Skip to main content
Loading video...

OATH Review | The Most Interesting Game We've Played

Transcript 36:10

hello everyone carlo and dylan here from all you can board and today we are reviewing a very exciting game called oath chronicles of empire and exile this is the beauty absolutely beautiful game this is designed by cole worley same designer as root uh probably his most popular game uh beautiful artwork by kyle ferran and published by leader games uh right away we'll mention this was sent to us as a review copy from the publisher um so dylan's going to start by giving a bit of an overview as to what goes on in the game we're obviously not going to cover all the rules because there is a lot to cover here there's some excellent videos online we can link a couple in the description below and then we're going to tell you what we did and didn't like and then give you our final thoughts at the end so yeah take it away yeah there is tons going on here so again this is gonna be very brief um and you know just for me running through it check the description for the full overview but basically an oath um there's going to be one person that's playing the chancellor and there's going to be a bunch of people that are starting at least in the first play through play is exiles and the entire goal is the chancellor's trying to keep control and remain the chancellor and in yeah all the other players are basically trying to find another way to become the chancellor whether that be from usurping the throne whether that be by becoming a citizen and having the secondary wing condition but there are a bunch of different win conditions so as an exile you might have your own private vision card that you're that you have that is going to give you your own secret goal that you have for a part of it and then eventually becomes a public goal that could win you the game you know the chancellor can make people citizens if they see that the game is getting away from them and they need to regain control and they can give make other

people citizens to help them out but those citizens will have secondary ways to win the game that if the chancellor would win now the citizen wins if this condition is met so there's a bunch of different ways that you can win the game and it's an a game with a bunch of different areas on the board beautiful board and you know it's got some area control aspects to it where depending on what the win condition is it might be a bigger factor you can have different you know units on different areas of the board as well as different units on your actual personal player board that adds to your power and you're trying to campaign and gain control of different areas and that also gives you access to the cards that are tied to that area as well and some battle plans that can help you in campaigning on your turn you basically have a bunch of supply you're going to be using that supply to take a bunch of different possible actions whether that be searching for cards through the discard piles or the actual world deck whether that be campaigning whether that be you know doing some trading to get different resources like favor and secrets um there's a whole bunch of stuff going muster to strengthen your army yeah like you're strengthening army on your board through mustering there's so much going on um that there's no way for me to summarize at all hopefully you get a little bit of idea of what's going on but generally i think if you want to learn more about it from a rules perspective check out one of those rules videos one of the thing i want to mention just real quick is that it can play over a maximum of eight rounds if it gets the end of the eighth round the game will automatically end but it can end much earlier from the fifth round onwards there's a die roll that can happen where someone if they roll a certain diet will trigger the end of the game or if one of those visions or other things so there are ways the game can end earlier but at most it'll be eight rounds and it is a

two to six player game so there's a special two-player mode we'll get into that a little bit later it's not designed as a two-player man i don't think uh three to six is generally like where you want to try to sit um but it can get pretty wild with six players as well so yeah should we touch on the kind of like not legacy because it's not quite a legacy game element as well yeah sure it's a it's a campaign game that isn't you know the same as maybe you know like a pandemic legacy or like a gloomhaven where you know you're bringing the same group and continuing the same story you are continuing the same story and lineage but it's very much easier i would say in this game to have one person drop in or drop out um the more you can keep the same group going the more the experience is going to just resonate with you but i think that as long as you keep the person who's won the last game which becomes a chancellor you do get to keep some of that essence and it's it's one that you know you're changing the game based on your actions and everything but it's not that's that's where the extent of the legacy aspects come from the game changes on what cards are going to be out but the rules stay the same otherwise it's just they're just going to be altered by which cards happen to be in the game so it's a different kind of legacy campaign experience you're not tearing anything up there's cards to get eliminated and go to a section of your of your box but those can even be brought back at some point so like and there's no end to the campaign there's no like we beat the campaign the game goes on forever it's just that every time it's going to be different because things go back into the box the setup changes so it's just something that evolves over time but it doesn't have an end like a campaign would yeah exactly so we're gonna start with uh what we liked and uh the first thing i'm gonna

