Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 185: Eric Zimmerman on Teaching Game Design

Transcript 1:00:00

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations at this very moment Greg lauring Albright's keep the faith is crowdfunding on backer kit it's a light RPG about the evolution of a new religion and I'm working on the curriculum guide for it so you already know I think it's great so keep an eye out for it I will also mention that if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com onol and help me keep the lights on but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beond solitier and this week on the Pod I have a very special guest this is Dr Eric Zimmerman he's an Arts professor at NYU game center and hold on I'm not I'm not actually a doctor no okay got you we'll re we'll rewind and we can talk about that rewinder you can keep you can keep me correcting you yeah I'm less educated less educated than you might think hey you know what you're still an Arts Professor n gam Center and a game designer so counts to me Professor practice baby nice okay so actually this kind of leads right into some of the stuff I wanted to talk about um which is you know you are a game designer you teach game design uh but that is not yet an academic traditional like pathway or professionalized pathway for people going to game design so how what does your educational background look like and then how have you ended up teaching game design specifically how did I get here yeah well actually I studied art as an undergraduate so when

I was uh I got a BFA in painting as my undergraduate degree um Bachelor of Fine Art and I got a master of Fine Art in art and Technology um so even though I'm not really a programmer I'm not really a technical person it was kind of like a a media arts sort of program sort of interdisciplinary um but it was still fine arts program so I actually right after graduate school I started working in the video game industry so I got an internship at a company in New York City and uh they ended up hiring me um actually the story is that I got the internship between my two years as a as a master student so that summer came to New York City got an internship and then they wanted to hire me and said you don't need to go back to school you don't need a master's degree what's that big deal but I ended up sort of negotiating that I was hired full-time while I was still a student and I was flying back and forth and doing some a lot of my school workor remote and ended up anyway so it was a very very busy year but I got I I hustled that through um and I ended up working in the video game industry for I mean since then I've been working I had my own studio for a while that I founded with Peter Lee um called gam lab um did a bunch of freelance work and also always was interested in tabletop games too so even though it's not been always like the main my main focus um uh I've you know published tabletop games and have a

number of tabletop games that I'm working on these days so um that's uh that's and then in terms of Academia like how I ended up becoming a professor was that the I was so I had just started working at this company New York City called RGA which had an interactive division they were making games and websites and other interactive things and I heard that at the ITP program which is the interactive telecommunications program and NYU it's kind of like a an interactive digital media type of program but it's not necessarily games focused um students do all kinds of Technology experiments and design experiments there um I heard that somebody we were working with said oh you know they wanted me to teach a game design program but no I I wouldn't want to do that I wouldn't and I was like suddenly I was like hold on a second they wanted you to teach a game design program I want to teach that class so so I ended up teaching that class and dragging along With Me Frank Lance who I was working with at the time who later became the founding director of the NYU game center but he and I started in like the the mid 1990s teaching that class at ITP and for many years I was teaching just as an Adjunct professor so for really for decades I was just teaching one class a semester um taught and then

I was teaching at other places like Parson School of Design uh MIT media lab um not not sorry not MIT compartive media studies School of Visual Arts these different kind of programs and things and a lot of it at NYU as well so I've just been teaching for a long time then eventually after gam lab um closed down and and I was doing freelance game design work I made the switch over to becoming a full-time Professor right around the time that they were starting the NYU Game Center so that rather than just teaching a class here and there became a whole full-fledged Department um and now we are in the School of Fine Arts so we're in Tish School of the Arts at NYU um that means that our orientation is that games are a form of culture so we see games as shoulder-to-shoulder with like film and dance and and um uh other forms of kind of cultural creative expression so rather than like we don't have a technology Focus we don't have a business focus or even like a games and learning Focus we try and get our students to think about who they are as designers and artists and what they want to say and what they want to express through games um through games as their cultural medium um so that's yeah I don't know I think I'm answering your question a very long-winded way but that's kind of like the the the cutus route that that that led me there and meanwhile I've always been making games so um you know my quote unquote research as a professor is the games that I make so one of the nice things about Tish is

that I don't have to publish peer-reviewed white papers I don't have to bring in research grants um I just they just want us being active in our field so my creative practices whatever I want it to be including this podcast right now so um but for me it's mostly making games that's awesome yeah one thing I wanted to ask actually is I'm I'm really I I love that you started talking about like the way that you frame games as like cultural interactive objects as a part of the Arts because um one I we will return to this but uh my friend Dan thow likes to say that games are not art and I would like an artist opinion on this but uh but um I also you know want to talk about sort of the professionalization of of game design because you know you just did an Arts education and started designing games um most game designers are just people who start designing games at this particular point in like the fields development you know I'm just a post act person I was a high school teacher and then I became a game designer just because that was what I was doing in my spare time I wouldn't even know how to tell people how to design a game so um what kind of Trends do you see I guess within the Ed World um you know in terms of game design becoming uh something that is taught um I mean is it spreading is it just a few places and then also how are people framing that right I mean that's a really big question I think that um we can kind of talk about two ways

