Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ierusalem: Anno Domini Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 21:41

Hey everybody, today I'm taking a look at Jerusalem Anno Domini. This is a one to four player Euro board game designed by Carmen G. Yimenez and published by Devir. You're looking at around 90 minutes to play this game on average. Now before I get started on my review of Jerusalem, I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor and place where I picked up my copy of Jerusalem, keyanda.co.uk, who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. Okay, so Jerusalem is going to look like this when it's set up. Now this is an area control game where you are trying to get the best seats at the Last Supper and be as close to Jesus as you possibly can. Or if you can't do that, hopefully be as close to these kind of disciples here. And you're also trying to collect these different stories from the Bible in a set collection method and the more you get, the better.

And this is all held together through a card management system where each player is going to have their own starting deck of 10 cards and you're going to have five of those cards available to you at any time, but there are of course ways to get better cards through this uh 33 AD deck here and through these Mahan cards here, which um have multiple symbols on them and are generally better. So on the board here, you have a market where you can exchange resources. You have all the different resources you can get such as the bread, the stone and the fish and the locations relating to those resources like the desert, the mountains and the lakes here. You're going to start with some presence in these locations and this is a a dynamic thing. So there's always going to be me pulls of your color coming in and out of these locations.

You have this kind of temple area here, which is a way to get people on to those locations and there's a couple more tracks such as this gift giving track where if you get up it, the more points you get and even get some bonuses along the way. And you'll also have these uh this kind of Jesus track here, which is a an end-of-game timer, because as soon as this token gets right to the top, it's going to immediately end the game. And when it reaches certain checkpoints on that kind of scale, you're going to score different categories uh depending on these kind of variable tiles. Now, the main feature of the board is this part here, where you can see that you're going to get influence points the closer you are to these different figures. So, you know, if you're right next to Jesus, you're going to get seven points. And if you're right next to this chap here, you're going to get six points. And every step away from those characters, you're going to lose one point. So, for example, this character would give you six points because he's right next to him, but the one behind it would only get five points because, you know, he has got a bit of a buffer there. And you can see that the further away you are from the actual um Last Supper table, you can potentially get some bonuses.

And in order to get to those spaces, you need to cash in these resources, and we'll touch on that a little bit later. Now, you also have this area here, which is where the different kind of apostles come from. Um and each person is going to have their own personal player board, which is a way to display the cards you've played, as well as being a storage area. You're going to have these favor tokens, and of course your deck, and even this additional tile, which can come into use later. Um additional resources are these um kind of offering tokens, and the money. So, the turn structure of the game is actually pretty straightforward. What all you're going to do is you're going to play a card from your hand. Those cards are going to give you kind of two blocks of actions. The first of which is going to be relating to the location, and that is where you are going to have a look at the matching location. So, if I was to play this little card here, you can see it links to the lake action. Therefore, I would look at the lake action here, see how many meeples I have there, in this example, two, and that would give me two fish to put onto my player board. Now, you can see here that the player board has a strict capacity of how many resources it can hold. So, in this example, I'll be fine, but um I may I could have some overspill, which I'll need to spend by the end of my turn or risk losing them.

Now, you can see here there's also some meeples blocking up some spaces, which will free up more space to put resources as I shift these from my personal player board onto the different spots here. So, you have the three different locations linking to the different resources, as well as that temple action, if you uh remember I mentioned that earlier, which is how you shift people from your player board to the different locations, costing different money. So, in order to spend a send someone to the desert, it'll cost you a coin. Um to the mountain, it'll cost you two coins. And to the lakes, it'll cost you three coins. And you can do that as many times as you like, as long as you can afford it, and send these people from your player board to free up some space and hopefully um increase your ability to harvest resources. However, you are capped at only having three people in each of those locations. And if you play with um the full player count, all of these spaces will be will be available. But, if you play with three players, then um two of those spots are going to be blocked off. And the final location action is this one here, where you can buy and sell resources for money. Like, for stone, you can change it for two money, and vice versa. Bread will cost three money, and vice versa. And fish will be four. Or, you can buy one of these upgrade cards, these Mahan cards, which will be one coin each. And once you've done the location action, you're going to follow it up with the follower action. And whenever you have these symbols, they have to be resolved from left to right. However, you can skip over them. And there are quite a few different actions you can do, but there is a very useful little uh key here on this little reference card.

