Cities USA Review: Athens, Moscow, Cairo, Paris, Rome
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Ye.
Today we're taking a look at a game called Cities USA. This is a direct sequel to the well-n named game Cities. Inside, outside, USA.
I think if this had been called Cities USA or Cities, whatever at the beginning, it would have been a better name.
Cities Europe, Cities USA.
It would be easier to go.
Cities of the Moon,
right? Uh, but this is very much the same game as the original, although if you've never played before, I'm going to go over the rules as if you've not played this game before. It is a two to four player game in which maybe there's solo in here. Yeah. and sorry, one to four player game in which you are building a city in front of you by drafting tiles, buildings, and more. Here's how it plays. Over the course of the game, each player will start with a single tile, and you'll have eight turns where you'll be adding eight more tiles to form a 3x3. You'll lose points at the end of the game for deadend roads, although each player has three bridges that they can use to extend these. So now that road goes across like that, so there's no more dead ends. Roads also form neighborhoods. So this here, for example, is one big neighborhood. Here's a small neighborhood. Different spots in the board have places to build towers of those matching colors. At the end of the game, you're going to get points based on how high each of the towers is. So, you can see here, if you get a tower at level five, it's five. Tower is level one is worth zero. You'll also lose points for construction sites that are on your board. You want to cover them up. You're also going to get points for little feature tiles. For example, this here gives me two points as long as it's in a grassy area. That's just one. If I put it here, it would not score me points. Same thing with this water tile.
needs to be an area that's four or bigger. I don't have anything like that on my board, so that wouldn't score me points. And then there are some spots on the board. These food trucks that are just worth two points. There's a few other feature tiles. When you play the game, you're going to stick in one of the included cities in the board. These just give you goals to go through. Like this one says, have a bridge is adjacent to two water areas of two spaces each. The first person to do that will put a ring on it and score five points. And so each of them will have three different ways to score. So you got Chicago, Miami, New York, New Orleans, and Seattle. And those so you'll pick one to play the game with. There's four rows here. And each round of the game, players are going to place out a mele in each row. Unless you're playing with two players, then you'll be putting out eight. On your turn, you pick one of these things. Let's say I want this tile. And I'll put my mele here, and I'll add this tile in front of me. This one here is face down. I don't know what it is, but I can choose that one.
However, once you put a person in a row, you can no longer put anyone else in that row. I might go here and decide to build buildings and I have to place these immediately onto spots on my board. If when I'm placing buildings and I make a level four building that matches one of the two colors of skyscrapers here, I can put that piece on. That's the only way to get your building to a level five. Here I get feature tiles which could also be have an unknown one. Uh here you don't you your buildings are drawn from a bag. So you're either taking a a plot some feature tiles buildings or you can take a scoring card. These will score at the end of the game. So this one for example gives two victory points for each neighborhood that has six or more spaces in it. This one gives you two points for each straight street that connects two opposite sides of the city. And this one gives you one point for each black building of any size. So you'll be collecting one of these each round.
You're going to get one thing from each row. It's up to you the order you go in these rows. Once everyone has gotten one, then you will reset everything and do it again. And once everyone has that 3x3 grid, you'll score. I already showed you scoring on the board. There's also scoring for the city, scoring for your cards. Whoever has the most points is the winner.
Component-wise, the game is pretty good. Um, the there's a few small issues. Uh, I mean, everything looks really good. I feel that the skyscraper tops are easy to put in the wrong bag. I know it seems like a dumb thing, but you put them out there. They also clutter the board a little bit more. It used to be I look at in the original one I'd see some space and like oh I can grab those. Wait no like those are colors. Those are only if you build that skyscraper.
Yeah. And they do try to make the tops they're like a slightly different sheen
than the actual buildings, but they're very similar.
It' have been nice if they were just a little pointier or something that I would have been like skyscraper top. But yes, I agree. Uh the bridges stand up just fine. They're a little narrow, but I mean they're close. These are minor complaints.
Yeah, very minor. Other than that, it's fine. It's not a very exciting looking game. Neither was the original.
Um, but this is a game real quickly. We all I think we all liked Cities the original game.
I gave it I gave an 8.5. I might have been the highest score of the bunch, but yeah, I liked the original a lot.
