Soccer & Football: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in soccer or football. I love soccer. I've played soccer my entire life. I'm 45 now. I probably started playing when I was around five. I've also watched soccer for my entire life. And while there are many different mechanisms in the game of soccer, I thought I would draw a a connection between soccer and tabletop games in today's video. And I'm filming it because the World Cup is happening right now. I'm filming it just as the US lost their final game somewhat miserably. They played terribly. But I'm proud of what they did earlier in the tournament. Um and I'm rooting for uh I don't know, great great soccer for great great games for the rest of the tournament, of course. Uh I love the World Cup. Uh but I thought it was a good time to film my favorite mechanism in it in it. And I think my favorite mechanism of soc in soccer is that it is not a point solid game. And I think this is more than relevant ever today than it was in the past because there are so many different metrics in a soccer game that determines who played better. Like who was the better team? The team who controlled the ball longer? The team who took more shots on goal?
The team who had more corner kicks? Fewer fouls? The team that uh strung together the most passes successfully? You can see all these metrics uh if you look at the stats for any game that's happening. You can even see now a momentum stat to see which game which team had the momentum more often or more often in a row. So, there are so many some ways that you can look at a game of soccer and say, "Okay, this team should have won. They took more shots. They controlled the ball longer. They they they passed more accurately. This team should have won." And I think in most tabletop Euro games, that team would just be the winner. You would say, "Okay." You would you would determine a system of points based on all those different statistics. And you would say, "Okay, this team is the winning team." But soccer doesn't do that. Soccer says the winning team is the team who has the highest score. And there's only one way to score. You have to put the ball across the line into the net.
That is the one way that you can do it. Um, now there are many ways that you can get the ball up the field to get to that point, different strategies you can employ, but there's only real one way really one way to score. And I think this is uh a little bit of a reminder to people like me who design Euro-style games. A Euro-style game, if you're watching this as someone who mostly plays soccer or enjoys soccer, is a uh a tabletop game that gives players a lot of control a lot of a lot of agency over the decisions they're making. Often times these games involve victory points, which look on the surface like the points in a soccer game. But typically in a game with victory points, there are lots of different ways to achieve them. So you're putting together different strategies, different paths to victory to get those victory points. Uh whereas in soccer, there's just one way to do that. You have to put the ball in the net, across the line, and you have to have more of those points, more of those goals, than the other team to win.
And again, so I think this is a good reminder to game designers, including myself, that sometimes just having a very simple binary way to win uh can be a pretty powerful way to uh to end the game and to determine the winner of the game. And I appreciate that soccer does that. I appreciate I like seeing all those other metrics. As someone who enjoys stats, I love seeing them, but I really like that soccer just comes down to who scored more goals this game. It means that sometimes teams that wouldn't otherwise be able to win a game against a much stronger team, they have a chance to win because all they have to do is have one more point than the other team. That's all you need. Um so yeah, that is I think my favorite mechanism, at least in connection to tabletop games, to soccer. Uh and I'd love to hear your favorite mechanism in soccer or football. And if you can think of any tabletop games that use this mechanism, where they say, "Okay, we're not going to be a point solid game.
There's just one way to win one it's a binary way to win, winner loss um in in game or a team game, soccer is a team game. And uh and this is how you achieve that goal. Let me know about that in the comments below. Thanks.