Audience HOT Takes: Host Your OWN Game Night!
Transcript
Good morning everybody. I'm Tom Vassel.
I'm Z Garcia.
I'm Camila.
I'm Mike Delicio.
I'm Joey Evans.
Welcome to Hot [clears throat] Takes.
Hot Takes. Um,
hot take.
Hot takes is a um show where we take your hot takes, which you can send into tomdictowwer.com. We get hundreds of them, but I'll take more. Send them in. We love talking about them. A couple things that you should know about this. One is that you'll be able to vote on today's hot takes. You can do that. There's a link in both the chat and in the description of this video. And um, also hot takes are hot takes, right? Yeah. You might get mad at some of them, but I don't know that any of them will be taken too seriously.
I don't like the marrynt going on that idea.
I feel like I should turn this car around. She was She looked back and I'm like, what is she looking?
Our color looked off. I was like, man, I look super tan. I was like, "Oh, had a good weekend."
I know. She's
not Look at that screen.
That's true. You Your side don't look You guys look like you're on screen. Oh,
you guys are tan.
Don't look as Samsung will make you feel like you need to go to the mortuary. Yeah,
we need the on.
We need on
Roku TV for the win.
I'm feeling nice and bright where I'm at here. That's right. Hot take. It's almost Gen Con, folks.
It is. And you know what? I didn't think about that. There is no hot take that has anything to do with Gen Con, but
I got one.
I got a hot take. Get to the Dice Tower booth first thing Thursday.
249.
Dwarves of Akalon. If you want it, get there quickly. 249 you said? Yeah, that's right.
Boom. I also should mention
I should say nothing else the whole stream.
Today is June 22nd, August 3rd, which is not that far away, registration for Dice Tower West opens up where you can come and yell at the people who made these hot takes because they're all going.
Yeah,
we're going to line them up.
I guarantee you can find somebody at Dice
to wear your hot take on your shirt.
This was mine.
Okay. All right. Let's start with the first hot take. Let's just jump here. Ros Ross U says, "If you can't win on the last move, why have a last move?" So, this is a riff, I think, on the uh
splatter game says, "If you can't lose on the first turn, why have a first turn?"
Okay. Um Yeah.
Well, that that's that splatter thing is stupid.
That's neither one of those takes makes any sense. I don't know. This is I understand. They're saying if it does if it is inconsequential, then why have it? That's not the same thing as if you can't lose or if you can't win. They're saying if you can't add to your winnings or if you can't add to your losses. Those are very different things, guys.
What would you do like if if like you have somebody like I obvious I can't beat you. They just don't take your last turn. I guess normally
that game needs to hide its points a little better.
True. And I I mean usually I've heard people say it doesn't really matter. I'll just do this. They take the move but they're like I can't catch up.
And that's a problem with that game. Like Kingsburg sucks at the end
because there is no hidden scoring.
Yeah.
So the last three turns you're like I'm losing by 15 points. I know I can't mathematically get 15 points.
Is that an attack card that possibly you know what I mean? They fixed it in expansions.
I think you could even zoom out from this take a little bit because I I do that as well. If it's like okay it's my last turn. I don't have one or lost but are there any more points out there for me? No that's one point. That's one. I mean that's minmax. It's like, okay, no, there are no points available. I I peaked one round too early. Sure. You know, or I So, that's a player issue. So, it's like, okay, it doesn't matter what I do.
Fine, I'll go here then.
But you might also because of you do something, you might pull somebody back, a perceived leader back, and that is points. You know what I mean?
Potentially, right?
There's there's more to it than like if you can't win on this turn, then why have it? That's that's
I'm going to go back to Z's go-to. He has a very good answer for a lot of these questions.
Shut up. That's what I thought.
That's his directive. That's his directive. This is This is a point. You ventured into a social contract at the beginning of the day.
I hate that word with the people around the table. It's a very good phrase. You say it
100% of the time.
Every time we 100% of the time.
100% of the time.
Social contract. Did I say social contract?
I've said it maybe once.
You've said it 14 times just in the last little pretentious IO. It's also an actual turn [clears throat] that suits. The idea is you've decided you're going to play this game with people. And you know what? You may have determined you're not going to win on your last turn, but you know what? Somebody's going to win on the last turn, and you should take your turn in the best way that you possibly can because you've entered into this agreement. We're going to play this game. And also, don't complain if you know you're not going to win on the last turn. It is what it is.
And if that fails to work,
shut up.
Right. I do think that there is issues sometimes with games where it's very clear who the winner is and you know you have no chance of winning halfway through the game. That's a design problem. I think
there he did.
I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I mean I think I think at the end of the day games aren't all about winning or losing. It's about doing your best and for me you know having time apparently is a hot take but I agree. Look
we have some wild
we have some very very uh on it people in our chats. I want someone keep it go back and check all of the hot takes. Okay. and count the number of times E. Garcia says social contract.
Oh my word. Let's go. By the way, don't forget to vote. I only have 18 votes for this, but they are majority disagree with this.
Okay.
I like the uh the thing here. It says we need to change the voting from agree to disagree to agree to shut up.
Yeah.
Except I think everyone would always shut up.
My god, that's too much. That's too much.
Okay, next. Our hot take from Travis H says, "It's literally impossible to rate party games relative to Eurogame." He says, "It's like saying Schindler's List is a great film, but it's no Dumb and Dumber."
He's That's true.
Don't ever start something with literally impossible unless it's literally impossible.
It's not literally impossible. Is it a good idea? Probably not. Is it going to give a great comparison? Probably not. But it's possible.
I mean, have you seen Demadeller in black and white? It's different.
It changes. Be careful here cuz you tread. He used Shindler's list. It's It's very difficult to argue that without sounding it sensitive.
So, let's take something that's not Shindler's List, but something like I don't know the what's the one Rose But um
Citizen Kane.
Citizen Kane versus Dumb and Dumber. I think you can compare any two things. Yes, they're harder to compare.
I I agree.
I don't think you can boil it down to just a number, but we also don't do that with games. That's why when we're talking about games and reviewing them, we don't just come out and, you know, publish a seven, an eight, a 8.5. It's some caveat, some justification to it, like, hey, this one's rated higher because the fun factor. This is lower because the fiddlin, like we're justifying it with it. So, I do think it you can compare them, but there needs to be some explanation behind it and how you weighted the different factors based on the category of game.
Yeah, I I agree with this. in the spirit of the law, but not the letter of the law.
It also means what that it depends what that number means for you. I can compare literally any two things numerically if I want to.
If the barometer is set to how much fun did I have with this thing,
I can compare a latte to a foot rub. You know what I mean? Like
it doesn't matter unless you give me you quantify what that thing entails.
So, yes, I can aren't even that far removed. They're both games. Yeah,
I can go really crazy comparing two things.
Yeah.
And that's why a game can be on, you know, the same game on two top 10 list and on one top 10 list it can be number two and the other one it can be an honorable mention or a nine, you know, because it is
based on the topic.
It gets my problem with this this question is or this hot take is the spirit of it
which is basically saying Eurogamers and oh you're party.
This person is definitely not a party gamer. And I'm I'm kind of tired of that take cuz some of my best moments of gaming
hands down are from party games.
There's an implied
imply that they are like some lower tier and you can't compare them. I can say Times Up is better than Brass.
I can say that and I can mean it
and I think that's okay.
It's a different type of fun. And here's the thing. If you look from the outside in, you look at two two tables. One is playing a party game and one is playing a Euro game. If you have to say which one of those two are you having more fun, you are 100% gonna go party game. This guy's over here laughing. Most people at these are head down going this feels so great. But they're having a good time and but it's a different type of fun.
Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. So my thing is that you can compare them in the sense that how well are they providing the type of experience that you're looking for in those types of games, right? How well is this party game pulling off what it's trying to do? How well is this Euro game dur pulling off what it's trying to do? They're trying to do very different. Oh, yeah. Somewhat different things.
Yeah.
All right. So, the people here have they're actually very split on this.
Interesting.
11. Well, it's more disagrees than agrees. It's 11 to 16.
Uh, with four people staying very neutral on it.
I just want to
You can't compare just one to food chain magnate because one of them is fun and the other is food chain magnate.
Sure. But, but I I could see people saying the exact opposite, right?
I know. I just think that's fun. Realistic people.
Travis has another hot take.
