Skip to main content
Loading video...

Francis Drake Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 12:44

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings and we generally like to talk a load of bollocks at tablesoft gaming in general and in this video we're going to be looking at an older game we're going to be looking at peter hall's francis drake and in this game you'll be first going shopping in plymouth and then you'll be taking your crew and guns out onto the seas of the caribbean and trying to pilfer riches that you're not entitled to right so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not francis drake is still worth playing about 13 is it 2008.

seven years after it's first released in 2013 so remember if you're new here please consider subscribing to this channel if you haven't already leave a comment a lot about all right crap and we'll see you after this bollocks so francis drake how'd you play this game so francis drake is split over two phases you've got the plymouth shopping phase and then you've got the sailing out into the sea nicking stuff phase right everyone's gonna get a ship and they'll put it in the docks of plymouth arbor and then you'll get a variety of components like disks and stuff some with numbers on you'll get a ghost ship and you'll get a golden high mark which you may or may not use later in the game right so the first thing you're going to do is you're going to go shopping in plymouth full supplies you're going to take your little discs and you will place them on one of the available spots on the location that you want to get stuff from right one thing you've got to be mindful of is that you can't go back which is good for me because i bleeding shopping so once you've gone to a spot all the stuff that's behind you is now off limit so you've got to choose wisely you might want to go shopping for crew crew i use to defeat troops when you attack forts and towns right in the second phase you might go shopping for guns you need guns to attack forts you might go shopping for supplies this will allow you to venture further out into the caribbean because it's split up into four different zones so one two three and four right you need one two or three supplies to go to zone one two or three

and you need four supplies to go to zone four so you can also get a pinis yeah i know it's a never-ending joke when we play this and i've got a credit steve for this because he did tell me that he does suffer from a lot of penis envy right so love that joke so there's also the tavern where you can roll a diet and get a certain amount of crew and if you roll a one or two you get a ghost ship which is like a bluffing ship it doesn't actually do anything but you can basically try and fall people into thinking you've gone somewhere when you ain't you go to shipyard which gives you a galleon which you need to attack the spanish fleets and then there's a variety of personalities that will mess with the game like francis drake you've got the queen the governor the admiral and informer the gold mined and everyone gets an investor card which allows them to lose four victory points but get a little bit of a bonus right once everybody has done their shopping and loaded their ships up with booty it comes time to venture out into the spanish main and try and steal stuff from people what you do you take your discs numbered one to four and you will place them on a location on the board like we said you've got to be mindful about the amount of supplies that you have collected because that will limit the amount of locations you can go to and when you place a discount you've got to think about what number you place because these discs will be resolved from low to high right so number one will be resolved first also if you've got the gold nine then you will be able to resolve that first one so it gives you a leg up as well you've also got to be aware that there are limited amount of spaces right so you can still go to these spaces but there's only going to

be two spaces that are going to be resolved for battles right so once everyone's placed out all their numbered disks you will reveal all the disks and you place them in number order and then you will resolve each location's disks from low to high so the player that played the lowest disc will get a chance to attack you will have to discard the amount of guns or crew that the board tells you to so it might be the case that you might have to discard two crew and two guns and there's also the unknown quantities of the tiles that need to be revealed on the forts and also the fleet there's also the restrictions of having a galleon when you're attacking the spanish fleet so if you successfully attack a fort a fleet or a town then you'll get the number of victory points that are listed on the board if you're the first person to successfully attack the town or the fall you'll get the gem that is placed on the location and you'll stick it in your little treasure chest there's also different sets of commodities that you can collect that will give you a varying amount of each point so this is important to collect as well and if you've got the admiral or the governor that will allow you to hoover up any gold or silver gems that are left out through people that made mistakes once you've had enough of pilfering the spanish main then you can go back to port you might get heroes bonus with a couple of which points if you end your turn early so you'll do this for three voyages and at the end of each voyage you'll do some end of round scoring you'll get victory points for different locations that you've conquered at the end of the game you'll do it a little bit differently you'll get points for different sets of commodities you've got if you've got all four get 26 victory points and these

