Darwin's Journey Review: A Journey Worth Taking?
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are board of it and Welcome to our review of Darwin's journey in this tight and tense worker placement Euro for one to four players you'll join Darwin as he recollects his adventures and research across the Galapagos and you'll also be sending some letters it's very important to keep in touch with your pals when you're adventuring around inspired by Darwin we're going to take you through the pros and the cons of Darwin's Journey you might wonder what I mean by that well famously Darwin was a big fan of the pros and cons list so much so he actually made one on whether he should marry his wife or not he had gems on the force such as someone to look after the house and better than a dog and on the against he had can't go to the club with a voice anymore and he wouldn't have enough money to spend on books is yours well I wouldn't say you're better than a dog Fair yep but on to the review here we have the Lesser spotted Swenson
Darwin's journey is a worker placement game that will last for five rounds each turn you take a worker from your player board and place it on the main board in order to take an action along the top you have the four main actions you have exploration and navigation which will allow you to move your Explorer and your ship respectively along the tracks at the bottom of the board then you have correspondence which will have you taking stamps off of your player boards and placing them onto the envelopes as a little area control minigame and the players with the most stamps in each area will get a bonus at the end of every round and then lastly you can study in order to buy seals many of the action spaces require the workers to have a certain combination of certain colors of seals and thus you can build your workers up how you want with regards to where they can go and what they can do then down here you have the special action spaces which are randomly drawn tiles which will change every game then underneath that there's a space where you can go to unlock actions and then you can send workers to those unlocked actions in future terms other than that you have your classic change turn order space and you're taking objective space once you fulfill an objective you pop it into your player board and then you'll get a reward and then finally you have the museum throughout the game you're going to be studying specimens and then you can go to the museum to deliver your
research and increase your understanding of evolution or you can study specimens out already at the Museum the evolution track represents the research that has gone into understanding the theory of evolution and acts as an end game scoring as it's a multiplier based on how full the museum is now you'll win the game if you score the most points and these come from a mix of gathering them throughout the game and or round scoring and end of game scoring each round will have a unique objective for example get six points for every bird that you've researched however these are linked to the HMS Beagle which will move along the navigation track each round if your ship is behind the HMS Beagle then you're going to start to lose points from what you would have scored we're going to tell it to you straight Darwin's journey is your bog standard Euro game no bells and whistles just all of the Euro things you know and love do you like tracks lots of tracks like five tracks do you like work placements faces plenty of those do you like contract fulfillment and around scoring end of game scoring all there the good news is that if you are a fan of Euro games you're going to pick this up really quickly and be away you're going to enjoy the different areas it gives you to explore the different strategies that become available to you the bad news though is if you're looking for something Innovative if you're looking for something a bit different not going to find that hair that said the game does really well at creating replayability and different challenges
within its system particularly if you have the collector's edition which you believe most people do there's only about 1 in 15 people on Kickstarter actually backed the base game not only does the randomness of the special action tiles the Beagle scoring tiles the objective tiles and the specimen tiles cause each game to feel unique the expansions included in the collector's edition send the variability into the stratosphere there's one big expansion along with four to five mini expansions which mix up the game in different ways or throw some new tiles into the mix interestingly you can also play scenarios which have you craft the game setup and thus push players into certain strategies to guide those strategies the game does really well at providing interesting decisions when you do navigation do you sell your ship sideways in order to get some Rewards or continue full steam ahead in order to keep up with the Beagle when you do exploration there are often branching paths with the rewards on those paths equally of Interest so it can be hard to decide which way to go for all of the main actions are of equal importance and have their own benefits so again it can be hard to decide which one to go for and then what sales do you buy for your workers what type of strategy you're going for and which skills do you need for that but arguably one of the best parts of Darwin's journey is the way it allows you to combo often the actions you take will
provide you with Rewards or further actions which at the best of times you can link to have a really powerful and epic turn it's really fulfilling and satisfying when this happens as well as providing a little endorphins bars of oh I get stuff it also allows what are fairly basic actions to become a lot more interesting through the puzzle of how do I do this to then get this to then trigger this to combo you'll need to be able to read the game and know all of your options available to you at any given time because Darwin's Journey has a lot of different elements and it's a tight game the more you play the more you're going to improve so if you're a fan of games that are tough but the more work you put in the more rewarding they are then Darwin's Journey might be for you with each game You'll Play you'll do more and more the combos become more exciting and the scoring is going to increase dramatically unfortunately despite all that work that comes to mind for me when I think about Darwin's journey is inelegant there are a lot of arbitrary roadblocks and strange decisions which just make us think why don't we just play the games this is aping and probably the kind of underlying factor which is behind a lot of our criticisms actually is the theme a lot of effort has gone into making this theme come to life of remembering Darwin's journey in
