Skip to main content
Loading video...

Skyward Republic Review - Grounded

Transcript 15:13

Hey everybody, Zee Garcia here. Today I'm taking a look at Skyward Republic. This is a follow-up to a game simply called Skyward that came out some time ago, which was a drafting city in the sky building game. This is the same theme. The drafting's been changed up a little bit to what I believe is address the two-player plus way of playing. With two players, it was a nice split you choose game, which you you know, it's it's very interesting. With more than two, you had to make a bunch of different piles, and it really slowed down the game. That was my big issue with that original game, Skyward. So, they've gone back to the drawing board. Have they fixed that that feeling with more than two players? Well, let's go ahead and take a look at how the game works. We'll come on back. I'll tell you what I think of it. The game's going to be played over several rounds, about eight rounds, and each of those rounds is broken down into three different phases. We're going to have the draft phase, the launch phase, and then the benefactor phase. So, starting from the top, the draft phase, we are going to be revealing on the table stacks of two cards equal to the number of players. In this case, we have one, two, three players. So, we're going to do this, like so.

Then, we are going to put on the table near the players stacks of face down cards of two cards again equal to the number of players. So, for example, we would do something like this. My two cards, their two cards, and the other player's two cards, like so. On your turn, and now I'll go ahead and start over here. This is also just going to go in the middle of the table somewhere, the warden token, and we'll put one gear on that token. I'm going to decide between picking or revealing taking one of these stacks of tiles of cards, basically, or revealing a card from the stack in front of me, adding it to one of these, and passing my turn, not taking yet, enriching these cards, but also giving up maybe something I really, really want to somebody else. So, let's say I'm first, I'm going to go ahead and reveal. I'm going to flip this card over, I'm going to add it to that stack right there. It is that opponent's go. They are also going to do that. They'll reveal a card.

They're going to add it to this stack right here. Then it is that player's turn. They're also going to do that. Like so. And they get to see it, by the way. It's not a random flip. They could look and then decide where it goes. Comes back to me. Maybe I really am liking that stack there. So, I'm going to take this time instead of of revealing a card and basically passing. I'm going to take these. Anything that has the lightning bolt is going to immediately be deployed in front of me. Now, everyone's area is going to be eight cards. You have four across, [snorts] and then two above each other. So, four, four, but then above that is the sky, which has an unlimited number of spaces, and the airship here, as well as some critters, are going to go in that row at the very top. So, this this goes out immediately.

It doesn't happen to have any text or anything. It just has the lightning, and it shows me three victory points right here. So, I would immediately score three victory points, one, two, three. These are going to go in my hand. If I had any cards face down in that pile that's near me, I have to now reveal the rest of them one at a time and add them to these stacks out here. So, I'm going to reveal that, it's going to go there, and I'm done. I'm out. It goes to that player. That player is going to reveal their card, and they are going to add it there. Then that player is going to go. They're going to take this stack. They have one card that immediately goes out. It has a an ability that says, "When you acquire this ibis, put one of the top three cards of the discard pile into your hand." All All fine. So, they'll take this, it goes in front of them.

They'll look at the top three cards of the discard pile and they'll take one, put that in their hand, and then they have to reveal this last one, which goes here, obviously, cuz it's the only pile left. And then, lastly, this player would take uh they're going to take this. And they also get this because it's the they're the last player to take anything. So, they get this, they get the gear. There's no lightning bolts, so they're good. That's phase one. It's this sort of slightly convoluted drafting phase. Then we go to phase two, which is the launch phase. During the launch phase, starting from whoever has the warden token, they may launch one um building and they may play any extensions as well. So, these all three of these are buildings, they'll say so right there, building, building, building right there, and then this one says extension, that goes attached to a building, okay?

And so, the costs are up here. They have to pay with cards that can pay those costs or the gears, which are wild. They can also discard three cards from hand to gain a gear. You are going to have a hard hand limit, uh I believe it's seven, so you want to be careful about that. But basically, you can only deploy one building unless the abilities on it say otherwise. And these are going to have immediate effects when you launch them, which is what this is called, or a little flag, which means end-game scoring. With that player having done that, then we go to this player who can do the same thing. Then we go to this player who can do the same thing. And then, we go to the third phase, the benefactor phase, starting again from whoever has the warden token, you can um take one of your little airship tokens here and play them on one of these benefactor cards if you qualify for it. So, for example, this card right here has three green uh symbols. If you have that among the things you have launched, this player is very close now, then you can put your airship there. If you're the first one, you get three victory points, which you'll track immediately, and then it might have a special ability you need to contend with. So, you'll do that. Anybody else can can still do it for the ability, but it won't have the victory points.

Everyone also began I flashed this card earlier. Everyone begins with one secret benefactor card, and you can also choose to reveal this one and complete it immediately. Uh but you are making it available to everyone else at that point. But of course, you you have first shot cuz you're the only one who sees the card. So, that's how that's going to work out. And we can all do one of these uh benefactor uh applications, right? Get some victory points or get the special abilities. With all of that done, then we are going to go to the next round, and the next round then would be putting out stacks of two cards face up, stacks of two cards face down. The benefactor, I'm sorry, the warden token here goes back in the middle with a gear. Whoever is the last one to take is going to get that. And we'll just do that a few different times. You always have to make sure you are scoring victory points for any buildings you launched, any critters that you put out. So, this player would have actually lost two victory points when they put out the ibis. This player, if they launched that, they would have gotten one victory point. You'll be tracking that up and down the entire game, okay?