stack up so it's in your interest to get as many of these sets as you possibly can you'll do three voyages you'll do the end of game scoring and then the player with the most victory points will be the winner francis drake so what do we like about francis drake so the first thing that we like about francis drake is the component quality is absolutely unbelievable when this was released in 2013 i almost wept myself when out of the box it looked absolutely astonishing the fact you get a little treasure chest you can play about with and stick you stick your gold and silver and stuff in there it made me want to go upstairs and back one off right but you've got the jewels as well which look fantastic on the board the artwork on the board is reminiscent of one of those oldie wieldy maps and this is just a tro of wonderful components it may look a bit dated compared to some of the kickstarter miniature games that you got today because things have moved on quite a bit but it still looks absolutely fantastic it's a huge sprawling mass of a game on board and it does look absolutely amazing so next thing we like about this is that the personality is messed with the game quite a bit and there's quite a few personalities in the game queen lets you upgrade your frigate to a galleon it gives you a couple of bits so if you get left behind on the guns or the trade goods that you use to collect commodities then going to see the queen and doing a favor might be in your interests so if you go to the informer this allows you to mess about with the discs on the board it allows you to have a look at some of the discs location that you're present at and it allows you to swap them around if you want so this is like a sneaky way of

altering the order of play after it's been sorted out so you might take the gold nine of which case this is the disc that will be resolved first it's a nice way of going first even if you're not going first so we really like the fact that the personalities mess up the game and allows you to sort of jig things around after you've locked in your stuff so the final thing that we like about francis drake is the fact that you not only need to worry about what you're getting and where you're going to be placing your disc but you've also got to be equally aware about what your opponents are going to be doing because if you're concentrating on amassing your own supplies and amassing your own guns and worrying about how far you can get on a map your opponent might be able to sneak ahead here right so this game is just as much about preventing your opponents from going where they want as it is from going where you want and this produces a bit of a quandary done it because if blocking your opponents you're going to be limiting the amount of stuff that you can get and you might have to in plymouth mainly go to locations and collect resources that you don't necessarily need but the fact that you're limiting the amount of victory points that your opponents can get means that the victory points that you're going to get are going to be worth more so it's a very interesting choice and it's an agonizing choice and that's one of the things that we really like about these euro style games is that they do tend to tear your brain in half so what time we like about francis strike so the first thing that we don't like about francis drake is that this game at

the end of the day is just placing discs on a board and you know i know that you'll be collecting resources but there's not really anything else to do right it's just a case of putting your disc on a board collecting a load of resources stick them on your mat and then taking a bigger disc and then sticking it out to the board and that's basically it there is a couple of expansions i can't remember when i was montezuma's revenge or something well they were released as little promos but amalgamated into uh an expansion that has a sixth player i'm not sure that would work we haven't played with the expansion so we don't really know but at the end of the day i suppose if you want to be cynical and more often than not i am you could just relegate this down to putting discs on a board and that isn't going to excite the anti-euro game posse out there so the second thing that we don't like and we're a bunch of hypocrites here because we've already said the component quality is outstanding is that it might be the case that this game is over produced when it was released this game was quite a lot of money i think it's about 60 odd quid and for 2013 that was an astronomical amount of money but this has been seen on sale recently few people i know have seen this for as low as 20 or 30 quid right was it overproduced was it too expensive for what it is because we've already said that it's just placing discs on the board could they have made it cheaper with maybe cardboard shits or maybe some euro cubes i don't know but there's something odd about the way that the game is so simple it's juxtaposed

against the lavish quality of the game right and it's something just doesn't match there so the final thing that we don't like about francis drake and this leads on from the other two points is that the theme sort of gets lost as you're playing a game right once you leave plymouth the theme just melts away and there's no real sense of exploration there's no real sense of actually going on a voyage and doing stuff because it's just like we said placing discs on a board so if there'd been something else in there that maybe locked the theme in made you feel like you're actually sort of making progress in some way rather than just placing discs and resolving them that would have been a welcome innovation so to summarise it's francis drake still worth your time and bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes absolutely i love francis drake it's a wonderful brain burning game that is really really simple to learn the shopping experience in plymouth stands in stark contrast to my shopping experience in reality because normally i just want to get in get out right when i'm shopping in this game i want to take as long as possible and peruse the establishments at a pace where i can think about it right this game does suffer from the theme getting lost in amongst all of the lavish components were you would have thought that a game that offers so much in that department this would transfer over to the actual gameplay but it doesn't really do that so you've basically got to accept

that this game is just a standard euro fest where you just could be placing discs out of board and agonizing over where you're gonna go right and that's not gonna excite everybody but every time we play this we always have an absolute blast there's conflict in blocking people from going to certain spaces and the game is always a close affair right so yeah francis drake is a superb euro game experience it might be a little bit overproduced a bit too big on the table for what it is so there's a bit of a quandary there trying to figure out exactly what this game actually is so yeah we do wholeheartedly recommend francis drake if you want a top-notch simple euro game experience if you don't don't touch it with a 10-foot barge pole but there you go that's francis drake so remember if you're it please consider subscribing to this channel if you ain't already hit the like button make a comment and all that bollocks and we'll see you in the next video

you

Progress saved