Skip to main content
Loading video...

Frenemy Pastry Party Review - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 12:50

hey folks another broken beeper review and we've got a couple of videos coming out from time one funny enough first up is a titchy little game called frenemy peachtree party not the first song name that would drag me towards a card game I admit but the interesting thing with this is that it's from me table games and they were at the UK games Expo and it was because of them I got introduced to small islands which is currently sitting right behind me on the shelf down there somewhere you know a really cool game now granted they were only distributing that one in Taiwan the original creator of that was mushroom games but this is from me so games directly and it's done by Jesse Lee who if some of you have played a lot of sort of dry euro games will recognize the name from a Ponzi scheme so it was a little bit like no no now that we found a Ponzi scheme but you know this looks like a fun little family card game so maybe this will be something a little bit different and in front of me pastry party the premise is very simple you're all a bunch of cute animals baking cakes okay sounds pretty cute here nice but is this gonna be for kids not quite although you can play it with them of course the idea is is that each of you takes control of an animal with a specific taste mango strawberry lime that kind of thing and all of you in the group are trying to bake cakes you're trying to get the most points at the end of the day in cakes or a five points a piece but what you do is that you are drawing from a sort of tableau of cards and they have different ingredients like strawberry mango like I mean oh my god yeah baby frickin I love

mango and I love lines so it's like yep on a mango and lime cake please somebody beat me one please but with this one is that you're drawing these currents and eventually one of you is gonna say Ryan well I need to bake this cake and I'm gonna go bake this one here on this tableau and it may require two strawberries freeline one mango whatever and your idea is is that if you can make all these if you do all the greedy ins yourself then great but that takes time it's not worth doing in this though you are trying to ask other players to help you you can ask up to two players for various ingredients and there you can lie about what they've got or they can offer to help by putting down the ingredients and if you're able to make the cake then you make it otherwise next player term otherwise you're basically drawing cards round and round it the idea is though is that when you help someone else bake a cake the ingredients that you put in go underneath your card and not only do they count as points but they count towards your bonus at the end which is your animal specific taste like mango and strawberry but if you bake the cake yourself you don't get the cards you just get the cake so you're trying to sort of coax other players into saying well you know look you assist me with this cake we'll get points you'll get points as well but as a result of me baking the cake I'll get points of the cake you can have points for your strawberries that you've contributed and maybe you have an incentive of getting all the strawberries so the idea is is that is kind of a group think game where it's semi co-op in the sense you know you're trying to win outright by yourself at the end of the day but as a result of other players semi cooperation you can actually get the cakes baked so as you

can tell this game is very group dependent but more on that later first up it's a nice little portable box you know it's cheapest chips you know this game is not gonna set you back a lot of money of course all the content is literally just a bunch of cards a lot of pretty cards I will admit don't worry it's fully language-independent there is no text other than the raw books and each ingredient is very easy to tell I mean a lime a mango and you to actually see it a chocolate and somewhere in there's a strawberry or blueberry even you know nice healthy berries and that's basically what the cards are just a ton of ingredients a bunch of cakes which I swear looks so indulgent I think I gained about freestone just by looking at the thing and then of course the cute little animals you get which beans or the Taiwanese or at least you know Asian theme I like the cutest of kawaii style cats rabbits believe ones called a Cooper Carper or something goes out when it's colder like a ferret little raccoon yeah it's very cutesy and definitely accessible for families as well I mean I could see you playing this with your kids without too much trouble now the rules are very simple as a thing I've explained pretty much 95% of the rules just by that little review and of course you know being cutesy themed in that it's just basically a nice little party game that can cater for between six players however much like Jeff Goldblum says in Jurassic Park just because you should doesn't mean no just because you could doesn't mean that you should but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't start to think as I

showed with three and four players this game kind of fails hard and that does sound pretty negative and it kind of is because I have played this for three four five and six players there is no reason you should ever play this for free players ever and probably not even a reason you should play it with four you should play this with a minimum of five and ideally you probably should just write a big fat six on the box and call it a six player game but five is right five and six players is the way you play this the reason for that is is because the game doesn't scale with play account so the cards in the middle are just the same and the problem you have is that Brandon and may be different with your grew bored even with your country but I swear in Britain we're just selfish players because everybody I play this with and this is back to the whole group dependent issue is that if people get really selfish and try to bake the cake themselves because they think oh well I'm not gonna let anyone else get points you know I don't care if they get only one or two points I'm not letting them have it I want the cake to myself they will just draw card after card after card ticket the right style hoard the cards and just try and bake the cakes themselves or just flat-out refuse to help you when you say look I'm gonna bake this cake do at mango nope well you do have mango because I've seen you joy nope don't help you and that can really get grating but with free and four players mold people want to just simply get the ingredients and fake their cakes and that gets very annoying because at that point it's like well why we even laying this group game where

