TDG: Hunt for Blackbeard
Transcript
Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I recently went to the house where I grew up in and I asked the people there if I could come inside and look around. They slammed the door in my face. My parents are mean. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Hunt for Blackbeard from Fort Circle Games.
In Hunt for Blackbeard from Fort Circle Games, two players take on the roles of either the Blackbeard the pirate or the hunters as they attempt to use hidden information, hidden movement to thwart their enemies. All right, ladies and gentlemen, I am not going to get into a deep rules breakdown of this game. I'm just going to give you an overview of the rules, tell you a little bit about how it plays, and then I'm going to tell you what I think. Now, as I said, one player will take on the role of Blackbeard. One player will take on the role of the hunters. Now, you're going to have your own uh player screens. You're going to have kind of a player board behind it. And this is it's a very asymmetrical game. So, these these two uh boards are not going to look a lot alike. Now, both the hunters and the pirates will have their own kind of tiles to draw from. They will also have kind of uh upgrades that they can purchase along the way as well.
Now, you're going to set up the board with these uh blocks, these blue blocks. Most of them just have seagulls on it. They're empty. But, a few of them may have something important. For instance, right at the beginning of the game, the pirate player is going to set up a camp. Now, he has his ship out there as well. And the hunter player won't have any idea where these objects are. The hunter player will begin on his side of the board. He's got two ships uh which are uh seen, which are evident where they're going to be. As well as he has uh kind of uh an army on land, a militia on land that will hunt down uh the pirates as well. Now, the first thing that's going to happen every round is both the hunters and the pirates are going to draw tiles. Now, the hunter has informants he is going to draw, and the pirate will have two kind of decks of um uh tiles to draw from that kind of do some different things, different locations. But, you go ahead and you draw them and you place them on your mat. Now, for the pirate, he's going to have to fulfill certain conditions on these tiles as they come out in order to win the game.
And the uh hunters are going to be able to use their informants to help them learn where Blackbeard potentially is or where he's been. Now, the hunters, when they have their informants out, that will tell them kind of certain areas of the board, certain things they can do to kind of look and see where potentially the pirates are. So, they can go ahead and pay whatever cost is associated with that in order to look at blocks. But, here is the dealio. The hunter isn't going to know which blocks they have looked at. So, the hunter or the pirate rather must turn away so that the hunter can look at that. So, while the you know, pirate has his eyes closed or is looking in another direction, the hunter can look and check certain blocks on the board that his informants will let him do that. Now, if he wants to, he can choose to surveil a space.
Essentially, he can turn that space up say, "I've got somebody there." In which case, the hunter the pirate will know that that space is probably not somewhere he must to go to. Now, Blackbeard has a number of pawns behind his player screen and he can commit these in different ways. One of the things he can do is plan piracy. Now, as I mentioned, as the game is progressing, he's getting more of these tiles that are coming out and they're kind of a you know, they're they're like in two rows, right? Now, he can go ahead each of these tiles have spaces on them for cubes or in the short term pawns and he can commit pawns on there to attempt to fulfill the conditions of that uh tile. But, that tile may take into certain locations on the board. He has to be in certain locations on the board in order to fulfill those conditions.
So, he can place those on there and that will take some of his cubes. But, he can also prepare defenses. He can spend some cubes to take some of these uh uh defenses that he can then add to his ship that will help him if he ever finds himself in combat. Finally, he can commit these pawns to movement. Essentially, one pawn per space. So, he can go ahead and move throughout the board. Now, if Blackbeard moves around the board, it's the same thing in reverse. Now, the hunter must look away or close his eyes as the pirate as Blackbeard goes ahead and puts his ship in a proper location. But, he also has to put blocks indicating where he has sailed through. So, he's leaving a trail behind him as he is moving. This will make it a little bit easier for the hunter, but to potentially narrow down where he has been if he can spot some of those some of that trail. Now, for the hunters' action, they too are committing pawns. Now, what they can do is again, they can commandeer assets. If they are in kind of their starting location for the ships, they can go ahead and place some of these kind of upgrades on the ships that will help them during combat.
They can sail. Essentially, they can spend the pawns to to to move to various locations on the board uh through adjacency. And they can also uh attempt to scout, meaning they can spend pawns to look at where they are, look at adjacent areas as well. Now, as I mentioned, the hunters also have a militia that moves along land. They can go ahead and spend pawns to move that militia along land. Again, the same thing, kind of inspecting uh these these ports that could potentially be where the pirates are located or a pirate base. Now, if the pirates are spotted, again, either the adventurer, the pirate ship, or the um uh Captain Blackbeard himself, the figure, or or Israel Hands, who's a figure on the board. Uh if Captain Brand is there or one of these other figures are there, you can attempt to do an arrest. Otherwise, you're just going to kind of have combat. Now, I'm not going to get again into the weeds in combat, but essentially, you're going to get dice for your ship, you're going to get dice for upgrades. You're going to have a big dice fest roll off here. So, you're going to as I say, look at your assets and your uh prepared defenses. You can figure out who rolls first. Yeah, you're rolling the die. Typically, a six hits the rigging. It's going to damage the ship. If you hit a five, it's going to hit the crew. If you roll a three or four, it's a miss unless you maybe have chains or some other special weapon that you've already declared at the beginning of combat, then it can become a hit. And then a one or two is always going to be a miss in combat. Now, depending on what how the rolls go, you're going to see if somebody is sunk, you're going to see if somebody can escape. Now, the last thing you're going to do in a phase is
Blackbeard is going to resolve piracy. So, he's going to look at all the pawns he placed on the uh prepared or the planned piracy uh tiles. And if he has been able to achieve those goals during the turn, he replaces the pawns with cubes. Now, those cubes are going to be important cuz that's going to lead to victory. Now, the game goes a total of four game rounds. Now, the hunters win instantly if they can successfully arrest Blackbeard or the adventurer, or if they can successfully board as a result of naval combat. They do that, they win instantly. Otherwise, you go to the end of the fourth game round. At the end of the fourth game round, uh you remove the player screen, and if Blackbeard has been able to gain uh half of the cubes, if he's completed piracy in half of the cube spaces, not half of the tiles, but half of the cube spaces in either row with gold or the black cubes, if he does either of those, if he's completed half of the spaces uh half of the cube spaces in either of those rows, then Blackbeard wins.