touch on because i think it's one of the things that completely caught my eye right from the echo is the the quality components and the art and everything uh we uh got sent the deluxe edition and it is absolutely beautiful um it's got this amazing rollout board it's like a neoprene yeah like beautiful colorful um we all the the you know the the secrets um are actual little books that are just like like they're just amazing to actually hold and work with a nice sound to them yeah like they just like are amazing that the coins have some great heft to them and and designs on both sides of them they're metal um there's different colored dice there's like orange dice and blue dice for attack and defending um that are being used um little meeples through the engraved like look at yours too they're all shaped and they're different colors one color for each of the super nice stuff the players the chancellor board like i can't get over the component quality and this show them the chronicle book too like there's this like leather-bound book here like that you actually can like write in and then have your you know entire like history of the game going on and stuff like that but they give you one of those to keep chronicled like even even all the cards in the different in these the decks that come out yeah these decks here as well as the location cards all have unique artwork it's done by the same artist again call fairnew did the art root if you're familiar with yeah so the sleeves are amazing too like um it just everything about it is phenomenal so in terms of table presence in terms of like when we had our friends over to play at the the our sessions of this um

i think everyone was just blown away by the aspect there was no complaints everyone loved to actually get their hands on the game itself um and that's something that just like right from the get-go puts it like in the exact right mindset to play with so yeah it really adds the level of immersion in the game when everything looks this good yeah yeah for sure so that was the first thing i like do you want to throw into one of the things you really like sure so the next thing we're going to get to is the kind of story and narrative that comes through this game and i think what made it stand out so much to me is that like i don't usually go to games for for story you know me i'm more about the mechanics and stuff i like story but um just to talk about some of the games we've played that have had story like i kind of mentioned in when i reviewed just you know not this exactly the same type of game but when i talked about gloomhaven jaws the lion or even the original gloomhaven that the story didn't quite do it for me a lot of the time and i think in that game you're reading the story from a book it's like you complete a scenario and you're reading this happened this happened there's characters talking in this game you're not reading anything but this is some of the strongest level of storytelling and narrative and like world building that i've seen in any game and nothing is something that you're reading everything is a result of the actions you know you have a fight in a certain area and then later on that fight that happened in the charming valley it was tough to leave the charming valley like these thematic places and everything that happens tells its own story and the story just emerges from what people do and there's i don't think i've ever played a game that has that much story without any actual text telling you what's happening yeah like it's a story of your own creation like the more that you get immersed in you don't have to fully role play but like the more you get immersed in what you're doing and really remembering certain

things and letting that be you know part of the experience i think is where you get the most out of both the thing you mentioned about like the charming valley and stuff like that is now an area that if it comes up for us in future games we're going to remember the battles that happen in the charming valley and just that is so unbelievably cool to me that we could have an experience where like remember and technically when you say remember in the last session you'd be saying remember uh in history books right like remember in history books the battle that took place in the charming valley how this person became king like those things become part of the your own lore that no one else who played oath might have and at the same time if you're keeping the same group of people going everything you're writing in the chronicle becomes the history and the campaign and the story of the game that instead of you having to read it you've written it you've written the story you can go back you can read it all after the fact and you can remember that like this person became the chancellor by pulling off this really deceptive technique and that might have made it in later games someone doesn't trust them and stuff having certain locations out completely changes the story of the game like we had a card called narrow pass that like completely changed that game compared to all the other ones we played because it made this this bottleneck where this you know that's where everything was happening now is in this pathway through the narrow pass to try to get to this one person that that didn't happen it wouldn't happen unless you had that card in the game right having certain car actual like denizen cards out and edifices and stuff will change how that game goes like i don't want to get into uh spoilers i'm going to say this specific one but i had a card that completely dictated our entire game like i i seemed everyone i was