that games are used in like a learning situation right on the one hand there are programs like mine where people are specifically coming to study game design and then on the other hand there is people using games in a in a classroom situation where it's not like a game design class but it's like we're going to use a game or game design thinking in some way in what we're doing so I've been sort of part of both of those um kinds of things again the games I make are not educ games they're mostly you know commercial entertainment games um but the I'm also have done a lot of work on on um educational games and and my main job now in NYU is teaching people game design who want to become game designer so yeah I don't I don't know where to start I guess I guess the you asked me what the biggest Trend with I think the biggest trend is that when I was starting uh you know to teach game design um people really turned up their nose at games so there there's there's this there's this uh this thing that happened to me when I was teaching when I first started teaching in NYU I remember thinking to myself you know why do I feel like the head of this program kind of like isn't super into game design doesn't see it as this cool amazing thing sort of is like somehow brushing off our class I didn't know exactly why and then I was walking by

the hallway and I saw this poster on the wall and the poster was from Voyager now at the time in the 1990s Voyager was like this super trendy cdrom company CD ROMs were this new new storage technology and um but Voyager was doing things with like Brian Eno and Lori Anderson and like they were publishing this sort of multimedia titles um really really cool and they had this poster they had this poster for um this contest called new voices New Visions and um the idea was oh let's get new people that want to design for this interactive medium and the judges of the contest were people like I mean Lori Anderson was there um William Gibson who like you know invented cyber Punk sort of or I guess not but like was instrumental in uh starting that whole genre um um uh the the the um the the author of of mouse Arts speleman that that uh um that graphic novel uh that about World War II um I don't know Terry Gilliam the director of um uh Brazil and you know a Monty Python alumni like these were the incred incredible cultural Gatekeepers of the time right they were the judges in this contest so on the poster it said do not enter this contest if you think home shopping encyclopedia and video games are the future of the

internet it was like video games is just totally being lumped in with all this crap that was like obviously home shopping encyclopedias and video games like the most boring yeah I guess in their case video games were like they were kid stuff they were addictive they were violent they were like the junk food of popular culture right so so why am I why am I going into this detail because um it hit me was like oh now I get it now I get it why the game design class like like there's this whole whole universe of people that don't see games as like this obviously this cool interesting form of culture but just see it as like this kind of wasteland um and I think the biggest change is that basically that has totally turned around right that there was games really have spread throughout the culture and at this point for example if you're talking about like an elementary or junior high school classroom the teacher is now someone who grew up playing games and doesn't have this bias and doesn't have this idea of like oh games like why like why would I you know why would I feed junk food to the kids in the cafeteria it's like no no no they get it they realize that games are you know really engaging and that they can teach all kinds of Social and cognitive and intellectual and and creative skills so for me that's been like the biggest changes was kind of like the general acceptance of games as a cultural form yeah seeing hearing games talked about the way like hurt my soul a little bit oh yeah but that's in the past baby

so we're doing okay now oh God thankfully so the other thing that I've noticed you know just in my conversations with academic Sor I didn't mean to call you baby that sounded a little weird but no we're good we're good we're good I say it all the time too and then I wondered the same thing I don't that was rhetorical that was not usually the language I use no no so one thing I have noticed um and in conversations with the academics over the last few years is that video games I feel like are much more mature in terms of their Acceptance in the academic Community uh in terms of both people who are looking at them for something like reception studies like oh let's look at the presentation of the ancient world uh but in video games and then also in design I think because computer science is also sort of like a hot thing to go study so you know you mentioned that board games have not always been at the Forefront for you so how have they kind of crept into your classroom and what do you see as like their kind of current status in the in the world of people taking game design courses right well it's weird to so board games have not always been the focus of my professional career but they've definitely always been a huge part of my gaming uh diet as a player so you know I grew up playing Dungeons and Dragons starting in fifth grade um and grew up just playing and inventing all kinds of board games just kind of ravenously so really grew up as a board game player board game designer um and in my classroom I'm not a I'm not a uh

programmer so and Frank Lance who I was teaching with he's also not a programmer so when we first got this class we were like how are we going to teach game design you know we're not going to have students making video games so what can we focus on that's going to teach what we feel are kind of like the basic elements of games but that are not um you know going to be about coding and digital production and basically the class focused on tabletop games so that we were we were having them make physical games uh social games card games board games as a way of learning about design and that is still very much um part of my practice today uh is that the you know I use um you know I we we're doing playground style games we're doing you know they're modding board games they're playing and analyzing tabletop games then that's the focus of the class and and that's that's how I teach design um and so for me I feel like I'm not I'm not really teaching them board game design although obviously they're going to learn that but what I'm teaching are the sort of fundamental things that for me about being a design student which is like collaboration and problem solving um how to communicate ideas how to think in terms of systems how to you know prototype um how to design meaningful choices how to tell stories interactively so there's sort of like

