Senjutsu: Battle for Japan - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Burning the Loft, and Zach and I are doing a discussion over Senjutsu Battle for Japan. Uh so this was a game that I had backed. I I don't remember why or themed. Or pretty much. Um cuz whenever it was coming in, I was like, I don't remember anything about this game. But I love this setting. I love this theme. And then as it started to come in, I was like, oh okay. Yeah, let's check it out. And I was like, oh, it's a skirmish game. Yay, because skirmish games typically do not work for me. Um they're either too random or That's usually actually mainly a lot of the reason is a lot of it it resolves in die rolling. Um but this game didn't have any dice. It has a deck of cards with what looks to be very overcomplicated like cards, but they they actually make sense once you bad. Um but yeah, I remember like kind of looking through it and seeing like this.
And you're like, oh my god. Like there's 18 different checks. Yeah, I kind of just looked at it like Gloomhaven where they have a lot of times where they have three different things and you just go in top to bottom order. So it wasn't Yeah, once you have any semblance of what the rules are, it it makes sense. Oh, okay, that color means I have to be in that stance. I'm not in that stance, so ignore it. Right. Um okay, so first and foremost, uh we uh have only used precon. So I want to cuz some people will be if any valid complaints that we have, they could be like, well, that's actually a really bad precon. Which so you need to build it this way, which I would argue no ever precon should be valid um from the get-go. Uh but yes, that's every game ever that's deck construction.
Right. Every magic precon is not meant to take Every magic precon is not meant to take to a tournament. Right. Uh It's get you into the game. Yeah, it's learn the essence of the game and then you're like, okay, now I understand what this this character is about. Let me build around it. So from my viewpoint I do enjoy this game, but the issues that you're going to bring up, um I'm also going to agree with. So I'm not going to be like well, actually, uh because I won handily, this game's a 10 out of 10. Uh no, because I want to say if I cuz usually people will be like, oh, you only like a game if you win, or you only don't like a game if you lose. It's like well, I'm not that shallow. So Uh or at least I hope I'm not.
Um but yes, if you lose a game, you're probably going to be more critical than you would if you won it. That's just human nature. But overall, I do like this game. I think it is very thematic um in what they're trying to do. And they have a lot of options in terms of expansions that are relatively cheap. So let's go into the game. Zach, what do you think of Senjutsu Battle for Japan? Battle for Japan. As game mechanics go, I think it's fine. Okay. Um and again, not looking through all the cards. I haven't looked through the entire deck. The way the game operates it's fine for most of it. Um it is a lot iconography and I'm trying to understand to a certain extent some of the purpose for all that iconography. Mhm. Um cuz you have complicated things like so if you both have initiative well, it comes down to the card type then breaks tie. Yeah.
But you already have something that says here's the break tie right there. Yeah. Why not just use that to break the tie right there? It's a skirmish game. If this played with four players at once, okay. Then maybe. Then it's a rock, paper, scissors situation, which And they do have rules for multiplayer. Okay. Um it seems a lot of people say this is best at two. Hell, even the game comes with two solo campaign rulebooks. So it seems like they wanted to be one or two players. Right. Cuz in the three-player game, one of the reasons why I opted to not have Brett here, one because I thought the I think the iconography he'd be like, I don't [ __ ] want to deal with this. Right. And two, yeah, you run into that weird thing of like, oh, you you know, Zach only has has three wounds. Let's take him out and get him out of the way. And I didn't want to deal with that. Yeah. And honestly, like I'm pretty good at being not having analysis paralysis in game. And here was like all these cards like, but I don't know what's good. Like should you just play something? Yeah. And it's hard like there's a couple cards where I'm like, okay, I'm going to hold these back to try playing to try to get to this. But then beyond that, I'm like, well I don't think it matters drastically.
Um that's actually that's really interesting because I had the opposite effect. And it could have been just because the the hands I kept drawing were like, I'm going to do this and this and this. I meticulously planned out what I was trying to do, hoping that I'd beat you out on initiative Right. card. What I will say is and this is again based off the precons the fact that you have to have a specific defense card um to block and I I don't have a fix for this, but that could be really annoying cuz it could turn into and it is and I will say every complaint that I think we're going to have is still thematic, um which is cool, but if you watch a lot of run-throughs, you'll hear me say theme doesn't always make good game mechanisms. Because yes, if I'm with this massive [ __ ] uh uh naginata just like hammering at you and just chipping away and you're just constantly on the defense getting rocked. Yeah, I'm going to keep pushing that aggressive. Um but from a game standpoint, if you're like, I wish I could [ __ ] block. I thought I was a warrior. Why can't I block? Oh, because you're not drawing them.
