Book Club: Homo Ludens
Transcript
yeah who knows yeah who knows everybody's here we're here that's all that matters yeah we are here I think that's that's what's important um but um those of you who are watching it later or who trickle it now hey everybody hang on I got a frog in my throat of course I have one right as we start good timing perfect timing hey Pierce here perfect um but Fred and I are here to have nerdy book club time I think that's about right yeah that's pretty much it yeah those of you who do you have not encountered Fred yet you should this is Fred Cyril from the homologous war game board game historical game channel historical game so it's the channel about history and board games and traditionally I've mostly talked about war games on the show but the ambition especially lately has been to really talk about um the history of board games but most importantly how history is depicted in board games uh that's that's the idea so not only War Games even if principally war games because I would say that it's usually War Games is the part of the hobby that is taking history the most seriously but not the only part of the hobby that's uh that is doing it so that's the that's the way I would describe it I think that's fair and it's also why I really enjoy your work I'm always really happy to talk to uh to somebody else who cares about historical games like as a as an Indian themselves and you're also
a designer so for people who don't know tell us what you designed uh so my first published game was red flag over Paris published by GMT uh and was released in late 2020 my next game was GMT should be released hopefully at the end of this year if everything goes well so I'm just uh crossing my figures knocking on wood and doing all that adjust the Robin Hood which is a a reinterpretation of the coin system and adapting it to Medieval England and um to the character of Robin Hood and uh I re we recently announced um that I was co-designing Napoleon 1870 for shackles games so that's another project so in the in the Napoleon Series so if you've played Napoleon 1806 and 18 seven it's basically the same idea or the same system but transport to the transpose to the beginning of the Frank operation war with a couple of twists here and there to adapt to the era and most recently I did a small print and play for a convention here in the UK called benchcon and this printing play is here and if you've seen it you should have a copy I do have a copy called a very civil list and I will have some big news about this in the near future I won't say anything uh for now but uh yeah that's the that's the latest project and yeah you can tell us this is a cozy not public at all chat I need to be careful but soon I will give some news uh for for sure uh but
yeah those were the things that have been actually released there are a lot of stuff on the side but uh but uh but those are the stuff that are that are out there or about to be out there that's awesome and so I'm just giving Stewart a hard time here he says I didn't do the homework can I copy someone's notes so you and I had homework for this yeah we read homologous we don't have the same Edition we don't Johan heisinger who publisher Edition just out of curiosity I've got the Martino publishing in Connecticut I've got the Angelico press uh that's from the UK and and just the thing I'm wondering is or is it the same translator I guess it might be I mean it was a reasonable translation let's see who did mine this is always kind of fun actually no I have a Martino publishing note in the front page okay what was the original one from yeah for me the original one so they I just took over the one that were published by Rutledge uh so I think it's the 1949 uh translation I guess yeah I have copyright 1950 by Roy Publishers okay I think it might be the same that might be the European one and and you have the one that was published in the US I can see that this looks like one of those things that's like almost a print on demand like it's got nothing on the back yeah I'm fairly certain this is like a it's just yeah it might be printed by Amazon or something like this uh I wouldn't be surprised
no it's got that soft cover that a lot of those books that are printed that may have which is not bad I don't actually mind the soft cover unless your fingers are grimy so handle the care but uh but we should talk about uh heisenga uh basically homologous is I would say it's a foundational academic book for people who want to talk about play as a serious academic and sociological topic yeah and it's old and it's not in line with a lot of current ideas but it's still foundational and that's why we decided to go and read it because it's you know it's the The Source from which a lot of things we think about now um come from yeah I think that's fair uh we we started discussing about uh like having a sort of informal book club about play and reflection about play and I think we both felt like starting with homolody dance was a place to start not that it's the book that we were necessarily the most inspired by even though my channel is named homuridans but it's more after the term that I think is one of the stroke of Genius of using uzinga more than the the book itself uh but I think we both thought it was a really good foundation because to my knowledge he was read the first person who dedicated a full book to it and was serious about thinking about play and I think there are some brilliant ideas in the book um but have some criticism of course but