all of these fundamentals of um making things um and thinking through how do I approach a problem right what's how what's the process I'm going to use to get from where I am now which is I have an idea to over there where I have a finished something you know to turn in so t top games are my method for that oh that's really really interesting um and then you know you mentioned you know you're not necessarily teaching board game design you're teaching like steps towards I guess behaving creatively uh yeah I don't know I mean I don't want to use you know you could say design thinking but there for me they're design classes I'm teaching design and and games are the way I'm are the my main method for teaching design but we're we're getting into the craft of games I mean okay get me wrong we're talking about you know Victory conditions we're talking about balancing game economies um all you know we're talking about player Behavior you know what it means to win or lose cooperation competition all of these tabletop stuff but they're like the the occasion and the concepts that we're kind of juggling um to you know to learn through doing so I feel like this kind of leads me to like you can teach people about what are Victory conditions how do I make meaningful choices here are some ways I can express myself but I feel like teaching art of any kind has to be really hard because you can teach people all the technicals but that

doesn't mean that they're going to make something that works right and so how do you handle that like in a classroom situation how do I how do I get them to point towards something that's creatively interesting you mean yeah and then you know what happens if they don't I mean I'm assuming that you just grade them on other things I don't know how that works like you have to assess as a teacher too that's hard well this is yeah it's super interesting question and I feel like um let me talk about the first part before I can talk about grading because I think that I'm actually really interested to talk about that but in terms of the um how you get them somewhere interesting it's all about scaffolding right so that's kind of like what what teaching is which is like how do you give them enough structure so that they know what they're doing um and but still enough Freedom so that they can kind of find their own way um and I would say that that's that's what teaching is that's also what you know game design is right I mean that's the same thing if you're designing an experience for players you're like how do I provide enough structure to sort of guide them so that they're going to have um kind of a focused experience but they're still going to be be able to be clever and creative and express themselves um so you know I for me figuring out what those constraints are on a project how

do I structure their creativity is a huge part of it and I'll just give you a quick example one of the sort of beginning exercises I do is called what's wrong with Rolland move and I and I designed it because so many students end up like if you're not really like a super literate game player you think oh it's a board game so I roll some dice and move move a piece and I get to the end and they end up with this sort of like boring rolling Move games and it's a huge like gravity Source like drawing them towards that design conclusion so I thought you know what maybe I'll just do an exercise where we just we kind of like try and wash that out of them so everybody starts when we play a Rolland move game so it's like okay they play they roll dice and I have the rules kind of like on cards so it's like here's the setup card here's the winning conditions card here's what you do on a turn card so it's kind of like visual rules for them and then and then we discuss we're like okay what is wrong with this let's really talk about what's wrong so you can actually end up with a whole long list of reasons like what was wrong with that game well the obvious one is that there's no choice it's just 100% random it's like Candy Land but with a die you know but also um uh there's things like there's dead time if it's not your turn and if you fall behind there's no way to catch up and you know sort of a long list of things that kind of make it a boring game so then to improve the

game I pass out new cards so I've come up with all these cards that have to do with like movement or interaction between pieces the the size and shape of the grid and they every group gets about 10 cards different categories and they don't have to use them all they can just take two or three of them and try and integr them into their game and and when you have like a simple rule like okay if you you can you know rather than going in turn order the last player always goes next or um if you de see how far you move everybody chooses a number on a die secretly and then reveals it and if your number is unique you get to move that many so like little mechanics that will sort of help help guide them towards something interesting and they sort of turn that corner they turn a corner from like a boring game to like fun street it's like we're on boring Street this game like I'm rolling dice I'm moving stuff it's not that fun and suddenly it's like oh my gosh like I really care about every turn like I'm making interesting choices and so giving them that experience but I'm scaffolding it's like okay I'm giving you these cards that sort of help help get you there but at the same time there're still doing analysis they're still doing um iteration they're having to try stuff out they're saying like Okay that doesn't work if we change this rule we have to change some other rules what other rules do we need to change they're still thinking in terms of systems and they're play testing you know their own games um then there's a later thing which is like they they theme it they figure out what is the theme that's good