Oh, Travis. You don't have to play a game multiple times to know there are balance issues. In fact, sometimes you don't have to play it at all. Sometimes basic math will tell you that one starting power is objectively better than another.
Travis sounds really fun to play.
I think we can double down on the he's not a party gamer now. I think yeah, that's pretty much wrapped up here. I'm sorry if you, unless you are a developer on a game or a designer or something of that game, mind you, show up at my game table and you look at, I don't know, starting factions and you go, "Oo, they're underpowered. I would like to not play with you, please."
That sounds like get out of this game card.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm sorry. Yeah.
I think if you slide
pulling out my entropy beast. Entropy beast.
I think this game's over in like two turns or less.
The entropy beast.
I love the entropy beast. It ends every game. I I feel like you can say I feel
you can say I feel to anything.
Sure. Well, no, but I mean sometimes you like because we played a game last night falling
and we had there was had special powers and people said, "Oh, your power definitely is stronger than all the rest."
But it wasn't right.
But initial things you're like, "Oh, that's even better." But you have to see the nuances of the game usually. That's the whole thing.
He's saying no. You sometimes don't even have to play it to know that. That's
He doesn't have to. I do. Travis is that much better than you. He's saying give him 20 seconds on a spreadsheet and he can tell you how broken your game is
before without playing it.
Sounds really just not fun.
Joyless. It sounds joyless.
Joyless.
Anyone else? Okay. The the there's a lot. Are there any other hot takes from Travis?
No.
I would say let's frontload this so we can
move on. Let's get through Travis's hot takes.
I like you.
Sorry, Travis.
All right. So, uh
I don't like you and I don't have to meet you to know that. That's the wild thing.
Wow. My goodness.
They say that I
13 people agreed with him, but 21 disagreed. So, there are some people who agree.
Travis is a large family. 13.
That's crazy.
Yeah, I'm doubling down.
We are now selling at the booth. I am Travis H. So, if you want to buy those shirts,
that would be hilarious.
Everybody get get a picture of Z.
And also, can we also say that
perfect balance is not necessarily an essential component of a good game? [clears throat]
For sure. Oh, that's
that's true. I agree with that.
We've been talking about that lately. Richard Garfield is that he's the king of that. We've been talking about that in uh
what's that?
Final Final Titan.
Yeah.
So unbalanced.
It is.
Yeah.
It's so great. All right, let's go to Adam A. Adam A says, "Risk Legacy is still the most exciting legacy game." He says, "While there have been arguably better legacy games, all of them are too reliant on orderly campaigns with precious little envelopes open in order."
That's a bit I don't like the word precious.
Well, okay. But he said Legacy's recipe is unmatched. Take a mediocre game from your childhood, give you the chance to absolutely wreck the thing, give you tough, permanent choices, and let crazy things happen in any order. A clear objective from the beginning. The story comes from you and not the game.
Is this a hot take or an opinion?
I think it's an opinion. I agree. It's not a hot take. There's some nostalgia in there likes it so much.
Well, I'll tell you what though. He's right on that thing about Risk Legacy. That game just was like
stuff's going to happen.
Isn't the first some in some sense always going to be the most exciting? You know what I mean? It's like you've never seen this before.
Yeah.
No, I played Dominion. No.
Oh my goodness. Okay, this is just Z doing.
I will say I think it's
Stop giving him coconut.
Oh my goodness.
Coconut. I want my coconut. Uh, I will say one thing that that uh, Adam is hitting on the nail on the head here with is the idea of taking an old not well regarded necessarily
unbalanced
and giving it this like injection in the arm. I agree that that they should do that some more.
Yeah.
Like they
restoration does that. I kind of
Yeah, they do. That's that's fair. But the idea of taking something like that and really taking go going crazy, you know? I [clears throat]
You're right. That part of it hasn't been replicated.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Okay. Well, here's the thing. He had zero people agree with him.
Oh. Oh.
17 disagrees, six neutrals. So, go figure.
Let's get Rob Davia out in the chat. Maybe he might not even
Adam has another hot take here.
Oh, okay.
Let me read the whole thing before you yell at us.
Charter Stone is still the most exciting. Like,
deluxe editions of games are getting pretty tasteless. He says, "Specifically, the Awaken Realms and Steam Forge special editions. These are becoming the goldplated headphones of our hobby. It's one thing to spend money on premium components. And far be it for me to judge people who enjoy things like designer Apple watches or Elvis painted on velvet,
but to the extent that these productions do more to showcase their own opulence than highlight game design and original artwork is offputting. They all look the same like someone is trying hard to make something look fancy.
Okay, let me tell you why I disagree strongly. Okay,
but just because people will upgrade their games. I mean, Quax is an example and a small example. They're going to upgrade. So, this is just them buying the same game upgraded. If you love it, make it look nice.
It's weird because
chets have done it forever.
I'm I'm I'm a big, you know, big shallow gamer and I I like and and but I do agree with some of his stuff. I think that
he's going for the hot take, which is what you're supposed to be doing in the comparing Apple watches to the hottest whatever. But, but that's what we're asking them to do in these. So, I don't mind it here. I think he makes some points, but I whenever you talk about a question of taste, it's just, you know, different people have different tastes.
I where where I agree with him is I feel like sometimes it's like
taking a game that really doesn't seem to be well suited for these types of things and making them is where I feel this kind of disconnect. And I'm talking about like Castles of Burgundy, things along those lines.
Sir, get like a
Yeah, that's that's a good example.
The table leg. I mean,
yeah, I'll even Yeah, that one too. The Canio one. It's like taking Scruggo and turning turning it into an heirloom furniture. It's like, you know, but it's basically
I actually even disagree on those chess sets. You spend thousands on a chess set that you'll never play chess on.
Yeah. You
probably shouldn't, honestly.
No, they sit there like, you can play chess. Here's a here's a set we can play.
Don't touch.
I mean, that being said, I love deluxe versions of games. I love blingy games, but I think where where where it seems like it's like this game didn't need, you know, all of these miniatures, like, you know, again, does Castles of Burgundy really need
Yeah.
all of those distinct buildings.
I don't think it necessarily needs it, though. I think it's okay for you to want it. And I think where his opinion is going in opinion when he's like, it they all look the same. It looks, you know, it's not highlighting the design. It's not highlighting the art. I would disagree strongly with that because I think it does do that. It brings it more into life. It makes it more tangible. It's more immersive. So, it's for me, it's more immersive into the gameplay. It's allowing me to experience that game design. So, it heightens that for me.
Would it make you play a game more like if someone wanted to play Castle Burgundy and you like it, you don't love it, but then they brought out this big one and you're like, I've never played this version.
Yeah. Would it make you That's exactly what I don't care for Castles of Burgundy. I wanted to play with the new one. That's something, right?
I enjoyed that play more. A lot of it was because of the usability increase and also did feel more like
a little more of a thematic or immersive experience. So for me, absolutely.
Mhm.
I think the thing about it is that he was talking about opulence and that's very very true. But people draw the line where something becomes opulent at different places. Otherwise,
yeah,
Google opulent. I don't know. You know, there's like people they sell fancy cars and some people that's just their car.
Okay. It's not. You're fine. Uh you're a line. You're drawing that line very little. But um
you know like having a Rolls-Royce is like but some people that's their car and that's not seen as like their a weird choice for them to have made that choice. It's a comfortable car. That's their vehicle.
Yeah. But a car spray painted gold [clears throat] and it is covered with gold. We know opulence are that guy swaggering down with a gold cup. And some some of these deluxe versions do things and you're like, you just did that to do it.
And I don't know that it makes the game better.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The game play.
Like for example, Suburbia.
Yeah.
The deluxe version of Suburbia came with 25 colors.
You don't need 25 colors.
And that's just that felt to me over the top. And it actually made the game less fun because you had to take out all those colors to get to the game.
It made it problematic to get to the table more. And that might be part of the case. It makes games harder to get to the table, but less fun. I don't know. Do you like collecting colors?
Then maybe you like that. Um it's not I mean you're not far off. I don't think this is necessarily I don't I don't say tasteless, but I understand that we are getting to that point where
there is this consumption of more is better. Full stop. And yes, we're definitely getting to that point where it's like getting ridiculous.
Yeah.