I like it a lot, too. Um, the this takes that concept and makes several changes, mostly adding adding to the game. So would add the skyscrapers
uh where you put the tops on if you're putting it in the right spot. There is the the roads deadend roads will make you lose points.
Um the construction spots that um there there's neighborhoods where you need to keep a track of how the roads the roads have a bigger deal. They score cards, but they also make neighborhoods which is how most of the cards are based off of them. And then you have these bridges where you can stop that roads or extend roads and again mess with the neighborhoods.
Right. Right. I actually really like a lot of what they added. I feel like it added more more depth to it without over complicating it and without making it go h this puzzle's too hard. And so I really enjoy the level that they bumped it up just enough. And also I find that these the scoring cards that you get are just more interesting than the original. I felt like the original ones were fine. These ones I find more interesting. I also find that be and I think it's because of the roadways. Roadways creating neighborhoods, roadways where you want to connect them across the board if possible. All of those little tweaks make the cities uh that you change out from game to game also, I think, a little more interesting and also add some little thematic touches. Like we played the Miami city board and it was kind of fun to like create that iconic Miami sky line where you need to have a bunch of, you know, tall buildings across the road directly from water. And I was like, "Oh, I get that.
I lived there. I know what that's like." You know what I mean? And so
that's where Chris lived
on that city skyline.
No, you said it's better two-player now.
Yeah. I think that that's the other big improvement is that the basic the original cities I just wrote it off as a two-player game. is way too loose, way too open. Uh I think that having the more stuff in here, but then also they intro, I believe, if memory serves, they introduce a two-player variant rule in this version where you cannot put your worker or draft from the same line until you have gone to all four spots. And I think that that keeps the tension good at two players, whereas the original one felt too loose at two.
It felt like you just pressed fast forward after you grabbed each spot. Yeah. This I think a good analogy for that is the King Domino two player variant that you make the bigger board. That's what this reminds me of. Like it's creates the tightness and you get to do a little bit more.
Oh, you do play Yeah. You make a bigger grid player. I think that the two-player rules in this one are a huge improvement. And if you're two-player gamer, you know, couple or something like that or have a one-on-one consistent game group, this is by and far the better version.
Yeah. If you're four players or three players, I think this is clearly a weaker version to the point where I dislike every change this game made to the point where I actually don't like this game.
Really?
I dislike everything.
I dislike that. You mentioned the cards, for example, you said, "Oh, they're so much more interesting." They're a pain in the neck now. Every card I have to pick up and go, "Okay, this is for the neighborhoods to do this." Well, before it was like, "Oh, a blue building card. Oh, a red building card. Now I got three red building cards. It just makes it easier to play and I think you like added complexity.
Yeah.
But I don't think it fits in this game. The skyscrapers felt not not only did it add a little bit of complexity, I thought it was random. Well, I really want that group of skyscrapers that that group of buildings
and then I can take that because I happen to have a four at this point in time.
I do think that that layout is a little bit odd that you don't just get the skyscraper. Why not just the first person to do it?
Yeah, I do think that's a little odd. And then I also disliked everything about the roads. I already mentioned it makes the scoring cards more complex, but putting those bridges out. The rules for that wasn't it's not clean. It's like you can put one out and you can put it here, but not I didn't like that. Something else I didn't like. Sorry. There's a lot of things I just didn't like. Basically, it Oh, this the feature tiles. They're just again they're just harder to figure out. Two tiles go together. If you have one, you get two. If you have two, you get five. How do I know they go together? The rules tell me there's nothing on the tile themselves to show you. I guess maybe the playground.
It makes sense if you have one piece of playground equipment, you have the other. Yeah.
But it would be cool if they formed a picture when you put them together or something like that.
And then the other ones like give you points if they're in a group of one, two, three, and four. And then the scoring cards.
Yeah. I just I if I was like I don't like these changes to the point where when we were done, I was like, I don't like the game anymore. I really like the original one. I don't like as much as Chris, but I really liked it.
And I think the simplicity was the charm. This added a lot of complexity that I didn't love.
And it's funny, someone evoked King Domino earlier, right? Where
was not I?
Yeah.
It's funny because I know some people really prefer King Domino because of the simplicity and other people absolutely prefer Queen Domino or uh King Domino or whatever because it's a simple framework and then you put build a little more of a game on it.
