Skip to main content
Loading video...

Papyria Board Game Review

Transcript 17:52

Join us on today's video as we travel back to 1500 BC to the region of Mesopotamia on the banks of the Tigris and Euphrates. We'll explore the extensive network of canals, discover inventions, develop mines, and build temples, sanctuaries, and cities in Papyra. Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Dub

and I'm Kevin Dup. Papyra is a rondelle action selection game that also has tile laying and resource management. It's for one to four players and takes about 2 hours to play. It's designed by Burned Eisenstein and published by Iron Games and I believe it will be available at Essen Gamefare this year. Now, the publisher sent us this review copy.

In this video, we're going to give a quick overview of the game and then discuss our opinions.

During the game, your turn consists of moving one of your ships or one of your wanderers along the paths. You'll perform two main actions wherever that piece lands. The wanderer activates both actions on the outer path. The ship activates the action on the inner path and then you can choose one of the two actions on the outer path.

These actions will allow you to collect landscape tiles to add to your personal landscape to take scoring multiplier tokens that you add to your base or to build a structure like a temple, city, or mine.

Another type of action is production either for lapis or papyrus. Both of those resources are integral to gameplay. There are also scoring tiles that you can pick up for an action. And these tiles give you knowledge and an immediate scoring opportunity.

Knowledge is key in this game. Your knowledge level determines how many points you can gain when you score a tile.

So, if my current score is 10, and I could earn 20 points from a tile, but I only have five knowledge, I will only gain five points to add to those 10 points I already have. As you deplete action tiles, you replace them with end of the game tiles. Once the stack of end of game tiles is exhausted, the game end is triggered. You'll finish the current round and then score endame points.

Now, that was a quick overview, and we are separating the review portion into our four C's, our thoughts about the components, our critiques, our commendations, and finally, our conclusions. Let's start with the components. So, when you open the box, you'll notice a lot and lot of pieces

that you have to punch out and punch out kind of set up.

Yeah, there's no organizer in the box. Um, but you can put everything in the box. Um, but there's just quite a bit and it was like the box is kind of heavy from all the stuff that's in the box.

So, one of the things that is interesting, the game board is three different pieces. So, they kind of puzzle piece together.

And they have cutouts for the different tiles that you'll be placing down. Also, the paths where your wanderers and ships move, there's an actual space for you to put the the mele piece in. So, that's really nice. We did notice that when we played at our house, we have a nice game mat and the board laid really well on that. We played again at someone else's house just on their dining room table and we had some trouble keeping the board flat.

Well, even though some of the pieces got like stuck underneath, right,

of the game board.

So, it and their table did have some like ridges and things in it. So,

but so played on game mat.

Game mat really good for the board laying flat.

There are some like overview pieces. Um it's kind of interesting. I would say in most games if you had these pieces in there it'd be

so so they're kind of like player aids.

Yeah, they're players. These would just be like um not cardboard, they'd just be some sort of like nice paper or something like that. It's very interesting that they're like thick cardboard, but it's they're nice.

Yeah, it they're helpful for understanding the scoring. Uh, I also do like that one of them gives the setup instructions because you do need to put out a different number of pieces based on player count and it is all listed right here on this board. So, you don't have to keep flipping through the rule book to find out that information.

Like we said, there are a lot of things in the box. Um, most of it's cardboard, but there are some wooden pieces. Uh, you have like the structures, those are fine. They have different designs for the different shapes for the uh temples and things like that. And then the resources um well, one of the resources is wooden.

Both.

Oh, yeah. The papyrus is wooden, too.

And the lapis.

Yeah. So, those two are like sort of the main resources in the game, and they're both wooden. And then your player pieces, the the people, the ships and the wanderers that you're

Yeah. And the tokens that you're using for scoring, those are also wooden.

Yep. Yep. So, yeah. I think. Oh, one other thing I did find interesting is usually in a score track, um, you're, you know, crossing 50. This one has a a 50 spot. You basically have, uh, the little gray pieces that sort of keep track of every 50. I found that interesting.

Oh, right. It's wooden um kind of like shields and you collect the shields to show each 50 point that you have instead of having,

you know, something that you place a token on.

Yeah, that was interesting. It threw me off. What are these gray pieces?