Right. And to try and draw them, this is we were talking about it during the game you have to play a core that lets you draw two, which is my kind of counter against your why are you drawing? It's because you're trying to search for a defense, but you also do have ways to at least one way that we saw that let you look for a defense. Yep. Um it can still be very annoying. It's like, wow, I'm stunned again, which counts against my hand limit, which means I'm discarding more cards, which means I'm not getting any more defense. So let's just call it a [ __ ] wash. I kill myself and just behead me, dude. Well, and some of the things that I saw with this one again, without going through building like you had high initiative for your attacks Mhm. from range that then allow you to move or do something to me that stopped me from doing stuff. Right. All my attacks were low initiative cards. Mhm. My high initiative cards were movement. Which I didn't want to get closer to you till you had already moved and done your stuff. Because all my stuff was up close. And so it was like, well, and that's why I was like some of the time, I don't care what I play because I need you to get closer, but you were never going to get closer. And anytime I tried to get closer would just put me instantly into range with you cuz I couldn't get close enough to hit you at those points.
Right. And so it was like, well, then what's the point of trying to get do a plan? Yeah, it is a little odd that a lot of like my reversed carved fang, for example, that's four smooth back. Right. But like the feral sweep um I mean, I get the timing, like the title of feral sweep is, but it's like you have a katana. You should have super high initiative. Like it's literally like the whole thing of like a Iaijutsu duel where it's like quick draw. Right. But I have this massive thing I'm trying to just do in large arcs. Right. Um so like the the feral sweep covers basically one whole side and in front of me. That should be the advantage, not the six initiative. Right.
Um so yeah, and and based off what we saw with the katana, the warrior like his movement like was just Nothing. Not really anything. Um I could see a counter of like and this is one of those games that you want to know what your opponent is doing. Right. Um which is a fair stance like that. Sure. But you have to know the game a lot. So maybe it's one of those things that you see like, oh, this is the precon for the naginata ronin guy. All of his attacks are right side. So that means as a katana player, I'm going to try and flank from the left because he has to start rotating.
And maybe that's why I didn't do as was use terrain better. Yeah, that was going to be my thing is like, maybe try and get around terrain cuz in the solo I watched the AI wants to flank. And I always thought that was just a stupid AI thing, but maybe that's game mechanics of like, oh, that's the weapon you're using and you're I guess right hand dominant, so you're going to be swinging from the right a lot. Sure. So I'll move to your left because I don't have a lot of ways to rotate. Right. Um so I have to bank on keeping you in my field to do a lot of a lot of damage. And again, maybe that's why cuz I don't know that you have like I have lots of ways to rotate. Half my cards will rotate. So maybe that's what I was supposed to be doing is trying to get behind you in essence. Yeah. Um Or you had um I don't think I have if I do, I don't have a whole lot of instance.
You had some instance that you could play that could be like, oh, okay. So I was going to be able to move into where he'd attacked. Now I'm going to play this instant replacement that doesn't. Right. I I think I got one in our two games for the instant replacement. That's yeah, that's true. My instant additionals, um I have an I have a heavy armor that reduces damage. Instant replacement is a wolf pounds that will hobble you. Yeah, I think that's pretty much it. Mine were basically like I had to have the focus to increase initiative I want. Um was the one I had for this entire or second game. Okay. Funny enough, I did draw into this and I would have pissed you off so bad cuz uh because yeah, as the naginata, keeping you at relative range is the entire goal. If you get up close Like whenever you did get up close and actually and hit me, I was like I could see this turning the tide. If like I'm like, "Oh shit."
to do. I do have an eight initiative quick dodge, which is a force move back. So it's like you finally getting close and then I dodge back. Right. Um and I get to change my kami. Um But I do think that this game overall does capture the feeling of a feudal Japan samurai duel. Right. So from a I call from a game mechanics, I think it's fine. Like I think it's a good game in that sense. From a well, but here are pre-cons. Just grab one and play and they'll work against each other equally. No. I I don't think so. I think the pre-cons are meant to because whenever you build your character, you pick a or yeah, when you build a deck, you pick a character and it tells you your weapon options and then there are of course rules on That's where the wood and jade and all those colors come into play.