for this and that's a whole another thing so I guess I'm explaining this this exercise just to say that um you know sort of like very carefully designed exercises now that's like it in class like let's G to do this let's do this for the next hour or two exercise there's also like you're going to take the you're going to be doing stuff at home over a couple of weeks and really iterating um and and modifying the game often that starts with like if we're working on narrative games they might be given assigned a game that they um uh have to play and analyze and then they might be given like a piece of narrative content like a short story um Octavia Butler short story or something like that and then they then they have to think about okay how do I how do I translate this into a game and they might even be given a genre or format like you're doing a Cooperative um simulation right or you're doing a um an interactive book as your format or or you're doing a you know a puzzle escape room on a tabletop kind of kind of experience so so that they're not having to invent the whole thing from scratch and the key game that they played and analyzed is tied to that format so again just trying to like guide and and structure their way way through the experience um and usually it works out okay but you know the the other thing that you asked about Liz is like well what happens if it doesn't work that's okay too it's like um you it's okay if they uh if they um if if they don't if they fail quote unquote fail right so

that's and that kind of leads to the second part of your question about grading um there's a there's a professor at um uh here at at the game center Alexander King game designer and he he um he started doing these blog posts about grading and like you know I've started doing research and maybe grades actually aren't that great for Education right so basically he he sort of sharing with our community like you know what actually grades are not um uh are not really tied with um achievement or academic Behavior or even learning right that they can actually be detrimental for all of these different reasons um and it's he was proposing and then he started trying out in his classroom things like ungrad where students give themselves grades for example um and it's had a huge impact on my teaching so basically a few years ago I just stopped grading projects I'm like you know what you're making a game it feels weird to give you a grade um and instead it's like if you do something if you fulfill the requirements if you turn turned into game this is a narrative game you have a fully playable game with all the rules even if it's quote unquote good or bad or broken not broken Innovative whatever you'll get full credit for it you do it your group did it that's great so that's and that's

completely it's completely changed my teaching in a positive way to do that um to not sort of hold over grades over students anymore I know I don't maybe we're straying too far from uh from games Liz but no I think not at all um I mean you know I like talk about education too and this makes me think of my own time like I'm no longer in the classroom but we switched to standards based grading and essentially allowed unlimited retakes because that was like the amount of flex that I had within like a high school setting to like just not grade things in that way but I also think about you know it's very hard so I taught Latin but we taught it like um like a real language as opposed to like memorizing charts you know uh but we talk about something called the aect of filter a lot in the school of Latin teaching that I did which is where if people feel pressure If you correct mistakes too often if they feel too judged then they will not learn because they're too busy trying to please you and they're not busy enough trying to actually learn anything and I feel like perfectionist student me would have freaked out in a class like yours and wanted to take it at the same time so I guess I was just sort of curious like how do you like bring enough relaxation out of your students I mean yeah that's so I I I that makes perfect sense what you're saying because when I first started not grading projects it was like this fog which was

in the classroom just kind of like cleared away that I didn't even realize was there because I had just been teaching with it for years and years and the fog was students trying to figure out like okay you're saying that it's this but what do I really need to do to get the a like what's okay you're saying that I should experiment and this and that but in the end like what's going to get me a better game even the ones that were like very independent and creative they still had that going on in their heads you you can't not right especially today students are very grade conscious um they feel like they're paying all this tuition so they're basically paying for you know the degree with good grades it's going to get them a job but as soon as I took that away all of that fog cleared and the students were so much more um open to experimentation and did such more interesting creative work and you know for years I had always said I would rather see an interesting project that's more of like a quote unquote failed experiment than a than a than a balanced but boring game right something that's that works but it's totally safe don't do that but on the other hand if you're rolling up to the final crit after like two or three or four weeks of work and you're like here's our game oh by the way it's a it's a failed experiment it doesn't quite work it's sort of broken you know it's hard to give that game an A and it's hard to feel like it's on par

with something that is like solid playable balanced but totally generic right um because at least that one you can get all the way through but as long as then if I'm not grading it doesn't matter so every game gets hard-hitting critical feedback they get it verbally during the critique that we're play testing it they get it written feedback like a you know analysis from from the instructor but they don't get a grade um and it's just like yeah I don't know how how was your experience once you removed the I mean once you gave them the ability to retake was that that must have changed their relationship to the material it did yeah so one of the Great the best things about that job was that I was teaching in one of the largest public school voluntary Latin programs in the country we had about we had over 700 kids in the 3,000 kids school choosing to take Latin and there were five Latin teachers because what we were doing was working in the sense that students wanted to be in the classes you know you're more anxious students will of course just retake everything until they have 100 because that's who they are and like the class accommodates that even if I'm mild irritated you know okay fine you can take it again um but the other thing was great was that I felt like I brought more out of my students who maybe weren't traditionally excellent students so Latin actually was also a popular choice for students who were uh students with IEPs students with 504s who were not necessarily being able