Once again, a reminder, if you're watching, you can vote on these. There's a link in the description and in the comments um where you can vote. Uh on this one, it was
uh 16 people agreed. Although most of them were mild agreement and then disagree was 20 and that was more split. There was seven hard disagree with the scale.
I'm kind of a on a soft agreement. I'm on a mild agree.
I just wish there was two versions, you know? Give me a retail option for those that don't want to go opulent.
Well, I think there I mean in most cases there are in most cases these deluxed editions are I mean the castles of burgundy it is a down the line after the game is proven and you like it you know what you're getting.
Um
I think that's my favorite kind of upgrade is when the game we already know what the game is.
Correct. You won an heirloom edition. There you go.
That's a good much better.
That was the word I was searching for in that review the other day by the way.
Heirloom.
Yes.
That was the one I
That is the word.
Okay. All righty.
I just said that. I know we were looking forward to
that was you he think
I couldn't think of the word and that's what it was.
James M says
receiving a newly purchased game box which was Dennit during shipping is an acceptable reason for return or exchange.
I need to know the severity because I'm seeing pictures of some people asking for
a new a replacement box and it's like real petty. I I'm sorry, but but like if people I think understood what it takes. Publishers don't print extra boxes. They don't.
They're taking a full game and getting the box from there. They don't print extra boxes.
So, if you've got a little dent on the side of your box, I don't think it's reasonable.
Now, if the box comes with an Amazon shipping label on the top, that's what I'm thinking. Absolutely. A hole in the side, something like that. I mean, Amazon has shipped it in a bag. You know, it needs to be in a box and protected, but at the end of the day, like
true.
No, it is a cardboard box to protect the game. Is the game damaged? The box is not part of the game.
That is that is
we have gotten to the point where we don't remember that. Like that's But it is. Yeah. Right. The box is the container and it tells you the information contained within the thing you're buying. I agree. Um, I used to be a lot less like this when I was newer in the hobby and so I understand that point of view very much, but it'll just get shelf wear on the shelf. Do you also try not to do you shrink wrap it when you put it back on the shelf?
Some people that do.
Yeah, but then it's, you know, you're being a little too precious maybe about that thing. Uh, buy two copies, have one pristine and then one that plays. Really? that that might be your solution.
Now, I will say a couple things. I mean, it depends on how the box got damaged. If it's the shipping company, hopefully they'll handle it.
But I will tell you, if you return the game and or don't return the game and they send you another one, they've now lost money on your purchase, which you may not may or may not care about, but if you like board, if you like that board game company and you have a tiny dent that you can [clears throat] barely see,
yes, you can say they should just do it. That that should be how it is. Great. But you're costing them money. And I sleep well at night, I guess, on that. I I don't know how else to say it. Cool stuff used to run a ding and dent sale at Dice Archon way back in the beginning
when they were still sold board games. And I used to go through and go,
"What?
Where's the ding? Where's the dent? These things look perfect." But they would have them sent back because there would be one small little thing on it.
And I'm also not belittling that. Like if you find a dent and I'm not saying get over it,
you know, it's
I'm going to say it depends on the severity. some of the pictures people think before you ask for.
That's it. That's exactly it. Think about
would that have happened in a couple of months of you owning it anyway? Is it worth sending back?
Yeah.
Right.
Mhm.
This is another very split one on the um the voting. 19 agrees, 23 disagrees,
although there are seven hard agrees.
Wow.
Yeah, I wasn't, you know, I wasn't surprised on that one.
Yeah.
All right. Next. Chris L says, "Games are overusing the same artists, particularly for the big releases. I would prefer to see a wider variet variability in artists used for games and not just Vincent Detroit 150 times per year. I love his art, but it's like eating chocolate every meal. Variety is the spice of life."
I hard hard agree with this.
Good. All right.
That was like the longest way. I was like, I think companies and then uh this is something I talk about AllPlay does fantastic all the time is they know the game. They understand the scope of the game, the feeling they want for the game and they get an artist to match that. Now, is that going to be Andrew Bosley? Is that going to be Vincent Duty? Is that going to be somebody else, you know, that we don't know? Is that going to be Santael is a perfect example of this game. Santael, they knew what they wanted. They wanted it to feel like this kind of vacation vibe of going to Santael. So they found a artist who specializes in artwork of Santael like beachcapes of Santael Island.
Yeah. Not a board game artist.
Not a board game artist. That is fantastic. That captured the scope of the game in the artist. And so I hard agree with this that it should not be the artist should not be a blanket to help sell the game. It should fit the vibe of the game. And you should develop the the game the way you want it to develop. And the art componentry is a part of that design process.
Can I pause a question really quick?
Why is this happening?
Because the artist has become as big as the game designer now,
which is fine, but people like Vincent Dutrey, Eno Tulle, Andrew Bosley, and I think that's I love these artists, too.
Absolutely.
But
and we have to be careful because All Play is our sponsor. Yeah.
But honestly, every time I get an Allplay game, I'm like, "Wow, I really love the vibe of the art on this game." And it's almost always I mean they do repeat artists but not that much
like the artist they got to do um things in rings which made it look like Dr. Seuss that's a great thing for that game.
Yeah.
But I think I think people are now realizing like we found this artist outside the industry and now people are like oh wow because when you bring out a unique style like Santa like that they notice. They're like oh
we're going to get a strongly worded email from Vincent Detroit. I want my work stop. It's
he's doing funny.
But it happens in every industry. Comics are doing it. You know, main the main cover artists are, you know, Campbell, Nakyama, all these, but then they reach out and they're like, "Oh, wow. This is different."
Different is good.
Yeah. And I don't disagree with this because I think, and someone said it in the in the chat, uh it's often times because publishers are playing it safe. They know that this artist is going to get me a certain number of people right away, right?
And it's easier to go to your rolod,
right? But you're right. Even artists I love, you know, can get oversaturated. The Meo, Vincent Dutra. I mean, they're oversaturated for a reason because they're great artists, but there's also other fantastic artists out there that we discover
all the time. You know,
I kind of like when I see a game with a brand new vibe. You're right. I like Dra. I'm always happy to see his artwork on a cover, but
sometimes I've also played games and I was like, "Huh, feels like he was wasted on this game."
100%.
You know, like I wish
Well, Dra's a good example. A lot of times
he is very Yeah, his look has this like particularly
snobby vibe that really fits something like Luier that setting. It's a period piece vibe, but then like
that work he did on the Umbrellas game. Like why is this
there's like six pieces of art in this game?
Yeah.
Also doesn't seem to fit the vibe. This could have been more
fun loving. His stuff seems very meticulous.
Yeah,
very serious. Very elegant.
Mhm.
It doesn't fit everything. Yeah. Yeah.
Well, I mean to that point, I mean, look at Unconscious Mind where they're merging two artists to grab two different vibes, right? They're using Dut Tree for that, you know, clinical kind of setting and then using Andrew Bosley for this this lush whimsical world, right? This dreamlight stake like that is such a fantastic uh representation of this. I think, you know, capturing an artist vibe for what you want it for in the game, for the design of the game.
Well, people agree mildly. 39 agreement. And it's interesting. 13 mild, 13 regular, 13 hard.
Disagree. 20 though. Six, six, and eight. So, and then six people are neutral.
I get it. It's hard.
Interesting.
Here's a much hotter take.
The only thing metal coins do is make your game box heavier.
I will not back your deluxe version of has metal coins. I would rather back a lower tier and take any extra stuff as add-ons, even if it results in a higher total price.
Take out the metal coins. Give them the box sleeves. That's what he wants. He wants soundtracks to to I disagree. I also
I love metal coins.
I like metal coins. I do agree. They make the game heavier. For sure. Of course. Absolutely.
Well,
I do agree. Oh. Huh. Oh, he got a couple people to agree with them.
I love metal coins. I think there's something about again that tactile feel, picking it up. You know, it's I'm a fidgeter. It immerses me in the game. If it's a coin, I want it to feel like a coin. It feels like a coin. It's one of the few currency and it looks like real currency. a few things that we can attach uh a relation to in our own lives. I know what coins feel like and now I'm immersed in this world and I have that real world connection to it.
And then beyond that, I bought those generic metal coins can be used for anything, right?
But still buying the metal coins to go with the game, it just feels better, right?
Dramatic. It does feel better. Although it's like by this logic, you should remove some of the artwork and then you pay less for the game because they have to pay the artist less
and the box will be lighter, right?