But to me it seems like oh, okay, do you want to be a ronin who's badass and stuns a [ __ ] ton and keeps people at a relative distance? Do you want to be um a warrior that dies? Right. He gets his ass beaten. Again, it could just be different things again, not understanding a principle of play. So like you know, we're comparing to like magic. Well, magic will tell you in their pre-con boxes, this is what this deck is going to try to do. That's true. Yeah. I had no idea. So maybe they need to say, "Well, for the baseline warrior, you need to try flank your opponents. That's your goal." No, that's a good point. Yeah. Or use terrain to your advantage. So then I know at least from a get-go what my kind of strategy needs to be versus oh, he just hits me from a mile away.
Stuns me so I can't do anything. my anime light blade that extends in a sweep. And then like, okay, so what what do I do now? No, that's actually that's a very good point. I 100% agree. I think any pre-con game that does that um cuz I played a game that was also a skirmish kind of card battle game called Aetherium Wars. And it does it like they go above and beyond. It's like a book of where your charac- where you It's like, "Hey, here's the deck you have. Here's everything about every card and what they're for and how you play this deck." And it is like it is one of the best like low barrier of entry games I've played in a long time for a card game. You know, cuz you know card games are hard. Yeah. Um they either get in this We're not This isn't even close to magic, but it's getting compared to magic cuz it's the Cuz you have deck building. You have deck building. Yeah.
deck that you're going to take against a one-on-one player. Right. Um cuz I would never in any game that has deck construction ever let someone deck construct before ever playing the game. I would hand them a pre-con. Like like what we did here to learn and play the game. Right. And what I So like I would do that I would not necessarily hand them a pre-con, but I hand them one of my 10 magic decks and I walk them through saying, "This is what the deck does. Right. These are the critical cards you're looking for. So if you have something that is a search, you probably want one of these Mhm. cards and these are what these five cards are going to do. So in these situations, you want that one or you want that one or you want that one. So I had a friend cuz I I in college, I had a friend who taught me magic. He would do that. He would hand me one of his decks and then he would play a deck a deck that was counter that was a good counter for it. And I'm not saying you do that, but that was like I hated magic for the longest time because of that and then I got into it and I played with people who weren't [ __ ] Yeah, I mean I would always play with just my one deck. It wasn't like, "Oh, this deck's just going to beat and crush everybody." It's like, "No, this one's a fun deck that I'm going to play. Here you go. You can play any of them. These are more beginner friendly, these are less beginner friendly. You can play any of them. I don't care."
Yeah. And this is still what they're all doing. even if your deck is good, you're probably not going to be like, "Oh, oh and then I'm going to I'm going to [ __ ] um But I yeah, no, I agree because I I do like this game. I think that with the character options and the deck construction that's there and the the cool the fact that you actually that facing matters. Yeah. That That's not in any game. Right, right. The fact that you have something that's moving, that's the Yeah, positioning is cool. That makes you think. gimmick. Like yeah, I get it is the gimmick and the kami tree. Like ooh, if I'm in balance stance, that's going to give me a lot more kind of Like if I'm doing aggression, I'm kind of locked into what I'm doing. Okay, maybe I want to go into balance so that I actually have some, you know, movement capabilities based off my deck. That's really cool. But if you don't know, like if I hand you a deck kind of like what we experienced the very first game and it's like I'm just doing what my deck is supposed to do.
It's going to turn people off. People are going to be pissed that this game either think it's unbalanced and it it 100% might be. Like I don't know who this company is, Sword Stone Sword Games. I know Lucky Duck sells this game now on their website. Sword Stone Games could have no [ __ ] clue what they're doing and just be like, "Oh, no, it's totally balanced without by play testing it with two people." Right. And that was their mom and their friend. Right. Um or you just have no idea when you're handed a deck because if I were to like if I were just to explain to you, "Oh, let's do master versus student." What does that mean? Master like master sounds like he has the answer for everything and the student just has dumbass like roll a die. Like every card like like here's the die for the student. He doesn't really know what's happening. Or student versus warrior.
