Skip to main content
Loading video...

What Am I Doing WRONG? Handling Critique

Transcript 13:45

in this video i'll tell you how to give and take critique in miniature painting i went to school college for uh art mainly graphic art and photography that was my main emphasis stuff initially more the graphic design and then later on photography and stuff and i've used both of those things in my professional life my current day job this youtube channel all that kind of stuff so um but that being said studio art classes are very different than normal college classes normal college classes you go in and you learn a bunch of stuff and then you take tests and tests have a specific number of questions and there's right answers and wrong answers and there's scores and things like that but it's a little bit more subjective with art classes what we would do in art classes is we would the professor would tell us hey next week like on thursday or whatever we're going to have for critique and then that critique was now a target that we had to hit we had to bring in a bunch of new work that we were doing in class that was finished so sometimes there were some late nights leading up to critique and then we would put them on the walls all around the the entire you know whatever studio there and then the professor would go through and say okay so who's this who's whose is this and you'll be like that's that's my stuff and then they would talk about it you would talk about it the class would talk about it and that's how things got done those were kind of the milestones you know across the semester and at the end then the professor would i don't

know pull a grade out of their hat and then give it to you and that's again kind of subjective whatever but nonetheless that's the way it worked the thing that was interesting about it to some degree and how it compares to um tabletop wargaming is we would go into those particular days in class knowing we were going in to be critiqued and sometimes you go into your local game store or local convention and you don't know you're about to be critiqued you should never give unsolicited advice now i understand that that sounds like unsolicited advice i get that but you came here to watch the video so you know that's all bets are off if i had just walked up to you and said look this is how you should live your life that would be unsolicited advice one video it's a different thing so i've talked in the past about people coming up to you and telling you that your paint job's not good and that kind of stuff it was uh don't listen to paint job bullies pachow and the thing is is that when you give unsolicited advice you are probably i i'm betting probably trying to help you are saying look you know you could get this better um if you did this and this and if you stop doing that and that's in most situations coming from a place of good faith now there are some folks out there specifically the paint job bullies as it were who are telling you that your work is bad to make them feel better that's i got no fix for that frankly but there are generally people who are trying to help and they just don't realize that unsolicited advice is something that

most people don't want some people hate being helped i'm kind of one of them it's a character flaw i'll admit but as soon as you come and go hey you know what uh what you should do with your videos or hey you know what you should do with the the game that you designed or whatever my brain kind of shuts off so uh it doesn't actually have any help but you know there are still even outside of unsolicited advice there are still ways that you can help somebody if they're kind of struggling with their paint job or that kind of stuff you know if you feel that you must generally if you walk up to someone and ask and say hey can i give you some some advice that's kind of still unsolicited even if you ask because they're probably going to be like you know uh i guess okay and that's not you know so so don't do that but if you are let's say at the shop and you're playing against somebody maybe somebody you know sort of well maybe somebody you don't know it all and they are complaining about their own paint job or you know some sort of trouble that they're having with their technique there's like i just wish my stuff looked better you know i just kind of it's not quite quite as good as i would like and and that kind of stuff if they're complaining about it or even commiserate you can you can commiserate and go oh yeah you know but here's the thing don't just go well can i give you some advice again don't go down that road what i would do instead which will kind of get you to the same spot is to start by trying to gauge by how long that they've been painting and don't just go well how long you've been

painting because again that's kind of a little bit too much ask them about the techniques that they use you know they may be completely brand new and this might be their first paint job right you know how was your first minis i mean here's mine it uh it was it's not good you know um so if this is very very early in their paint journey then you know they're going to be complaining maybe a little bit about it or trying to figure out how to get better but you want to try to not necessarily make them feel bad by how you know how short of a time they've been painting you want to start off by going well you know like what about um have you tried dry brushing do you familiar with dry brushing or you know like what about do you use washes you know that kind of stuff ask those kind of questions and then find out kind of through that how long that they've been painting and then once you've got a general idea of how long they've been painting then you can kind of address their complaint and gently tell them how that you might fix it so you could look at it and go well you know i mean here's here and again don't go well here's what i would do i would again say it's a better idea to say you know ask questions if you ask questions versus tell people things then they feel a little bit more agency i think in it versus you just saying coming down from the mountain and telling them what to do at least in that type of situation and it also depends on a lot of other things how well do you know this person that kind of stuff but um you know the idea being that going back and forth

