Skip to main content
Loading video...

Underwater Cities Board Game Review

Transcript 15:42

I won't blame you if you're seeing underwater cities for the first time and going because honestly everything about this is fine it looks fine feels fine smells fine even talks fine okay let's not get silly we all know that this board game cannot talk because it's underwater cities comes from delicious games a new publisher who clearly did not get my memo that board games are not food over the course of 10 rounds you will build cities that are wait for it underwater in those cities you will build factories that will produce resources and with some clever finagling at the end of the game those resources will convert into points and the one with the most points wins so far that's the elevator pitch for every euro game ever but what if I told you that this game has domes sassy dolphins x-wing pilots a robotized octopus and kelp kelp yeah kelp because people under water need food and so you build your kelp farms and kelp is brilliant you can make literally anything out of it kelp bread kelp burgers kelp Cats literally anything that doesn't make any sense how would you for example make beer out of how did you get that so fast see right here is how you can make for example bear out of kelp oh yeah it also says that you say I ordered it after I

read the script and right there is the line when you point out to me huh does it say how we end this sketch that's just the surface level but let's dive deeper at the heart of this car driven engine builder sexy words were never spoken other three production phases have a look this is your underwater country it starts with one city but as the game goes on you'll build tunnels to connect new cities regular Hospital white non symbiotic or steamy brothel red symbiotic each city has spaces for factories you could build a lab that makes science a desalination plant that makes a credit or count farm that makes a kelp of course no one is giving you these factories for free and you'll often find that building a factory costs as much as it produces and considering that you'll at maximum only produce three times and one of those times is that the end of the game where you can't actually spend the resources anymore it feels a little stingy but every factory can be upgraded increasing its yield and here's the real kicker if a single city has two upgraded factors at the same time you will get a hefty dollop of extra right so because the city can only have three factories at most the best configuration is to have to upgrade a factories of the same type like these laboratories producing you a boatload of steel plastun science and then a further upgrade a factory of a different kind like this desalination plant right here yeah almost and it's certainly the best configuration for setting up your engine but at the end of

the game each city will score you points two points if you have a single type of factory four points if you have two types of factory and a whopping six points if you have three different types of factories which already poses a question do you diversify or do you double down let me paint a slightly broader picture for the first four rounds which is more than a third of the game we'll be working hard to set up these cities with running factories you'll start with a little kit of resources that don't get you very far and getting more is a real struggle every beat in underwater cities is a conundrum do i build a non symbiotic city which i most likely have the resources for or do i spend time trying to acquire biomatter a resource that isn't in your starting resources and isn't available as an action on the board but it will get me two points every production phase and then after turns in terms of what feels like mentally digging trenches finally the culmination of your work comes together like a surfer coasting a wave and then crashing into a pile of glorious kelp underwater cities drew some obvious comparisons to terraforming Mars because both of these games are card based engine builders where the goal is to set up an urban infrastructure in an inhospitable environment but honestly that where the similarities end whereas in terraforming Mars the game will show you with rewards every single round of which there are likely to be many creating some wonky economies this game has a

much more restricted approach but when you Sisyphus finally push that Boulder on top of that hill you will be tumbling down in riches as much as we made this game sound laborious every time you get to act is an absolute delight at the beginning of your turn you will always have three cards all you have to do is select from a dwindling plethora of actions so for example you could get yourself a bunch of resources or build a tunnel or if someone actually stole the action you wanted to take and you're feeling a little bit salty get yourself a desalination plant or two so if you want something you better act quick because each time you take an action you block it off for the other players that round that is a new or exciting that's just worker placement but if underwater cities was a bear than that bears board game board isn't too big or too loose it is just right for example there are only two spaces that let you upgrade your factories regular ngon upgraded factories are fine but in the same way like being hit by a thunderstorm and getting home and being happy that your underwear is still partially dry kind of fine one of these spaces lets you upgrade free things at the cost of one science per thing the other spot lets you upgrade one thing and do some other incidental actions but

you won't be swimming in science and guess what is the one reliable space on this board to actually get science that's right the space that lets you upgrade things in alternative mode and consider now that each round only one person can actually go on that space what's that Quinn's did I hear you say knife fight in a phone booth more like a shark fight in a bathtub ah but what's with these free cards you might ask oh nothing they're just this you know thing pretty much the thing that makes the game but whatever who cares I care here's the deal every time you go to take an action you must also play a card if the card is of the same color then you get to do the action that is on the card as well but if the card is of the wrong color then what's so hard about this it's just free colors how hard is it to magic hard to an action space a lot of these cards are really really good but they're also really really situational this card lets me build a city for free right well no I still have to pay all the regular resources this a little bit of a discount but it doesn't cost me an action and this deck is a gigantic

