4 Seasons Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at four seasons which is a small box card game designed by team cyan that came out in 2010. this one is for strictly two players and takes 15 to 30 minutes to play so this is an i split you choose style game where you're trying to collect cards from the center of the table and by bidding cards yourself but you do that in quite a in quite a backwards way so i've advanced the game a few rounds here just to give you an idea of what the table is going to look like as the game develops so basically you've got these four different markers here relating to the four different seasons and each of those seasons is going to correspond to a certain suit of cards so you can see here that you've got the summer suit here which are these yellow bright cards here corresponding to this marker here um and basically as the game goes on you are trying to build up a pool of points in the middle and then try to win the bid for those points by having the highest sum of numbers next to that particular type and the cards come in three different denominations they come in ones twos and threes and at the start of the game those cards are going to be divided out quite meticulously to make sure that each player has a very balanced deck so a player's turn is quite simple in this game you're just going to have your hand of eight cards and you're going to pick two of those cards to offer to your opponent so let's say for example i chose this blue one and then this this number two here with this awesome
colors then i'm going to give those to my opponent and then they're going to choose out those two cards which to play in the middle and which to play on their side so for example they might say i'll play this blue one in the middle like this because we're still both you know relatively balanced in this one we've got two each side to bid for that middle um middle bunch of points and then the other one is going to go into my bid here meaning that any future cards at least we're going to be closer to fight over that and that's going to be how the game is basically going to progress it's going to go onto your opponent's side they're going to pick two cards i'm going to do this randomly and they're going to give you two cards so in this example i've got no choice so i'm going to have to play one as a bid and then one in the center of the table and this is going to return again and again until all your cards have been exhausted so let's let's advance the game somewhat and show what the end game scoring is going to look like so the end of the game is going to look something like this where each players play through all of their cards we've got a big pool of points in the middle and of course each player's bids for those points and then meticulously we're going to go from one side and through to the next one to determine who's going to get these victory points so you can see here in this autumn symbol that we've got one two three four five six seven eight points up for grabs and each player has actually been got a total value of four so therefore nobody is going to grab those points this one here you've got three four five six seven eight points in the center there this person's got a total bit of five this one's only got four therefore these eight points are going to get awarded to this player i'm going to do the same thing for the other seasons so this one
again a pool of five points in the middle this person's bid five this person's bid four therefore they're going to get those points and here again uh this person's bid three this person's bid five and we've got a big point a big bunch of points here we've got two four uh five six seven eight nine ten eleven points for this player so therefore this person's gonna have a score of 11. uh this person is going to have a score of five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen therefore this player is going to be the winner because i got the most points and that is essentially how a game of four seasons works so let's get let's go into my final thoughts on the game okay so mechanisms wise i generally really enjoy that i split you choose mechanism i think it's a really cool decision to be made you know you get some control of what you have your opponent but not too much control and vice versa you know you have to work with what you've been provided and in a game like this where it is so tight and very delicately balanced it's um it's a very agonizing decision to make it particularly as the game goes on and that's probably one of my biggest observations in this game is the game arc and how it crescendos because the first half of the game you're generally just going through the motions you're just painting this portrait of what the game is going to look like at the end you know how many points are going to be in the middle and you don't really know how much you're willing to bid but as that second half starts coming into play you start to understand right i really don't want to give my opponent this because this pool of points is massive therefore i got to be very careful when i give them these cards and what to what to pair that card with because if i'm going to