I mean, you know what I mean? No, I'm sorry. At some point, yeah, whatever. That's their line is drawn be beneath coins, metal coins. Mine is past it for sure.
And to be clear, that's fine. If you don't like metal coins, it's it's okay, you know, um that it's kind of like, do you if it has wood dice, I don't want to use except for plastic, you know, whatever your own not plastic, sorry, present, but um
I think you have it's okay to have that opinion. I don't want metal coins. I just hard disagree with this person.
Go play with Travis. I I I love metal coins, but there is a a funny point that my old pal Matthew Jude made about these. It's like, okay, well, if you want coins for a Japanese game, metal coins, you can get yen for much cheaper. Like the actual currency is cheaper. But yeah, no, I love metal coins.
Although, if you're going to use pennies, get them now.
Get them now. They're going bye-bye.
I will agree with metal dice, though. I
Oh, I did not know how much I dislike metal dice.
That's a different thing. That's a different context.
I don't I like them as counters cuz they're heavy and I'm not going to like knock them over. But even for dice play any rolling at all? No.
All right. Well, there was zero neutral people on this. That makes sense. That makes sense.
And there was nine eurogamers. Three hard agrees, but 57 people disagreed. 32 of them hard disagree.
That's a hot take. That is a hot take. Well done.
People love the metal coins.
Oh, wow.
All righty. ENT, not E and O T, but ENT says, "If your board game rules say something like, if you're in doubt about a rule, choose the most fun option, then your rules suck and you are trying to shame people into being okay with it by implying they are against fun."
All right, just say you don't like Thunder Road.
Just come out and say it.
This is my This might be one of the hardest agrees I have ever seen up on this screen.
Really?
No. I
I disagree. I think the rule of cool is good.
I disagree.
Finish the rule book. Mhm.
But okay, but on that note, you also you don't like in Oathssworn where they take and they are very pedantic about the the movement and you're like, "Guys, that's just too pedantic." Like, just make it easier. I'm like, "No, no. If they have a specific way they want it to go, it's okay to be really pedantic about it."
Yes. The rules are too complicated.
Look up.
Yeah. Look up podantic. Yeah.
Foot doctor.
How do you spell it?
Yeah. So, no, I think I actually think it's okay where it's like, hey, here it is spelled out or do what works for your group.
But they're not saying that. They're not saying
here's the real rule. It's convoluted and takes forever to figure out or you can bypass that and just kind of guess at what it might be. That's oathorn. It's kind of what it does, right?
No.
No. This person is saying that rule does not exist. And the company or the the game, the design couldn't bother to figure out every interaction. So they're like, "Some things are going to happen that we don't really know how to deal with, so do what you think is right."
I hate that. I hate it. I hate it. That feels like guessing at the game.
Man, I'm so happy.
I can just do that with anything.
I can just take a different game. I can take unconscious mind
and play a trick taking game with those cards and I'll just make up the rules.
But you're you're you're extremeing the thing. I'm talking about a game that has all kinds of combinations and like sometimes there's edge case they can't cover every edge case and so they'll say
just figure out what's good for the group and we always can I can be like well this makes sense that this would happen and you would usually you're like yeah and we go on okay with that I'm okay if the rule is unspoken because the thing is so complicated I hated saying this I hated making you feel like an idiot for expecting a complete rule book
I don't like that I don't like THAT IDEA OF LIKE HEY IF THING HAPPENS, do the fun thing.
That's not true at all because if it's like not addressed in the rule book, so that they didn't have this line and then you don't know what to do and there's not this line in the rule book, then this ridiculous. You can't even develop the game. So, it needs this line to cover that.
Think that anyway. To be fair, this rule, but
I think if you're using for major rules, then yes, it's bad. But for edge cases, yeah, come on. They can't cover every single thing.
To be fair, a lot of my favorite games of all time have this rule in them. Okay. I just I just don't like it. Like, you know, Arkham Horror, the card game, has what's called the grim rule. If you don't know how the way something should go, pick the worst thing for you and then keep going.
I do the exact opposite.
Yeah, I do the opposite. I'm like,
I'm not a big fan of the grim rule. Yeah, but it's in there and I get it.
It's It's two things. It's the implication that if you don't if you're not okay with the rule, you're not fun, which I agree with Ian. And it's the feeling of some games gave up and they're just like, "Well, play it for fun." It's like, "What do you think I was doing, man?"
I guess for me, I just feel like you're taking the rule book personal at that point.
Like, I'm not taking offense. Like, my selfesteem is how does the
Before the I would I do take offense to rule books all the time. Personally, take offense because they're terrible. Often
I miss Travis H.
That's right.
We all got along so much better. I'm going to take a nappy nap.
More people agree with Z 39 and 12 hard agrees and 19 disagrees and there was eight neutrals. A lot of people are like, I'm out of this one.
Kind of neutral, but if I I will tell you if I do see this in a rule book, I'm going to feel some type of way. I'm going to be like, really?
You know, but I also
I wouldn't I feel like it's like, okay, it's given me permission to what's you know what's fun? Well, fun for me is for us to agree on the rules beforehand and or in Arkham Horror, maybe we're gonna go with the easier option for the group or in this one we're gonna go with the harder, you know, something like that. Like I think fun is a subjective way of saying do what works your for your group.
Also, I think like I can't see a Euro doing this, by the way. I mean, I can see the Americans, you know,
they would have a meltdown.
Oh, could you imagine? They would there's riot. Yeah.
All right. Ben W has a response to many of our reviews. I'm sure many people all board games are activities. An activity is a thing that a person or group does or has done. Therefore, playing any board game is an activity. It does not matter how much player agency a person has or how much strategy is in the game. All games are an activity.
Mike's face says
all arguments are pedantic. Come on. This is a semantic.
Yeah. You're not liking the semantics, the terminology that we use.
No, but I agree. All board games are activities, but not all activities are board games. That's what we're saying when we say something's an activity, not a board game.
That's what we mean.
Yeah. And you're just being
that it's not a board game. That is only an activity. It's
right. All dogs are animals, but not all animals are dogs. That's the re the reverse isn't true. So if I say some game, I'm like, we played it, but it was basically just an activity.
You're implying only an activity, not a board game, which is also an activity,
right? And I feel like everyone understands that.
Yes. Not Ben, baby. I completely understand. Yes. All board games are an activity you are choosing to engage in. Of course. Yes. Some of them have less board game in it.
He's having a lot of people agree with it. But I also think if you just see it, it just said all board games are activities. So I it's hard to disagree with that, right?
Yeah.
Yes. Yes.
Hot take. My shirt is on correctly. Thank you.
What are we doing here?
Distracted. Does it have a tag in the back?
I'm glad you read it.
PROVE IT.
WHY ARE WE TALKING ABOUT IT?
IS NOT ON BACKWARDS. Thank you.
I'M GLAD YOU'RE AT BECAUSE I was doing this just to see if I can in the chat somewhere. Is Mike shirt on backwards
and we were very distracted.
We haven't talked so much about shirts as we have this morning.
I like that. Okay.
No, I'm I'm the exorcist and my head is just spun around.
Let's go to the one our episode is named after from Scott S. He says, "If I have 200 plus games, a game table, and upgraded pieces for my most popular games, don't bring your games to my game night. Host your own game night."
Oh my.
Now, this makes me laugh. SOMETIMES WE INVITE PEOPLE HERE to studio to game and I have people email me like, "Am can I bring my own games?"
Yeah.
And if anyone would have like an opportunity to say no, right, you could be like, "Well, we have all the games, right?" No, bring
Absolutely. You should. I think I think this to me just immediately gives me this idea or this picture of like walking in to see the king, you know, like I'm like like come see my game table and come look at my you know big board games. I'm like oh my gosh, get over yourself.
I love this also and upgraded pieces for my most popular games.
Isn't that like icky? It's immediately icky. You know what I mean? Agree.
I do understand sometimes the point there is the people who have maybe one game table, right? And they invite some people over to the game and every week they're like, "Oh, I can't wait to play Puerto Rico or Castle Burgundy, whatever." And every week that one guy shows up and goes, "Here's my news Kickstarter." Bam. Everyone plays it. And the next week that guy comes, bam. I'm like,
that's a different That's a
But that might be who he's referring to here.
Yeah. But then he needs to get his messenger to go tell the peasants.