terms of the art and the components and the actions but there's quite a big disconnect between the actions and their mechanisms and the theme and what it means is that a lot of the things here which are quite obviously there to make the game feel crunchy or tight they just feel like an arbitrary roadblock thrown up done because it's how other games do it it doesn't tied to anything and that leads to kind of feelings of player frustration I can't remember a game where I played this many times and I'm still checking the rulebook for basic actions just because it feels off to me like it's common to have to pay a penalty to take the same action as another player in a work placement game that's completely fine but here why are you paying money to go visit the same page of the diary is Darwin it aren't we all Darwin like why are we paying ourselves to re-read the diary it just doesn't make any sense why money is involved and even worse than that and this boggles me as decision in the two to three player game you have to pay to the supply to take a completely different and unrelated action just because another player happens to be in the same area they arbitrarily designate as a section all one part the same thing this doesn't happen in four player game where the actions are split into their individual actions even worse than that
a two-player game you have to pay more money than you do in a three-player game to go where someone else's even though there's the same number of spaces and you might say oh well that you have more freedom no because there's only really four places you would go the sections if you will and where you go isn't really you're not going to go just because it's free you're going to go to where you need to go or where you can go based on your resources or the seals your workers have so over the course of a game you can pay 10 to 20 more coins than you would in a two player or a three-player game and money is tight and why is you play being punished for playing two players it just feels like they needed to make the game Tighter and they just thought oh well how can we do this I'll just make you pay money for it that's what you're doing work placement games and it's so jarring in relation to the theme and every the actions next let's go to the end of round scoring this system is lifted wholesale from branch you know five rounds unique and round goal to score and it tied to how far you are per track if you aren't far enough of that track you begin to lose the points you gain now in barrage is tied to a core element of the game producing power in fact that could be said to be the goal in Branch also branch is very tight and tense and if you're getting any points from these objectives you're doing really well it
is high or impossible to farm the objectives there at least more than one here is tied to the progress of the beagle thematically what is that are we not remembering quick enough secondly to kind of catch up with the Beagle you have to do navigation arguably the most boring action in the game because all you do is move your ship up and most of the spaces do nothing secondly you can easily find these objectives which is completely fine it's a viable strategy but to the extent that if you're not interacting with the beagle and these objectives and other players are you're probably going to have a tough time so you're also being forced to take the most boring action in the game still a few more on top of that smaller ones though theory of evolution track the majority of multipliers for that whole specimen system are within the first third of that track and you tend to move up it a fair bit just passively and it just means that players who really engage with that system are only getting kind of double the points if that of people who haven't looked at it at all and it takes a lot of effort to interact with that and kind of deliver to the museum and move up so it's like why bother then you have the special actions and they just tend to fall a little flat
they're a bit too situational they all kind of need three to four seals and this means not only do you have to have workers that will match them or build workers to match them they have to be unlocked and so they're not really getting much use if at all until the late game where you probably have a strategy and you maybe don't want to divert anymore to just do what it gives you then the wax seals sounds like a really interesting idea building up new workers giving them the right attributes that you want to send them different places but in reality it was never an interesting decision you're basically going to build them to match the crew cards because you get a quite good reward or you can build them to be able to take the special actions and once you decide that that's the decision that's done you anything else is incidental finally it feels like a game made to be played at four players and every player you take away from that it gets a little bit worse so far thoughts important to note that a lot of other people are really loving this game from the talk we've seen online they find it to be a crunchy decision-filled Euro with a lot of different paths to Victory so maybe just have a look at some other reviews as we feel like we might be in the minority here yeah and the thing is despite what it might have sounded like we don't hate that one's Journey uh we've played it a number of times and we enjoyed playing it enough it was just that as nothing's unique here a lot of other
games have done what it does better yeah in fact several aspects are ripped wholesale from one of our favorite games of all time branch and I just think when I play this why wouldn't we just play one of those other games um but and and when I think about Darwin's journey and talking about it I just think of all the little annoyances as well how it just doesn't quite come together for us I think yeah but I mean it's still fine and you know please tell us below why you completely disagree with us which I assume will be like 80 of people uh but hopefully this review was helpful though or at least gave you a different opinion uh as always really appreciate you watching and if you did find it helpful please consider subscribing but if not then we will see you next time and thanks for watching again