unassuming no one thought i was even in the game and i flipped over a card and suddenly became the biggest threat and it got to the point where my uh the friend of ours was like i'm actually okay with losing because this is like the perfect story like that's the thing the story was so good that it didn't feel like a cheap move it was like oh what a lucky card or it was just like wow that's amazing what an awesome thing that's part of our health story yeah yeah and i should we should have said this at the beginning but actually a big thanks to our two friends uh jake and braden who uh joined us for this entire journey so we can get a bunch of plays and and review this but um yeah so that i think that's the biggest thing with the story is just yeah it's a story of your own making and it's i've never had a boredom with that experience and i'll say right now like there's going to be things we talk about later that we don't like but for me personally that's by far my favorite part about the game and by far the most impressive thing about the game is just that level of immersion and narrative that comes out of all of the things you're doing it's just it's yeah never never played anything quite like this in that sense yeah the the next big thing comes from that is multiple ways to win i think that many games have multiple paths of victory uh this is the one that this is one of the only games i've played where they're just very drastically different ways to win you know like and they're not always obvious no and like you know you play a game like you know uh like uh i i reference this game a lot but it's just one that the works uh like feast rodent right like there's multiple paths to victory like someone could be going more into like hunting when someone could be going more into like you know a livestock and things like that right and find different ways to get their point totals up but the end goal is get the most points in this it's not like the end goal is get the most points it's yes you're trying to become the chancellor

but you might be doing so by getting the people's favor and holding on to it and we have to start discerning that that's what you're doing whereas i'm trying to gain the most territories or something or put someone in a situation where they have to make me a citizen like you can't account for everything until you've probably played this game a dozen times maybe and so you're always kind of thinking like what are they scheming are they actually out of the game are they like is there something i'm not even aware of that they have a card i haven't seen yet that's gonna produce an opportunity for victory like that to me is so exciting and some might not like having to play you know with the unknown of like what am i even doing but i feel like when you embrace the the unknown a little bit and just you know how am i going to win this game and start trying to find your path it might not always work but when it does man is it satisfying for sure for sure coming up not only with your own grand plan but like you said trying to figure out what other people are doing and all that ties into one of my favorite moments in the game going back to when you flip that crazy card that we're not going to get into too much above spoilers is the kind of grand reveal is like when you know someone's cooking something up you don't know quite what it is and you're just waiting and you kind of have your eye on them and actually there is last game we played so there's these two banners they're called the people's favor and the darkest secret okay i'm not going to get too enthused but basically there's vision cards that can come up that if you own this you win the game and there's other ways you can kind of fight to take these back from each other and you had a card that said something with the darkest secret yes in front of you an advisor card and so i kept thinking oh dylan's gonna be going for the darkest secret so i kept thinking but then you flip this other card and do this other thing and instead

you went for the people's favor and none of us saw it coming and it was just confused by like why yeah and it was this big but the reveal moment where you see someone flip this and they play their vision or whatever and now it's like a next turn if you guys don't stop me i win is like oh shoot we all sit there like now the stakes are and now we know exactly what's going to be happening i love that kind of reveal all the victory conditions the way that play in is is an awesome part of the game yeah phenomenal because you never know how it's going to end or when it's going to end yeah exactly um and then another great thing about this game is just how much variety and how interesting all the cards are like there's like you know this is like the world deck we're looking at right now right so like there's a decent amount of cards here but what you're not seeing is the fact and i think they're all unique right yeah i'm pretty sure they're all sure they're all unique but what you're not seeing is the fact that there's like another stack that i think is larger than this in the box and at the end of every session depending on who wins and what cards they own you're removing six cards from the deck and adding six cards in and so you're constantly getting new cards that you don't even know until you see them for your next game so there's always going to be an element of i don't know what could come out so instead of there being like this meta that develops where you say okay i'm going to play to to this card and keep drawing until i get to this card to something that card may have been removed you don't know what other cards might be in there and that creates this element of there's always discovery going on an oath and i would i would wager that it would take you lots of plays to get to the point where you've finally gone through every card i don't even know how many that would take because you're only adding six in you're not even potentially seeing them in the next game like or some might be more situational there's that one that says like if the narrow pass is available you