Oh my goodness.
You are so hot today. Now, now I I agree this only in the fact that you have that those four guys that just play hgemony. They bring their own game. They want to use your table.
Look up.
Hegeman. I You know what? I went through my mind several times to whatever.
Both technically okay.
There are people that just want to play those four. I mean, that doesn't never happen because I don't have those guys.
That's why I like having more than one table.
If you have something you want to play on game night, though, and you're hosting, then that's how you set that expectation. expectation. Hey guys, I have this. Do you want to come over? Hey guys, I have a, you know, let's do a game night. Does anyone have suggestions? Then you're opening it up. This is up to you as the host to set that expectation.
Harder for introverts to like that
that Kickstarter pusher can be sometimes,
well, you already open you already somehow invited them.
Then stop inviting that person. Or if you if you don't feel comfortable addressing it, then stop inviting them. I mean, there's you have the power here.
They do get the attention. They walk like I just got this. Oh, you got yours? I've been curious about that. It does suck the air out of the room.
I get it. I get it.
But you're right. You're like, "Hey, you're come over. We're gonna play this."
Yeah.
And one time maybe you have to suck it up. And then you set yourself up to not have that happen again.
But the expectation is not like, "I'm going to invite you to game night and you need to come here and understand that I am king."
Yeah. They sent they sent the edict out into the land.
And my update
here. My favorite part of this hot take is I bet there's several people out there who are just giggling themselves silly that this person is talking about 200 plus games, right? Oh, yeah.
They're like, "Oh, THAT'S CUTE.
THAT'S QUAINT.
200 plus."
You know what I mean?
That's adorable.
200 is a lot. Don't see.
No, I'm just saying I'm sure there are people out there who are looking at this going, "Do we have no choices?" Right. Well, I love this this solution up here. It said set up the game that you want to play ahead of time. You didn't set that expectation. You set up and then when that guy comes in the kickstart, oh, that's so cool. I wanted to see that. You spend five minutes looking at it with him. All right, let's get to the g let's get to the game now. Like, you can be problem solving if this is a specific case. I don't think that you can universally apply this standard.
Well, 15 people, eight of them hard, agreed with him, but then 50 people said no.
I like that. I love love love this hot take. Very funny. Entry entry fee. Yeah.
All righty. Now, kind of the opposite here. Mike C says, "You should buy games for your game group, not yourself. Unless they're being played solo, it's important to buy games that fit the other people in your game group. Otherwise, you're just buying decorations." Hey folks, you want to know how you get 200 plus games? Right here. I did this when I first started playing games. I thought, you know who would like this game? Sally. I'm buying this game. You know what? Sally is not really all that interested in that game. I still have the game. I was looking for excuses to buy games. I'm like, "Oh, I know somebody who like to play this."
That's not quite He's saying don't buy a game that only you're interested in. Only buy a game if you know you're going to get players for it.
Buy games you want to buy. I don't
It's weird. I somewhat agree, but I hard agree with the opposite where it's like there are games that I like, but I know my group will never play it, so I don't buy it.
Correct. The opposite is a stronger argument. I think it's more like, hey, don't buy games, you know, you can't get played, right? I agree.
You know, unless you want decorations, you know what I mean? If you want the decoration or you just feel good owning the thing, go to town. But,
but yeah, ideally you want to get it to the table. And if you know it's a nofly, then don't do that. Try to get something you can actually get to the table,
which you're saying that was kind of the idea behind it was just wording,
I think. So, yeah. Doesn't matter. People still disagreed with him.
40 32 disagrees only nine degrees.
I'm trying to think if I ever actually have known a Sally.
I I was wondering if you knew one.
You usually use Sally as your
Sally is I usually use Sally because I don't and never have known a Sally.
I don't think I've known a Sally.
Sally's short for something.
It can't be right.
Salowious.
Okay. I'm just asking. Can you
That's No, it's the one from Java's past.
You never know. Okay. All right.
Delicious.
I I answered you. Thank you.
Bertha. Bertha. You can use too good. I don't know. Bertha.
I don't know. Hoarding is also a hobby.
Yeah, I don't think Sally short.
All right, just weird.
Gets more specific here. Let's do some more mild hot takes.
Okay.
All deck builder games need to have a permanent trash a card mechanic. Otherwise, you're stuck with useless cards from the beginning of the game mixed in with all that new good stuff.
Isn't that flight? He says, is the game without this mechanic? That may mean you would never touch that game again.
Which one?
Wait, first flight doesn't have it.
First in flight has cards that cycle out, right?
No. No, you
you have you um fix it and so it becomes less problematic. You like downgrade the card um but you don't cycle out
and and so on your final flight you can draw some crap cards. It can happen on your final flight sometimes. It's not very exciting final flight
I guess.
But first in flight is
first in flight is uh behaves the same way as mystic veil where you don't draw a hand of five or six cards.
No, you're pushing your luck.
Yeah. So, what's it matter if the deck is full of stuff as long as it's not penalizing you? It's like a free draw another one.
Yeah, I will say that matter.
I in deck builders, I like to run a very lean deck. You know, in Lost Dru, I almost every round draw my entire deck. I like it. That's my strategy. I like a lean deck. I like a well curated deck.
I need to be better at that.
And but that's my play style, you know, and so I
in [clears throat] theory I agree with what I think this is going for. Yeah. you know, because that's my play style. But I also love games where it doesn't have that because to me that's a different type of deck builder. You know, it is more of a pusher luck. It is more of a manipulate the odds. Yeah. You know, I want to have the odds as far in my favor as possible and I've built out these combos within my deck to to hit at the right time.
Eyes in your favor. Sorry.
Okay. I know you're going I think you got a question.
Sorry. I thought you was asking like, "Huh?" Now, I will say this though. I think I like culling in games, too. But the problem with that is it becomes almost like in worker placement games where you buy another worker. I know.
So, there's a game there's one card out there that says
get a card out of your deck and people are like done. I'm buying that. I'm like, oh, but there are other strategies
there are. Right.
You know, Dominion was almost
beat down at the very beginning because there was some the seller and some other cards and that was all people were like, I got my card deck down to five cards. I'm like, "Okay, that's great, but I would like to see other strategies."
There's also like if you can hold cards from hand to hand, it also becomes less important that you that you call your deck. You know, if you have a hand of six and you play three, but you hold the other three and and replenish, then it's a little less problematic, right? Because you can make cards meet up.
Yeah. Also, I don't want any kind of a restriction on how games can be designed.
Yeah, I agree. I think that is Yeah.
All right. Well, 29 agreed, 23 disagreed, 10 neutral. very very spoiled.
Wow.
Speaking of more more specific specific specific stuff, Mike C says, "Economic games with lots of cash transactions should include $2 coin denominations or two, you know what I mean? It's not
C stands for Canadian 51020 is a silly choice for coins. I want a looney coin and two tokens get significantly more mileage than 20 or even 10. It's a huge quality of life upgrade. Thank you, Concordia.
[clears throat]
If you don't believe me, try being banker in a game like power grid or brass for 10 minutes. What about three?
Is there a don't?
That's a That's an interesting question. That's a very interesting question. Are we thinking
1 2 5 10 whatever or 1 three 5 10 whatever.
It depends how much you make small transactions.
I forget the
those are close enough where it really shouldn't matter. It'll apply to either game. And which one feels better? I don't know. I think I'm kind of in the three camp. But threes are so hard to My mind is not wrapped around a three very
I'm definitely with Mike though.
I get that. I want there to be a lot of coins. I I don't like ones and tens. That's two.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's why.
But if you have a one five,
as long as there's enough coins, you don't have [clears throat] to make I don't like when it's like every time you get five coins, you accidentally make change or the table instantly runs out of ones.
That sucks.
Yeah.
Yeah. I don't This to me is I guess I would choose neutral, but that would have
neutrals we've ever got. There's 21 neutrals right now.
Maybe it's cuz I just don't really care much about economic games, you know what I mean? So, it's not
not an issue for me. It's more I use the higher denominations just to make change and like resource games and things, but so I'm in the hard I don't care for skulls. So, the audience here 49 votes, 24 are neutral. 11 agrees, 14 disagrees. Let's go a hot take. All right. L says, "Can we stop pretending that our hobby is mainly about the people?" It's not. It's about unique shared experience at the game table that only the game can provide. If you would be here only for people, you would not play games, but only hang out with the people and chat about anything. Not constrict yourself with superficial rules that in no way help any social communication. So what he's saying here I think is that
you are getting together to play games and if the games weren't there you probably won't hang out with those people anyway.