Like what I mean, what do you know this one is doing? Yeah. What's your deck supposed to do? So I I I 100% think that they missed the mark on at least the pre-con aspect of being like, "Okay, here's a pre-con. Here's what this deck Right. Here's what you're trying to do kind of with at least the pre-con because all that goes out the window when you deck construct. Right. Like you have limits on what you're going to build, but it's like, "I don't want to play the warrior uh to be I want to try and play the warrior uh with range. So I'm going to give him this type of weapon. Or I want to have him hit hard. I want to give him a massive club that every attack is two wounds." Right. Uh But yeah, one of our first game was it's like and I and I'm like and I say this not to be like I'm amazing. But it felt one-sided just for me just going, "I'm going to play this card." Yep. And it's like, "Okay, you got it. I'm going to kick you into the wall. Oh, there's another stun. Oh, going to hit you again. Stun." And I can't do anything.
you to move so you're basically facing the wall like I'm going to die and I'm just like slamming your head into the wall. Right. Cuz I think yeah, that was like how the first one ended cuz you can win a couple of different ways. Um Which I like that idea that there's different ways to win the game. You can stun a person so they have nothing to do in their hand. You can just outright kill them. You can try force them to basically stall it out and bleed them a little bit so their deck drains faster. Yeah. Okay. All valid ways you would win a fight. Right. Um And again, like I think from a conceptual standpoint, it's good. Mhm. My problem is there's a reason why there's only a few deck builder games out there that are successful.
Yeah. And it's because it's super hard to do balance. deck skirmishing games specifically, they're very, very hard. Um and like I can think of two that came out um that work. Aetherium Wars is one to talk about that you didn't play obviously, but then Summoner Wars Yeah. is a 100% card skirmish game and it's brilliant. Well, I I'm specifically talking about second edition. I hate first edition of Summoner Wars. But you're right. I've played games of Summoner Wars where I was like, "This is [ __ ] unbalanced." And then someone would be like, "Actually, based off, you know, 80 plays, the fact that faction won 51 times." And I'm like, "Well, shut the [ __ ] up." Yeah. Don't Don't come to me with your facts and data. I mean you can have a bad game. Like I have no problem with that. We literally played the same game twice knowing ahead time kind of what you could do and try and counter it and got nowhere. Well, you got nowhere.
Don't you? Yeah. I mean realistically, that that's the thing is like even with knowledge a little bit, it didn't matter. Mhm. Which tells me that again, it doesn't make the game bad, but your pre-con decks are unbalanced to that point. Right. Um it shouldn't be like, "Okay, you should play this one versus this one to learn the game." Or you should play this one versus that. why pre-con magic decks come with a pair of Well, actually now they just come with one commander deck, but no, back in the day I don't know if they still do, but they would have two decks. Yeah, the dual decks. they'll pull out like five and they're all balanced against each other. None of them are powerful or that fairly fair. Yeah, I was like last time I did pre-con commanders, it was like 2018, which was a awesome commander set, but yeah, there was one that was like really shitty, but was busted when you actually built it.
Right. Um There were there every now and then like in in span, there's like two that are Yeah. have one that's bad or one that's over the top good. But for the vast majority, it's pretty balanced. I do think this game does have legs, though. I think that the Someone could go in the comments and be like, "Well, actually no, they are balanced. The warrior just needs to do this." It's like, cool. I think all of our complaints could very much just be countered with a "Oh, well, actually." Um Well, I'm interested, though, is how cuz the gimmick we talked about was like facing a movement. I actually think that the kami tree cuz ours is different, uh which is nice because ronin and warrior are relatively the exact same type of character Right. theme-wise. It's like, "Oh, you follow a code, I don't. That's the difference."
Um but our trees are different, and I like that. Like if I move up into aggression, I'm pretty much locked there unless I play someone that that allows me to switch out. I'm very interested to know and this would be through tons and tons of play if precon Well, let's go precon for uh for now. How much that matters. If I'm in aggression cuz you know it's the it's the um rock, paper, scissors. Oh, he's in aggression, I'm going to be in this stance cuz that's going to allow me to counter a lot of his aggressive cards. Right. We don't know that cuz we haven't sat here and played 200 games. Uh I would never do that for any game. Um Yeah, I don't think there's a single game that I would play that many times to learn every single in and out.
I just don't That That's just my type. I just don't like to know everything about a game cuz then I'm like, "Well, figured it out. Done." Yeah. But that that could be a really cool element. Um cuz there is uh one resource in the game called focus Mhm. that um you might also try and play for. Like do a lot of stuff that lets you constantly cycle through and get your focus thing. So, you're just sitting here with like, you know, you get your If you could play and I'm like, "Oh, [ __ ] he has three focus. I know he has an execute card in that deck, but does he have it?" Right. And then you're trying to position, and it's like, "Boom, I'm going to do this. I'm going to do an instant additional that bust that boosts boosts that uh boosts my initiative so I beat him. He's in the execute spot, he's dead." Right.
like, "Shit." And that's cool. Yeah. Um I think that that's really neat. Um cuz a lot of the cards rely on here's the benefit I gain for being in a certain stance. Haven't seen that before. Yeah. Um So, yeah. Uh I think the game is is neat. Uh they have tons of accessibility in terms of characters, anyway. They have ways and rules for you to make a longer board. Mhm. Um they have different types of terrain. Although, stupidly enough, they don't have rules at Well, I should I should say the rulebook is it's good at teaching you the rules. If you ever have to reference something, it is the worst. Cuz it's like, "What happens if you get knocked out of bounds?" [ __ ] if I know. It's kind of in a paragraph somewhere. Right. There's no index um to look and Well, maybe there is. I could There is an index.