to be their best in a more traditional classroom but because they had time to figure it out with me ah and could be assessed on a number of different like types of contributions to the class because I was caring about can you answer a question in Latin if I ask a question in Latin and they do something I can get credit for that you know and so by by kind of changing the way I was assessing to try to hit what I actually wanted to see and also give students multiple chances I feel like I got more out of more kids and that they got more out of me yeah that makes yeah that makes perfect sense to me um and I think for me it especially makes sense in like an art school it's like why would I grade your art project or design project but even in an academic uh setting I think that makes yeah that makes perfect sense um to just yeah change change the relationship with the grading system I mean we know this from game design right it's like we use Victory conditions and end conditions as a way of shaping players experience and their relationship with the whole game so how can you shift it in a way so that it's like the victory condition isn't like hanging out somehow outside the system and experience but it's really helping motivate the kind of core activity a core experience that you want your players or your students to to to to have yeah so there something that you said earlier that does have me thinking though this is a question I

don't know how to ask it because it always feels like a rude question but I also think it's an important question oh love rude question so and I also have mixed feelings about this so okay I am the queen of having like I've made zero practical choices in my life I went to college and I studied Classics and then I went and I got a PhD in ancient Christianity and I studied Coptic and it was amazing this is not the sort of thing that makes somebody money though um but the good thing is for me like I was a scholarship student and when you go into those like PHD programs like I got paid peanuts but I got paid I didn't have to pay them right a master's program in Fine Arts cost money and I actually remember not going to NYU when I was admitted as an undergrad because they offer me a scholarship that was just nothing on the tuition at NYU and also like you know I now have this game design job that I am so lucky to have this job it's like the only reason I left the classroom was because I got like it's like I I rolled a critical success and two through two or three of them in a row and like now I'm just here right no I I I I I'm I'm sure that you got that job because you're awesome not some through some random chance it years of effort combin with some luck but so I think about this though you know you have aspiring game designers you teach aspiring artists who want to work in fields that are extremely iffy at the best of times and they're paying a lot of tuition so like how how do I justify

that how do you justify how do you make sure they're getting something from you that they can take no matter what happens I think that's an excellent question and it's not rude at all and I ask myself all the time and I talk to my students about this all the time too NYU has perversely High tuition right that's a problem with the whole American University system I mean I even have friends that teach at like state universities that used to have like fairly inexpensive especially for instate tuition all of their tuition is going up and up and up as well so but NYU is yeah it's incredibly High tuition um I and okay so it often gives me paused to think about like what am I doing why am I contributing to this education system that in many ways is like an engine of inequality it's like oh rich people can afford to go to school so they get better education so they get better jobs people that can't afford to go to school um end up getting less education and it's like you know it's something it's like designed to kind of further separate the people you know rich people from from people that have less means so yes I I it's a huge problem and Challenge and so I guess I can answer that question a bunch of different ways because I think about this a lot one one thing I'm thinking about is well first of all NYU I think even though I really don't necessarily love the administration one

thing that they just started um I think for this coming fall which is fantastic is that they've instituted a new policy which is that if your family makes a less a combined income of I think a 100,000 or less I might be getting the exact number wrong then NYU will cover your tuition 100% for undergraduate this is for undergraduate and it is for anyone in the city outside the city United States um International that's still expensive to like if you're going to move to New York City and live here but at least in terms of tuition I think that that's an amazing uh thing that NYU is doing again I'm not I'm very critical of the NYU Administration I don't want to seem like I'm being a shill for them here but that one policy I think is fantastic um another thing I think about is that you know I we're in a school of the arts the biggest program in the art school is the acting program the theater program so students come in they want to be actors and there's like thousands of them it seems like uh in in the school and I know that they're going to graduate and be like waiting tables in tending bar going to auditions and a very very tiny percentage of them are going to be able to make a living as actors it's just it it's just acting is an incredibly brutal field right but I do feel like a couple things with game so first of all the game industry the video game industry it's in general booming now I know there's ups and downs

and right now a lot of companies are laying off people but in general compared to film compared to television compared to theater compared to book publishing compared to whatever cultural format you want to you want to name games year on year are a growing industry we they are potentially we're giving them really good job skills we are also really training them to work in the 21st century we're giving them technology skills we're giving them problem solving skills we're we're teaching them how to communicate we're teaching them how to collaborate um how how to solve problems how to work in media produce content our students actually many of them work in the game industry but those that don't can find they find jobs in like publishing or advertising or any kind of media or content or Technology field they're amazing problem solvers so I do feel like in that sense even though they're paying a ridiculous amount of money they're getting a really good degree and really good skills that can translate again don't I don't want to overemphasize job skills because I think that that's kind of like been the decline of the whole American you know there should be more students like you Liz that were like I'm here just to learn and study things and enrich myself um but and kind of study and learn for its own sake I you know I think that's better but in terms of trying to justify the tuition I think what we're teaching is actually really valuable I keep on trying to think about what are some hacks that we can do like I just