How How do I How do I show that I have more points? Oh, that's what those are.

All right, let's move on to our critiques. So, my main critique probably has to do with setup. Setup is a beast for this game.

All those pieces that we talked about.

Yeah. Yeah. uh they you're you're doing a lot of like stacking and then you're putting those stacks in the different spots on the main board and and then the player pieces and then just all the things that are going around the board. I I I just found that that was a little detracting for me getting into the game.

Yeah, it's not a oh five minutes we're up and ready playing it. it's going to be a while to even with multiple people helping to get everything set up and make sure that you're using the right amount for your player count as well.

So, yeah, I definitely agree on that one with the the setup. Um, another thing that is a minor critique and and this will go away the more you play it, but I do think your first game or two, it can be a little overwhelming. Not what you're doing on your turn, cuz that's pretty simple. Move a piece and do the actions, but the scoring because each thing scores in a different way. And you do have the overview boards that kind of walk you through that. So, you're playing the game and you're like, "Yes, I've got this scoring down. I know what I'm doing." At the end of the game, there's more scoring. And while it's similar to the scoring you do during the game,

it's different.

Yep. So there's certain things that whoever has the most of this will score their trees. So

yeah,

it's not only knowing, oh, how do I score trees, but at the end of the game, if I do this other thing, I'll get to score this again. So the complexity of that, I think, can take some people by surprise their first game or two trying to balance how everything scores.

My uh next critique is a small critique. uh you are laying tiles um in front of you if your own sort of like city that you're building, you are sort of restricted by where your priest is.

And especially in a like a

So you are restricted. You can only build next to a tile. That's where your priest is. You're restricted by where your priest is. And then with a higher player count, it's harder to move your priest because there are ways when your ship and your wanderer get together, you can move your priest any anywhere, which is sort of very helpful to then place tiles where you want to. But in a fourplayer game, you only have one ship and one wanderer. And sometimes you could be blocked. I mean, it's you can get unblocked, but it's just a little bit more difficult to move your priest in a higher player count game,

right? Because in lower player counts, you may have two wanderers in a ship or two ships or multiple things to try to line them up.

And in this tile laying game, you want tiles in a certain spot, you want things together or you don't want things together,

right? The where you place the tiles will impact your scoring potentially majorly. So yeah, that that is its own little puzzle of trying to figure out

sort of enjoy it but wish it wasn't as restrictive.

Okay. Um, with all those choices that you have going on, I I think the game, okay, the game can produce a little bit of AP analysis paralysis because not only are you trying to figure out, oh, what two actions do I want to do? Can I get to them with my wanderer or my ship?

Then there's the aspect of the tile laying and where my Oh, that's a great tile. I want to take that. Oh, my priest isn't in the right spot, so I don't want to go there.

Or I'm gonna score a certain thing. How do I get that?

Yeah. And there is there are ways to mitigate what's going on where you can move. So, that's great to give you more options, but it gives you more options to consider because you can uh potentially move farther or take places where other people are. So there's a lot to process to make good decisions and some of us don't process that information as quickly

as some other people or someone else

does something that then alters what you were planning to do taking a tile you want to get.

Right. I was going to say a simple um example of that is you sort of build up a scoring option cuz you see that scoring tile that you want to get and then someone else takes that scoring tile and you're sort of like oh I can't score that now right now maybe then maybe later in the game but that's sort of what I was planning on doing. So now what am I going to do?

So reassessing the turn after someone else's. Um so ju just be aware of that if you play with people who take a little longer to process options. This game has a lot of options. Let's move on to our accommodations. All right. Right off the bat, the simplicity of gameplay really drew me into the game after we set up. After I set up, man, it was so easy to explain, so easy to explain to people. It's easy to understand. Really, on your turn, you're moving one of your pieces, either the ship or your wonder, and then you're going to take two actions. Um, with your ship, it's that they're basically have a specific types of actions that you're doing with your ship or your wonder. So that's why you maybe want to move your wonder or your ship. But I like how simple it is. Just move your piece, take the two actions, and your turn's over. So sometimes your turn can be pretty quick depending on what those two actions are. And sometimes it may take a little longer.

It's like, which piece do I want to move? So there's a lot of strategy involved in that, but I love the simplicity of gameplay and it's easy to explain to people, which I always appreciate.

