Garden Guests Review: A Battle Of Flowers and Beetles
Transcript
so truthfully this one was a little bit of a hard one for me to review I really really really wanted to like it a lot and unfortunately it just kind of came in a lot lower than I was than I was anticipating it being for me personally Hello friends welcome back to the channel today My Name Is Karly and today we are going to be reviewing the two to six player game garding guests from Van Riner games The Beatles have officially entered the garden these beetles will be spreading out across your garden building colonies making stone pathways um in the hopes of trying to connect both of their sides of the board so before I share my thoughts on this game I'm going to be giving you a really General overview of how this game plays and then we'll jump back here and I will share my thoughts on Garden guests all right so welcome to a game of garden guests we currently have this set up for three players so we'll have player one um player two and then player three right there in a game of garden guests you are trying to fully connect um your two sides of the board so I'll shift the camera up here a tad bit so you can see a little bit better but we have the white player sides right here the black players sides right here and then the gold player sides right here those are your home um your home sides or your home tiles and so in order to win you need to fully have um a connected a connected pathway from one
side to the other so let's quickly kind of talk about um what a turn looks like so when it is your turn um there are basically three things that you can choose to do um you can choose to collect flowers which are these cards here you can choose to build a colony or you can choose to um lay a pathway um in between two colonies that you have already established on the board um so let's kind of quickly talk about each of those actions so the first action you can do is collecting flowers again like I kind of showed you these are um these Little Flower cards that you'll be collecting throughout the game and why these are important is because um in order to lay Pathways you need to have the appropriate flowers um that are necessary in order to lay that pathway so for example if I was trying to connect a pathway here I would need two purple flowers um and currently I oh I guess I do have two purple flowers in my hand um then I could um spend those in order to connect a pathway um but when you are taking flowers every team has um some numbers in front of them these little numbered cards in front of them so when you are choosing this action of collecting flowers you have to actually pick one of these numbers and then that is the number of cards that you get to draw so for example um I don't have a lot of cards in my hand right now so I'm going to choose to draw four flowers so I choose the number four I grab four um cards here add them to my hand and this card actually flips over and so now at a
future round um my options are if I would if I want to um do this um action again of collecting flowers now I have the option of collecting one flower or two flowers so these numbers are always fluctuating um but yes so that is how you collect flowers so the next action that you can choose to do is building a colony now if you take a look at the board here most of what you see is just a bunch of flowers kind of in the meadow um but there are um a handful of white little hexagon spots that are kind of scattered throughout so those are um pedestals those are pedestals that are kind of in your garden and you will actually be building colonies onto those pedestals for example if I wanted to build a colony on this um pink um flower pedestal right here I play any number of um matching flowers that I want to so let's pretend I had um two um of those matching flower cards I could go ahead and play those cards um building um a colony there with a power of two because I only played two um I only played two uh of those pink flowers now the interesting thing about colonies is as long as they are not connected to another Colony by the path by a pathway they are actually still up for grabs so for example if um the gold player over here wanted to steal this colony from me all they would have to do is play one more flower card than I had played in order to claim this so again this little marker on the top kind of helps remind people what flower um is needed so um if this gold player played three of this
little pink card pink flower card here they would actually knock me off and they would instead claim this spot adding um their third um adding three of their beetles here indicating that they now own that they would place the flower on top now technically that is still up for grabs um so um this uh this player over here this player could come in and again just play one more they could play four of those pink flower cards in order to them knock them off and then they would reclaim that um so as long as a um a colony is not connected to another Colony by the path it is always up for grabs The Last Action that you can choose to take is actually building a path um so if you have two colonies so pretend I had um a Col I built a colony um right here let's say I built a colony right here um one U my final action that I could choose to do is actually connecting those two colonies so again I look at the flowers that are in my hand and I have to play um the necessary flowers that are needed so for example if I were to connect the pathway right here I would need one purple and one um of like these like kind of pink yellowish um cards right here so I'll go ahead and play those cards from my hand and now I I can go ahead and claim this pathway every single time you lay a pathway it actually makes it so the colonies that you previously built are now set in stone nobody can take those