proposed this to our faculty um what if for example this year if we have an MFA student in our program that can't be admitted because um they can't afford to they just say like look I know you're giving me scholarship it's not enough I can't afford to be there what if we propose to them you know what we're gonna let you um we're going to let you attend all the classes you know enter the building use your resources but in the end you won't pay tuition and you won't get a paper degree but you'll but but we will vouch for you that you did all the things so I don't know there's also some problems with that but I'm just showing that as an example of like I'm really trying to think about are there some creative hacks we can do to kind of like help open up the our program even more somehow to to a public or to people to students that wouldn't otherwise be able to afford it so yeah it sucks it sucks that money makes the world go around especially in the United States you know yeah no it's It's just tough like it's it's expensive even at lower levels now to get an education but then if you're going for that like high futin Masters especially because master's degrees are cash cows for PHD programs right so I mean it's a tough it's a tough road um but I guess the one thing that I would ask then is before we move on to another topic is if you are talking to somebody who's interested in

doing a game design program with the interest of becoming a game designer um what would you tell them about the intentions and expectations they should come in with to make sure that they're walking the right path for them you mean if they're interested in like entering the industry or going to study it so if you're if you're planning to get the degree where should you think that you're going to go with that well first of all I would say you don't have to come to school to study game design right I think that there's lots of ways to um become a game designer to learn about game design to practice game design I feel like as long as you're playing games and making games and trying to meet other people that are doing the same thing you can eventually make your way into the industry I mean Liz I think you're excellent example of that right without a formal study I never studied game design it wasn't a thing one could do right so um okay but I'm not answering your question uh your question was like what are the expectations that you should bring like what do you mean by expectations like how much time you're gonna spend or no I think what you'll get out of it so like for example when I went to my PhD program I knew that the academic job market was a hellscape I knew um nobody lied to me about that but I went anyway and so I thought about it as like okay well I need to have some sort of alternate plan to go through

this um and you know I think I want to be a professor but if I don't what am I going to do and then how will I make sure that I don't feel like the six years that I spent in a PhD program was a waste of my time and like I in fact don't I in fact think it was amazing for me it was transformative for me as a person I learned a lot about writing and thinking and reading and I would go back and do it again in a heartbeat but it did not lead to a job um I also didn't try but you know I think that that's a I don't know maybe it could have but still like everybody thinks maybe it could and you roll the dice and some people just end up miserably trekking from post to postto so okay a few things one is that we actually make thinking about your life after school part of our curriculum so there's a class that everybody has to take called survival skills which is like what are you going to do after school what can you do with a game degree that class is like a whole bunch of visiting people that come and talk about their experience of like some of it is in games tabletop industry video game industry some of it is um people in like game adjacent Fields I went into the kind of like games and learning field I'm working in the art worlding in marketing advertising but doing interactive stuff um I'm working at a non-traditional company like at the New York Times games division right so like people coming in to talk about their experience and meanwhile you're working on your resume and portfolio how you present yourself how you find jobs and internships so it's not a class with a

lot of homework it's more like a let's all come and talk about this everybody has to take that before they graduate um and we have other things like we have an incubator program um so students can apply for that they get funding and mentorship for projects um and actually people that aren't even students can also apply to the incubator as well so if you people teams with a prototype T again tabletop or video game or even some something else um so we try and ease that transition we have like a you know like a incredibly active slack Community we have email we have all kinds of discords that are official and unofficial um where students in alumni are getting together they're posting job job opportunities internship opportunities um at their company or other places they know and at this point the game Center's been around for like 10 or more years so that's another benefit I think a lot of our students also want to end up teaching they want to teach uh as an adjunct they want to get on and get some of them even get phds and want to become full-time academics which you don't need necessarily to get to to teach game design but I might I don't know if I'm answering your question but um I think the expectation is that you will definitely like in our program we try and make it uh part of what we're talking about and teaching about I have advisees like every full-time faculty has like a whole like I have like 30 different students that are I'm advising and we always talk about I always ask them about what what what what are you

doing this summer you know are you thinking about internships like let's talk about what you're going to do when you graduate so like it's it's something to kind of keep them thinking about you know again and I want to find the balance your whole life shows you know you don't if you focus too much on um school as like job training then you're just G to kind of have a sort of a crappy functional education like you're not going to like fig you know open up new kind of creative doors in your you know in your potential like in your find new talents and new interests and things like that but you you also want to feel like you're not just like throwing money down a pit you know um and your time down a pit that it's that it's valuable and useful am I answering your question yeah I think so all right so we talked about kind of teaching game design and like going into a program for game design uh but you also are you know as we mentioned earlier right like you mentioned that you are both in teaching game design and in using games as a way to teach things so you're also a co-founder of The Institute of play and so you it's it's a nonprofit and you have opened a public school in New York City with play based learning I want to know all about this how did you get to this like how did you get somebody to let you over to school what's what are you doing what does it look like right so when I yeah when I had a was running game lab with Peter Lee we we kind of created a sister company or sibling