Yeah. And with that simplicity I think comes because of the rondelle aspect of the game because you know you have to move along this path

in the same direction. So only certain options are available to you

on your turn.

Normally your wanderer can move

two spaces. Now he can jump over other people or you can even pay people to take their space. So there's a little bit of interaction with the other players. um sort of indirect interaction. Your ship can move or maybe it's your wanderer moves one.

Yeah, I think your wanderer moves one and your ship moves two. That's fine.

Something like that. You can even get tiles that increase your movement.

But when it comes down to it,

you only have a certain aspect of the board that is pertinent for your next turn. You can look ahead and see what's coming. So, you can plan and hope other people don't take that. But I do like the rondelle aspect of the game because I was talking about so many choices earlier. At least it does uh limit the specific choices for each turn.

Yep. Now, the other thing I appreciate about the game is sort of like goals. I appreciate things to work toward. There are these key tiles that tell you once you get nine rivers or once you get certain number of things in the game, then you're going to basically score that key tile and gain that tile into your your little player thing. I forget what that's called. But I appreciate there are things that you can work towards and it's better if you can get the if you get there first,

right?

Cuz I think they might all be the same. Uh like I think you all need nine like exam all nervous but the benefit of like the multiplier it's just a little different um as you go down the number of tiles

and as you're looking like oh Kevin has oh he's going to get the river tile oh can I get enough of the other thing to get that tile first. So yeah kind of racing towards those scoring opportunities. Uh another thing that I think works really well in this game is the knowledge

track. So cool. So it it doesn't limit your total score. It just limits what you can score in one chunk.

Yep.

Now you can get with your ship these multiplier tokens. So say I am getting ready to score my mines. So connected mines and mountains and those sort of things. Um but I have a mult like three multipliers on that. I could get a pretty big score and later in the game you could get scores of like 40 50 points for one thing,

but if your knowledge isn't up, you're not going to like dump those 40 or 50 points at the beginning of the game. So,

you're not going to have someone

usually run away with high scores at the beginning of the game because you have to build up to those. And that plays into the strategy of when do I want to score something? Oh, I I have enough to score 30 points.

Maybe I'll wait.

But my knowledge is only at 10. Is it a waste to try to score that right now?

It's true. Yep. I I really like how that works. So there's a little catch the leader in the hopefully in the sense that everyone's sort of working to get that knowledge up. Um so sort of restricts people in a good way. I like it. So all right, why don't we move on to our conclusions? Well, I have to say I'm kind of a sucker for these types of games. I don't know if why the theme draws me in. Like it's like this uh rivers and collecting resources, but it sort of hits all the buttons that I like. So the theme and I think the game play really marries well for what I appreciate in games. And I think I like it mainly the maybe two or three player, four player, it was a little longer for what I wanted maybe game length and then just getting it back to my turn.

Right. and and you have fewer pieces to move at four players than you do at the lower player count. So, you have a little bit more

um

variety on your turn. More options.

Yeah, a little more options. I like that.

More options, which can be good or bad if you're trying to calculate everything. Uh I also really enjoyed this game. I wasn't sure what it was going to be like going into it, just looking at the pieces and reading through the rules and trying to figure out how the scoring would actually work with the mechanics. But I've really enjoyed my place of it, trying to think through the optimization and efficiency of what resources to collect, the timing aspect of when to score and what things to um go after. I do think that there's going to be a lot of variability based on setup because you're putting those action tiles out randomly and you may have similar actions near each other or they may be on opposite sides of the river the board. So, it's going to have a slightly different feel each time based on where you need to go to get the things that you're trying to build. and tiling aspect. I like tiling games, so having that as part of the game,

I I enjoyed collecting the landscape tiles and working out that part of it. So, I really enjoyed Papyr. I would put it in the medium weight. I think the

the scoring aspect and the number of choices ups the complexity a little bit more than

it just you know what you're

think it's a heavy game when you're setting it up but it's not. So yeah I would put a medium weight maybe a little bit touch higher than medium weight. So yeah totally agree with that. Do you like rondell games? Let us know in the comments what your favorite rondelle type game is. We'd love to hear from you and thank you so much for watching this video. Check out more videos coming soon from Tantrum

Progress saved