No
that makes it about the people though. This is giving me an avenue to hang out with those people which is about the people.
No he's saying maybe this gives me an avenue to play this game I want to play. This might as well be three lifeless robots I'm playing.
I need three automatons. I want to play this game and it needs three other people to move stuff around
to to to keep the game going. I don't really care about who I'm playing with unless they're on the show because our show is Dice Ter is a podcast about board games but especially about the people, right?
I highly disagree with this if only because
I have I don't mind sitting around talking with people but after an hour I'm like I need something to do and I love the board game. It gives us something to do and we can still chat and talk and have a good time.
Yeah.
So it's for me the people are first.
I don't know about finding something to do but it for me it's like when you talk to people it can get boring because you have that you try to find that common thing to talk about. Sometimes you just can't you know sports are different whatever. This gives you something to do as you make small talk and you'll find it over a board game. It's it really just makes it to where
it's less awkward man to be honest. But I mean, I also have those really close friends that I'm not going to get bored in conversation. And a lot of times we end up playing a game that should take an hour and it does take three hours because we're joshing around and we're having fun and we're laughing and we're sidetrack conversations. That's an avenue to hang out with that person, an option to hang out with that person. I have other people that I'm like, "This is my only connection with you. I'm glad to have you in my life, but I don't know what to do without a physical thing to draw our shared attention." This could be said about watching sports, playing golf, playing doing whatever you do with friends.
Well, going to a party,
right?
If this is if this was true, then going to a party would entail no music,
no activities to engage in. Get the food out of there. We don't need food and drink.
No,
you should just go there because there are people there. And you went for the people, right?
It's not your birthday. It's just this. Yeah.
No, I mean, you
get it. It was Joy's birthday on Monday.
You want to
You had the day off, right? Yeah, I did.
Sounds good.
You want to engage in doing something. Yes, it is.
It's about the people. Now, I don't want to play a terrible game with people I like, but that's cuz I don't want to do something boring with people I like. [clears throat]
Right. This is an This is a Eurogame argument. I'm sorry. What about the games that the people around the table are a crucial component? A lot of party games, a lot of games. I know, but I've met I've seen online there's certain people I've met many I know their usernames online who say, "I don't care who I'm playing against. I'm here to play that game."
I do care. Even in the Vegas Euro game where it is a multi and my head's down, I still don't want to play with unfun people, unlikable people.
I No,
that is the only mental list I have.
Yeah, someone the point is you need people, but the individual person doesn't matter. I disagree. I I cannot. There are plenty of people that I flat out will not play a game with.
Yeah. Yeah. I just need three warm bodies.
Right. Right. No.
Some people can make a game more fun and some can make a game less fun.
Correct.
And those people can probably make anything more fun and anything less fun to be fair. You know what I mean?
And some people I wouldn't hang out with without a game. Some people I would hang out with regardless. And the game is just an addition to that hangout. You know what I mean? Like that's okay. But it really is
it is about the individual. It is about people.
All right. Well, most people disagree with this. 45 disagree, but there were 19 agrees, but they were mostly mild.
There were 19 hard disagrees.
Speaking of people, these people.
Whoa, these people.
No, listen. Raphael says,
"If you can't read the table, you're not as [clears throat] good at board games as you think you are. Being a good player, it's about actively understanding when to push, when to back off, when to explain, when to stay quiet, and what kind of experience the table is trying to have." Sure.
I agree. I I You can go beyond this. If you can't read the table, you're not good at life as you think you are.
Social skills, right?
It's a social contract. And to be fair, for some people, it is harder to read. For sure.
Oh, yeah. And for that, if if you do have a harder time reading, that's where you ask other people to help you. I mean, sometimes someone's like, "No, no, no." And you're like, "Dude, this is a serious Euro game."
You're right.
That your chaos really is making the game unfun.
Exactly. I wouldn't say it makes you less good at board games because I have people that are really good at board games that can't read the table.
I think it goes back to what do you consider good at board games? This here is talking about the social contracted being part of that. I'm always going to point to you for THAT [clears throat] WORD. YEP.
UM
but she's like I'm simply using the old terminology,
you know, but some people say I'm good at board games because I win all the time. That's not what I consider to be good at board games. I think board games is an experience, right?
You know, and again it's an avenue of it. So, it really is what are you defining good at board games? Do you win a lot? That doesn't necessarily mean mean you're good at experiencing board games. You're good at math and spreadsheets and seeing, you know, available options
and maximizing those.
Broken beard has a rebuttal. That's a load of garbage.
If you win the game, you're good at board games.
But I tell you what, this feels like this feels like the headline of a movie where the guy has won the tournament and he's like, I've won and the person's like, you have no friends and without friends, you're nothing. I feel like that same kind of Hallmark movie moment.
Absolutely. What do you consider good at board games? Is it winning a lot? Then yeah, this is a garbage take in that case, but that's I I don't think so. I think being good at board games is also part of that is being a good player that people want to play with. You want to go be good at board games and be a jerk about it. Good luck solo gaming.
And that's what I was going to say. I hope you like solo games.
I hope you enjoy BGA or whatever. Right.
Yeah.
Well, 39 people agreed, 11 disagreed, nine neutral. By the way, if you're missing, if you're just joining us, you can vote on these. There's a link in the description of this video to vote. Speaking of that, let's go to the next one. This one I agree with a thousand% even though it's not a real thing.
Um, player colors should never be the same color as any of the resource tokens in the game.
Yes.
Yes. I [clears throat] done
you. You laugh about this, but this just came up in we're going to review it later this week. The game makers
where you have five cubes that go up tracks that are the same colors as the player colors in the game. And it was confusing because like the red cubes are mine. No, each player gets a red cube.
The the even one of my favorite games, Ticket to Ride, for the longest time when I would teach people the game, I'd be like there are red train cards. Oh, these are mine.
No, you're the red player.
I'm sorry that this is a stupid thing in this game. It's worse if it's a shared track thing. I mean, you have your own player board. Doesn't matter as much, but it's still you could have avoided it.
So many games I played, there's a yellow player in the game and there's also gold tokens that are the same as the yellow player. And I'm like, are you kidding me?
Like I said, the sparks that has the I'm the yellow player and there's a yellow track, but I'm going up the blue track. But but I'm the yellow player, so I move on the yellow, you know, whatever. Yeah, it gets confusing. It's just extra effort to me. It doesn't break the game, you know, like I still can enjoy it beyond that, but it definitely complicates the game. And that's probably
needlessly because you could just pick a different color. Yeah. And a lot of times that's when I'm looking for, oh, can [clears throat] I supplement this? Yeah. Rather than us having those player meeples, can I get a mele from a different game oralins instead? Metal coins 100%.
Every game should be like deluxe suburbia. 85 colors in the game.
Agreed.
That's what we never draw back.
Well, this is the least hot take we've had so far cuz only two real grande employees.
There was two regular disagrees, a mild disagree, and then 64 agrees. 49 of them hard.
Wow.
All right. This one's for you parents. If you bring your child, you as the parent or guardian should be the person playing games with him or her rather than expecting the host to entertain them with a game.
Let me say that.
What did you say? A thousand%.
Oh, 10,000 hard hard agree.
I'm sorry.
I will say your kid sitting here on an iPad at the end of the table grabbing you the whole time, talking to you the whole time, me having to have pretend to have an interesting conversation with a 9-year-old. Like, no. That that to me is a hard line.
You want a hot take?
Goodbye.
If you bring your child, you're not as good at board GAMES AS YOU THINK YOU ARE.
OKAY. I'm not hating your children like Mike is. I I have children. I didn't bring them to board game days.
Or if I did, it was with the group that knew that that also had, you know, something like that. We had pre-established kind of systems.
I agree with this so much.
I don't have children. you win because of the attraction and mate.
But but this is a this is a big problem
that makes massive problem
that for people who run events and we run a lot of events.
We're constantly having to deal with children.
Not because children are children. I love kids.
Parents, if your kids run up and grab a piece off a table,
you should be embarrassed.
Yes.
When you're like, "Ah, just kids being kids."