company The Institute of play a nonprofit and the whole idea was like let's investigate the intersection of games and learning and you know our Inspirations were things like um 862 Valencia the Dave Edgars company that was like a storefront where kids go in and learn about writing and are publishing books and things um Katie Salin who was my co-author on rules of play which is a kind of a standard textbook for game design these days Katie came in and was the director of The Institute of play for many years and I was always on the board of it um but I was not like full-time there so you're going to sort of get like a slightly I know want to say on the outside but I was never like 100% on the inside because I was doing a lot I was also running the commercial Studio at the time but what the Institute of play did was it looked at this this question of games and learning and it wasn't just okay students are playing games and the game is teaching them something so it was it was less about educational games and it was more about what is game like thinking and how can we translate that to an educational context so for example can we have teachers think more like game designers when they're thinking about designing their classroom space or designing lesson or running a project that students were making and in truth it was

really a lot of project-based learning that that the students were doing so a lot of collaborative work and doing things like maybe narrativizing a project so it was like okay these aliens are coming in to study humans and we have to like communicate with them and we have to like bring things to them and and invent things for them the whole the whole curriculum was a little bit redesigned so like for example one one one of the one of the spes was called code worlds and they were teaching math and English together as like symbolic languages and things like that so they're really playing with the curriculum um I think the maybe the most significant thing that they did was that they we had gotten a very big Grant from The Gates Foundation that paid for uh game designers to be in Residence at the school so there were two game designers who are basically Bally living at the school and teachers could just sort of come and collaborate with them and say like hey I have this I have this unit coming up on you know whatever US Government let's talk about how we can make like a government simulation as our next big project so those game designers were just constantly working with the teachers and making things and it was a great resource for them it's obviously not necessarily replicable not every school can afford to bring in game designers like that but it was really cool so um the the school did really well the students you know the students loved it the school still exists in New York City

it's called the quest tole learn school um and they did a lot of Consulting and collaboration on designing other schools as well so they they worked on a lot of different curriculum for different schools um a few years ago The Institute of play closed its doors so like many nonprofits they lasted for about 10 years they had a great run um but they've uh that nonprofit doesn't exist anymore so they're no longer directly involved in the quest to learn school which continues but they're it's really um was an amazing group of people and they were really well known for um uh innovating in this realm of of games and learning and games in the classroom and you know how you teach with games and everything so it was a wonderful experience I mean I you know for example at the end of each semester they had what they called a boss level and whole classrooms would have like a big challenge that they'd have to do together and I went in as a judge uh one semester and it was like uh rub Goldberg machine so the classes had to do like this giant Contraption where they're using all these like scientific principles and things to try and make a big machine um and we went in and they talked about their process and they showed it to us and then they ran the machines and we you know we had to give Awards and judge them and things like that so it was really cool so they were trying to structure the school like a game in a sense you know um in the sense of like having boss

levels and you know making making the day more playful for the students interesting oh that's awesome um so okay um I want to ask so we think about so we talk about game design thinking it's a way of teaching um it's potentially a job skill um but you're also also teaching games within an art context so just out of curiosity do you think the games are art and why or why not well I mean I okay this is like a old uh off off debated question I mean I mean it really really what the question inside that question is what art right yes and so in the in the in the 21st century like you know even a hundred years ago more than a hundred years ago you know Marcel Duchamp made Fountain right put a like wrote his name wrote the wrote a fictional name arm mut on a toilet put it in a museum and was like this is already made I want to undermine the whole idea of what art is and what's considered art and how we value art the cultural kind of Machinery that makes art happen this was like more than a hundred years ago that that that people were questioning these kind of fixed categories so I find usually inside that

question is like somebody's like idea of what art is in their head right so and I I feel like and I don't know if this is the case for you Liz but usually people have this idea of like well art is a sort of exalted um uh cultural category right that we aspire to um and I guess I would say like I would just want to question the question and it's like first of all art is also its own professional practice like art if you're if you're a working artist and trying to make a living at Art it's like not a hobby for you you're not like going to painting classes and stuff but you're really trying to do that hustle like art is like it's an industry it's a job it's an it's like a whole bunch of Institutions it's like certain people paying money for luxury goods you know through galleries or artists hustling for Grants through a system trying to figure out what are the big buzzwords this year who do I need to network with how can I like improve my artist statement to try and get more attention from a certain curator so like it's its own hustle and Industry and uh the art world is definitely um it's a thing right so in that CA in that in that sense um it's like there's some overlap there's plenty of artists that use games or there's lots of game designers that do projects that end up in museums including myself um uh but it's kind of like a separate thing but that's art seen from like an Institutional point of view but I think you know from an from a more like an Aesthetics point of view like can can game can we consider games as a sort of