Uh but that's basically what's going on. At the end of the game, uh which is when somebody has launched eight or more buildings, you are going to figure out any final scoring, and whoever has the most victory points is going to be the winner of the game. This is a game I had very high expectations for. I do feel like I'm in the minority as people who think fondly of Skyward, but I like Skyward, especially with two players. A nice split you choose game that gave you a lot of interesting things to think about, that had a cool setting, a weird sort of steampunk-y launching buildings up into the clouds, and there was a city up there. It it was it was unique. It had its own vibe. The theme here is the same, and they did attempt to change up how that game felt with more than two, and they did that.

And then unfortunately kind of kept going and adding more things and changing up more things to the point that I find the game now to be very slow, very unfocused. I have a hard time with this one. It I don't like it very much. Let me see if I can articulate why I feel that way. The good things are yes, the the artwork is still the same. It's very cool artwork and the world building is nice and strange and captivating. The splitting idea, this concept of there being piles out there and you do this sort of no thanks style passing where you take a group or you flip a card, make something better and don't have to pick yet. That works ish. But there's so many things you have to keep track of even just with three players and never mind with four players.

That when you reveal a card and decide where to put it, there are permutations galore that you have to consider by looking around the table. And all of these cards have a little bit of writing at the bottom. You saw the cards are very, you know, nice large format cards with a lot of great artwork and very small writing. I know they want to put their artwork front and center. And that worked out okay when it was here's a pile of cards, here's a pile of cards because the person was doing the splitting in the original Skyward could look at all of them in their hand and decide, okay, I want this one here, this one there, da da da. Okay, here here are the piles everybody. You all pick, I get to pick last, right? I split, you all choose. Okay. Now, I flip over a card from my own little stack in front of me. I read that and then I have to figure out what all the cards in the middle say and what everybody's cards in front of them say and then add it to one of those and it just draws out like a knife. It's very, very slow.

Um it feels like you're walking through molasses a little bit and eventually in the games I've played everybody just sort of gives up caring about what anybody else gets. They're like, I don't care. That that one. Um and that's not a good feeling. You don't feel like you have much control many of the times much of the time and you don't feel particularly clever much of the time. That the system did not lead to what I was hoping it would be a upon reading the rules, a feeling of cleverness. I did not get that feeling, okay? So, the gameplay is very slow. There's also the phases feel like there's very little connective tissue between them. That idea of we do this big split. Okay. Then you get to do the launch and and now it's launch a building if you want.

But also the extensions, which I'm not a big fan of the extensions because they make your 4x2 grid in front of you with the sky above it, they make it messy. You start stacking cards underneath and now you have these messed up looking columns. The whole thing's just not it doesn't look very nice. And so that that didn't feel great. And then after that phase comes this sort of, you know, uh um extra appendage of like, oh, also if you got the correct symbols, you can appeal to these things down here and they have their own abilities and things. And oftentimes y- y- there's no connective tissue between some of these phases, so it doesn't flow naturally, I thought. Um there's also some the the feel of the game will by turns be tons of take that like, I'm stealing a building from you and I give you a replacement. Here's some trash, I'm taking your eight-point building.

There's all of everything from a very much a take that side of the spectrum to wow, this is Euro gamey galore, right? And it's all this like if for every one of these things you have, you get this many points, but also this. And so it there's a little bit of an identity crisis in there a little bit for me. Um I feel like this game would have benefited from going simpler, not more complex. The splitting could have easily worked um and is an interesting idea, the note the the the No Thanks kind of splitting from that game. I like that concept of I don't want to take yet. I want the piles to get bigger, but I have to offer you guys something before I get to decide if I want to pick again. That works.

But the game the the things you are picking and splitting got more complicated from Skyward. Whereas I think maybe going simpler would have been better. Would have been punchier. Would have made this game a little bit faster. As it is right now, the game length lists 30 to 75 minutes. And this is not a game I want to play for 75 minutes. It just doesn't feel like it supports that much it by you know, 60 minutes in I've been doing the same thing over and over. My stuff got stolen. I stole it back. You took this. I did that. And it all kind of grinds me down a little bit. And I'm ready for the game to wrap it up. So, there's that feeling a little bit.

A lot of the ideas here are interesting. And it sort of breaks my heart a little bit that this wasn't a that for me anyway a slam dunk cuz I really like Skyward with two players. And I was hoping this would then be great with three and four. But it's it's really still a the best at two. It's kind of like a two-player game. Maybe that should have been the move. Take Skyward. Make it exclusively a two-player game. Call it Skyward Republic for two players. And really hone in what you want to do. That might have been better. But I think pursuing the thing that wasn't great the first time around in Skyward didn't pan out the way I was hoping. So, there you go. This one's a little bit of a heartbreaker. But I'm going to come down at a five out of 10 on this one.

It's not horrible. I I'll play it again if somebody really wants to, but it's not one I think I'll be bringing out. And if anybody asked what should I get Skyward or Skyward Republic? I think the the first one's still better. Um so there you go. Five out of 10 from me, folks, for this one. Um that's going to do it. Thank you very much for tuning in and and checking this one out. My name is Z Garcia. I'll see you on the next one.

Hey, thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. We really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description of this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there, so definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vasel and I hope you enjoyed this video.

Progress saved