can ignore it so the first thing you play you might not even have the narrow path the ability might not really happen and then the next time you play you see the real potential of that card when the narrow pass is in play or the cards let you jump from one coast to another or things that change the you know the basic rules of the game or what you're allowed to do yeah um and yeah there's these we haven't gone over really yet there's these different houses that have these different symbols um and they can change there's favor that changes hands throughout the game so that you can access you know basically ask certain houses to help you out but then if you use them too much they're kind of out of favor so you can't rely on them anymore so there's these changing things throughout the game too that are just yeah really interesting to keep track of yeah yes and then there's also relic cards as well like there's there's a lot of different cards a lot of variety that can change up each game and they're all interesting like i'm sure some are less interesting than others there's some that we flipped over we're like oh that doesn't really affect our game but it could affect a game and that interest is what makes it uh you know is just something that makes it so fun it's like we've had games with lots of cards before where you know yes there's lots but it just feels like sometimes there's a lot for the sake of it whereas this yeah they're all similar yeah this you're being rewarded by everyone has its moment in the sun i would say yeah depending on the game when it comes out all of a sudden they could be the most important card in this game it could be the least important card right that keeps it really you know keeps you on your toes so absolutely um yeah so that those are all the main things i had for my uh things like is there anything you wanted to add on or did i cover most of them um i think i just wanted to mention also the thing with the chancellor and the exiles and the citizens is pretty cool i like that aspect of being able to recruit and the

negotiation a lot of time it's just an interesting thing to try and figure out as players does this make sense to even be offering like i think the first couple games we weren't really sure it's like should i be trying to offer citizenship should i not it's kind of an interesting like thing to try and navigate and figure out when and does it make sense or by offering this person we had a game where someone offered citizenship and all this stuff and then later they regretted they're like i gave you too much power i should have negotiated differently so yeah you know even though it might end up being like you feel like you maybe made a mistake it is a really fun thing to try and figure out and even if you're not involved i have to say one of the things i like a lot about this game is you know we're going to talk later about downtime and length of player turns and stuff but when it's not your turn you're still involved like i never felt like i was just sitting there bored waiting for someone to do something because even when you guys are making negotiations or i'm seeing someone plan their turn there's always i always feel like i'm invested in knowing what's going on yeah and especially even we played at three we played at four um and it was interesting because even at three there's times where i was almost like i wish i had more time to think about it yeah my turns right like it never felt like too much down time because you there's so much you're thinking about like it absolutely it works great at those like those both those playercats i'd imagine maybe when you get to like you know we didn't play with six but at six it could probably get to the point where it's coming back and you're like okay i really want to take my turn but at the same time it's just interesting to watch everyone else take see how the board's gonna change by the time it gets to and what what you're gonna not have to react to and adapt to right so yeah very good so are we good to jump into the things we did not like i think so yeah great so we're going to talk about all the things we didn't like about oath um i don't know about you but

i wasn't crazy about the king making aspect so for those who don't know king making is basically when you as a group are almost deciding who is king so like kind of like deciding who's gonna win at the end so what happens we were talking before about the different victory conditions so a lot of times someone will flip over a card and it's basically saying at the end of your or the start of your next turn at your wake phase or whatever you win the game if no one has stopped you kind of thing so a lot of the time when that happens the game then becomes you know if you're the next player before that player takes their winning turn is people might neglect their own duties and be like i don't need to stop that person when it gets to me if after my turn that person is going to win i might feel like i have to spend my whole turn now doing something just to stop that person it might not actually help me win but for the sake of the game if i don't do that the game will just end and we'll all lose so not only is it that sometimes as a group you start discussing sometimes it feels like it becomes a sort of a cooperative game where three people are like how can we stop that person oh no but you should do this on your board and then it feels like people are almost kind of taking part of each other's turns or suggesting stuff and sometimes you're like i would have maybe preferred to figure that out on my own and it feels like the game is forcing you into like you don't have as many choices late in the game right early on you have this massive realm of possibilities you can do anything you can make whatever plans and the later the game goes on it feels like there's more things that you have to do that call for your attention you have to go here to stop this person or you have to do this otherwise this is going to get out of control yeah so it just felt a bit like that and i also again making again the kind of like where it becomes a bit more cooperative and discussing together how to stop i would have preferred we're all each maybe we're