menagerie of effects some that are instantaneous some that permanently alter the rules of the games of the trigger during production and some that you have to take a special action to activate a much like a trainer you'll be assembling your roster of pokémon each meant to deal with a specific problem but focus too much in things that you want and you'll end up with a hand that looks like this and not a single action on the board that you want to take that wouldn't match this color and since you're limited to having only three pokemons in your hand you'll very soon get to that bit where you face a trainer that has every type that counters your types and then you'll start hating every pokeball that you have ever thrown are we still reviewing underwater cities yes but to turn from comparisons from terraforming Mars even further I would posit that this game is a lot more like brass okay the different games yes but this you must play a card every turn and that card is at the same time liberating and restricting because there's literally about a hundred possible decisions but you know what you want but how do you actually get it game play reminds me of the claustrophobic Lea invigorating feeling you get from brass yeah right but I think you're gonna give people the wrong impression

in brass you so often get a kick of leveraging your opponent's actions to your advantage and that is not at all what's happening here uh-huh but there is some confrontation in the workers selection aspect if you can figure out what your this board is so tight if you can figure out what your opponents want you can swing in and snatch it before they do it's like comparing cherries outs with Jigglypuff ish it's not the same see I brought it back round to pokemon nice nice why are we saying damn cuz it's a long review Elaine and we're not really done yet honestly I'm pretty sure it's a recommendation for me it's fun it's tight it's dynamic it's slow it's really really slow despite its setting it's less like surfing on a board and more like swimming through golden syrup Jemaine tray cool no she that's trademark in fact whilst you can certainly think on your opponent's turns I have felt myself slowing down so much that I started thinking about my Turner became painfully aware that it's actually now my turn and the other players are staring at me and now I'm thinking of that instead of actually thinking about my turn and oh my god somebody just please take me away in fact whilst the line inevitably comes up with a strong rebuttal I don't think this time to squeeze in just a few more criticisms many reviewers have noted that this game just falls apart with

four players because the game length balloons from a sleek dolphin to a bloated well and was I'm still perfectly happy playing this with two or three players the four player game is as barren a wasteland as the surface world this oceanic dystopia is depicting that minor of course my real bear comes with scoring and I think fans of your games might be left scratching their heads at this because the scoring in this game is the same as the scoring in any bog-standard euro game right at the centre of this board you have special cards in fact they are so special but just getting one of them requires a separate action but the rewards are so nice that it's worth the distraction alternatively there's some special end of game scoring cards that are gone when they're gone and they'll reward you for whatever strategy you've settled on it works it's serviceable but I just didn't find myself that engaged by it at the end of the game unless this entire pile of resources and I was left asking myself is that what that effort building this entire engine amounted to stuff and points is that what makes my underwater nation great that might just be my growing dissatisfaction with non innovative euro game scoring talking which is certainly appropriate for some games especially lighter puzzles that are a touch more abstract but it feels a

little remiss here in something that's just more thematic and more expansive but let's talk about the components because this game looks like it was made 10 years ago with toilet paper thin flare boards and artwork that the best compliment I can come up for is practical and sometimes downright intimidating imagine opening up your body a box for the first time and finding something like this if you were new to games you would run for the hills ok I agree in many respects underwater cities does feel like a 10 year old game but in a time where board game fans are dissatisfied by many of the current releases I'm reminded of all the great games that were published a decade ago and how perfectly this fits in with them this player reference sheet is probably the best example it's scary yeah but when you learn the game you have to admit that this is brilliant look at it and you just see everything you need to know it reminds me of when I first learned race for the galaxy and its seemingly impenetrable iconography that when understood becomes like a second language I was suddenly bilingual speaking race for the galaxy just as fluently as I was speaking English that's a good point and another good point in this game's favor probably one of the best rule books written for a euro game ever exactly you've got a game that makes sense not only thematically in terms of what's going on but it's

easy to recommend as the next step for someone who's played something like Catan it's quite a bit more complex but the care that's been put into this manual means that with a bit of perseverance most people will learn to tame this and wildebeest and we haven't even mentioned that the player boards are asymmetrical encouraging different play styles each time you sit down to play and heck there's even an option for more asymmetry it's like walking into an ice cream parlor and finding there's an option for more ice cream do you not want more ice cream Edgar I like my ice cream just fine but the asymmetry is what ultimately bothers me about scoring in this game sometimes a combination of a particular board and personal scoring objectives feels like an accidental blessing and sometimes it's just a disjointed mess a competent black could be dealt a winning hand before they even made their first move see that just doesn't bother me if you start playing and realize something it's not working then change it make this game your own and with so much variability this is a box that you can dive into and find joy in again and again and you have to admit this game is fun and we would be mistaken not to recommend it okay I agree I think we can definitely give it the Elaine recommends and FK also recommends but has some minor hesitations rosette which in some circles is a very prestigious rosette don't you just love saying the word like a tiny rose why don't you tell our viewers what are we going to be getting up to at UK games actually I'm gonna be

doing a Victorian parlor game show which is that European leg of the tour we did it at chucks in Canada it's a link right here this one is on Saturday at 4 p.m. at UK games Expo we wanted to say before we sign off that we're sorry we've been gone for so long that's because we took a little holiday after our Kickstarter and then Elaine God knock off measles which is too much information so bye-bye

Progress saved