I would like to preface that by the fact that I'm not an academic at all I have no serious background in philosophy um and I must say that at the time this book fell off my hands like some sections I was like oh my God I have no idea what he's talking about it I'm I'm tired it was maybe a bit too abstract um so I just want to say that before we go into the discussion uh if you are interested in what we say don't take what we say for granted go and have a read at the book I'm just a normal man I'm just an innocent man I just tried to read the book for the second time but I would say I I retained a lot more than the first time I read it so that was that was good so I would I wanted to thank you to give me the opportunity because actually it was a good way for me to re-engage with this book um and with actually a lot of different perspectives on play than when I read it for the first time so it was really interesting and I think I was a lot more critical also about it but in a way better understood some of the ideas that I liked into in it so that was that was nice yeah I also I'll give my own caveats you know I have a doctorate I did academic training but for me like this kind of falls into the category of you know um I'm a history of ancient Christianity in the early church but we read a lot of this kind of philosophical Theory it's kind of a way to bounce off of something when we wanted to have like an academic idea so to me like reading Isaac kind of falls in the same category as reading
maybe like Foucault or reading um Bordeaux like where you're looking for like somebody making declarations about society and how it works so that you can bounce off of it um with your own ideas or apply it to something else and I kind of feel like that's the main use of something like homologins now uh so I would have one comment about what you say I think the the problem with Foucault is actually really interesting because I think that fuku in a lot of his work actually um invoked history to prove some of his points and uh he was clearly not a historian and sometimes he had some weird perspective on history and the way he was reading it and I think that's really interesting and definitely something that you can kind of feel here even if it feels like wazinga is a lot more robust especially when he talks about medieval history compared to fuku and a lot of stuff that he can come up with uh but I wouldn't maybe uh put a bit of distance with broader which is on the other hand another that I know really well that I've studied um and I would say that the difference with Bordeaux is that almost everything that he writes the assumption that the theory that he develops is based on actual research which is definitely not the case of a book like this or definitely not the case of of um books that you would read from fuku which can have some brilliant Strokes of like like can think about things and that you don't expect about society and everything but not necessarily based on
a foundation of science like I would say Bordeaux has even if it's not a hard science it's still a very scientific approach in the way uh someone like him would come up with his reflection this is not the case in in here and there is a there's a lot of linguistic stuff um you know I think it's clearly really into like language and trying to look at the meanings behind words and he's just kind of combining a whole bunch of basic anthropological observations about different cultures from this time period I have a lot of questions about the anthropology of this time period yeah but yeah actually so we'll table this for now but I do want a flag I would love to talk about about for you and distinction yeah um and board games I think that would be an awesome topic that should be potentially be uh because I I never so I never thought that much about board you and and and games uh that much before the first time I made the connection in my mind was when I did the presentation for Georgetown University where I actually invoked both you because uh he gave me an idea of uh the ludic capital of individuals how much in for like how much previous knowledge do you have about games depending on your upbringing and everything and how it impacts the way you interact with games so that's the first time I met that connection in my head but I would be actually really interested in re-exploring will do uh while thinking about play specifically together I think that could be a super interesting uh and they're definitely and to your point about Linguistics I think it's one of
the interesting thing uh sometimes I'm not really sure uh well I don't speak Greek or Latin so I I couldn't say but sometimes it said stuff about French that I was like man sure like it's like it's I wouldn't say that maybe uh and and French 1938 was completely French that is today like there is not a lot of differences so I thought but I thought that was really interesting and the thing that I liked is that he it was really Broad and you can see that wazinga has a wide range of interests like uh he talks a lot about Indian mythology Indian language greek latin like he explores really across the world and I think this is this is quite fascinating but then to your point some of the stuff is a bit surface level or a bit uh misunderstood probably and I think everything that falls under the scope of anthropology is falls into the weird but I think it's really the product of its time like he It Was Written in 1938 and it comes with its limits uh regarding the the knowledge that uh we have of of different kinds of people across the world but yeah but I I still thought it was really interesting the fact that it was so eclectic and so uh I don't know how to save it's open to to different cultures uh that was that was actually a uh an interesting aspect of it yeah play and then it's pretty clear that you know for him
contradictory definition of play but I think that that actually makes sense when we think about play a lot um the idea is that play is something that we all engage in like basically even before there's a defined culture there is play and um there are aspects of it that kind of pop up in his definition that I think are interesting so like one of those things um is he really focuses on kind of the competitive aspect of play um he focuses on sort of like what we talk about is the magic circle like I would say that a lot of that talk has its origins in this book um and you know I also think that that sort of idea of like play being really serious but at the same time you don't mean it was really interesting because actually I would say that that has your thumb on the pulse of what it means to play and and I think that one of the things that I really liked about this is is probably the the thing that I like the most about the book is is all reflection about what is playing uh even if it's imperfect the fact that there is someone sitting down and trying to map out the Contour of what is what is play and what does it mean is actually one of the things that I really like the concept of magic circle is really interesting and I think it it's very valuable and I think it's really true um and and this is really this idea that you're gonna have a a uh space and time which is dedicated in
