Skip to main content
Loading video...

Duel of Meloch - Board Game Review

Transcript 19:19

Welcome to Allies or Enemies. I'm Jess.

And I am Shawn, and today we are talking about Jewel of Mellocks, Side versus Expeditions. And our copy was provided, but thoughts are all our own.

Jewel of Mellock is a one to two player game designed by Jamie Stegmaier that smooshes together Side and Expeditions. And you can also use it to play a two-player version of Side or a two-player version of Expeditions, or you can use it as expansions to either game. Let's start off with talking about Side versus Expeditions.

So, this is usually where we teach the game, but this is a lot to teach because you kind of got to learn all of Side and all of Expeditions. So, we're just going to talk about kind of where they meet in the middle with this. So, what is happening here is you're going to have a map. It's really nice little neoprene mat. On one side is going to be a player with all of their normal Side stuff. On the other side is going to be player with all of their Expeditions stuff. The Expeditions player is pretty much just playing Expeditions. So, on that you've got all of the hexes, you've got two cards out. Those are the cards that you can grab. You're going to be moving around, you're going to be vanquishing and gathering and playing and all the stuff you would expect to do in Expeditions. The Side player, same thing. They're going to be doing playing exactly the same as Side. They're going to be putting out resources, moving around. You can fight in Expeditions.

There isn't really fighting in this way, but you can fight each other. Both players can fight. So, Expeditions players can use vanquish to fight, but the main thing here is you've got a shared track. And that's where you're going to put your stars. On one side is all the things that Side player needs. On the other side is all the things the Expedition player needs. When either player gets a star that they can put out, the other player is going to get a bonus from these really clever little Mel Lot cards. Whoever gets four stars out first wins the game.

And the interesting thing is, unlike either of the games that this originates from, it's a race to those stars where only one player can get that type of star. So, if you see that your opponent is going towards like the star for people, then as the other player, you think, "Well, there's no point in me racing to that if I'm not going to get there first."

Yeah, yeah, that is interesting because yes, you're right. Inside the expeditions, you can both get everything that you want to get. You don't get in each other's way. But the thing with this game is it's really meant to be like a lot faster. It is a lot faster. It's not just meant to be. It succeeds in that. It's a lot quicker game than either of those games. And so, it doesn't hurt as much when you're racing for those stars. Someone blocks it, you got to go for something else. But I really like the catch-up mechanic of those Mel Lot cards. I really like that because the nice thing is if someone gets one star ahead of you, you're going to get two bonus things cuz you're going to put down one one card. You decide which way it faces. You're going to get all the bonuses that point at you. If they got another star ahead of you, you're going to add another one to that whole row. You're going to get three things. But if you got the next star, they're going to put a card on top of that. And so, you're going to kind of lose what you would get the next time.

You're going to be back to two things when it's so clever as a catch-up mechanism and it really does work well here to balance it out.

Another key difference is the map is quite a bit smaller than either of the games. And so, you're are going to be running into each other a lot more because this is specifically meant to do that where because you're only two players, you need fewer spaces. And as a result, you're really competing to be the first to get those map tokens, the first to get to all of the different spots.

Yeah, yeah, no, you really do run into each other. And it's interesting cuz as the Expeditions player, you're not flipping over any new tiles. You can see where everything is right at the start of the game. There are two sides to that map, which is really cool. So, you can change the layout of where things are. But still, you can see where everything is.

Yeah, and I think the map is really well designed because the Scythe player is restricted for being able to leave because they have the river and the lakes in the way, whereas the Expeditions player doesn't have that restriction and can move up to three spaces. But like you mentioned in the like how to play, they can't initiate combat unless they do a vanquish. So, I think that's a nice balance.

Yeah, it is because in Expeditions, you need four stars. In Scythe, in base game Scythe, you need six stars. I hope I'm right about that. But so, you'd think, oh, this is going to be a little bit harder for the Expeditions player. But they do quite a few things that helps them catch up a bit. They get the first turn every time, which does help a bit. And like you said, they can get further around the map, which is quite an advantage early on as well. But we found that it's pretty 50/50. Like we've played this a bunch already, and I think it's been almost exactly 50/50 when we play with these two factions.

Yeah, absolutely. And I think what's neat is some of the tokens and things, well, specifically like the map tokens that you're collecting are slightly differently used depending on which faction you are. Because if you're the Scythe player, you're you just get the token as you normally would, and you get to do an explore card. Whereas if you're the Expeditions player, all of them have a different bonus on the back. So, I like that even those have been like incorporated, but slightly differently.

