Merchant's Quest Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Merchants quest which is a 1 to6 player board game that takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play uh on average this one is launching on Kickstarter on the 21st of May 2023 and all of the components I'm showing you today are of a prototype copy so there may be some changes between the version you're seeing here uh and the final copy but before I get started on my review of Merchants Quest I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor K ender.an retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so during the setup of merchants Quest you are going to randomize all of these hexes on the board and you can see there are a ton of these divided up into three different terrain types you've got the lowlands which where you're going to start with your Your Wagon to work through you're going to go into the mountains and then you're going going to go into the highlands and hopefully end up in the castle uh on one side of the board you have the round tracker and depending on the player count you'll have more or fewer rounds so you can see here in a one or two player game You'll Play 25 rounds but in a 5 to six player game you'll only play 15 now you also have a bunch of additional resources such as these gems you've got the actual resour resources themselves such as the
bread and the fish and the potions Etc and you've got the money you've also got a few decks of cards such as these quests you've got these items from the wagons and you also have some dice these three different dice you've got the gem die you've got the movement die and you also have the resource die um and each player will also get given a number of these little Huts that'll be used on the board as the game goes on you'll see why each player will also get given a resource guide to show how much the resources can be bought for and sold for in the different locations uh on the map now during setup you're going to get given a number of these quests that will give you some bonus points and I should say that the overall kind of objective of the game is to make as much money as you can when the game ends so you can see here that I've been given these quests here I think you only start with three but I've given four out here just to show you some examples so if I travel through a cave I'll get an additional three coins if I sell a wheat at a village I'll get three bronze if I'm the first player to enter the castle I'll get three bronze or if I carry four different resources at the same time I'll get three bronze so after deciding the starting spot for Your Wagon on each player's turn you are going to roll uh the movement die so for example I'll roll it like this uh I've rolled a four so that means I can move four hex's uh on the board so it is a true roll and
move Style game now when you move onto hex you're going to reveal what's on it so let's just say I go here for one you can see most of the tiles will look like this where it's just a simple pathway and a thorough fair to move on to the next tile you can go back on yourself you can go sideways or of course you can progress throughout the map so let's keep on pushing let's go for two movement uh three movement here and finally let's go for movement and hopefully we'll find something and we have found uh something here we found a village so when you find a village you are going to roll the resource die like so I've rolled the uh the Water symbol therefore I can refer to my resource guide and buy as much water as I like bearing in mind that I can only ever hold up to five of a particular resource at any time so I could say spend 10 coins in order to get five water into my Supply and hold it there with aim of trying to sell it down the road so as I said if I end up selling it to a uh a a village in the highlands and that particular Village wants that resource then I'm going to get some profit there and if I bring it all the way to the castle I'll get some additional profit now something else that's important to say is that things like villages will end your turn if you decide to engage with that tile so you know if this was the first tile that I moved on to and I decided to buy some resources then and I'll end my turn immediately but let's take a look at some of the other hexes
that you may find um in the lowlands so I've progressed a few rounds on here and bumped into some different tiles so the first one is this one here that will simply allow you to draw a new Quest from the deck you have these wagons that look like this where you will reel the next card from the wagon deck which will give you a bunch of different things such as getting resources so in that this example I'll get a free uh piece of rad you'll find other Villages and you will find um these little Bandits that are hiding in the woods as well which will actually steal your most valuable resource from you now something I should have said earlier is that when you visit one of the villages you will place one of your huts on it to show that you have already visited that Village and that's important and it stops you from going back and forth to keep on buying uh resources however if you end up venturing into the highlands and selling that particular resource or sorry any resource then all of the Huts will come off any Village that you visited before meaning that you can visit them again so let's take a look at what you might find in the mountains so the mountains are a bit more difficult to Traverse through whilst you have got still the standard Pathways you will be spending a lot of your time when you discover TS finding uh these little mountain peaks that you cannot travel through is impassible terrain meaning again it's going to take you a bit more time to sess out where you can and go you might find dead ends and you might find complete barricades and will present themselves to you
meaning you have to again move around however there are some different things that may pop up such as the caves uh the caves allow you to move from one to another with a single uh movement point and as you can imagine as more caves pop up you might be able to go all the way um across the mountain range there you also have these Minds when you reveal one of those mind tiles uh that player will get the chance to roll the gem die and they'll be able to take a number of gems from the supply depending on what they rolled and that corresponds to the Dwarven Village because if you end up having gems in your supply going to the Dwarven Village which is normally hard to find because it's only one of them in the entire um stack of those hexes then you will have a chance to sell those gems for five bronze each they're very valuable again it's going to be an all or nothing style strategy additionally when you visit the Dwarven Village you'll have the chance to obtain one of the special items you you first come first served on these you've got the climbing equipment which will actually allow you to pass through the mountain peaks you've got the shield that prevents you from getting robbed by thieves you've got the horse that adds one to your die roll uh and you've also got the backpack that allows you to carry seven of each resource rather than the standard five and finally in the highlands you'll still find the tiles you found previously such as new Mission tiles Etc and you'll also find the delivery Villages that look like this so