You're off the invite list straight up on that point. Yes.
And it should be okay in those situations. I mean like we have we seven and up is for Dice Tower East, right? And so I should be able to say no thank you to a game if there is a 11, 12, 13year-old that can handle this game. This isn't about them being able to play the game. This isn't about them being able to socially interact and understand the game. This is about immediately being an adult. You're putting me in a babysitting situation. I have to change my mindset and I should not have to do that. Now, if I want to, that's fine. But it should be okay to me like you guys, you know what? Never mind. I wish you the best. No, I'm out. I don't want to play with
Here's the deeper issue, I think, because like you're right. You're you're 11year-old maybe just, oh, they love they love brass or whatever. Fine, they're still 11. I think as an adult in this world, you have so few opportunities to talk to other adults, build relationships. That's what I like about these. You stick an 11-year-old at the table,
that breaks down no matter how well they play games. So that's what it's about for me.
And this is not to reply to anybody specifically in the chat, but your child is probably not as good at board games as you think they are,
right?
Um yeah, maybe they can handle some of the decision making. Uh maybe they have, you know, better impulse control than other children that same age, but it's exactly what you said. It's going to change matter if they're good at the board game part.
Are they good at the
tonally? They've changed the table. But again, I'm not saying that they can't come, but you definitely need to be the guardian. And it needs to be obvious. And I'll play a game with kids. At our game night here on Tuesday nights, we no kids are allowed in that includes my kids, too.
But there are times I get together and play games with kids. I love playing games with my kids, right?
I And I love playing games with other people's kids. But it is a very different, like you said, tonal shift. I'm like, now I'm playing games with kids.
Yep.
It's a different experience. And when that expectation is placed on you, especially unknowingly, you know, I
I think that's
I'm trying to like filter this out. I don't want to say that's bad parenting. That's but but I I think it is very poor decision- making and inconsiderate.
We will starve Juliet from a tablet for like the day or so before the game day. So on that game day, we're bad parents. She watches her tablet, you know, so I can play games or we'll play a game with her, but that's on us. It's not on anyone else to play. or I set up a playd date for them. Or as a parent, I understand there's things I want to do that I don't get to do because I have a kid.
That is part of being a parent. I have set out of many things in my life I want to do.
Yes,
that's being a parent. That's the seasonal life.
We don't care about this subject at all. Um,
yeah. It's al also it's often a selfish decision that the parent
at Dice Hour at Dice East I ran some uh what's w I mean sorry raise that bet
and there was one where some kids came in and some adults and I was like you know what this will be the kids game.
Mhm.
Because then the next game was the adults game and the same game but they ran slightly differently. Right. Right. And it just worked well.
Also
there's two hard disagrees and then 52 hard agrees. 71-6 here. So,
um, all right. Greg T says, "The board gaming hobby is becoming unwelcoming again." What he means by this,
interesting.
There are too many second edition, sequels, spiritual successors, dual versions, streamlined versions, etc. of games, even for the smallest and simplest of games. If I got into the hobby today, I would have a hard time sifting through all these things. It's called product confusion. It's a marketing term.
It's interesting. He I thought he was going to go with like the people, but he's going
No, no, no. Well, the people don't matter, Joey. Um,
but that's why I I always wait till reading these before I open up the voting. I still think people are going to vote based on that. I think the board game hobby,
taking what he said out of the case, I think it's very welcoming right now.
But I do agree. I was just thinking as I was looking at the Gen Con list.
If I walked in and I'm like, a board game store could be very overwhelming. Like, oh, I bought this. Oh, it's an expansion.
We just got an expansion for expansions.
Yeah.
You know,
Yeah. But if you walked into Gen Con 10 years ago
and you were new, it's still an overwhelming experience,
but for a different reason.
For a different I but I I understand to some extent. I don't know if I would take it to the level of it being unwelcoming. But I will say that certain product lines like I think it's if you were trying to get into Everddale right now or if you were trying to get into Dominion right now or if you you know it's like things that have so many different things like what's a good starting point. Um, some companies are better than others at saying, "Hey, here's a good place to jump in." And and uh, but yeah, I can understand a little bit of that.
I don't know if I would I don't know if I agree with this. I think the companies that are able to get games on a shelf at Target, the companies that have that sort of market penetration, right, are doing friendlier games than ever, really. So, you'd have to already be in the hobby
to then run into the unwelcoming things. And at that point then you've been initiated.
It's like jumping in the deep end.
Yeah. And you're choosing to do that because what are you talking about? There's a ton of like very very welcoming things out there. One of the most popular games right now is Flip 7, right? It's everywhere. I mean it it is unavoidable. Very welcoming. Very easy to get into. We were talking about Santael a little earlier.
That's an Avalon Hill game.
Avalon Hill 20 years ago.
Some war gamer is dying right now.
Yeah. Right. Well, they probably 88. You know what I mean? That's why they're
That's why they're dying. It wasn't me saying Santa bell.
Remember this for a future hot take.
Oh my goodness me. I killed somebody when Z said that my grandpa passed.
Um it's getting worse. Pull back, Z.
Pull up. Pull up. You're running down.
That is interesting. Some of the comments here clarifies it and I think that this would make me agree more. I don't know. I know what he means, but I would say it's overwhelming, not unwelcoming.
That is a I think I would agree with overwhelming. I think I agree with Z. I think we see it more in the hobby than
sure the surface people
because you can go to Target and see just Everdell and not realize that there are 79 and a half expans,
right?
It's like, wait, where's where's the city? We're like, where's the city on this? Which one is it?
It's Ticket to Ride.
Right. Correct. and they don't understand that Wingspan has all these expansions and that the pocket edition and different variations of Worms they don't. So to me that would be a barrier to entry. I think it can be overwhelming when you get in and we're definitely seeing that trend of people. I I think in my opinion from what I've noticed is like people getting in and they that harder jump in where it's like you know you jump in you start buying every game. Well, also now is more every game and every expansion and everything with that artist and everything with that designer and you know there's a bigger
and then you discover Kickstarter and suddenly like overwhelming hits you and you know Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah.
Okay. Um so it's a split decision here. 25 agree but 42 disagree. So I guess it's more of disagree not.
Okay. Next hot take here. Um, Ruben M says, "People that complain that games should not come with solo components that they are not using but paying for should complain also that any component in a box that they do not use is a waste and should be in expansion boxes. This would mean that all games become modular. You buy the base game for one player, then you pay for two, three, four players, etc. Players expansion and any other expansions over that."
This is known as the slippery slope argument here.
Yes, it is. Yes. So basically for some people, and I've been definitely done this in the past, I said, "I bought this game and there's so much solo stuff in. I'm paying for all the stuff, but I'm never going to play this game solo." And so Ruben is saying, "Well, yeah, but if you play mostly two-player, you paid for all the three and four player stuff, too."
Makes sense. Yeah,
it sounds good. But I will argue that the solo player stuff often adds a lot more stuff than another player.
I think that's what it is. How much? How much stuff?
Yeah, maybe. Maybe. Yeah, I I Yeah, but this is kind of a logical fallacy a little bit, but yeah, I understand what he's saying.
But I mean, I'm not really a solo player, but there's some games where I'll use that solo stuff um you know, to dummy a third player or something like that. You know, I think that that having that in there does increase the accessibility of the game when it is not changing that scope of the game like you're talking about. It's not basically a whole expansion in there or a whole module in there to change the game to be solo. That's a different you're changing the scope of it at that point. If it is some componentry to run an autonom to you know
allow that accessibility. I'm very glad that's involved and that's coming from not really a solo gamer.
Yeah. And I will say just as a general rule the more solo stuff that's in the box means that the game is probably less suited to be a solo game. If you've got to put in
15 20 different components and a whole new rule book, it means it probably shouldn't be a solo game to [clears throat] begin with. Right.
My biggest complaint against this is when an expansion comes out for a game and it adds solo play and then adds a fun module for the game.
Yeah.
Then I feel cheated because I'm like, I wasn't going to play this game solo.
So only half of this expansion is useful for me and I'm paying for all this extra stuff that has happened in the past. Race for the Galaxy and other
uh games have had that.
Sure.
I don't mind for the most part. I will say I really appreciate when games tell you what the solo components are because that's where I get annoyed. Last night I was playing Foing. Yeah.
And all the solo cards say solo on them. They do a very very good job.