And they are all pretty simple in their own right, and some of them you'll see more often than others. So, let's quickly run through them. So, this one here, listen to a parable, will let you take one of these tiles here. You always have to go from left to right, going from the worst ones to the best ones, or they in a particular order. And if you're the first to do it, you'll get more points than the people who are later to do it. And they will go on your player board like so, potentially giving you resources um and even end of point end of game bonuses here. Where if you get all seven, that's going to be a massive 18 points. However, you can only get um the new parables as long as you are at least equal with it in terms of presence on the last supper. So, at the moment you can see I have two meeples here. Therefore, I could only ever go up to uh the level two, but I'd have to have more people at the last supper in order to get more of those. Uh you have this gift-giving uh or do a favor here, which is probably one of the weirdest actions where you will give one of these tokens to an opponent and they'll give you a bunch of different kind of um you know, benefits such as more resources or more cards, etc. Um but you have to give that away. And when you give that away, not only will you give the ability away, but you'll also give them one of these location symbols, which can come into play a bit later. But, for doing it, you will go up this track, get some instant points, and also draw one of these 33 AD cards, which are great because they have multiple symbols on them or multiple actions, and the actions are generally a lot better. Another one of the main actions you'll take is to go to the last supper. And that is when you are going to uh spend a number of resources to

send your meeples from the locations to the last supper. When you send uh the meeples, it's going to have to be from the most numerous spot you're in. So, if I was the yellow player, I'd have to send it from the lake because every other location only have has one meeple in. You'd spend the resources in order to claim your seat. So, for example, for me to go here right next to Jesus, that's going to cost me two bread and two fish, but that's going to be a massive seven points at the end of the game. And of course, I could take one of these other bonuses if I wanted to sit further back, such as getting coins or bonus actions. And whenever you send anybody to the last supper, you are going to have the option to claim one of these offering tokens, which are going to be points at the end of the game. However, they are going to clog up your capacity. Um they're kind of useless, but they are going to be points. So, that's a decision you have to make immediately.

You have the Jesus track action where you are going to shift this one up to the next spot. And if it hits one of these tiles, you are going to score that category immediately. If you are the player to activate it, you'll get full points for that. Everybody else will only get half of the points rounded down. So, that's all a timing exercise. And these are a bunch of different things you'll be graded on such as how many followers you have on the locations, how many people you have at the last supper, how many parables you have, how many favors you've given, how many offering tokens you have, or how many resources you have. And there are some other actions such as being invited to the last supper. That works exactly the same as go to the last supper. However, you do not need to spend those resources. You've got the go to the temple, which we've already talked about. Go to the market. You can change places in the last supper to jump to another seat and maybe get another bonus. Um calling a follower, which is sending people to those locations.

Receiving money, receiving resources, or the redistribute action. Which will allow you to move cards around on your player board. Because whenever you play a card, you will actually play them on one of these three columns, which is really important for the next step in the game. And that next step in the game, once you finish playing your card, is going to be the visit an apostle step. And this is where you are going to check if the cards you've played match the symbols of this kind of apostle part of the board here. So, you can see here that in order to play one of these English disciples, you're going to have to play the mountain symbol, then the temple symbol, and then the lake symbol, and so on. And you can see that I've done that here in a very specific order. So, you cannot do that out of order. It needs to be exactly three cards in exactly the right order, which makes that redistribute action quite useful because that lets you jiggle around the order to achieve those that or that particular set of cards.

Now, if you have successfully done that, you are going to send that matching disciple to the last supper with the aim of trying to benefit from it, of course. So, you know, I can put this whenever I wherever I want on the seat here, hopefully trying to benefit me and nobody else. And also, each of these disciples comes with a particular bonus, such as sending somebody to the last supper with an invitation, and being able to score that disciple immediately, or even being able to switch spots with somebody else where, you know, this blue player could perhaps switch with this red player to get right next to Jesus. Also, when you have successfully sent a apostle to the table, you are going to score points based on that column of cards you've just built. So, you can see here in the top right-hand corner, we've got a three, one, and a three. This particular set is going to give me six points. Now, if I was to play with my starting cards, I'm going to discard those cards ready to be drawn again later, but if that set contributed all one of these or a multiple of these 33 AD cards or the Mahan cards, then they're going to get discarded back to the bottom of those decks. And once you've played your card and potentially visited one of these apostles, you have the option to buy one of these Mahan cards for two coins and add it to your hand. And that is completely optional.