The other thing that is new in this game as well is the combat cards because those also have to work for both players. And I really like these, because they do a few different things. One, they just work like combat cards, exactly the same as Scythe. And everything we're doing here, we are really assuming that you know Scythe and Expeditions. We're not really going to dive into those games. We have videos about that, but just to get that Well, I should have got that out of the way, but to get it out of the way now. But, these combat cards, you can discard to get a bonus that's at the top of those cards, and they also have an ability when you play them, which is great, because some of the weaker cards have strong abilities. I think some of the three cards let you add another card to whatever you're doing. And then some of the stronger cards, the seven for example, doesn't let you put down a star even if you win. So, you can use that to defend, but it's not actually going to help you to get that star. And so, I I I like that a lot. I like these cards a lot in this game. And because there are two sides to that uh to the achievement board, you can just have one combat if you want, or you can flip that over and have two combats, have combat be an even bigger part of the game.

Yeah, it's really good that there are those two sides to that board, cuz there are quite a few differences between the achievements that you can get. So, for example, one where it has two combats, you as an Expeditions player, you can't get a star for like your fist, which I think makes sense, because you're going to be spending those fists for combat, but you can get a star for like the brains. I'm using probably the wrong term there, uh which is interesting, because on the other side, you there's you're not rewarded as much for getting those.

Yeah, you Well, on the other side, you're really going to be using brains to vanquish. Vanquish is going to be on both sides of it, but it also works the same for the melding, I think it's called the meteorites, because those get you money in the game. So, on one side, it's how many of those have you melted? On the other side, it's getting money. And you can obviously get money in other ways as well. So, this is it's it's a really interesting weird game. I don't know of another game that does this that mushes two games together. I don't think there is another game that does this.

And I think another thing I was also surprised about is I expected that we would very much be doing our own thing, which is is what it feels like, but because of the competition for the stars, because [clears throat] of the tighter map, because of the combat that can happen, there was more interaction or awareness, I think, of what the other player was doing than I expected.

Yeah, I was definitely looking at what what are you gunning for? Like, oh, she set up three people on a people space. She's obviously going to be doing a production and getting three more people. Maybe I don't Or or maybe I rush the people and block that star or maybe I decide to go for money instead and do that. So, that is a big part of the interaction and I think that really does work because there can only be one star on each thing, which I think is really really smart. But, let's go into the the how this works as a two-player game of each game cuz I think that part's really interesting, too.

So, the one I think is the most interesting of the two is Scythe because, and I said this earlier, that Scythe has that giant board. And when you're playing as two players, it can be a while till you run into each other. Sometimes it can be a little bit quicker, but often you really it just becomes a resource management race and and that's fine. But, here it's super super tight. As soon as you get across that river, you're in each other's faces. The second that you cross that river. And so, that makes this I think a lot more interesting. And really this to me is the two-player version of Scythe.

Yeah, it is and it feels also quicker. Well, it is quicker. I think it's quite a bit quicker because those achievements as well, you only need four instead of six, but some of them are significantly easier to achieve. Like I think you're only putting out three of your houses or buildings instead of four, for example. So, the pace is so fast, you really feel like you absolutely have to focus on which ones you're getting and block your opponent because it just go gets to the end so quickly.

Yeah, I love that we can play a half-hour game of Scythe, but it still does feel like we are playing a game of Scythe. And I I do like those new combat cards as well. And when you play Scythe versus Scythe as well, you just you take that the exact same board that you would use in Scythe versus Expeditions, but you're just going to turn it so it faces just the Scythe way. Again, you can still use either side as well, which gives some interesting ones cuz there's one of the goals that I like that is just control seven of the places, which is harder than you think, but can it it can really push you to quickly build out fast and get people all over the place. And I like that part of it, too. So, it makes you play it a little bit different and it makes it a lot more interactive.

And you can add elements from Scythe, such as the exploration cards and the factory cards and factions. And in fact, in order to play Scythe versus Scythe, you have to add another faction because this game only comes with one, but you can experiment with the factions in a two-player game.

Yeah, you can. And some of them are a little bit surprising as well as those boards as well. So, it just gives you other ways to mix and match all that stuff. But another thing you can do to mix and match that stuff is this tournament. So, they give you they just give you one sheet that's got all these different size. And I love a tournament. And I think there's a way that you can print these off or whatever, so you can do all different tournament or you can just make your own bracket as well. But that can also be a thing that you do with the Scythe versus Scythe, Scythe versus Expeditions, Expeditions versus Expeditions, and all that stuff mixed together. But, let's talk about Expeditions versus Expeditions. [clears throat]

So, like the Scythe versus Scythe, Expeditions versus Expeditions again is going to take Expeditions, [clears throat] smoosh it down to this smaller board. That one, I feel like Expeditions does work a little bit better as a two-player game already, but this makes it a much quicker two-player game, and I really appreciate that.

Yeah, and there are a few changes because you don't have any tiles that are like upside down that stop your movement. So, you are able to go more across the board in different ways. But, as a result, you're also going to be more likely probably to block each other, too. And I the map tokens still go out, so you still get that bonus from being able to get there first and getting that that token.