doing our own thing in negotiating but not helping each other figure out how to stop the one person right yeah i i i agree with a lot of what you're saying i don't think it bothered me as much but it i don't think it ever affected me as much in the games we played i was trying to think about this after and i think i didn't have to make as many of those decisions as you guys were um and just worked out that way but i know what you're saying is like it becomes less interesting and less exciting if all of a sudden you have to stop focusing on what you're doing and you have to just focus on you know stopping someone else but i do like when we got to the point where we're like he's gonna run away with it and we all of a sudden did become cooperative i actually liked that because i i think the idea of a game flip-flopping like temporarily to cooperative and competitive and the fact that there are these allegiances that can sometimes form someone can become a citizen and everything like the fact that that led to we had a game where someone was going to win and the only way they could get it the chancellor was going to lose and the only way they could not lose potentially the only chance they would have was to make someone a citizen and it might not work out but it was the only chance they had and they're like they formed a pact they seemed like they were gonna work together and then the citizen ran away with it and it's like i like that it becomes temporarily cooperative but like very uneasy alliances i'm a fan of that i just i agree that i wasn't a fan of when it gets the point at the end of the game where it's like well who's going to be the one to stop him and if these two don't it's left one person to basically say i either stopped or the game ends right like yeah that that is not as interesting but uh yeah i don't think i i did enjoy the the difference that's fair and just to be clear i don't

think it's done poorly like if for people who like king making this has done super well there's games like people love this sometimes and it's just for me it's something that i don't like and something that you should be aware of going into it is like as soon as you stick your neck out a little bit and show what your victory condition is everyone's coming after you and there's nothing you can do about it and you might somehow sometimes have to drop your plans just to stop someone yeah for sure another thing we'll bring up is uh because i think it's something that some might not like um is there's like we mentioned there's chances for this game to end very early um so there are eight rounds but as carlo mentioned there's this purple die and you're going to start rolling it i believe on the fifth round end of the fifth round yes and so the first time you roll it if you roll a six the game ends and then next time i think it's a five or six and then it's a three four five or six um so there's a chance that at the end of round five you roll it you roll a six and the game ends and that would mean that the chancellor wins or i guess the usurper or whatever but yeah the the citizen or whatever um but the the fact that like the game can end that way it's not that part that necessarily bothers me because thematically it does kind of make sense like the kingdom's getting more and more stable and there's a chance that it can you know stabilize early or it can take you know the full length of the game to stabilize for the chancellor um it's just the fact that it all comes down to a die roll that can be a little bit anticlimactic like it's exciting to see if someone's going to roll it but at the same time you're playing all these strategies you know you're having all this fun you know there's all this tension and all this like narrative going on and then you get to the fifth round and if we you haven't stopped them from being able to do this role because it's i should say the role

doesn't always happen there if you've taken oath keeper away from the chancellor it might not be that they roll but if it does happen suddenly you could you could roll and you could uh say well it's a six and you're like oh well i was planning everything it looked like we were about to get to the really interesting part of the game and the game's over so i feel like it's going to be not as often that that is a huge problem but its existence is going to inevitably make it so that some people are going to have a negative experience with it yeah i think that's fair and for me personally i was it was only just the way that it was integrated because i didn't mind we talk i think we both agree that we like the what it does for the kind of the feeling of the squeeze at the end of the game where you know the stable kingdom all that kind of stuff it was just the fact that i wish maybe there was a different way they could have done it with cards instead or something would have made it more thematic because even in the chronicle when you write it in you're like oh we had this fight in the narrow pass and all this stuff and then what and then the die was rolled yeah what's the dramatic like to say this kingdom is stabilized but really what you're saying is we rolled the number on the die earlier yeah and it just felt like again for a game that did so many of these amazing story and narrative things to have it just be a die that doesn't have any thematic integration just felt like a missed opportunity to maybe have something just tie in a little more to the story to have that extra kind of powerful ending to the game for sure and then the other one i think we both agree on that again it might be so this is definitely something that probably improves over time and especially if you're playing this uh you know very often with the same group of players this is your gathering game is it's very intricate there are a lot of rules there are a lot of specific rules that you can't even account for when you

