Murder on the Moon Review: Being On The Moon Can Be Exciting, But Also Frustrating
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we're bard of it and today we're going to be reviewing murder on the moon which is a oneshot mystery escape room type game in the similar style of kind of like exit games it's set across three acts so you can choose to play it all in one session or split it across the three it has a recommended age of 12 and over and just to note we were very kindly sent this by the publisher for review yep so this is kind of your classic Escape Game you've got three episodes you play through an order uh you're going to be doing a lot of little puzzles um and in this one it's very uh interactive so the setting is that there's a moon base uh funded by a startup and and there's um been a murder and you're kind of a detective So you you're basically not there but you're looking for all the information that uh the commander of the mission provides to help solve that murder and then it kind of progresses from there and what's quite interesting about it is that it's kind of um app driven you could say but you don't need an app it's just a website link uh but basically where it's almost set up like a live chat with the commander and this is where you can ask for hints or you input your answers or sometimes you'll get voice recordings or videos things like that um so it's quite
immersive actually and the story is kind of running very tightly through the puzzles and everything you're doing uh yeah and obviously it's it's a one shot but you're not destroying anything so you could also pass it on y once you've completed it so turning to what we thought about it uh overall I think we had a good time with this uh it was a very nice Escape game box yeah uh I think on the whole what we' want to praise the most is the the variety of the puzzles that we were doing and kind of um how well done they were for the most part uh it was always something new um moment to moment yeah I think as well the narrative and the story of it was very well done I was very engaged the entire time and really wanted to kind of solve the murder but there was little elements of the story along the way whereby you were kind of always kept with something fresh in a way it wasn't just there was always kind of like yeah different things to solve which like you said really tied in very well with the narrative so there's the kind of puzzle escape room part but the story itself is also very interesting so they merge together very very nicely to create a really fun experience yeah there was also a lot of kind of light touch humor injected into kind of the materials you get and some of the the the way or the story and really appreciated that it
landed almost all the time and I was actually very impressed by yeah kind of how comedic they made it at time so it definitely added a nice element to it I always appreciate that I also thought that in general the puzzles had quite a nice level of challenge um for the most part they were kind of very solvable but challenging at the same time so kind of had a lot of fun figuring out what we had to do and then going through it yeah and a kind of last highlight you could say was the interactivity with the kind of web app if you will um like I said in the beginning is very immersive and it's quite um fun to kind of like be part of that and be like yeah novel it'd be like a live chat then at some points in the latrax you're even kind of doing little puzzles you could say on that as well and they use that as kind of a way to shake things up as well yeah um so that was um another highlight as well yeah I think with the puzzles and kind of challenge level they weren't like incredibly difficult that they weren't on the most part like solvable and if you did get it wrong there was one part that we got a little bit wrong but we were able to kind of see that later on and then Rectify it so it's not like again like you said you don't rip anything up or anything like that so if you get something wrong you can kind of just walk back and um change it in a way so I thought that's quite nice if it's not yeah uh you completely mess it up if
you do something wrong yeah so then kind of turning away from what was good we did have a couple of nitpicks you could say I think the we said most of the puzzles were kind of good and challenging but there are definitely some acts that and some puzzles that are much worse is a bad term kind of thing that's but definitely I think act three in particular it starts out with a puzzle and it was I mean it's always going to be personal opinion I think but it was a bit like we we all we kind of knew exactly what we had to do but kind of um there it was a bit too removed that even though we knew what we were trying to do I think it was a bit like little bit nonsensical the what you had to get to yeah and you know it's not impossible but it just it just was very strange that there hadd been a level and then suddenly like you're hit in the face and then some of the puzzles after that in act 3 were like nothing basically so then it felt a bit like weird in terms of balancing um I think you also had had an issue with having to go out of the game yeah there was something which you just might not know and I would say the vast majority of people might not know a clue so essentially you kind of had to go on Google to research resarch something let's say so I thought up analogy for this obviously we can't
do spoilers So It's tricky to talk about in detail essentially it would be like you have a photo and they have a picture uh of a car framed on their desk and there's like a poster that says I love Aston Martin and you would have to like go on the internet and find the exact year maker model of that car to answer the question yeah and it's not something I mean granted we could have potentially missed it I don't think we did cuz I don't know where that would be in the material we were given but um you basically had to do that so you had to go like you say on the internet some quite Niche knowledge I would say yeah and yeah I just didn't like the feeling of having to research something that wasn't in the game like the clue was there like you said but we did have to go out and kind of Google it and then like you said it's so IM iive and then that takes you out of it and there's no indication that you do need to Google right so you could spend a lot of time we were spending a lot of time looking through everything to see if there was a clue to solve it and eventually said I think we're just going to have to go on Google and that's wasn't clear that you might have to go out the game yeah so maybe if it was clear at somewhere oh maybe you have to like research something by yourself then that's one thing but you just I think you wouldn't expect to have to do that because it was the only time as well which is even weirder it's one and this was another small small issue but there's on rare occasion you had to