I'm just It's not on the back like I thought. It's in the contents. Um Well, that's solo rules. So, let's see if I can find out of bounds. No. But you would have to probably be like, "Oh, okay. Well, I'm pushing you out of bounds, so let me go look at what the push effect is." Right. It's still not intuitive enough to find specific things when you need it cuz it does that thing of like, "Oh, let me explain how the core element works. So, let me explain how what all the cards and what these symbols mean, character, and all that. And then let me go into setup." Right. Which I don't I personally don't like that. No, I want my setup first. Yeah. I want my setup first, then explain the rules of the game cuz once the game's set up, I want to see the stuff I'm going to be looking at anyway. Exactly. Yep. Cuz I'm not going to retain I'm not going to know what any of this means.
No. Um I played too many games that and they're all just slightly different. So, But they do have a ton of different terrain. They have um characters that use poison. Yeah. Um things like that. Uh concealment where you can be hidden. That's most likely the ninja. They have Yeah, large battlefield mats. They have um Yeah, terrain. So, they have rocks, bamboo uh shrines, boats, torii gates, cherry trees, just a bunch of different um terrain but no rules like in KDM where it's like, "Hey, place this in a certain spot." That's not in the rulebook. Sure. So, it's kind of like And there's not even any rules for setup of terrain where it's like, "Oh, okay. Here's the terrain we're going to use. So, in reverse initiative order, I decide where this goes." Right. And then you do the other one, and you put it right there in the middle. Right. There's none of that.
I kind of find that annoying. Um I mean, I could find it annoying and not cuz you could just say, "Well, you could do it that you house rule whatever how you set that up Sure. board is." But house rules should be done uh optionally. Right. Like I shouldn't be forced to be figuring out how the terrain is supposed to work. Like if this is like, "Hey, here's how we do it. Here's the rules for it." You can be like, "I don't really like that. I'll change it." Um but yeah, the fact that it is there, terrain depending on your character, so It's It's a neat game. Um that probably just requires a lot more a lot more play to figure out maybe the slight nuances or optionally, there is no slight nuance. Yeah.
And then the precons and the characters are very one note. Yeah. And it's like, "Nope, sorry. The The warrior just cannot beat the ronin." Right. Like that it could like people could play this game for tournaments and be like uh like like, "Oh, no, the ronin wins 80% of the time." Right. Some cards. Okay, well, then that that's [ __ ] Right. Um Do you have any other things that you want to you want to talk about? No. Okay. Well, on a scale of 1 to 10, uh what are you giving Senjutsu: Battle for Japan? Six. Six? Yeah. That's what I figured. Um Mostly just cuz I'm never going to play this game enough to get the nuances of it. I don't want to deck like precon building decks before playing games anymore.
Yeah. If I was, I'd just stick have stuck with Magic. Yeah. No, no, I agree. Yeah, cuz for Marvel Champions stuff and Summoner Wars, I use their precons. Right. I've never customized a deck. Yeah. I know I have a friend who does whenever we rank the Marvel Champion characters, he constructs, I don't. And so, we have a cool difference there. Um I know there's people that are going to do that, and that's their game style. I just I play so many games that I don't have time to make that a reality. Yeah, exactly. was, that's why I was playing Magic. I was playing Magic two to five times a week. Exactly. Yeah. Like No, I completely agree. Um I do like the skirmish aspect. I like how the only randomness is your deck.
I think I'm going to give it a 7.5. Yeah. I'm just tied between I was like, "Eight sounds too high, but I It's like I like it more than a seven." So, we're we're ranking games too often cuz that's exactly I thought I was like, "Okay, it's going to go seven or eight for this." Right. Um I think if I played this game a lot more and tried all the different characters and was like "This was my skirmish game." I could definitely see an eight. Uh but I'm going to give it a 7.5 right now. Um And I'm pleasantly surprised. Yeah. So, that's our thoughts on Senjutsu: Battle for Japan. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey, everyone. Thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on.
Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.