lofty cultural form you know of course we can I mean of course we can it's in that sense it's a silly question not not that that you're asking a silly question it's interesting question but I I but the other thing is like why is Art the aspirational category like why why do again this let this goes all the way back to that story I told about like do not enter this contest if you know home shopping and encyclopedias and video games are the future of the Internet it's like why why not make games the aspirational category right like to me it's like you know in some ways the artwor wishes it had the juice that games does right like games video games tabletop games we are getting our audiences engaged we are doing things that are like both High art and mass media and pop culture and in education it's like why do we why do we have to why do we why do games have to be like the nerdy uh sort of wallflower in the cultural Pantheon uh you know wishing that we were more like art like like I that that's the thing I I that bothers me most about that question is like like let's let's actually like art should be nipping at our heels like art should be the one saying like oh we wish we were more like game so anyway so it's it's a complicated question I I I just love the question because everybody's answer is like so revealing even though it's a it's a common question like what is a war game is a common one in my world as well but um I ask uh just because I think that there is also sort of within board games people talk about okay well there is Art in board games you illustrate them but

like can sure a rules bound interactive activity where the designer may not even be present or have a lot of say about how the game goes still be art yeah but there's I guess what I'm there's there's so many schools of of contemporary Fine Art like people that are artists they're shown in museums they have big exhibitions they're getting funding that do that right like the whole flexus movement in the 1960s rule-based things the situationists um and and ulipo rule-bound procedures for generating behaviors or for literary work more recently there's kind of artist social practice um which is kind of like I'm as an artist I'm gonna in you know invent a cafe the in the lobby of the museum and that's my installation and the rules of capitalism are not going to hold here and I'm going to have my own different economy for how things are going to be paid for like that's a whole genre of Contemporary Art this idea of like can rule-bound things or procedures that are not directly authored like that's a very romantic idea of what art is it's like it has to be the hand of the artist placing it uh there's conceptual artists like you know um uh that uh like solowit in the in the 1960s was doing things that are like you know what museum here's the artwork the artwork is a set of rules and the rules are like draw draw 10,000 lines each at a slightly different angle within a

square you know 12 x 12 feet and like follow those rules and then that's the artwork and so every time um a uh a gallery shows this thing they have to redo it and it's a procedure it's an algorithm and it's totally process-based art and it's basically a game but it's not interactive like playable but everything that you were just saying so I guess what I'm saying is like the art world is full of examples of people that are already doing that so yeah of course of course games could fall in you know could could do that the idea that it's like it has to be authored by the hand of the artist is like a kind of an oldfashioned idea of what art is you know hell yeah I enjoyed this answer very much because it's a little spicy and it actually has like show me some more art to look at excellent um so uh we've kind of come to the end of this uh hour so I want to ask you what I ask everybody which is uh you know you're a gamer what have you played recently that has excited you or brought you some Joy um I oh I'm just gonna grab this off my desk I've been playing some oink games recently I've been getting into them uh someone I don't know if you've played uh Town 77 uh not this is a this is a beautiful little um it's a beautiful little game I love the I love the graphic design of the of the pieces and it is a it's a game that is incredibly approachable like I've played this with family members that are not at all game players um but it at the same time it's like the

game has a turn and it get suddenly gets very intense and strategic so it's like extremely approachable beautiful and like many oink games um you know awesome graphic design lovely packaging uh and uh and and beautiful game design too so this is a game that I've been playing Town 77 I can I also plug one more thing um please I've been working with this group of um uh were you gonna ask me for plugs at the end uh yeah no this the time this is plug away all right plug away okay I'm gonna plug two things if you're interested in like the stuff we've been talking about um using games to teach bringing games into a classroom or learning about game design through through Play and games learning about learning about design in general um the this is my most recent book The Rules we break and it is basically um a whole bunch of the exercises that I use to to teach design through games and plays so it's games to play to mod um how to have game design projects so I'd recommend that the rules we break the other thing I want to mention is that I've been working with this group called The Green games guide you have you heard about about that initiative Liz only through stalking you on the internet so tell us about it ah okay well the green games guide is uh it's a best practices guide for sustainably Designing manufacturing publishing

Distributing tabletop games so if you are working as a designer or publisher um please uh look us up greeng games guide.com and that's an ongoing kind of volunteer project but I'm really proud of the work that we're doing um and trying to think about how to make tabletop games World more environmentally sustainable fantastic and um you so you've mentioned something about where people can find you and your projects online but where else if anywhere do you like to be found if people want to follow your work and engage with what you're doing um yeah my website is Eric zimmer.com and otherwise I'm not I'm not that active on social media these days but um you know I guess if you're in the New York City area uh come and visit the NYU Game Center we have a bunch of events uh happening all the time uh look me up and uh come say hi fantastic uh I of course I'm everywhere everybody is beyond solitire I'm terminally online and easy to find uh but Eric thank you so much for coming on this was an absolute delight and I loved getting to talk to you about games teaching them making them the whole shebang yeah Liz it was really awesome conversation thank you so much all right everybody out there please like subscribe comment and most of all happy gaming

oh

Progress saved