colonies from you um so every time you do that um it kind of locks in those colonies in place um ensuring that you are safe so I told you at the beginning of this video that I have this game set up for three players um and I and I do um but this game actually plays from two players all the way up to six um and how we go about doing that is um you actually still play as three players but you just would play with teams if you play more than three players so for example if you play with six players you would play with on three teams of two if you play with four players it would be um two teams of two and then if you played with five players you would actually um one player would play by themselves while two of the teams would play with two um two players something else to know is when you are playing with teams you have to be silent while you are playing this game um that's something that's very important when you are playing this game on team team so something um definitely to point out and remember when you're playing with Team um teammates you can actually choose another action which is passing flowers to your teammate which can become very helpful um during rounds um we use that very often in our games and it helped us quite a bit so it's a little bit difficult to see on this overhead camera here but like I mentioned before the game does end once a player has successfully connected both of their like home tiles both of their home sides um in one single pathway so the moment that this player plays um a pink card and is able to connect these two right
here this player has successfully won the game because they have a complete chain connecting both of their sides um so that is what triggers the end of the game so when I first received this game um from Van Ridder games I was I was really really anxious and really really looking forward to playing it um the board everything really looked really visually appealing and the idea of um trying to collect the flowers and play and um play out your um beetles in certain ways trying to connect past it just seemed really interesting to me um so I was really looking forward to playing it um so obviously since then I've been able to play this game a lot I actually played this game probably more than most games I play um before my review and um let's go ahead and chat about all the stuff that I really enjoyed about this game so something that I really liked is how simple it was to teach um literally the rule book is just a handful of pages it was really easy and clear to go through and read and understand the rule book I feel like the rule book really explained everything really well um and as far as teaching the game it's really easy to teach too because um if you're just playing um uh if you're not playing on teams so if you're playing either a two or three player game then um there's only really three things that you can do you can draw flowers build colonies or or um create Pathways that's really it um and so it's it literally takes 2 seconds to teach it's really really clean and simple um there's not like a bunch of rules that you have to go through a bunch of stuff that you have to like keep reminding people um it is it is very straightforward very streamlined very easy to understand another thing that I really loved about this game is when you choose the action
of drawing flowers or getting more flower Cards into your hand I absolutely love um I really loved this little puzzle here so um you have two cards that are um set in front of you throughout um in the game and so when you do um decide to draw cards you have to pick one of the numbers flip it over and the next time you go to draw flower cards and you'll have the new numbers revealed so that's the new number that you can pick from um I really loved that puzzle and I really especially loved the puzzle when you're working with teams um and and the reason why is because like for example I was working with a teammate um and he had a bunch of cards in his hand a bunch of cards and I believe the cards that were in front of him would like were I think these two um and so he purposefully chose an action he purposely chose um the one um and he collected one car because he knew that by the time it got to me cuz I like hardly had any cards in my hand um so he purposely picked the one so by the time it was my turn to play I could have the option to choose a four um and so it was I don't know it was just really interesting that puzzle of um trying trying to kind of manage these cards here along with the cards in your hands and trying to be as efficient as possible like I said working with a teammate especially um just kind of made it a really fun interesting puzzle I also really like how when you when you um build a colony out here on the board um I like how it's still technically up for grabs until you connect it with a pathway um so it was really fun because there were a couple times in the game where people had claimed some I mean
throughout all the games that I've played there definitely comes times where people claim um very clear um winning like potential winning um colonies and you know okay like if they really if they claim that if they get that it's game over they're going to win so it's really fun to try your best to get the cards you you need to knock your opponents off um it's very it's very Cutthroat in regards to fighting over the colonies but it was a really fun puzzle because the moment somebody claims a colony you you as the opposing players you're able to kind of guess how what pathway they're going to take to connect that and how can you disrupt that or how can you get there before them or knock them off um so it again it adds to a kind of interesting puzzle because the moment you claim a territory it kind of gives away your plan um so you've got to be strategic about when you claim colonies and how quickly you then um claim that Colony by connecting a path to it as far as these little Stones go um I mean they they all feel really really nice they're like nice little um acrylic Stones um that for for me personally I really they were really tactile and um they feel really really nice and smooth Lots about the production did feel really nice as well like these cards felt really nice and sturdy um really really nice cards I was actually really impressed um with the card um the card quality in this game all of all of like I kind of mentioned all these like little acrylic pieces felt really nice even this board um feels really nice and thick and sturdy um and the insert as well the insert works
