we would have to talk about is like what our thoughts on early ons are which we're not doing that's a runaway leader on this with something else we had decided we had talked about that yeah i feel like if if and here's my problem with uh not not a lot of games but with certain games um what i like so much about like you mentioned early on the other sometimes we have that game where that like this is a strat to at least aim for
um but if you play it enough then it's like okay well you're gonna go after the silk is they're worth the most points well i'm gonna go after other stuff that effectively blocks that um but there's so much variety in that game that in that in that particular instance me trying to take away silk from you is not the the only thing i'm focusing on there are games where it's like oh to stop you from winning i have to play my entire game to stop you from winning and i hate that but there's enough variety and early ons to prevent uh to to have variety here i would never not go for this oh yeah oh yeah like your your entire you would have to essentially stop me like you stopped me with the barn like because i was five five money and it's like okay well now you ended up taking the rest of it so it wasn't there but that'll come back in era four more more wheat will come back ten more wheat so then it's like okay great i'm gonna go for that um they're obvious there's some that are obviously better yeah and this because the randomness isn't right and then here's the thing because this stays the same it's like okay so in error two we get money for each village well i'm gonna take the secret village and then i'm just gonna sit here and then just stay there and then just go back to the pub and just block think if they just if we just got a papercut if they trust if we just got scissors and just try it just just like break this i would laugh if this was a punchboard i'm like oh no and even on the back it looks like there was like hey look here's the board i believe that the very first one era one collins would always be the
first one yeah but then everything else everything else could be random except error one and era eight because that's yeah you can't all right collins i should say we're in peace of having an actual campaign with these all centers because i think actually having like a game where it's a new setup and it's actually a war like it's new war mechanics that would have been cool it would have completely in dealing with plague you know and it's like this would be a food battle you know yeah trying to get enough food to to fend off the famine it's like what could have been what could have been but in all honesty uh dlp or reiner whatever the collab there was just just [ __ ] it up so bad that it's like i would never play this i would never play this again nah like i can't i wouldn't say that before i mean like but why would you why would you go through this same thing when you could easily play orleans well no no yeah i'm not saying i when i say i would i mean if i was in a game day yeah with people you know that were they were long game players yeah then i would probably you know but it's like with most game days it's like you want to try and play as many games as possible throughout the day and it's like hey how about we get our fill of orleans by actually playing early on and you know wow it didn't take up the entire game day yeah so yeah i mean bad time
yeah well not really a bad time because we played long enough to it's not a great time and now it's already almost one and it's like i wasted our whole morning it's like great thanks for ruining my life i hate myself i yeah uh all right so scala won the ten cat i'll just give it a dang ol solid five it's pretty much orleans but i would rather just play i would just personally rather play early on brad um i'll only six a six yeah mainly because i i i you know because orleans is almost a perfect score for me this hat i still get that feeling of it yeah you know and like i said if i was playing with people that preferred long stretch i'd play something else yeah if if i would orleans be your number one take ignore all this would it be your number one if it was four hours no because right right and that's what this is right and that's why this is this is a six yeah you know and it's it's it has a lot of a lot of needs for improvement for sure yeah um the box art is better yeah do you like the box or do you like the box it's not ugliest i i wouldn't buy it yeah i mean it's her own definitely play it if somebody else had it yeah um i'm actually giving it a four i think this is below average like because it like i was thinking five but i cannot give this game credit because it steals orleans like the reason why it works is because orleans is like an eight or a nine out of ten for me
and so it's like okay well i can't give this the credit because it didn't it didn't do anything new so i have to rate it based off of everything new that it implemented and it [ __ ] up so bad on everything new that it's not i would never play this again yeah there's no way um i'm only corleone's that much to sit here and do and literally just draw from a bag for [ __ ] for four hours there's no way yeah and even if like it's one of those things where you can bum rush the errors and that's basically them saying hey everything new about the game don't [ __ ] do yeah like just rush through it all to finish the same checklist that like that you just wouldn't ever see you would never like the only thing that bugs me about the checklist i'll just say it real quick cause i know we're pretty much done um is at first i don't mind it being the same because like i said it is a race we are all trying to win the same goal it's gonna be the same that every single i know every single time i'm looking at this dirty piece of paper i'm gonna i'm gonna go to five go to five yeah just because i mean that's just yeah that's kind of that and that's the thing is yeah fives um five five four yeah and and and that's the thing is like because it's i think it's below average is because they miss the mark so bad in what could have been and like in the marketing also like miss marketing and it's just it almost seems like a scam like really is what it feels like i
don't have that i don't have a dirty taste on my tongue or anything but like the more we talk about it the more i'm thinking man did they really just like this is madden this is like they did they rehashed early ons and just made some slight changes and [ __ ] up it's just it's so bad and it it says to me i mean it says everything to me that it didn't go to kickstarter yeah yeah because if it would have went to kickstarter people actually dissected it because the the pre-order page does not have a lot of information on this game that's true at all yeah i bought it on a whim right honestly so there was not much information on this game they were just kind of relying it's like okay people like doraleon's like they'll still get our game and they were wrong that's probably the correct way to pronounce that or leon's i go i mean i don't know early on yeah yeah anyway but yeah so that that's why it's just the more we talk about it the more i yeah i'm not like seething yeah because once again when we were playing it wasn't bad it's just yeah it's i'm i no it's it does not work so so yeah that's a four out of ten uh for me um but that's our thoughts on early on stories everyone let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon
link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you