read the first rulebook you can get a cards added into your deck or have different territories now come up that are you're never gonna have seen before so almost every game we played we had to refer to the rule books we had to further the appendix we had to refer to things to get clarification um it was a lot of we even went to bgg and get clarification on different things like there's so many specific things because of how intricate it is that i don't know how many plays it would take us to get to the point where we can confidently put the rule book in another room and never have to refer to it right like yeah if you're if you're not a fan of having to flip back and have that uncertainty and having to learn the rules still by the third fourth fifth game uh you might have some frustration it could be very difficult because because of that to introduce new people into a group if we had played like you and me like five games and all of a sudden a friend of ours wanted to play for the first time they're gonna feel a little lost and a little out of it and at a disadvantage so i feel like and i've heard that with with root so i feel like that might even just be you know a natural consequence of these type of games that are being designed is that you know they are fantastic games for the group that sticks around and plays over and over again but for someone to now join that experience with a bunch of experienced players um is probably gonna be not as fun for them right so yeah that thing that's like that's actually probably i would say even one of my higher up criticisms because it would be great to have someone just like drop in and say like yeah join our oath group or whatever but like i don't know how to do that and i'll have them feel like they're so lost for yeah i'd have to like play a lot lighter and less competitive to make them feel okay right experience right so yeah and we talk

about player count as well like it's we always like when games can accommodate wider ranges of players but in two to six we both agreed we didn't even really want to try it as a two-player game with that clockwork prince system yeah and that even with five or six we thought maybe five would be really good still but six is like feels like it's gonna be a bit of a slog a lot of down time keeping track of what everyone's cards are and things that you you know it just feels like a little much and so it's it's kind of a tough one you have to decide for yourself you know but i think we we liked it most at three or four and think that's probably the sweet spot for the game yeah i'll just say straight up i i don't ever want to play with a two-player game i think i'm very impressed and by the way they did the two-player game and i think that the the this brain that exists that you know only does certain things depend on the state of the board is super cool and i commend them for doing that um and given that option but this is not the type of experience i'm looking to play at two players like you you lose the i think you lose the intrigue from everyone having their own goals around the table and everything like that like the more people you have the more you're going to get of that i think at two player i don't think you're buying this for the two-player experience i think if you're you know thinking oh i'll play with it with three and up sometimes but at the very least i'll play with two i think you're probably gonna have a lesser experience by a long shot compared to the one we're having so i would say that that's not necessarily a negative as it is a caution don't get this to play as a two-player only experience in my opinion yeah i'd say maybe one more thing i'm not crazy about in the game and it depends on the game depends on the state of the game who you're playing with player count and

all that stuff sometimes the player turns it's not necessarily that they are too long because again i mentioned there's a lot of stuff you can do and be keeping track when it's not your turn but because you only get at most eight rounds in the game and each of those rounds are going to get one turn with a few actions that you do and sometimes depending if you have a bigger army on your board you refill fewer supply for the next turn so next year you might only get one thing that you do or two things instead so every everything you do it feels like there's so much weight to it because you're only gonna do a certain number of actions in total throughout the whole game and it just feels like there's this conflict in my mind between usually the longer a game is the less randomness i want and the more i want it to be about like the mechanics and the strategy and there's this weird thing where what i love most about this game is the narrative and the story and i want to be able to just like enjoy the story regardless of whether i win or lose and regardless of how things go but there's other times where you take a turn and at the end of the turn you realize that you put yourself in such a bad state that you've either maybe not completely lost the game early but you've just lost so much momentum like i had to turn i built up my army went and did all this stuff and went to fight a big battle but at the end of your battles if you don't have troops to actually put on the locations that you've won the battles you can't rule those areas so basically spent my whole turn doing this doing this doing this whatever and then at the end of this like whatever however many minute turn i realized i didn't even have the units to conquer the places that i won so the whole battle was for nothing and i just thought well i'm not gonna ask to take my turn back just but like it basically was a wasted turn and so i had to accept that we're playing this three plus hour game where i probably don't have my