and figuring this out a little bit you might be able to then teach them something which is generally better than unsolicited advice so if you've determined that someone is relatively new to this hobby things that you might want to suggest to them if they're again if they're complaining about their particular paint job if they've got a paint job that makes you a little nauseated like a little bit in the back of the throat just a little look but uh they seem to dig it just keep zip it you know what i mean just let them be happy with what they've got going on please you know but if they're like gosh i kind of wish that like especially like maybe let's say you've been doing it longer and they're comparing themselves to you which i'll get to comparison in a second we've talked about it in the past but if they're like man i wish that this you know whatever you could ask them like well okay here wet palette have you thinned your paints i can tell you from going on to reddit uh and looking at miniature painting uh subreddits and and warhammer subreddits and all kinds of different things like that when people are asking for critique on reddit nine times out of ten the first thing is well you should thin your paints because newer people have a tendency not to thin their paints and then everything looks real chalky and thick and that's kind of a problem right so ask them about thinning their paints and if they're not doing it you know ask them about wet palette because that can help you to thin your paints if you really want to let them know you could send them to this video pachow where i teach you how to make a wet palette it's a good idea i think most people like to go down that road eventually but you can also ask them about well dry brushing not just

dry brushing but are using a makeup brush are you doing something like that because makeup brushes can do a lot of work for you again we can talk a little bit about a video but ciao about using makeup brushes and that kind of stuff but also ask about washes people who are new are going to ask you things about or are going to be looking for maybe you know some information about things like dry brushing um and thinning their paints things that they may have not necessarily even known exist but you can kind of help them with that things to not bring up probably to a person who's relatively brand new you've determined they're pretty brand new don't bring up like tuber two brush blending uh airbrush xenothal edge highlighting lots of stuff like that there are people out there that are like yep you should definitely learn those things right from the get but for the most part there's you're thinning your paints you're dry brushing and you're doing some washes those have a tendency to be can you know things that work better for newer people though i still use them all the time i'm not a great painter but i do okay but the the the wet blending the two brush blending all kinds of stuff like that airbrush xenothal i like to use airbrush senoth and i even sometimes edge highlight stuff a little bit but those things can tend to tend to be a little bit more advanced and telling a person oh you know what you should be doing you should definitely be getting yourself an airbrush and a compressor doing that's kind of difficult to do um on a new person and you need to properly kind of judge your audience the person that you're trying to give a little bit of help and support to so you don't scare them away now as i said unsolicited advice

it's bad uh it's just straight up bad but unsolicited praise is not bad at all if you see something uh you know even one thing that they did that you think looks pretty okay on their paint job whether they're even complaining or not like this is a person who's sitting in front of you with models it is almost always nice if you're trying to get people into the hobby you're trying to help people grow in the hobby even just be going like wow i really like the way you did those bases or wow that guy's helmet is really neat or anything like that picking something out like that if there's absolutely nothing that you can say positive then you know that's fine you can also just you know that just just talk about something else and play your game and jog on but if there's something you can point to that says i really like what you did here or this is pretty cool that's going to help them feel better about what they're doing and hopefully not leave the hobby so that's giving critique but what about receiving critique as well now if somebody gives me advice that i didn't ask for and it happens from time to time and i'm not even talking about necessarily miniatures and stuff like that it could be all kinds of different things at this age i have a tendency to just look them just dead in the eye and just go huh after they give me some advice that i didn't ask for and generally all but the least self-aware people will kind of get the hint and and you know leave it alone hopefully change the subject um if i'm complaining about my paint job right uh the stuff that i'm working on i'm at a shop i'm playing a game or

whatever and i'm complaining about it and then somebody gives me advice what that teaches me is that i shouldn't complain in public about my paint job you should definitely be critical about the work that you're doing to some degree don't be overly critical but to yourself you should be critical but how can i make this better do i want to make it better there's lots of things you can go back and forth about but when you're very public about it you're going to get people who are going to tell you well you know what you should do and you may not necessarily want that now what if you do if somebody offers you advice that you know and you actually asked for it you were like hey uh you know i trust your judgment can you give me some advice and if they do that then you should pay attention to it because they might be smart it is very smart of you in my opinion to talk to people who are good painters if you are having questions that kind of stuff asking for advice and then telling the person who gives you the advice that they're wrong is also kind of toxic i've said it before and i'll say it again you should mainly compare your work to your previous work is it at least as good as stuff that i have done just recently is it better than the stuff am i getting better that kind of stuff you should not be comparing your work to the work of the people in the magazines and online and in the contest that you see all that kind of stuff those people have probably been doing it a lot longer than you have and it would make complete sense that they are better now if you do want advice it is very important i think to ask people who you know to be better painters and who you have some sort of relationship with and i don't mean like you're dating

them i'm saying if you have a friend who's a better painter than you that's the person you should be asking if there's a person online on instagram or whatever who is a better painter than you and you start asking all kinds of questions it's a little bit difficult sometimes because either a maybe they get lots of questions or b they don't know you as well your friends know you as well even people who hang out at the shop that you see frequently that you know to be better painters at least have a better idea maybe of how long you've been doing it all that kind of stuff and they can generally give you better answers and give you better critique and then if you're paying attention and you're listening hopefully you can take it as well what are your thoughts about giving and receiving critique on miniature painting like do you do it does it happen to you do people just talk to you and say hey you should do this differently that kind of stuff let us all know in the comments and if you can drop a like below really helps the channel thanks for watching so i'm

Progress saved