And after that, you are going to simply refill your hand back up to five cards and move on to the next player. So, the game is going to continue like that, you know, trying to get as many points as you can until either this track reaches right to the top, until somebody has sent all of their followers to the last supper, or also the game will be sped up as soon as all of these apostles are, you know, completed and sent to the last supper. And then, of course, you're going to add up all the points you've got from during the game with these and different parable tiles you've collected. If you have not spent this extra token here, you're going to get a bonus five points, but this is for once in the game once in the game is going to allow you to cash it in and flip it over in order to take one of these kind of ascension bonuses, and without even having to place one of those uh And that's essentially it. You know, the player with the most points at the end of the game will be the winner. Okay, so hopefully that gives you an idea about how to play Jerusalem, but let let's get into my thoughts on the game. And I want to start with some pretty basic stuff here. And that is the flow of the meeples from your player board all the way to the Last Supper. I love the way that everything has a consequence here.

Now, you're going to start with a pretty convoluted and congested board here, which means you can only ever store a few resources. And of course, that means you want to start sending your meeples to the locations to free up some space, but also to increase your yield when it comes to harvesting the resources by playing those location cards. But at the same time, as soon as you send someone to the Last Supper, you are weakening your ability to harvest those resources. So, I do like that constant flow of, you know, shipping things from your player board to the locations, to the supper, and trying to keep that balanced at all times. Otherwise, you're going to be, you know, pretty inefficient, I suppose. But I also like the fact that whenever you send something to the Last Supper, you have that option to take one of those offering tokens. Now, you know, at the start of the game, you know, space is massively at a premium. So, you're probably going to have to forsake a few of these tokens. But if you choose to play efficiently, or if you manage to play efficiently, then that's quite a few points you're throwing away. So, I do like the way that works. You know, are you going to completely block out a space for the rest of the game and take that point, or are you going to give you yourself a bit more wiggle room and freedom to collect more resources uh without risking overspending and basically wasting them? I think the hand management in this game is pretty excellent, but it can be pretty brain burnery um at times because you are considering so many different things.

Not only are you thinking about the location you're playing because that's going to be the resources that you might need for the action you're taking this turn or even in future turns. Um but of course, you are also thinking about those columns of cards you're building to link to the apostles. So, this is always kind of an ongoing thread that you need to manage and building those columns efficiently is quite an engaging puzzle because you do have that kind of three column leeway, but and you are going to want to keep them in a very fixed order because you have no wiggle room in order to like make mistakes for example. Um, but I do like the way you do have a little bit of forgiveness in terms of building multiple columns at once and you want to be getting these bonuses as often as you can because these ascension bonuses by placing the apostles are pretty excellent, you know, sending people to for free. I'm scoring those apostles immediately or even switching seats with other players. And of course you are building towards you know where you want to sit on the table as well. And but more importantly, there's a huge chunk of points here available to you whenever you build those columns. So again, you are missing a trick if you're not building towards these. Now do like how restrictive it is, but it's not restrictive to the point where it's paralyzing because you do have a little bit of freedom at times if you are to take this kind of redistribute action and I'm start jiggling your cards around to fit them in a certain order.

But you know, these symbols are pretty scarce so when they come along, you want to be utilizing them to the max. This gift giving mechanism is also pretty interesting because you have to consider about who is going to get the net gain by rewarding these gifts to another player. And you can be quite savvy and sneaky about how you deal with this because you maybe you'll choose one of these tokens and give to another player knowing that they're not going to really benefit from them. Maybe they already have a ton of resources and you know they can't store them anymore. Maybe you know that they cannot even use one of these parable tokens because they haven't got enough people at the last supper cuz you know, although the intention is supposed to be good, you can use it to make sure that you know, it's going to be okay for you, but it's going to be great for me because I'm going to flat this track here, get these instant points and bonuses and more importantly get one of these fantastic 33 AD cards.

Yes, you are rewarding them the ability to um, have these great tokens in order to build those columns because I don't think I mentioned that when you collect these tokens, you can use them whenever you want in these sequences. So, it gives you a lot more freedom to build those columns, but sometimes it's worth it, especially if you really focus on it cuz these cards are kind of cumu- cumulative and you can get a ton of points by flying up this track. I also like the timing exercise of this Jesus track because you sometimes have to be quite careful about how well your opponents are doing in these different categories. Like for example, if you know that your opponent has a ton of followers in those locations and if they're the ones to trigger that action, they're going to get a ton of points and you're of course only going to get half. But sometimes you might want to bite the bullet, force that move. Yes, you might not get many points yourself, but you're going to stop your opponent getting the full range of points and only going to half their points in that specific category. And I've not even touched on the area control parts of the game. I think this works extremely well. Um, I like the idea that you have to spend a ton of resources to get right next to uh, the table for those big end game points, but at the same time you might want to sit a little bit further back to get these instant rewards and even maybe able to to move them later by taking one of those shifting actions to move your spot and even switch places with other people. So, there's a good amount of kind of um, rubbing elbows with other people here um, and trying to fight your way to the front. But it also comes with this kind of different dynamic where because of the the way that the all your meeples and the apostles get to the