chance of winning anymore but okay i'm in it for the story sort of thing so it's just i wish it was either maybe a little shorter or that the turns were maybe there was less to think of or something it just yeah it's tough for me to and i think like over time over time i feel like the more you play oath the more that you'll understand some of these mechanisms and maybe have a better idea of when to fight those campaigns and when to hold back because i feel like there was we all made those decisions where we're like we're gonna do this and all of a sudden by the end of it we're like that was not the best play by a long shot and you don't know until the end you're not gonna ask to take back your turn because that's part of the experience but i feel like you'll learn that as you go a little bit um but at the same time yeah like it it's not to say that it's not a good criticism because i think to say oh it's not a criticism because after five plays will be fine well you still have to go five plays with it yeah like yeah it's it's not that might be something that deters a lot of people and makes them they might only play it five times but i think it is important to point out though the more familiar you are that probably won't be a problem the more you play the game but if you're only looking to dabble in it a few times that might be an issue for you yeah i think for sure um yeah so that's pretty much everything uh we didn't like um again i would say the big takeaway from the things we didn't like is just that like it is going to be a very involved experience if you're not playing this with the same group at least with like some of the same members coming back and playing it semi-regular semi-regularly like once a month or you know mean a couple times every couple months or something i think you're gonna have a different experience with oath i think that's where the the the joy of it comes out of creating this narrative with the

same people chronicling it in the book and having these memories about the territories and the battles that took place and everything and if you're not getting that you might say what is it all for why am i putting this much effort into learning and doing all this stuff just to have a subpar experience right that seems overly complicated but in our case you know we met with the idea of the same people and having this experience and carrying it over and writing the chronicle and like i said i look back and read the the stories we developed and it's just i have a huge smile on my face i'm like oh man i remember that oh my god that was the big turning point oh when that person did this like that to me is the biggest takeaway if you don't have that that's going to be something that you're just not going to have nearly as good of an experience with oath as we did right no absolutely and think about any games we've played i don't know but i shouldn't speak for you but when i think i've had we've had memorable game sessions we've played games like gloomhaven we've played legs you've played pandemic legacy we've played games that have these amazing moments and stuff and even though this isn't going to be like one of my favorite games or anything the moments from this game it's it's crazy how specific those memories are in terms of like you remember exactly how that first game went down and that second one like there's such a unique kind of like snapshot of how a game went down where it's so rare that i find myself thinking about the game this much afterwards or that it like i have such a vivid memory of how exactly it went down rather than just oh there was that one turn in that one game kind of thing but like this feels like the whole thing is an experience that sticks with you even if you like the game or not it feels like yeah i totally agree so let's get into the final uh little chapter of

our video here which is um a couple different things it's sort of a summary of our thoughts but who do we like i think i talked about a little bit now but who do we think this game is for right um for me i'll just say a quick little thing i'll throw it to you um again i think that if this is a game that you're adding to your collection when you have a massive collection like this like we're an interesting case because we're obviously content creators and stuff but if you already have a massive collection you just like having a bunch of games to play and you're going to kind of you know not play this game for a while played this game a bunch of things flip-flop i don't think oath is probably one that's necessarily going to have a good spot in that collection because this sort of demands consistent play at least like you know playing it every couple months i feel like if you have to the good thing is you can go back and you can read your chronicle and remember but you still want to meet with the same group you still want to have those memories that you can associate with certain denizens and with certain areas on the board so i think if you have a massive collection and you're not playing a game very frequently or multiple times very often maybe this isn't the right one for you whereas if you would you agree that if you have one like if you have less games but you're looking for a game that you can meet up and play consistently with the same group like you would like rising sun and things like that blood rage that this is one that those people might be like very very attractive for sure for sure although it again uh i would recommend it more heavily for those who like like the kind of storytelling whatever rather than the fighty if you like those fighty games like you're talking bloodrage and even i think root and stuff like that seems to be more like of a war game this one is more about the chronicle and the story that it tells and the kind of locations and everything coming to life but yeah it's definitely something that it will be best when you dive into it over and over with the same group of