really good um so everything everything about the production I feel like or Lots about the production um I felt like it was really well produced and I feel like it's really sturdy and nice so I know the theming of this game is like Beatles going through the garden and everything um I didn't really get the theme super strong in this game it's basically just an strategy game personally in my opinion um you're basically just you know trying to find the quickest route the most efficient route based on the flowers that you get it felt very much like a race because you know um inevitably that the moment somebody connects I mean obviously the winning condition is by connecting one side fully connecting one both of your sides together um and so very quickly um if you're not being efficient and you're not being careful you can become cut off and then you're basically out at that point um and so um it was it was just kind of an interesting puzzle to try to manage your flowers as efficiently as you could without wasting um wasting them too early in the game so I've kind of briefly mentioned in this video how I really was expecting and hoping to like this game more than I actually did um so we're going to kind of go in and kind of chat a little bit about some some of the things that I was I was a little bit disappointed for truthfully in regards to this game um and I think the biggest thing for me the biggest thing for me in this game is I every single game of this that I've played it gets to a point where it feels pointless to finish it and the reason why is because when you
are connecting two of your sides there are crucial moments that happen in this game where Let's Pretend This white was right here and this black had almost got it well the moment that the black gets that key part and cuts off Cuts white off completely there's literally there's no point to finish the game at that point because you know that black is going to win it's just a matter of time there's no way there are times where you go where you're playing this game and you just cut off people or completely stop um somebody in their tracks and there's there's no way to come back from it there's literally no way literally every single game of this I've played it hasn't ended in like a Oh yay like we finally got it we literally you could just stop playing at that point you don't even need to finish the game and for me that's that's huge like why why play a game if there literally it comes to a point where there's there's no point to finish like there's just there's just no point um like me and my me and my husband and my daughter we sat down and we played this and granted we might have been playing a little bit too rough with her but we very quickly we cut her off very quickly in the game we cut her off and we and I mean she she was just out she was just out at that point so then it was down to me and my husband so we kept going on and playing but there was a really crucial part that I managed um a really crucial section of the board that I managed to claim a colony and I managed to get all the right flower cards so I completely cut him off and at that point we were just
like okay let's just stop the game because there's there was literally no point to continue because no matter what happened I was going to win um and so that was super unsatisfying for me truthfully um because I want that ground finish I want to be able to want to finish a game and so that that's that's that was probably my biggest thing with this game and my the biggest thing that pulled it down for me um and the biggest thing that kind of keeps me from wanting to pull it off the shelf because what's the point of playing a game if you know there's there's no really nice big fun satisfying ending another thing is out is visually pretty as this board is the very first time I opened this board I was like oh this is really pretty this is you know this is going to look so nice but it's actually quite frustrating um truthfully the the way that this game is laid out because the flowers while it looks really pretty a lot of these flowers on these hexagon shapes actually kind of overlap and so at first glance it looks beautiful but while you're sitting and playing and you're trying to count out how many flowers and what flowers you need in order to connect two colonies it actually makes it quite difficult because um it's not always quite clear what flowers are on what like for example here like this little hexagon here you have flowers from you have red flowers and then um these like cream colored flowers and both of them are on the hexagon at the same time clearly like when you look at it and really look at it it's I mean it's clear
that this yellow flower is on more of that hexagon than the red one but the fact that they overlap it all it just it makes it confusing um and it makes it less clear it just requires more brain effort to sit and count like I would I would find myself one at a time laying a flower down placing a stone lay another flower down place a stone because I had to do that in order to keep track of what flowers I had played and what flowers I need um because it's just it's just not always clear based on the iconography um or based on the way that they drew out this board another thing are the colors are slightly off in this game um sometimes so like for example the the the the colors on the cards for some of these flowers especially like these ones these these are the ones I struggle with the most um and the reason why is because I feel like on the board the board and these ones match pretty well the color is slightly off um but they match okay but when you claim a a a colony and you put the matching flow on Top This is the the token that you use for this flower and it doesn't look anything it doesn't look anything like the flower that's actually on the colony um the one on the colony is pink and this is like yellow um when we played this game um with um uh with a hand we actually played that we played a four-player game of this one night um and uh one of the gentlemen that we were playing with kept getting these um