table are different, sometimes you might actually end up building columns before you invest in putting the apostles there. Um, and that adds some kind of um, skulduggery when it comes to the other players because they might think, "You know what? You've got a ton of meeples here. You're obviously going for one of these big valuable ones. Maybe I'm going to pull this horrible Judas token out which is going to score you negative points for every person there." So, it is this kind of pacing exercise of getting meeples down into the best seats, but before the apostles are even there and vice versa. So, there is that good kind of again, always shifting here. But, not too much um nastiness when it comes to the interaction, either. Just a good amount of competition. Player interaction is a big part of the game. You we've already touched on about all the interaction when it comes to the Last Supper, but there is a race to get to or to get the apostles down to get the bonuses and to get the best seats.

Um there is competition to get um your people into the locations here because there's not enough room uh for everybody. Uh there's the card drafting here, which you want to making sure that you're getting the cards that you want. There's a race to get to the parable tiles before the other people do um because of course the top tiles are going to be worth more points. And I mentioned earlier that um that timing exercise when it comes to the Jesus track, as well. I think the production for this game is amazing. You know, this is right on the money uh for me. Everything looks fantastic when it's on the table. It has a great table presence and some good wooden um components here. Uh it is a little bit of a fiddle at first because when you get the game, you do have to stick uh all these stickers on, but I think it's worth it. They do look really cool. And there are even stickers for the meeples, but I think I'll le- leave those off my own um my own set here. Um all the artwork is fantastic. The components are of a good quality. It just all looks fantastic when it's on the table. You know, the resources look good and you can again, you can choose to stick the stickers on or not.

Um and yeah, I've got no complaints at all when it comes to the way the game is put together. I think it's a fantastic production. Okay, so let's get into some final thoughts for Jerusalem Anno Domini. And boy oh boy, did this game just come out of nowhere for me. I didn't really know anything about it, but I saw it pop up on Kickstarter. I thought this looks cool. Um I tend to at least be interested in what Devir are putting out there. And this game has so much that I like. You know, it has tons of crunchy decisions from the get-go. The hand management is great. The resource management is great. There's competition for everything. This kind of matrix of trying to put all your people in the right places is great. There's good competition there. Everything comes together wonderfully and I was so surprised that this game was designed by a first-time designer.

You know, no other previous accreditations to her name and she should be very proud of herself cuz this is so well put together. It's very polished and it's just those extra wrinkles and layers upon layers um of decision-making here. They all tie back to how are you going to play your cards? What order should I play them? And always thinking about trying to get those apostle bonuses. Yeah, I really cannot really find much to complain about or even small issues I have with this one. I think it is just a joy to play and again it just really did catch me um by surprise and it's gone down a storm with who I've played this with. A nice fresh concept, you know. I know it might not be everybody's cup of tea in terms of the theme and setting, but I love it when they're trying these different um settings here. This has not been done before and I think it works extremely well and it has a real kind of tangible uh theme and setting to the way the game scores. You know, trying to be closer to the main table there. The further away, the fewer points you're going to get because you know, you haven't got the best seats in the house.

So, yeah, if you like your medium medium heavy Euros, this is a great one to to give it a go. And I do like the blend between the you know, the Euro nature of the board game with that card hand management as well. Um yeah, at first I was a little bit daunted by all the symbology um but in their own right they are all pretty simple and even by the end of the first game all the symbols were very familiar to me. So, um I wouldn't really be too concerned if I were you if the symbology looks a little bit overwhelming at first cuz it is actually very digestible and you'll only see a few some of those symbols pretty rarely to be honest. Um but yeah, I've got no real complaints here. This is um I'd be very surprised if this game isn't going to reach my top 10 um of 2023 and maybe even top five. Um I'm massively massively impressed. And I think this one might even be sneaking into my top 100 from the get-go. It is a fantastic game.

And if you remember, not too long ago, Devir released a game called Lacrimosa, which was another game with an interesting theme, and another mix of kind of area control with hand management. For me, I think this game improves on every aspect of Lacrimosa, and this is kind of the game that I wanted Lacrimosa to be, if I'm honest. So, um hey, take that for what what it's worth. I think the game is great, and um it's definitely going to get a commendation from me. That is Jerusalem: Anno Domini.

Progress saved