And I'm in that group actually. I like those because of the complexity.
Yeah, it's kind of opposite. I prefer OG King Domino.
Yeah. So, something about this game system does it different. I do agree that the bridges are unintuitive of like when you can place them out and how you can place them out. It definitely has a little bit of that like complexity creep. Comes with a couple of odd rules, but I found the neighborhoods pretty easy to to visually see and everything. I found the the the cards I agree with one. I think that they're more interesting.
So
I think though that they did themselves a disservice with this game in the sense that I felt like when they were making it they're like we cannot duplicate anything from the original game. But you could have like a card for sizes of buildings, a card for well they have a few but
well you already score for size of buildings,
right? But I mean there was some really easy cards and they were like well we can't reuse any cards. But I think that would have been fine. And same thing with the feature tiles. It was like everything had to be different.
Now, do you know if they're going to come out with some sort of combined things?
No, I don't know. I know there's an expansion that can fit in
either. I think the little expansion pack is only for the original.
Yeah. Okay. I I'm not sure. But Oh, and the cities. The cities. You mentioned the Miami thing. I also played Miami because why would I not, you know? Um, but when I went through all the different cities, they all felt again, I had to read some of those things twice and go, "Okay, you want what? This needs to be here." And they leaned into the theme. Like the Miami one you mentioned, they want the the C and then the It's like that's so much work and effort and it's not even that many points. If you if you go out of your way to score the cities, you will not probably win unless you are also doing everything else that other people need.
And I don't know. So
yeah, I wouldn't go up. Let's get my rating out of the way. I'm a five out of 10.
Okay.
And I But I'm not trying again. I get that some people are like it. I think some people are really going to enjoy that added complexity.
I just thought the base game was pretty solid out the gate.
Okay. Um after playing the the base game, I haven't come back to it. It's been to me it felt especially as I stepped away from it. I don't remember my original score, but it just kind of was forgettable to me. I was like, "Okay, that was cool. I know people liked it. I liked it. It was fine." Um, but coming back to this, I really enjoy that upper level of complexity. I do find that the tiles matter so much more what you draft because the roads that affects so much. And so I feel like getting the tile that you want matters more. Whereas before, I feel like I kind of can take anything. Like sure, I'd prefer blue buildings because I have more scoring for that, but I'll kind of take whatever's left over. And so I feel like this adds more tension in that line specifically, which I'm okay with. Um, and then I mentioned, yeah, I like the cards that they're more compelling.
However, there's definitely moments where you're like, ah, that's not happening. Like, I can't do that. I can't complete the city. And so, I think you have to be okay with not finishing as much um, if you've got a variety of cards. So, I I just enjoy the tension. So, this one is a 7.5 for me. I'm I'm coming in at the same score that I gave the original 8.5. I think that this is a ton of fun and I like the fact that it is the same framework. You take one of each of the rows of tiles by the end of the round, set it up again and play it.
Great framework, by the way.
Yeah. And I think it adds to a lot of tension and I find that it's there the same. And for everything that I think is an improvement, there's also I agree a little bit of like a oh this is not as as clean or or you know everything had to be different. Sure.
That's why you're not saying it's clearly better.
Yeah. I think that they serve kind of different audiences, right? The original Cities is such a clean such a clean and simple and approachable game. This one is less so. But I also like trying to build those roadways across. I like trying to build up lots of tiny neighborhoods if possible or uh I I like that the city goals are harder to accomplish so that you might only get one or two of them in a game and I'm okay with that. Once I think it's kind of like a different mindset to play the game and it's odd that there's such like sympatico in terms of like system
but they are very different in terms of execution. But I like both I would say probably equally.
I'm curious. I wonder I think people will probably line up be behind one or the other for the most part.
Yeah,
I'm curious which one will go over better.
Well, there you go folks. That's Cities USA. I hope your city's in it.
Well, that means you're a big city person. Well, we'll hang out with a big city folk.
They don't have uh I'm
from a big city.
What? Uh let's see. Wala Wala when they come out that that one there.
That's true.
All right. Until next time, I'm Tom.
I'm Wendy Ye.
I'm Chris Ye.
We'll see you next time. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.