people um but i have to say even just if you're in a position like us where who knows how many more times we're gonna play this game sort of thing for me even if i never played this game again i would feel like i'm totally even the however what 15 20 hours however many hours learning the game playing it thinking about whatever i have zero regrets i've i it's one of those things that everyone should i think experience as long as you're open to the kind of overhead rules like if it's interesting to you and you're open to getting those two or three plays in at least to kind of like get the rules under your belt even just if you're someone who just likes exploring what game design has to offer you can't overlook this game like there's it's such an ambitious design it's such a unique design um yeah honestly for designing something like this and for coming together this well even though there are things that we clearly don't like about it or things that maybe just aren't quite for us um i would say like the best way i could summarize it at least for me personally is that it may just be the most interesting board game experience i've had you know gloomhaven's up there for a lot of reasons but i just feel like the uniqueness of this and what i'm taking away from it and the reason i'm gonna always remember this game and compare a lot of games to it is just because of how interesting uh and memorable it is um it's gonna like it i don't think i will soon forget our plays and we're gonna keep playing it obviously but it's gonna be this story that i'm gonna constantly refer to with that group being remember when that thing happened remember when this happened like i i just love that and i think that like you said for that reason alone i think a lot

of people should at least find a way to try it and have that same experience and be able to you know have the same absolutely so for you if it was up to you do you think this is something you would want to keep meeting up with the group and playing regularly kind of thing or is this something that you'd like to maybe come back to every once in a while never played where do you kind of stand i mean it take away busyness aspect and life and and commitments and stuff i would love to uh meet up like once a month to play this game i think once a month would be a good way to sort of like have enough time past they it's almost thematically making sense with it being in another generation um but at the same time and having to refer to the chronicle but at the same time not enough that you would have completely forgotten anything i don't think i would forget rules with a month gap like maybe uh small things but if we started doing it consistently i don't think would be too big of a deal and you're rediscovering every game anyways um but yeah i would love i'm i'm always a huge fan of meeting up playing the same game um and continuing a certain story like that's why i love gloomhaven we have a bunch of campaign games coming over the next little bit um i would never say no to like uh continuing our story of writing new chapters in the chronicle so fair enough yeah i think i maybe i might like it just a little bit less than you or at least maybe want to come back to it a little bit less than you i've absolutely had a blast with this game i've loved exploring this win or lose it's always so fun having the kind of like the big moments that happen throughout the game i just think for how long it is and for how much we still have been checking the rules i don't think i'm going to be the next the person to suggest it because next time we have let's say three hours free on a game night there might be other games that i want to play more rather than you know getting back into oath and having to check the rules again kind of thing um but it's something i've been so

happy and i feel so lucky to have been able to actually play a game like this of this quality um multiple times over with people because there's just so much to explore here yeah for sure so yeah that's all our thoughts on oath so as you can see we both liked it to different degrees but obviously no game's perfect so uh let us know in the comments uh where you land how much did you like it you know how are you still playing with a gaming group do you how if you do how often do you meet like tell us your experiences if you want to get really in depth put in the comments what like a really memorable moment from one of your games was because there were some here we didn't share because we wanted to hold back from spoilers and certain things but i would love to hear how other people's games have gone i think i could read thread after thread of like experiences from oh yes because they're so unique and different yeah and that's maybe the coolest thing is thinking that every single person who has a copy of it on their shelf might have their own unique thing in that box because they have their own yeah their own tales in the book trade chronicle books and read a story right exactly yeah exactly everyone has their own unique story they're building so just very very cool yeah so that is our review of oath uh let us know what you think and again thanks uh for the leader games for sending us this um we are absolutely thrilled to be able to check it out and let us know in the comments what you think and otherwise we'll see you in the next one thanks for watching

Progress saved