Twilight Imperium: 4th Edition – Review
Transcript
last weekend i was invited to play my very first game of twilight imperium 4th edition this is a game of epic proportions that took 11 hours to play this game is very very famous for being an epic uh strategy and role playing game with different alien races vying for the position of the next emperor of the um galaxy i guess it's a galaxy or universe or whatever first of all i was very happy to be invited and i enjoyed my time playing with the group that it invited me in however i don't feel like i played a game with them i feel like i participated in an experience as a game and strictly speaking about the game itself and not the great day that i had with these friends of mine i did not like the game i would not recommend the game i would never buy the game if i was invited to play again because i enjoy those people i would gladly play again with those people if i was invited and they asked me what do you want to play i would never say twilight imperium so that being said we're going to go into the review of course i'm going to break this down to theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity so first of all most surprisingly theme i especially
haven't read the rulebook in advance i expected this to be a perfect 10 for theme usually games that are this epic go to great lengths to cover the theme and to make it feel like you're acting out these roles but i would actually give the game an eight for theme and the reason i'm given an eight for theme is not because it doesn't do a great job with the alien factions not because the battle and the ships and the movement across the board isn't great but because the game wants to be more than just a game about taking over planets and area control it wants to be a game about politics and it does this through a um mechanic which is voting for agendas players together vote on these actions and their vote determines how the rest of the game is going to be played i wanted to see more i wanted to see the politics theme more flushed out um and i will talk a little bit more about that in mechanics but for theme and eight so for mechanics there are several mechanics in this game that are brilliant but if there are things that interfere with that that lowers the mechanics score so let me talk about the things that are brilliant first i love that during game play you can do i would say one of two but maybe one of three things so you can use a command token to do basically an action on the board you activate a hexagon and you can do all of the things within that area of space there are cards that you can play that have actions on them so that would be the second thing and then the third
thing you can do is you can play your strategy card and your strategy card gives the holder a unique ability and everybody else a secondary ability i love that mechanic i also love the command tokens and my goodness do i love the mechanic of voting on a law that influences the game these things are brilliant however they are not enough to raise the game against the burden that it carries it carries the burden of having way too much to think about oh my gosh oh my gosh i spent 11 hours 11 hours just reading things and processing what's going on i like complexity complexity is a separate score complexity is engaging in itself but as a game mechanic you will constantly refer to reference cards and reading texts a new law comes out that changes the rules every character has abilities there are technologies things are constantly occurring the game just unfolds and you keep reaching these points of realization and then you have to sit there and think about the implications of this new rule or you know this new technology or whatever that means that is one of the reasons why the game is so exciting when you sit down you don't know what's going to happen and so to the game's credit that can be very appealing i don't want to play that i would say if that sounds
overwhelming to you oh my gosh never play this but if you like the idea of surprise it's like it's like watching a movie or reading a book and you know turning the page and something totally unexpected happens i felt that constantly and processing all that stuff but it does that at the deterrent of the mechanics so for mechanics i give it like a two despite the brilliance of the strategy cards the command tokens and so much else that's going on it's just not a game that lends itself to uh gameplay that you can really even process you just sort of witness it unravel okay with luck 10 that's it i mean this is one of the luckiest games i've ever played a single card can change the entire course of the game um when when things happen there is so like dice rolling dice rolling determines the outcome of a battle don't like that i don't like the cards i i don't mind luck what i mind is luck under the guise of a strategic game where your choices matter for strategy i would say the game is very tactical any given turn you're trying to do the very best thing you can do under the given circumstances by your next turn everything can change completely so long term there is you know what to give the game credit
there is an important strategy which is how you interact with your opponents how you play other players are you going to um violate an alliance that was established earlier in the game are you going to be friendly are you going to be aggressive are you going to invade somebody's home world and really really upset them that is very strategic because even though the conditions of the game can change immensely the relationships around the table pretty much stay the same come to think of it i think of it as a game um and i'm trying to analyze the game play it's not the game is not about the gameplay the game is about the social interaction and if you think about that an opportunity to have an interesting social interaction for 11 hours that can be a lot of fun i would recommend it to people who value that experience and even as i say it it's like well maybe the game's not so bad as long as i don't think that i'm playing a game and then complexity is so easily a 10.
there's so much to think about there's so much to read it's it is oh my god there are so many pieces and then and then all of that stuff has reading material on it and there's a lot of flavor text too i actually kind of like the flavor text and the planets are are kind of interesting um there are so many combinations and the way that the game can change with different factions but look at the end of the day here's the thing would i play it again yes i like it because it's a great social interaction if i wanted to play a game a game that feels like a game and i wanted a great social interaction and i didn't want to play for 11 hours i would play cosmic encounter because cosmic encounter accomplishes so much of what twilight imperium accomplishes in the social interaction if i wanted to play a game where i was a cool alien race exploring the galaxy and fighting other ships i'm gonna play eclipse because eclipse feels more manageable and also eclipse does technology way better and there's so much less overhead and by the way i am speaking of the first edition of eclipse i have not played the second edition of eclipse and i've heard the second edition is even better twilight imperium for being the fourth edition is not as great as i expected it to be i think that they could really fix the technology which is so hard to build and they could really fix the agendas which has the potential to be so much more interesting um thankful that i played not what i recommend those are my thoughts thanks for watching bye