Warcry: Catacombs Review
Transcript
hey everybody welcome to drive-thru review number 700. today we're going to take a look at the catacombs box set for the warhammer age of sigmar warcry skirmish game now this is a kind of a standalone slash expansion box set so if you're new to the game and you want to jump right in this will kind of get you everything you need to to play the game or if you've already played some warcraft before this will give you kind of two different game modes you get the catacombs mode which is the namesake and that's kind of a dungeony sort of underground sort of layer with some its own kind of terrain rules but it does give you some above ground terrain with the other side of the board and some terrain to go with that and you get the two different warbands as well to use so i've already done a review for it i'll put a link in the description below talking about the mechanics and all that kind of stuff largely the mechanics are the same there's some new modes and some new campaign bits and stuff like that so i'm going to kind of dive down i got everything assembled painted up have a chance to play a couple games of it and i kind of give you kind of a component overview kind of thing and then jump back up here to kind of tell you my thoughts on the box set in general so first real quick you get a copy of the core book in the catacombs box set this is the exact same core book that you got in the original starter set and that you can buy separately online nothing changes here and one thing they have not done which is a little bit of a disappointment is update this with some of the faq and some of the errata and stuff like that which is relatively significant i would have been nice to have kind of had you know kind of an updated rulebook inside here as well
and you get a separate rule book here for the catacombs and you get kind of your typical stuff a little bit of lore and background some cool art and everything as well as some pictures of some of the miniatures that are painted that come with the set which i'll show you in a minute and some other scenic kind of things and then you get the rules here for the dungeon terrain and so on now to set up a scenario if you remember you typically had like decks of cards that you would deal out and then kind of randomize your terrain setup randomize your victory objectives and all that kind of stuff here there's you don't get any cards in the box but you do get some sort of cards printed out here and that you can kind of roll off on and then you see you've got victory objectives there and so on and twists and then here you've got sort of the layout and setup for the above ground uh missions that you can do here now you also get here uh these quests so you get the quest lines for the two war bands that come in the box so you get two quest lines kind of per uh warband there you can see some of these have the above ground ones here and then some of these take place in the dungeons and then here we got some more but then you also do get some quests for everybody else so these are called faded quests and these are sort of generic quests because you have sort of your faction specific quests in a game of war cry and that's just for that faction but then you have faded quest which pretty much anybody can go and take on and they and they work the same way so like you see this one has like uh one
convergence quest scenario for the above ground and then two under underground and so on and this one has two above and then one under and so on like that so i'm going to kind of show you what all you get in the box component wise i apologize for the glare on this side i'll fix that in just a second here you've got the one side of the board which is the underground map with all the little terrains and doors and things in here you can see the shadow stalker minis out here on that side but you also get all this outdoor train now here you can see there's two separate boards you don't get two boards but this sort of art on this board that you see this comes from the original starter set that's on the back side of this board over here so you just flip the board over and then you can either kind of play outdoors or play indoors and that's scattered around here some of these signs of flame figures i just want to kind of zoom in and give you kind of a quick sense of what an amateur paint job looks like on this stuff so here i've got this terrain all painted up i have you know all the figures painted up and so on a lot of these guys are on fire or deal with fire and so on and typically kind of in comparison to the shadow stalkers these guys are a little bit tougher they've got a couple of less figures for their warband but they're slightly more melee focus although some of their special abilities and things that you can activate with those initiative dice that you roll you can get some ranged effects out of them there but this is kind of how this kind of terrain looks and so there you go that's how that works now here you can see the shadow stalkers over there there's a couple of different terrain pieces that are new to the game
obviously with this kind of setup here the first of which are these doors here so you have kind of these doors that players will set up at the beginning of a match and some of them are open like this and they have some cool little skulls and things on them sometimes you'll set out a closed door like so and as a part of setup you can see these small gaps here players will take turns putting out uh these different doors you're kind of sealing off different areas maybe there'll be objectives or something that you want to sort of have a bottleneck or a choke point force them to kind of go around and so on you can as part of deployment also put out different terrain features one of them which could be a lever here to open the door so you can have that and then you can put down the open door version of that and so now they can get through there they've also got some bridges here you have kind of these two sturdy bridges over there as well as these two kind of wooden uh weaker bridges on either side there and so if you actually move your figure here and stop at any point during your movement you have to roll to see if maybe that bridge doesn't collapse or get weaker if it does then you of course fall into the pit and then your character will be immediately removed from play there now typically your characters are going to come in from the edge of the board here and then you're going to deploy your different like dagger sword and shield groups from within three inches of these places here and they're all over the board here something to zoom out kind of haphazardly here so you can see over here you've got entrances and the maps and the setups
