Earth Abundance - Expansion Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about abundance which is the first expansion for Earth and like Earth this is designed by Maxim tardiff and our prototype copy is supplied by the publisher but the thoughts in this video are all our own and this is a prototype so some of the things you'll see will change and we'll point the ones that we know about out as we go along and because this is an expansion and plays quite similarly to the base game we're not going to go through a how to playay of the base game it's assumed that you already know how to play but instead let's look at what's in the box again this is a prototype so things may change but in abundance you will get a player board and player markers for a six player an updated scor pad more soil tokens Sprouts Trunks and canopies an 11o VP token for the first to finish their Tableau two more Island cards and climate cards three more fauna and ecosystem cards a full set of board extensions and note the real ones will be better ours are just printed out seed tokens which we are told will be 10 in the final product and 70 Earth cards
with a mix of Flora terrain and event cards so the biggest thing here is those 70 new cards and and those cards their main focus not for all of them but for quite a few of them is to tackle what a lot of people's biggest criticism was of the base game which was that there was not enough interaction and so these new cards most of them at least have one of two icons one of them is that whenever you do stuff when you'll get a bonus and everyone else will also get a bonus but it only goes to all the other players and usually it's getting Sprouts that they can play and then the other one is cards that are based on what your neighbors have so it'll be something like you get one growth for every whatever icon that is in your neighbor's Garden Tableau T oh yeah that's better Garden those more thematic and you choose one of your two neighbors so it does work kind of the same at two players too because you're just looking at one person but that so that gets you something based on what they've got which gives you a reason to actually look over and see what they've got and I think for the most part both of those worked pretty well yeah I always like getting things when you told me to because you like oh I get this but you get these things and so I like it that it is a take this instead of a take that you're never removing things from from my Tableau so I do appreciate when they add interaction of it being a positive interaction like the case is here and the neighbor thing when I first saw that
I thought it would be a bit of a pain to constantly kind of be looking over and seeing like what you had but I usually only ended up with like one or two of those cards in my Tableau and it was only tied to a specific color so it wasn't like activated every single round yeah I think that is a big part of it too because the base gamees already got I don't know a lot lot lot of cards whatever it is 300ish cards whatever it might be this has got what 15 of those cards I think 16 of the cards have that make you look at your neighbors so if you've got two in a game that's all you're ever going to have so it's not like you're doing tons of that it also we haven't got to this point yet but I think I could really see it being a thing where you know that your neighbor wants you to build that sort of thing so you're not going to build that sort of thing and so that does lead to a little bit of interaction yeah the other bit of interaction but it's only on three cards is you pick one person that gets a bonus so again the odds of seeing those cards are quite minimal but if you're playing with lots of players that is nice because you'll probably give it to the person who looks like they're maybe not doing as well and I like that basically all of the bonuses are those Sprouts because the Sprouts I think is it really was the weakest path in the in the original game and this adds a lot more to that where you're going to get a lot more of them you're going to fill you've also got a little holding place for your extra Sprouts that you're getting on other players um turns that are giving them to you that you can put out at the end of your turn but also these Sprouts
tie interestingly to the seeds which is the other key mechanic because you can spend four Sprouts to get a seed and the seeds I think can be super powerful yeah and so the seeds are going to be a different color than the color we have so just as a note for that but it is a great little extra everybody starts with one seed at the beginning and like you say there is opportunity to get seeds some cards also get you seeds and you could trade the seeds in for various things which is really handy cuz if you're just like a couple of dirt shy of being able to build a card it's nice that you have this option of being able to trade something in and it gives you various options as well because you can get a couple of growth which might come in handy you can get a few more Sprouts you can add cards to your compost um and you can also get a couple dirt and what was the last one and germinate and germinate is a is a brand new uh mechanic in the game and so germinate is you can name you can kind of name a card so you name a card based on your goals so if you've got um what are they called like the island goals or whatever they are if you've got one of those that is saying that you need uh you need growth powers in your Tableau you can say I want a card that has a growth power on it and then you go from the you flip over the deck you go from the bottom and you just go through the cards till you get one with a growth power and then you add that to your hand and so that's what germinate is so it lets you kind of grab specific cards we actually haven't used that that much we mostly have been using the seeds for either for quick dirt to
quickly get some to be able to buy a card you couldn't afford or to um or or to bury a bunch of cards at the end of the game where we've got a bunch of cards in our hand and we just want to compost a bunch of stuff quick to get those points but it is really nice that it gives a bit of a wild card thing and it makes those Sprouts so much more useful because now you can trade basically you can trade four sprouts for two dirt or four sprouts for to growth or whatever it is you can now because those Sprouts felt like they were just such an extra like I guess um now they feel a lot more interesting yeah and I think being able to germinate we'll probably use a bit more because a lot of the new fauna cards that they've added are now tied to Ability so it might be that you have cards in your Tableau that give you some ability that has to do with dirt and so I think it is an interesting addition cuz some of the cards tie to like having specific types of icons or specific colors so this is just yet another another level that they didn't have before of the type of ability that you can do and so germinating might come in handy for that as well the one thing that I don't love and this is such a nitpick as well but there are a couple of the the new the goal cards the fauna cards that want you to have cards that have a colon in them or cards that have like the little Roundy symbol the Roundy symbol doesn't doesn't bother me as much but the colon it just feels like it's looking for like a type thing on the card like literal
type versus it's looking for like a more thematic thing and that just feels just a little bit weird um but it's it's such a small nitpick and I don't know if anyone else is really going to feel like that and it works perfect like mechanically it works just as well as anything else so it's fine yeah and that there are a couple more of the climate cards as well and a couple more of the island cards so if you felt like you know you're going through the other ones quite a bit and you've seen most of them it's nice to have additions I like that one of them is Vancouver Island right so I quite like that just because I'm from Vancouver so that was nice and the other big thing it adds is the stuff for a six player so if you are interested in playing at six players you now have the capacity to do so this actually this expansion both in that and in the um the interaction of the cards reminds me a lot of some of the wingspan expansions too like this feels quite quite a bit like the Euro one where they just added a bunch of new cards and a few of those cards if I'm remembering correctly had more interactive abilities because that also was the big knock on wingspan when it first came out too and so I think in that way abundance does a very similar job yeah it doesn't change things drastically there isn't a big new mechanic or a big shift or like a new it's not a new way of playing it is just adding those 70 cards that do like exactly that a little bit of interaction so if you like Earth then abundance does Earth and just adds a few little things
yeah I think this is this is just a more stuff expansion and I think if you like Earth you're probably going to like it yeah it also changes that if you complete your Tableau and you're the first person to do so you get 11 points instead of seven and even though it's only four points I have found that has made me race towards that end a little bit faster which is nice cuz I can see people really trying to stretch out the game as long as possible and I like that it is on a little bit of a timer of completing that Tempo yeah it makes a it makes a little bit of a difference but it is really a difference and this is one of those expansions where you know we've mixed all those cards into the base game cards now and I don't see any reason that we would ever take them out it's just it's just more stuff into a game that we already like and it just spices it up that little bit extra and that is it that is abundance the first expansion for Earth and if you are interested there's going to be a little link to the kickstarter in the description we don't get anything for that but feel free to go check it out thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you have played the base game of Earth and what you're hoping for from the expansion as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game