each of these Villages wants two types of kind of preferred Goods in this example you've got the bread and the water so if you remember I ended up paying at 10 coins for five water earlier here because now this Village wants the um the water I can sell those for three each meaning that I'm making a profit of five there so that's how you are essentially going to get your money um again if you make it to the castle um providing that the dice will work in your favor and you've left yourself enough time that any resources you have will sell for the maximum price here and end up getting you some additional points but of course it is a push of the luck because uh the game is quite well balanced in terms of how long things take and how quick it's going to take you to get uh to the castle before the time runs out so you may want to cash in before you get to the castle because you might not even make it there uh in the first place and that's essentially how the game works the player with the most points uh at the end of the game will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on Merchants quests now as you can see this game is a roll and move game and I think instantly that is going to deter quite a few players but I have to say it works really well for this game and that is because the the timing of rolling the dice and you know weighing up the averages and what you can Poss possibly do uh in contradiction with the time track is really interesting because again you do need to allow yourself time
to get what you want done and there are different ways you can approach the game as well you do you want to kind of meander around the part here collect um all the goods that you want you load up with the hope of pushing through the mountains and then maybe going straight to the castle or do you want to find a settlement and go back and forth as much as you can um do you want to go make a be line straight for the mountains find all those gem Minds before anybody else does then go searching for the Dwarven City completely get your money that way and then make a be line for the castle um or do you want to you know take a nice mixed approach um of all of them and the fact that you are subject to the dice roles makes it a lot more interesting because again you are always against that ticking clock you know can you get everything you want done before that R uh that before that um turn counter moves right to the bottom I think this game does a fantastic job job of kind of Bridging the Gap between older more traditional games you may have played as a child and more modern kind of Euro style games because yes you have got the role and move um but you have got that kind of resource management you have got sub decisions in terms of how you want to um you know progress with the game do you want to sit back and let other players pave the routes for you and then piggy back off their efforts or do you want to again take that chance potentially get robbed or potentially find you know a literal gold mine out there so I do like the fact especially with the mountains that if people are really pushing on and ignoring the first part of the game you can kind of lay up or follow up in their
footsteps and use their already established routes without wasting your movement discovering um all of those mountain peaks I think the game does a good job of bringing forward that feeling of Adventure now because it always feels good when you you know reveal these tires when you step into a new one are you going to get robbed and that that fear is there but at the same time that risk and reward Factor does shine through and going back to the roll and move Style part of the game even a lot of the times when you are um you know Rolling High that is somewhat going to get mitigated because if you do want to stop at certain spots again like um you know the quest s The Villages and things that's going to end your turn anyway so again that is going to somewhat even things out as the game goes on and you're not going to keep on getting massive benefits by know rolling higher in in opposition to say your opponent and rolling low all the time of course that is going to hurt you if you are moving slow um but you know I think the game has enough time for that to even itself out unless you are incredibly hard done by the player interaction in general is fairly low uh in this game I did mention earlier about the option of piggybacking of other people's efforts that does come through quite quite a lot and happens a lot in this game um but mostly you'll be focusing on what you're doing by yourself you know establishing your own trade routes and focusing on what you're doing and there are some little things you can do by blocking certain spots by parking on there and stuff but is still fairly low in general uh there are some cards that might mix up a little bit such as I mentioned earlier with this Quest here says beat the first player to
enter the castle and several play players might have this card which again could bring a little bit more tension into the game okay so let's share some final thoughts on Merchants Quest and again I want to stress that this is a prototype copy I'm sure some of the imagery will be changed up a little bit um hence why I didn't want to comment too much on the um production quality here the copy I have here is lovely um but I'm sure it's going to be different to what it's going to look like finally um you know if only better um but all in all this game is actually um it works way better than I thought it would do this game oozes charm as I said it bridges that gap between older style games and newer newer games um exceptionally uh well the roll the move actually complement the gameplay quite a lot the fact that that ties in so well with that round counter brings through a lot of tension and when you manage to pull off everything you want to with just a round or two to go if feels really good and it does have that kind of gambling effort you know are you going to have a whole wagon full of goods and you're going to die right on the border before you get to the castle or are you going to play a bit safer and visit these preferred Villages and offload your goods Al together you know sometimes you might even be tempted to sell um unwanted Goods at these locations just to increase your cash flow so that you can continue with what you're doing um and because sometimes finding those preferred Villages um just might not be an option because you just cannot um Discover it but all in all it's a lot of fun um any everybody I've played this game with has left with a big smile uh on their face because again it's hard not to be Charmed uh with this game it doesn't outstay as welcome at all you know we played the three playay
game of this in about 40 minutes and which feels right on the money for me and if you have say a younger family um and you want to start introducing them to some Eurostar mechanisms again bridging that Gap with those older roller move star mechanisms then this is like the perfect option because you've got that that supply and demand thing going on um and you've got that risk management thing going on um as well and you know what I am actually really intrigued about what you could potentially do with this simple system you you could add so many little um modules and little bonus tiwes you could throw into the mix just to spice the game up you know my mind is really running away with me when it comes to that and I hope that the game does well because I want to see what else this can bring but as it stands I think it's lovely um I think that if you are into heavier games and you play with exclusive you know hardcore Gamers and this probably isn't going to be one for you long term you might want to give it a go as a novelty but again if you are a more family oriented gamer um then you are I think you're going to be Charmed uh with Merchants quests so again the kickstarter is launching at the end of this month so be sure to check that one out so that's Merchants Quest by shander games