will kind of help you with that and where you put objectives and the different conditions and all that kind of stuff but i wanted to look at some of these other terrain features which kind of really are kind of the crux of the game here so this thing if you one of the players decides to put it out that can also be an entrance uh in later rounds so what happens is you usually put out two of your groups and then after the second round the beginning of the third round then your other third group will come in and so somebody can make use of of that entrance and you know based on the proximity of where it is to certain terrain pieces or you know where the objectives might be or the treasure tokens or whatever you're trying to fight over for that round that placement is going to be pretty important now the couple other features here you can see this kind of coffin here there's certain terrain features that could theoretically damage uh players so you have these kind of tombs and other little features like that so you don't want to stand too close to them but that can you know make the positioning pretty important here's another example of that one there then you have also these these walls here so typically this is a solid wall there but then you can have a collapsed wall like that so that can kind of clear space and i should say there's two other boards that you can get that don't come in this box set that have different layouts quite different layouts actually so but all of this terrain that you see here is going to interact with them so really kind of the key takeaway with this system here in this kind of new mode is you have some of these terrain features that you can interact with more on a game level and you can actually like knock through walls and
create these and bust those down and try to jump over the pits and there's some other special abilities and stuff that you can interact with in the environment that's very specific to this and then you have sort of a little bit more not dungeon crawly thing but you know the indoor part of it where you're kind of creeping around walls and setting up choke points and stuff like that that's just a kind of a different flavor than if you're playing in an outdoor series kind of jumping off catwalks and so on they each kind of have their own flavor and sensibility there but that's pretty much it there as far as kind of the components and the general flavor of of how the game works so let's kind of go up to my talking head there we'll kind of give you a little bit of a review in my breakdown of my thoughts okay so that was a real general overview of everything that you get in the box and the components some of the different game modes and things like that i'm going to skip the three pillars of review that i normally do like i said i've got a review already down link in the description there so i've talked about the gameplay quite a bit and if you watched about a month ago i did my top 10 skirmish games of all time and this was in my top five so i really do enjoy this system uh it's one of my favorites and i've actually discussed with a lot of folks in my comments and then also over on the blackjack legacy's channel in terms of what is the best uh rule set that games workshop has ever put out it seems like a lot of folks really think that warcry is their best rule set although a lot of folks also seem to say the middle earth uh combat game which i've never played is really good too um but anyway that's
another conversation so i really the point is i really do enjoy this game i think it's a great system um and as terms as far as what you get in this box it's kind of a mixed bag because the original box set was so good the first starter set you got so much terrain in that you got the two war bands you got the kind of the npc monsters and demons and stuff like that that could come in and so on but you kind of had just kind of that one style of play whereas this one you get the above ground terrain and you get also the dungeon train so terrain wise you're kind of in the same ballpark in terms of the amount of stuff you get but you get a little bit more in terms of the variety of the game modes in this box and i really do enjoy the underground game mode it adds a nice different sensibility uh to the game with just the doorways the closed doors the open doors the pits the traps the bridges uh you know in terms of traps like the you know the undead traps or the undead try to come and do damage to you and stuff like that so that kind of positional sort of variety to the game is really cool and they did a really good job of it and like the different objectives and twists and everything like that really work well and it really makes the games very very interesting in terms of you know the mechanics and how you play i think it's really cool like that now the one thing that is really just it's a disappointment and it's almost coming into where the price comes in i don't usually typically like to talk about price of a game to value because it's such a
nebulous thing in terms of a board game because you can find a game that costs you 10 and gives you tons of fun and hours of fun and you can find another game that has a lot more components and stuff and strategy and it's 50 and it gives you a ton of fun and everything but it is in a different way so it's hard to kind of compare it's really comparing apples to oranges but in terms of this like i can almost see where they missed in terms of getting you to that level of quality and so it's going to kind of come down to if you have the money to get it then i would get it because i think it's really good but also i i have to look out of a little bit of a side eye because it just kind of barely touches on a lot of things where i think would have made the price point a little bit more warranted because it is like 200 plus or something in msrp you know before discounts and all that stuff because the catacombs part of it actually sort of ties into the larger age of sigmar narrative especially with the shadow stalkers in terms of what's going on with the marathi broken realm storyline and all that kind of stuff but it really doesn't even address it and the stuff that's there is just kind of there like it just sort of hap happenstance that it sort of syncs up with it now i'm sure they planned it of course because there's stories in the broken realms things that tie back to this but that's not really that big of a deal but my point is they really could have leaned into that and developed that further and make this a real kind of pivot point or something like that for that storyline it really had you