That was fantastic.
But then there's also those games where the solo components don't come in it is it is it is its own standalone expansion or something like that. And because that is not
as popular then that goes out of print which means a solo player can't get into the game.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
You know.
Yeah. Yep.
Okay. So, most people uh where did I say that in that one? It was this was a split one. 29 a degree 23 disagree and most of those were mild.
Yeah.
Okay.
Okay. Z about the 88y old guy. Mark T says
it's my favorite hot take. The true value of a game is the box price divided by the number of remaining years you realistically expect to live.
Mathematically valid. I agree. I love it.
The older you are, he says
Logan's game.
The more he says, the older you are, the more you should seriously consider whether buying new games is a good use of your money.
Although I might argue, I've noticed that older people are like, well, I don't have much time to live, so I don't really care anymore. I also love that we've got across the world.
Baby mele up here as this. That's that's also fantastic.
I love that.
Also, this is math. It's infallible. You can't argue against this. This is 100% valid.
I love it.
I'm joking. I think it's silly, but it's funny.
I think it's funny. Yeah. Yeah, it's funny.
I think though, like I I really do think that it it is offset because older people and especially in our hobby buy more games because they just they don't care as much.
They just want that one experience. If they experience it once
because they don't have a whole lot of time left. They better get through that experience sooner. You know,
they will finish that.
Point being, they're not they don't have a shelf of shame.
Okay. Yeah, I will say this isn't the reason that uh I buy games by any means, but I truly believe that if you are playing games as you get older, it is good for your mental acuity. It's good for keeping the synapses firing. I think that a lot of times people as they get older
need things to keep them occupied. And board games, you're decision making, you're doing a lot of different things. I think it's good for older people.
I want that number on the box.
That's right. How old are you?
A sliding scale. How old are you?
You should be cheaper when you get old. That's right. It'll be great. You're only going to play 12.
They start putting the upper limit on there.
They're like good for 9 to 61.
62.
Now you Now you've tipped the scales.
Not worth it anymore. Yeah.
Wow.
I always abuse. They don't do that anymore. That three to 99. No.
But they used to do that all the time on boxes. And someone turns 99, people are like, "Well, you're done with games." I'm sorry.
All right. Well, again, this one 11 people agreed, but uh 42 disagreed. This is a true hot take, I guess.
Three more.
Amazing.
Um Bill S says, "Every cooperative game should have an official hidden trader motive."
What? No.
It has everything if even if things look dire, a player can still feel like they won by unmasking the bad actor. It also prevents the everpresent quarterbacking.
Okay, this just means you don't like cooperative games. I MEAN, THAT'S ALL YOU'RE SAYING. Hey guy, hot take. You don't like cooperative games.
Bill S is Travis's roommate. This is very, very silly.
It's like,
I love this. This is wild. What a wild game.
Horrible one. Especially considering every like cooperative games is get harder and harder lately.
Yeah. Like think about a word game, you know, where it's like there are word games with
No, there's no S's, you know?
My goodness. That's not how you spell potato.
Yeah, exactly. Well, actually that fiction isn't
I was going to say there are word games with
but that's not a hidden trader actually jabble.
That's what I'm saying. Like
it'll be like S A Q.
Yeah. Yeah.
The second letter he'd be like he would say S. I'd be X.
What?
You wouldn't be very you wouldn't be a very good hidden trader if you did that.
That's hilarious.
Wow. Okay. I think we're fine. So nine people do agree. Six hard agree. There are 48 hard disagrees on
nine people just read the quote.
That's very funny.
Wow.
All right. Second last. Jamie CT says, "If your board game has legacy in the title of your board game, it should not be a game that you reset back to that you can reset back to its starting condition. That's just a campaign game. Too many recent games are slapping the word legacy in their title without actually committing to the permanent alterations that make the decisions in proper legacy games so exciting. People need to accept that legacy games just maybe aren't for them if they don't like the idea of permanent change instead of demanding that game designers make their legacy games resettable, which I've seen a lot in the comments for Witcher Legacy and Nemesis Legacy crowdfunding campaigns. I do agree with this final sentence there where this
they'll make a legacy game and people will lose their minds going, "If it's not resetable, I'm out." Like you're out.
Right. Right. Right.
This is probably the strongest I've ever felt about something. I 100% agree with this. It drives me, and this is the one thing that I am kind of pedantic about. I'm like, there is a difference
in legacy and campaign. There's a difference for a reason. If you want it resettable in the box it comes in, then you're interested in a campaign game and this isn't for you, and that is okay.
But it is also okay to have a one-time use game, and I shouldn't be shamed for that. If I don't have a problem with an exit game that I'm going to cut up, if I don't have a problem with this game having this memory that I'm going to play over these hours and at the end of the day, that's what I'm walking away from, a memory. Now, do I think it's okay if you can buy a reset pack or something like that to replace those components? Absolutely. I have no problem with that. But
but at that point, you're replacing components that I have the liberty to destroy, to make those those actual alterations to this game. That is a legacy experience and that is what I expect when I play a legacy game. If I don't have that experience, then you're selling me a campaign game and be clear about that. Just be clear about the game you're play that you're making for me.
Mountain Goats Legacy.
Yeah. No, I I
a legacy game.
I I agree with this. But I do think it's neat like if you have a legacy game that permanently changes it and you cannot reset it back, but you can still play that final version. That's kind of fun if you don't need that cuz I never do that. But you know what? But it's neat if you have that neat. That's fine. That's fine.
You have your own Charter Stone game. I mean, that's your game.
No one ever plays and it makes me so sad.
I know. Library.
Uh, yeah.
No, I think this is I agree with you 100%. 100%.
Mhm.
All right. Well, unfortunately more Well, no. You know what? It's a split. 28 agree, 23 disagree, and nine are neutral.
Yeah. The ones that disagree are the ones that want to
All right. I think this last one was put in here just to get a hot take here. Sean S says, "Player aids are useless and looking in the rules is always better." Come on. Come on.
Is that Sean? Is that Shawn Stewart?
Is that Shawn Stewart?
Uh,
we're going to need some
If it is, then the next time he comes,
then he's just in there rage baiting.
We're going to take player aids out of any game he's playing.
Oh man, this is a hard disagree.
I don't This is wild. This is This person cannot really mean this plan. I think this is just
No, it's not. It's not our Sean. Okay. Wow. I I still have doubts.
This is wild. No way.
It's a terrible take.
This is not good.
Yeah. No, this is
Player eights are useless. Looking at the rules is always bad.
I think this is a I think this is a troll. I think this has got to be way this is right.
Yeah, I think this is
Unless this is by the company that gives you no player aids and they're like, I refuse to make them.
I'M GOING TO ASSUME since that's Mike Keller's little dice guy. I'm going to assume this is Mike Keller.
I know. Poor Mike. If it's not Sean, it's him.
I think so.
Look, it's a lot of work to make these things. I stopped trying to match the picture to the thing. It's just random.
I'm still blaming Mike.
Definitely 100% Mike Heler put this out there to troll everyone. Uh yeah. No, this is this is terrible.
But two people hard agree with this one. I think they're also trolls.
Mike Heler and Sean.
59 59 or 60 hard disagrees. It's 71 to four. No one's neutral on this.
Yeah. And again, I think the four people are trolling at this point.
Yeah.
Um All right. That's silliness. All right. Well, there you go, folks. Um hot takes. If you have hot takes, send them to me at tomdicar.com. We'll do this in several weeks from now. We'll be back live later today with Crowd Surfing.
So, check that out. And then tomorrow, we will have the news and tomorrow we're going to be bringing you a first of several Gen Con previews.
So, and lots of reviews going up. And this weekend you'll hear about a legacy game.
All righty. Thank you all for playing. I don't know playing, but for voting, I guess.
Sure.
And if you're watching this later on, you can still vote after the fact if you want to.
Okay. Really?
Oh, that's interesting. That's cool.
Vote often.
Yeah. I still would never understand the whole American Idol like you can vote up to 10 times.
Why? I know. Yeah.
Like, isn't once good enough?
Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. All right. Anyway, until next time. I'm Tom.
I'm Z.
I'm Camila.
I'm Mike.
And I'm Joey.
We're Legacy. One of us is not permanent. Hey, uh, thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh, we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description of this video, and we have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel, and I hope you enjoyed this video.