Yeah, you do. But, yes, you you can move further, but also the board is way way smaller, and there are also fewer cards to choose from. You only ever are going to have two cards that are out there you're choosing from. But, then the other thing is that generally you're trying to do three of any of those uh the different things that you're talking instead of doing four, and all of those goals are just a little bit quicker to reach, which just makes it a little bit of a quicker tighter game, and a game that I really appreciate. I'll be honest, I was a little on the fence with Expeditions. I liked it, but I really like this way of playing Expeditions.

And you can add elements from Expeditions, such as the discovery cards, and all of the the leaders and their companions and the mechs.

Yeah, and I I I think this is maybe even almost more interesting than Scythe just in that way and how those all mishmash together because those mechs are so different and the leader slash pets are so different and I really like the leader pet combos. And this works a little bit like the Expeditions expansion. So you've got a card that is going to give you bonus things, also give you all of the starting resources for Expeditions and you've also got like the double layer board. So I like that. So if you've got the expansion stuff, this is all going to fit perfectly with that stuff.

And speaking of expansions, you can also use most of the elements in this game as expansions in the other games. And so you've got a new leader and a new board for Scythe, a new leader and companion and mech board for Expeditions.

And while those are kind of tooled for this game, they definitely are made to work specifically in this game. They do totally work in the base games. And I'll be interested We haven't tried them in the base games yet, but they will. They will definitely work. And I'm interested to see how well they work. But the Scythe leader specifically has kind of an interesting power.

Yeah, so it lets you be able to discard a star to be able to get any resource. And then later you can spend a resource to get that star back, which can be quite handy. And the other thing that's interesting is being able to use the new combat cards.

Yeah, so obviously you're going to be using those in Scythe. And those do change the game quite a bit. As we already talked about, you've got a power when you play those. You've also got something when you discard them. You can use all of that in the base game for Scythe. But I will say that the other cards aren't going to make so much of an impact. So you've got a few new factory cards. You could mix those in. I don't think you necessarily need to. You also have a few new exploration cards. Again, I don't think you necessarily need to, especially because we use the alternate deck all the time for Scythe and I honestly just still think that that's better. And then you do also have a bunch of new cards for Expeditions. You could mix those in, but I kind of like having them separate just so I've got cards for this game, I got cards for that game. You don't You've got enough for both games, and I don't think there's a big need to mix those either. You could if you wanted, you don't need to.

So, who do we think this is for? I think one of the main audiences is for people who already own both Scythe and Expeditions, and they know how to play both of those games, and they have all of the different stuff for those games, and they'd be interested in using the all that stuff in a new way.

Yeah, I think that's going to be a huge audience of folks for this who both want to take this and use that in the in in those two different games, but also be able to bring everything, have those tournaments, smoosh those characters against each other, use this in all those different ways. And in a lot of ways this feels a little bit like Unmatched when Unmatched added the co-op mode, and I felt like amazing. I've got this giant toy box of things, and now I can play with them in a new way. This feels a bit like that.

Yeah, it is a really different way to play. And so, I think another audience are people who tend to play these games at two players, and having a specific two-player version. And I think both of them do work well on their own as two-player games, but I think this works even better.

Yeah, I would argue I don't know that Scythe Scythe definitely is not at its best at two. There's no way that anyone's going to argue that. It works okay for some people at two who don't like fighting. This is an infinitely better way to play Scythe at two. The restriction of that, obviously, is this is only for people who want to play this at one or two players. We didn't talk about the solo mode. It's by

Automa Factory.

Automa Factory and they did both these other ones and I have full faith that it's excellent because I've always liked the stuff that they do. So, I feel like this is going to be fine solo, too, but primarily you're going to be using this to play it too. So, if you only play those games at four and five, that's all you want to ever do, then this this isn't this is just going to be a two-player game.

Yeah, and I can also potentially see this being a game of people who've been interested in either of the other games, but haven't tried playing it and thought, well, maybe I can try this, get a sense how each of them play, and see if like the bigger games are fit for me.

Yeah, yeah, I I could definitely see this because it's going to have obviously a much lower price tag, especially than buying both of those big boys together. So, this is, you know, a little bit of a of a taster that you you can do as well, and then you know if I like both of those or if I like one or the other of those, I've got something I can add to those as well. As an expansion, it adds a little bit. I do like having the the cards for Scythe, but I don't know that I would necessarily say this is like just for the expansion for the other two games. I think it's nice. I'm glad we have it. I'm glad it has that other stuff, but I think really where this is going to shine is those those different two-player versions of the games and that smooshed together, which is more interesting than I expected. And that is it. I think you can tell that we really like this game. I am quite a fan of this game. Are there other two-player adaptations of games out there that you would recommend? Or even more, are there other games that just kind of mix up games in interesting ways like this?

Because I don't know if I know of another game that feels quite like this.

Yeah, so if you know of any, please put them in the comments. And as usual, thank you so much for watching. Please like, subscribe, and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game.

Progress saved