go back and use old information and I don't necessarily have a problem with when you know mystery games or escape games do this but I think it needs to be clear that it's being done all the time or that it needs to be done because sometimes if the piece you're missing is something from box one and it's not clear that that hasn't been established you do that yeah it can be a little bit frustrating and that happened like once or twice um not to any degree that I would really complain about it but I just think it could be a bit smoother yeah agree yeah and then I think there was also we came across some like minor little errors like uh I saw some spelling errors in the app and there was one puzzle where again it could just be us but we knew what we were doing but but the way they had like written the instructions I would spend like 10 minutes after going through it and I just couldn't reconcile what they were saying or the way they were saying it with the answer they got to we basically got like we knew what the answer was it was fine we knew how to do the puzzle but just the way they phrased it didn't seem correct to me yeah and I just couldn't like get it knowing the answer kind of thing based on their calculations so there's some minor things like that and um and then there's also some idiosyncrasies like in the First Act there's kind of voice acted statements and then in the second act it
just goes to text even though it's the same characters yeah so it's almost like a drop in production um and then I think we've already talked about act three being our least favorite and I think one big part of that is that up till now the the kind of app web app had always been just a live where you kind of input the answers and then had a video that you showed every to everyone or something where in act three suddenly like I said before it's where you started doing puzzles and it became almost the Keystone to the entire act but yeah it doesn't necessarily warn you that that's the case because you could get it up on a laptop but it doesn't really tell you to because you start always with like a QR code so you'd have to inut it manually yeah informational or instruction um when you have to refer to your phone it was on your phone and to be honest I think it was the combination and again it's personal experience maybe um and obviously with these sorts of games usually when we review a game we're playing it at least five times depending on the game but this of course you can only play once and have that one experience so it's a bit tricky but in act three there was the kind of ambiguous language of the puzzle which you were trying to really figure out plus the fact that then the puzzle was being done on your phone it was like very centered on like you and the other three of us to be honest we got like pretty bored because we had absolutely nothing to do like you said maybe we
could have got it up on a laptop but even then but we just like didn't there nothing else to do know it was going to go that way and then there was also for example um a mini game or mini game puzzle that came up and it was like a very simplistic puzzle for anyone who's played video games in the last 20 years right and and the thing is like again like you say I could have got that up on a laptop but it doesn't need four people's input it was a one person like half-minded job MH and it just suddenly changed the concept that yeah it was like so Central I'm like well I can't really share anything for you because it I was the point yeah I mean I can do it in the time it takes to and that kind of um and that was kind of M with the fact that what we would say about this it says uh one to four players and we had kind of 3.5 yeah and I have to say that at times there was not anything to do for the third player no some of the puzzles just the way they are they just need one person to like look at it and the other person to confirm or translate or whatever yeah and it that you just there's not anything more for people to do and then in some acts where you have a lot of puzzles people can do different puzzles but then some people are missing out on the game play so highly highly would recommend this to only play as like a couple two people maybe three that's okay if you know each other well you can get around that but I just think
that it's really best at two players and I wouldn't play it with a full four people because you would struggle to get everyone involved delegating at some point to the 0. five player um oh can you just look through this and find that thing that I already knew was there and that was it just for something to do but they weren't it wasn't solving anything right so it's um that .5 player didn't mind doing that but obviously if you have players who really want to get involved in the puzzles then yeah that's obviously not super fulfilling yeah so I think we did just say you know some negative things about it but I think overall it's a good uh it was a good experience we really enjoyed it like we said the story the puzzles the variety uh enjoyed it in the moment there's just some frustrations and I think it's an uneven experience yeah um but they do I guess you can always say that they throw a lot at the wall and only some of it's sticking and maybe that's just what happens with the variety maybe different people find different puzzles better or worse than we did y so that's just something to consider but the one issue uh I think that we come to is the the list price for this on the Publishers website I would never pay it for what this was I think in part because it's a one-time play um the second part is components you do get uh you know board and um the
kind of app web app integration but it's I you could buy a standard board game and a half for that same price and play that thing for the next 20 years right and obviously as a board game reviewer that's what we're going to come back to I think it particularly doesn't help that it's so uneven yeah um and that we had some issues it wasn't all roses uh and and it's not something that we would recommend to play with a big group right only two people we' have safe to play with not something we'd recommend you know where you could all chip in as a big group because then you're diminishing The Experience so there's also that consideration with regards to the price I think yeah so essentially it leaves us in you know a kind of you could say bad position because I I wouldn't recommend it for the prices uh which is kind of you know sad to say but it is uh and the issue is just that it's a one shot game and particularly because there are many great detective kind of more board game type things or which are cheaper like Sherlock Homes Consulting detective the perspective series um or even you know probably like the the Escape rooms exit rooms sorry yeah which not so story driven like this I mean this does have a lot going for it but they will see much cheaper for a similar experience so I think if you're interested in it if it's your thing to do these kind of things I do recommend it there's a lot here to like there's a lot that's interesting it's got a great story but just know that I think it's
very overpriced for what you get the kind of component quality the quality of the production uh yeah anything final Tad agree well that was our review of of murder on the moon and if this was helpful please consider subscribing if you're not already it' be really helpful and with that we would like to say goodbye but just know you can ask us any questions see you byebye