kind of uh you know immerse yourself a little bit better and more and i don't know what that would be in my head that would be like flushing out a lot of these quest lines you have these faded quests which are kind of here or there and then you have a couple of quests specific for each of the warbands that come in this that's cool but the expansion that the the tomah champions expansion really kind of just dug in there and gave you a lot of narrative tools to uh play a cool campaign i would have liked to seen something like this because if you look at these books i mean this is just it's a terrible example but if you look at the two books this one's you know good and thick it's a couple hundred pages you know 150 pages and then you have the catacombs book which is skinny and it's just just over 60 pages so i think they could have used the space in this book to flesh out some kind of linear story or something that you could jump in and be a part of and and do something a little bit interesting and neat and and just a little bit of a twist on the whole way that the campaign works in warcry which i really like again it's in my top five i like how they give you that sort of plug and play you know i'm on my quest you're on your quest sometimes we're going to meet and converge in the middle one maybe i'll play one of your convergence class or you'll play one of mine and so on and the way that that whole system works is awesome i love it but it seems to me when i look at this and then look at the value of this box versus the original box i would have expected a little bit more not in terms of like stuff in the box because i think it's about
there you get two warbands in both of them you get about the same amount of terrain you know split across two game modes and maybe that's a little bit of a buff in this case a little bit of a plus you know in this box versus this original starter box we don't get any npc you know minions but that's yeah whatever but i think they could have fleshed out some other things here and really leaned into this instead of just feels like a kind of a fire and forget kind of thing with this which is you know it is what it is um so i think they could have flushed he fleshed out a lot more quest lines maybe ones for each of the different factions that you can play in this a lot more specific things something to kind of like tie it together tie it back into broken realms and that kind of thing that just feels like a missed opportunity um i mean it is kind of tool boxy by nature but i i i think that would have been really kind of a neat thing to do and really kind of maybe set up the beginning of a larger storyline anyway there's a lot they could have done i could probably go on for a while about it and the other thing is one of the cool things about this outdoor terrain and some of the other terrain boxes that they've come out with for it is there are ways to kind of mix and match that terrain so you have your kind of catwalky ruined terrain with kind of this decrepit force terrain or um like graveyard uh tomb terrain and you have those separate things you can go play there but then there's also cards that you can get to kind of mix all that stuff together so it gives you a ton of variety but they don't really carry any of this into
that larger world that they've created there's no real mixing here of the terrain and all that stuff you don't even get any cards in the box to set you up to do that give you like a handful of scenario objectives and victory conditions and twists and all that stuff in the book but they don't give you any cards they don't give you any kind of like player aids and cheat sheets or anything like that too because you get some new abilities when you play in the dungeon that you can do that when you play on a dungeon map that you can only do there and so on so there's another player rate so it's like when you get to that certain level of price point i i think there should be an extra level of care and sort of polish on top of that so when you are getting like a premium product like this you feel like you're getting a premium product and that's where like it just kind of falls short so it's tricky because you can't get the original starter set anymore and like this is if you wanted to jump in and you've got like a lot of stuff like this is a great this is where i'm kind of coming to that like dual thought about it i think it's a good price like if you can afford that um because you get the two warbands you get the two modes there's gonna be a lot for you to dig into but if you already have stuff for it which i do um this is not really like a must-get because they are gonna release these warbands separately i mean you just know they are going to have little 30 boxes or whatever they're going to be and you're going to be good to go and that's why you get the one you like and that's it so the rest of this stuff it doesn't
really integrate enough back into the uh the existing lines you know there's not enough mixing or anything and there could have been some kind of crossover and then in terms of like the narrative part of it you know the kind of the the catacombs part of it it just kind of feels like a cool game mode that's just a different one of those terrain boxes so it's almost like this is a big glorified terrain box which you get some starter warbands and stuff but it doesn't take the game to enough of a level it's kind of like a version 1.5 or something right where you have okay you've got the new underground mode cool that's it and then it's gone and then you know there's a couple of boards you can pick up but i've been really cool they kind of leaned into that and again i'm really hitting at it because of the price point because i think it was cheaper like 150 or something which is about the ballpark of the other one you know it's like 50 50 difference i mean i don't know see price is such a tricky thing but looking at what they've done here it's just like a new terrain set in a new mode with some other game options and that's it and it's also a starter set but i think they they really could have made this kind of expand the war cry universe in terms of the narrative and everything so i kind of beat up on it but i didn't want to kind of showcase and everything definitely go take a look at the old review if the mechanics seem interesting to you and if you're not if you i doubt you're even watching this video if you're not already in the game but i would say if you are this is a pretty decent starter spot
and you're going to get a lot of play out of it like hours and hours honestly of play out of this but it's just there's a couple of misses right and it's it's simple as maybe they could have had cards and player aids and had an updated rule book with a little bit of stuff in there and not even just the errata and the faq they could have had other modes or rules or advanced modes or you know whatever other kind of things that they could have like reinvested into the system with um other than that so i just want to highlight this because it's a cool system it's really fun i have a lot of fun playing this uh played it quite a bit actually over the last well not the last year because still on lockdown kind of sort of and then but you know the year prior to that really played a lot of it a couple of tournaments and things like that and really had a lot of fun with it so i recommend the system overall this is a little bit on the high end for the pricing i think they could have done a lot more with it so hopefully they will kind of keep come back to this though so sorry for the kind of ramble it's kind of all over the place but that's kind of where i'm at um with recommending the box set great system but not sure about this box
thanks you