colors mixed up because they are confusing um it's confusing because the colors they just don't really match super well and because the backgrounds are different it just I don't know I just had issues with the coloring um but by far this this little piece here this drove me crazy you definitely have to play this game very very very aggressively you have to be cutting people off you have have to be knocking people over um you have to be very strategic and strategic to the point where you're trying your best just to cut everybody off you possibly can um when you are playing a three-player game of this because you have to play that way I mean every three player game that I personally have played one player gets eliminated relatively quickly when you're playing a two-player game it's not it's it's not quite as bad um because there more of the board is open so I feel like both players are able to go relatively long again until you hit that crucial moment and then whoever wins basically is kind of set to win the game at that point um but in a three-player game somebody gets eliminated relatively quick and it it does not feel good when that's you um because again it happens at least in my experience it happened just happened so many times so early in the game like the other player literally should just get up and leave and either start another game or go do something else at that point because there's it's it's not like it's at the very end of the game it's a crucial moment oh I win okay let's just
wait to see who wins usually it happens pretty early and if you're that third player that that happens to you're out and you're just out of luck and there's just no point for you to even continue finishing at that point a game that I kept thinking about the whole time I was playing this game is blockus um and I I know it's like it's nothing like blockus but in blockus when you are going and trying your best to place if somebody cuts you off there's usually ways that you can still get around them um either you know cutting through a corner or or or doing something you're you're not I mean other than like maybe at the very end of blockus there's really you can still kind of mitigate you can still try your best to cut through people there is none of that in this game so when you do get cut off there's no way for you to really continue to really have any chance to win it's just you're just done um at that point so I wish I wish there was something similar to blockus again I don't quite know how you would go about doing that without breaking this game um because if you did have like one Rainbow Stone or something that you could use that allows you to hop over somebody else I do think that would break the game but I also at the same time feel like this game is missing something like that and I I don't quite know how to put my how to explain it now I did want to briefly mention this the game group that um we play this with we play this with Kim's kind of game group that she does um every every Tuesday um so one of the people that we played with his name is Will shout out to will will actually
really really really enjoyed this game um and so I kind of want we were actually really hoping that we would be able to get him to be um on this review today I really wanted him to kind of speak his his thoughts um on it but unfortunately with me right about to have this baby and timelines it just didn't work out but I want to speak on behalf of will CU I think he brought up some really good points um so will really really really liked this game he he actually just I I asked him like what he would re what he would rate it and I believe he rated it an eight or an 8.5 um he really really liked it and the reason why he liked it and he he's a really big chess player so he really he really loves that puzzle but something that he mentioned in regards to this game is he says he feels like there's like a depth to this game in regards to um how you build your colonies and how you place CU you can be really strategic making people think you're going to go one way but then you you cut in and you go around um and you and you um just have to be really strategic about the way that you play stuff so will really really enjoyed this game there was he really liked the puzzle um he liked the um when when when you play with um four um or five or six players you play on teams and so when you do that um you're like there's no communication and so the way you have to communicate with people like I I was playing with will I was playing on his team um and I I could see that he had a lot of cards and we had a really crucial area that we needed to take and so I chose to hand him my cards
trying to indicate to him hey we need to take this crucial pathway and because I did that he was able to play the cards he needed to in order to win um and so he really just he really enjoyed that um The Cooperative level um when you played this with more players and how you're trying to communicate with the other players while trying to take those key spots so will really actually enjoyed the puzzle um so again I wish I wish that he was here with me today um sharing his thoughts but I did want to share that on behalf of him um and and kind of all the reasons why why he actually enjoyed this game for me personally though I am coming in um pretty low on this game truthfully and the reason why the thing that just keep bringing it down for me is just that it's just that point where every single game I've played of this there's just no point to finish there's literally no point to finish once somebody is you know takes that crucial part you know the game is over at that point so why finish and for me to play a game that you don't feel like you don't need to finish that just is so unsatisfying for me um so for me personally I'm going to be giving this game a 5.5 there are are stuff that I do like about it and I do really want to like it more and will might be totally right there might be a level of strategy that I just simply haven't unlocked yet with this game or I haven't simply realized with this game um but for me it just that it just wasn't satisfying enough and um I feel
like there are some stuff still kind of missing for me to personally enjoy it to the level that I want to so there you go those are my thoughts on Garden guests from Van Rider games huge shout out to Van Rider games for sending us this copy to review today and if you have played this game or you're interested in playing this game please let me know what your thoughts are um or why you personally want to play in all of the comments below and if you did enjoy this video and you haven't yet subscribed it would mean so much if you could it really helps support me in kind of everything that we are doing over here on the channel I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you next time definitely having like attraction uh I'm so ready to be done being pregnant yep I'm just going to lay down for a minute