help him somewhere i want to hurt him somewhere else so the decision space is actually pretty damn good particularly when it comes to that second half of the game and that is probably one of my biggest criticisms because again that that second half is great the fast half just feels like you're just going through the motions and not really have much to aim for i really like the way the game is balanced because you know you'd think that a game like this you might get given a random bunch of cards to play with therefore your opponent might get all the threes and you just get all the ones so that wouldn't work quite well so you actually do have to go through this quite um there's quite particular shuffling mechanism um where you each have a very balanced set of cards despite having a bunch of cars taken out at random so you don't have complete control over what cards you're going to have but you do know the numbers you've got so yeah i like the fact that you know this might be a very blue heavy game but you're not going to know that so yeah i like the way that works and that the game does make an effort to make sure that both players are going to kind of play on a level playing field the time investment of this game is pretty great to be honest it only takes about 15 20 minutes to play amanda offers quite a lot of decisions considering how quick it is to play and there is a little bit of scope for some analysis for us again particularly when it comes to the end of the game and you know the cards you've got on your hand you know what your opponent is particularly or are potentially going to get and where they're going to place them so yeah as the game goes on the ap does wrap up quite a lot but that does add to the tension of the game the interaction is essentially everything in this game i'm you know you are it's a head-to-head game it's very cerebral you need to know what you can give them um and why and what you know the consequences of your actions so yeah it's a very
interactive style game but i will say that those decisions and how you're going to get a leg up on your opponent is quite micro you know there's a smallest mistake can end up costing you the game and sometimes those decisions aren't as kind of transparent as you might think you know you think you might be doing the right thing when in reality you might be doing the opposite so you do feel like you you make mistakes in this game you can learn from them but you the kind of potential to foresee things happening um is quite is quite small i think but aesthetically and from a production standpoint i think the game looks fantastic you know they're very very striking artwork you've got these faces depicting the different seasons um all the iconography is but well i can obviously different colors are very clear you know i'm color blind and i can clearly see what the different colors are and you know if you don't like the colors you can just look at the artwork and see i've got no issues at all with the production these little kind of perspex markers are fine you can stand them upright if you want to because they do come with stands um but yeah i've got no issues so this is a small box card game the card quality is adequate you know i've got no issues at all so yeah probably what you'd expect from a small box card game so i'm going to go into some final thoughts now and that's going to very close closely relate to comparisons of this game because if sometimes i talk about comparison sometimes i don't this one i cannot avoid talking about comparisons because i generally love this again this i split youtube's mechanism um and if i played this game before playing another game i'm going to mention now i'd say this is a keeper all day long i love the decisions you have in this one however i feel like i'd be completely misreviewing this game if i did not mention a game called hanumakoji
so hanumakoji uses a very similar system where you you know you give your opponents cards they choose which ones to take some they're going to help them and some of them are going to get given to you so again you have that that mitigated control this one it uses a very similar mechanism it has that core decision which is the same but i feel like this one misses out on some of the tension of a game like kamikoji again particularly on the first half of the game whereas hanumakoji is tense from the get-go this one does you know you do have to go through the motions before you get to that point where every decision really starts to matter and i think that is what's gonna kind of be the be the crux of this game because do i have room for both of them in my collection i'm not sure i do because you know if hana makoji was a longer game then i might say yeah i do have room for both of them because this one takes 20 minutes hanamikoji takes about 20 minutes so i think this is one of those examples where despite being a fantastic game it's just going to be a direct um fight for the same spot on my shelf and hanover koji is going to edge it out um pretty significantly to be honest but as i said the main thing working against this is because it's just not as good in any any kind of field of comparison to hana mikoji um but if again if i hadn't played that game and this one maybe it was even the one i played first i might have more kind of a sentimental relationship with it and i might rate this one higher but unfortunately for that reason i can't really warrant picking this one up because there is a better game out there that does the same thing in the same time frame and more exciting from the get-go a bit more
elegant and a bit more nuanced but despite that this is still a very good game in its own right so yeah unfortunately it's one of those examples where a game has been directly um superseded and improved upon um but hey if you know maybe if you're fatigued on a game like panama coach you want to try something a bit different this one is definitely one to look at you know if you can find this one for a good price pick it up because it is very solid mechanically it does have some tense decisions some clever kind of card play and hand management but yeah ultimately for that reason i cannot recommend picking up four seasons because it's just not as good as that other game so yeah unfortunately that's where i stand on four seasons