Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 10:30

st. noir is an Amazon echo integrated murder-mystery board game in which you take the role of a private investigator attempting to puzzle out which of the 12 suspects is the murderer Alexa open Saint noir x2 games presents Saint noir when the game begins the echo will play a produced audio piece that will tell you the story of who was murdered and what type of weapon was used either a blunt weapon a bladed weapon or a firearm in the game you have seven nights to find the culprit in each night you have three actions you can take so a total of 21 actions before the murderer gets away there are three different actions you can take all of which are asked directly to your Amazon echo and each will result in a dramatic telling of what happened Alexa questions sheriff Kilmer sheriff Gilbert local lawman around these parts first you can question a suspect by asking them where they were on the night of the murder Alexa where were you on the night of the murder well look at you sounding like a real detective and all that was at the book store get dad into your timeline once you know where the suspect was located you can ask who was President any locations adjacent to them Alexa who was at the Community College well I saw dr. Wilker over there sure what did they want ain't that the million-dollar question

detective the final action you could take is to search a location this will tell you which item is located at that site Alexa searched the bookstore Oracle books a fitting scene for a Greek tragedy aluminum bat hidden under a cabinet I suppose softball season is right around the corner when questioned some suspects will always tell you the truth but others will lie to you using logic you need to deduce which suspects are being honest so you can piece together where each suspect was on the night of the murder knowing that the actual murderer will always lie to you you need to figure out which lying suspect was at the location with the type of weapon used to kill the victim when you think you've figured it out you can accuse them of the crime but be careful you only have two chances to make accusations if you're right you'll arrest the hood and be known as the greatest private dick to ever ankle the streets of that Ruttenberg Saint noir Saint noir now this is a game I was really excited about and I pre-ordered it not even really knowing much about the gameplay of it mostly I was excited that it was an Amazon echo integrated murder mystery board game that was designed by the original founder of the Atari corporation so I was excited I wanted to see what they were gonna do with this new technology and I'll say when I first opened up the box and I got

out all the components I was blown away this thing looks really cool the board is well done the cards have beautiful sort of minimalistic artwork on them the production was well done they got all this cool like silver inking on it that just looks really neat that everything was cool about it and when I started up the app I loved the way the app sounded the cool ambient music and the acting and the drama and the writing was fun it's not the best in the world but it was fun it gave it a really good experience but when I read the rulebook and got into the game I was slightly disappointed the reason I was disappointed was mostly because I expected it to be a murder-mystery board game and it really isn't a murder mystery at all that's really just the theme of the game really what you're getting here is mostly a I would call almost like a logic puzzle that you go about solving this puzzle by asking a bunch of questions of the difference specs on the board so yes I was disappointed I thought maybe that you know what the people would say would have some bearing on the the figuring out the puzzle but no the things they say are just kind of fluffy dialogue just to make it more fun which is okay but that's not what I expected it going into it so after I came to terms with the fact that I didn't get exactly what I wanted do I like the game well I kind of do I think it's a pretty good game it's not the best game but I have fun playing it played it eight times now and that's a pretty good number of times over a week's span to not like a game so

I think I do like it now when I say it's more of a logic puzzle you really have three questions you can ask where were you on the night of the murder who was adjacent to you on the night of the murder and then you could search a location and see what items are there and you have two it's a really weird thing because the rulebook doesn't exactly describe it very well which are trying to figure out and really what you're trying to figure out is who is honest because if you figure out who is honest then you can trust their answers to find out where other people who are lying are and then you need to find the one liar that is in the same location as the type of weapon that killed the victim going through all of these questioning this questioning process is fun it's really kind of cool to see where everybody was and it is fun to hear the dialogue that they give you and all this different stuff so it's fun too it's fun to figure out the puzzle now I will say that the puzzle does have a shelf life despite the fact that it is completely random and that every single instance of the game the murderer is different the location of all the suspects and all of the items is different so you're gonna have a different game every time you play but the puzzle of the game is the exact same every time the way you go about figuring out the answers to this puzzle is the same every time and then I and I'm pretty sure there is one best procedure to go through to figure that out after you've played it so many times really okay I know which what I have to ask first I know I have to figure out certain things first and then I can go from there and the puzzle getting from A to B to C the deed to the murderer is

always the same every time at that point now that doesn't make it bad because like I said I played it eight times and I said fun every time but when I put this back in the box am I gonna get it back out very often probably not so it does have a shelf life that is for sure now it does say on the box that it is one or more players and that is an accurate representation what this game is it's a solo game that you can have company with you sitting around you while you play it there's no difference between playing with one or six players the the game plays exactly the same you're just gonna sit around and talk about what to do next which there isn't a whole lot of deduction involved it's just who do you who do you ask next so it really is a solo game that you can have somebody nearby if you really want to now one of the things I think kind of is annoying about the game is that the dialogue does get repetitive and old quickly and the fact that none of that dialogue really matters until the final answer of what you're really asking is is answered the rest of the dialogue is irrelevant and it does repeat a lot the people say the same things pretty much all the time and it gets really boring hearing the same thing over and over and over again after you played it a number of times now there supposed to be a quick play option which I've activated quick play and it has not changed the experience at all so I think that might be a bug or I might be confused as to what quick play is supposed to be I assumed it was just gonna get you to the answers quicker so you didn't have to hear the same crap over and over again I don't know if that's a bug or not and

bugs are fixable in this because the board game components are sheerly they're for you to help you kind of remember where people are and who's honest and who's not it really doesn't have any bearing on the actual game as a matter of fact you can play the game come without that components at all if you want it to you just need to know where the locations are on the board and after playing it eight times now I've memorized the whole thing so I could play it without the board or the cards or any of that stuff and just the app but you want those cool components but it's funny that that is the way it is but they could fix any of those bugs anytime they wanted you know so at this point right now the bugs that I've encountered so far could possibly have been fixed and that's I guess one thing I do want to kind of I want to mention even though it might not be relevant after a while but I did meant encounter some bugs a lot of times when you're questioning the suspects if you ask him to repeat it forgets that you were questioning them and then you lose an action because you asked the wrong thing and it got confused I've had it jump around arounds by accident every now and then like it jumped from around three to five at one point it went back from round six to round three at one point but I sort of figured out how to manage that and I think they're gonna fix a lot of those bugs over time because it is an app and they can just roll out fixes really quickly and you wouldn't even notice that it happened so I wouldn't be too fired up about that the game of the game is all that really matters here now all in all I like the game I think it's fun after I came to terms with the fact that I wasn't getting a murder-mystery game like I wanted I realized it's it's a fun

game I've played at eight times I paid $40 for it feel like I got my money's worth so it was a fun experience of a game I like where they're going with this Amazon echo integrated type stuff I feel like this was more of a proof of concept then an actual fully realized board game I think they could go even more with like a sort of a second edition or a new version of this game part two kind of thing where some of that dialogue did matter into the deduction of who the murderer was but without that stuff it's still a fun logic puzzle game that might be fun to sit down with your from you with your spouse or your kids or whatever and go through the process a few times I thought it was a good game production stellar not the best thing in the world but it's a cool direction for technology in board games so check out Saint Noir if that sounds interesting to you thanks so much everybody if you've enjoyed this video please do us a giant favor by subscribing to the channel and click on that wacky Bell icon if you're into board games miniatures games role-playing games we have a bunch of audio podcasts you might enjoy you can find those at the secret cabal comm or on iTunes and stitcher

Progress saved