Hunt for Blackbeard. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, Hunt for Blackbeard, ladies and gentlemen. Now, before I get into it, let me just say one thing. I have been in discussions with Fort Circle Games about possibly publishing a board game design that I have been working on for a few years. I, you know, it's it's early days, and we'll see what happens, but uh the that relationship that I have in no way colors my review of this game, but I just want full transparency here.
Now, I have to say I love hidden movement games. If you know the channel, you know I'm a big, big fan of hidden movement games. I love Fury of Dracula is one of my favorite games of all time. Um Sniper Elite, Letters from Whitechapel. I just played the Sherlock Holmes uh uh edition of Scotland Yard. I mean, I just love these games. They're so much fun. And so, I was really looking forward to Hunt for Blackbeard. Now, this is also a Volko Ruhnke design. I believe I believe he came up with Coin. So, and I'm a big fan of Coin games. Just started playing those a year or two ago. Uh so, I was I was really looking forward to this game. And I'll tell you right now, uh one of the big positives for me here is I love the fact that it's not just a matter of Blackbeard trying to hide, right? It's not Blackbeard just staying away.
Um as much as I love Fury of Dracula, if Dracula just stays away the whole game, it doesn't engage with the hunters, it's not going to be a very fun game. But, this game kind of has a system baked into it where Blackbeard has to take risks. And Blackbeard has to potentially expose himself in order to successfully complete piracy. Because again, he is going to win or lose based on that, not just not being found out. So, that is really cool. And like I say, it it it it makes the Blackbeard player need to run risks. And need to be able to to to expose himself to danger if he's going to win the game. So, I really like that aspect of this game quite a bit. I think that's a lot of fun. And I really like too kind of how the the hunters, they have different options.
You know, you're both trying to kind of soup up your ships with defense or commandeering assets. But, the the um hunters are kind of limited. They want to do that in the first part of the game cuz once they leave that area, it's not as easy to do. So, I really like that aspect of the game as well. Uh that you're you're trying to soup up your ship for what may be eventually a confrontation. But, the hunters, of course, are are trading that for for time because that's less time they can actually go out and hunt, right? And actually do the hunt. So, I like the variety of missions that the pirates can get with those with those piracy tiles. I like the different ways the informants come out for the for the hunters and the different things you can do there. And sometimes it just doesn't behoove you to to go after those. Sometimes you just want to husband your resources for later. So, there there's some real good choices on both sides here. And like I said, the pirates can choose different kinds of piracy. Uh they can try to play it safe, uh but it's going to it's may cost them in other areas. Or they can be more brazen and possibly that's going to lead to a quicker victory or at least a more uh they're going to kind of reach where they need to be sooner. So, I really like that. I think that's just an awesome trade-off that the that the that the pirates have there.
So, really both sides have some awesome awesome decisions here. Both sides several times in a round have to do this or look away. And I just I mean, I realize that's kind of the nature of the beast here, but uh uh it's I don't like that. I don't You know, one of the great things about some of these other hidden movement games that I've discussed is I really like the fact that you uh you've got kind of this, you you know, card play and stuff where that's not an issue. Where the hidden movement is is not something where you where you have to close your eyes or look away. So, that was disappointing. I was I was not I was not happy about that. That's easily my least favorite aspect of the game. But all told, this game is a lot of fun.
Uh Ray and I really enjoyed it. As I said, there is a learning curve. Uh there are some concepts. Uh I actually had to um um text Kevin a few times at Portal Circle Games cuz I had a few rules questions. And then once once he kind of explained it to me, it's like, "Okay." Yo, it made sense. But there was just stuff I wasn't quite getting from the rule book. But again, it's fun. Once everything's figured out and you know what you're doing, it's like, "Oh my gosh. This is really a great game." And the thing the icing on the cake, what makes this game work, in my opinion, is it plays in less than an hour. If this were like a 2-hour game, it would probably wear out its welcome, but it's a tight game. And it's a tight contest here, and I really, really like that. Um this is a game that kind of the the more you play and the more that the more nuances you find here, uh the more you're going to like it. Now, there's a lot more I didn't cover nearly everything in the rules. I just I I didn't want to get into all that here.
Um but the more you learn about this game and the more strategies you find and the more ways to bluff and double-bluff and and all sorts of things is just a lot of fun. Hunt for Blackbeard is a great game. On the Cody scale, I'm going to give Hunt for Blackbeard an eight out of 10, even despite some of my criticisms, which are not insignificant. I still think this is an eight out of 10. It is a tremendously fun game and uh I recommend it. Thank you once again, ladies and gentlemen, for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on our Facebook page, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. I'd love to hear what you have to say about these games or anything else you want to comment on. Uh please like this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel. And if you do really like what we do here on the Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on that channel. Please check that out and subscribe. It would mean the world to me. And if you do really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip.
Did you hear the one about the pirate boxer? He had a mean left hook. Please somebody help me. I'm on my feet again and I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING AND I DON'T know where I've been. Please somebody help me. I'm on solid ground. IT'S A LONG [screaming] TIME THAT I'VE BEEN DYING. ONCE A YEAR I WIND UP IN THE VAN.
[screaming]