you're supposed to think about oh yeah I'm going to be doing this with you know grow these cards and now I know he's got strawberry and nobody's got blueberry so if I get these to the help they'll probably help and then you find out they weren't anyway again very very group dependent but in three and four players everybody just draws cards and also you can ask a maximum of two players for help so with free and four players I mean four players you've literally got three people to pick from and in free players you are asking both other players all the time you're not even anyone out so you really need the five and six play account in order for people to sort of go alright now I've got to remember who was picking up strawberries who was picking up mango you know at least that opens it up not to mention that because there's more players the card count doesn't change which means there's less cards to go around which means there's hopefully less incentive for people to just try and horde cards and bake cakes themselves of course I play with a lot of selfish players they kind of forget this fact you're supposed to help other players make cakes but not too often so that they get all the cakes but you can't just try and bake a cake yourself because you typically won't win unless everybody in the group does it and then it's really just the case of who baked the most cakes it it's it's one of those games where this is very very fragile you you play with the ROM play account it will just fall flat it will fall on its face and hit the ground hard you play with the right player account you still have to wait for somebody to sorry

you still have to sort of get that perfect group it's for oh I am gonna semi cooperate with all you lot I will help you with these ingredients I mean I'm they're constantly offering ingredients not even necessarily my special buy taste I'm just like look I want points I will help you with this cake and people just don't want to take it so it's it's kind of an odd one this I mean it's got a good amount going for it it's short this game will last between was it say 15 to 30 minutes that's pretty accurate 30 minutes is as long as six player game should take and less players god forbid you play with less players will take you even less time it is a quick filler game and granted we need a few more of those in the industry at the moment because we always seem to overstep the filler mark it is beauty artwork very colorful language independent color blindness is not a problem it's different pictures so all like manner of gaming ability gamer abilities and you know and experiences and ages you know can happily play this game without any trouble at all is gateway level you know free to six players like I said do not play would ruin four point five and six but the thing that stops me really liking this game is like I said the that problem with it being fragile when the game works it works fine it's a nice little filler game it doesn't blow my mind but the idea that you're trying to remember who's got what ingredients and you're trying to there's a bit of a bluffing aspect to like no no I didn't

draw the mango no you miss wrong or more the kind of not necessarily the live thing but that cooperation I think do I want to help you do I want to help you and you got to be careful not to ask somebody for too many ingredients because you just say have you got any strawberries well if they've got free for your cake that requires free strawberries then bang they put down free strawberries and it's like no I didn't want you to help yeah much you know so you gotta be a little bit careful there's a bit of a memory aspect to it but yeah I mean all in all it's a simple filler card game I think that in a game cafe it works perfect and I think for families it's gonna work perfect as well I'm not certain I can see this being a gamer like that a veteran gamer level game this is definitely gonna be like an entry level thing more for families more for newer gamers that kind of thing but again my biggest problem is just that it does not scale very well and the fragility is that word of the nature of the game based on who are playing is also going to affect your experience because if people play selfishly it doesn't matter who wins and loses the game won't be enjoyable but if people really get into that whole sort of semi cooperative team aspect then it starts to shine so all in all it it's fine it it's it's hard to write something that is that fragile but for me it gets an average six I like it above-average six you know it looks good it's easy that it's easily accessible it's you know short it's just got that major player scaling problem and the fragile rook thing and I'm just not I can't write it any higher because that

is a legitimate problem but for a filler game those cheapest chips you get the right group of six people and you should probably give this one a try because I saw a lot of people having fun with this at the expo and I've watched other groups play with this and find that they're constantly offering ingredients for other cakes and when that happens perfect you've gathered hit on your hands but for me it's just not working with the people I play with it's a bit of a shame because I would have liked to have sorted this in somewhere in the collection but for me I'm probably gonna donate this to my local game cafe and hopefully more people will get to enjoy it so that's a frenemy peach tree party from me so games by Jesse Lee so that's it for me I'll see you on the next review when I will be looking at read on - cow also from Taiwan so take care and I'll see you on the next Roca meatball video remember to click Subscribe if you like the content and remember whether you offer it well whether you slip to me a dodgy mango or not in my cake it's still only a game take care and I'll see you next time

you

Progress saved