which play is going to occur and that it's gonna live within its own Rule and you on your own free will decide to enter the magic circle and it's and its rules and everything and I think this is really interesting and the other thing that I really like is the fact that he's starting to categorize play and start to think about the different aspects of it like the aegon the Alia and the mimicry it's imperfect but still I think it covers a lot of ground and says a lot of interesting things um you're right that he has this big focus on the aegon because I think it's dies really well into the second part of his book around what is the play element of culture and how play is uh like something that creates civilization in a way and I guess that focusing on aegon so the competition makes a lot of sense because in a lot of ways civilization is making a structure around competition so it's not the always the strongest that wins but that we actually make a structure for everyone to have a chance and and and everyone feels like within the context of civilization is itself a magic circle and and we actually rule the fact that there is the opposition so I understand why he's focusing on this and then he focuses on mimicry only in the context of art um which is quite interesting uh but uh but yeah I think just for this for me this Foundation like laying this Foundation is really interesting uh and I and I actually quite uh enjoyed that then the thing that where it becomes a bit fluffy is I guess when he took calls
about he talks about how it becomes a cvd a civilizing uh um a function yes and and this is this is where actually for me I was kind of convinced by some aspects I think that maybe he reaches out a bit too far uh like uh about the uh the function of play and the fact that things are play but I think you probably have a lot of thoughts uh about this and I would be happy to react to it yeah okay so actually I um I'm really happy that I read a few articles in conjunction with hazinga and I mean we might want to talk about his stuff a little bit more but I want to flag a really good article that uh Luis Aguas Vegas Aguas Vives sent me um Aaron tremel's torture play and the black experience because when we talk about the circle right the magic circle yeah and when we talk about play as a consensual experience and then we also bring in competition the thing that bugged me personally the most through my read of the book was this feeling of you know he wants to make everything that's a competition also into something that is play to the point where it extends to war to the point where it extends to like nobility and society and you know social structures and that made me feel agitated because when I'm competing for something that I really want um it completely destroys the aspect of play that he also talks about which is that everybody's really engaged and everybody's like really like enjoying it and then you don't really mean it and
you know there are certainly aspects of competition that I absolutely mean and I have to be careful like one of the reasons I think gaming is good for me as a person is that I have to work on the part of myself that is agonistic right that has you know getting under control and tremel's article was really interesting because he brings up the issue of consent that you can pull people into games that are not actually fun they're not consensual they're not pleasurable for all of the people engaged in the game and I felt that kind of Misses that and he misses that in a way that like is obviously it makes sense for his time yeah but I think that when we talk about our own time and thinking about even something like tag which tramel brings up in his article where somebody goes tag you're it like even if you don't really want to play like you've been forced into this game and you have to decide how to react and you know heisington talks about people not being part of the game as like spoil sports or like breaking the rules breaking the magic circle and again that's only true if everybody entered it because they wanted to and I just kind of think that he he at some point kind of Skips over the part where this was supposed to be mutually engaging and bumps into well it's all competition is play but like I don't think that all competitions laughing matter or playful at all yeah so I think the the part about consent is is really interesting and he definitely miss that and I didn't think about it either and I think that's a competing
point the the aspect about all competition is play I'm not sure it's exactly what he's saying um the the way that I that I felt about it is that and it's really the way I understood it is that we are actually using some elements of play to structure the uh agonistic parts of society but those are not games like uh the law take some uh take some some elements of play with the rules uh with specific sequences and everything so you take the idea of play that that you that you that you could say where you create a magic circle where everyone has to respect specific rules and everything but it's not it doesn't make low again it just uses elements and this is where I think it's it's really this is the part that I think is interesting from his book is that he says well we like humans realize that play could actually be a way to structure uh the way we interact with each other and I think in that sense it's quite interesting because we do see it in religion um so I said that he talks about mimicry mostly in art but he talks also about it a lot in in the context of religion and I think that's that's probably fair I think there is that's a really compelling point that I didn't think about it that they didn't think about and he talks about it within everything around aegon so the the opposition within Society but I'm not sure it's fair to say that he considers that all of conflicts uh in society or or play but he does say that the attack elements
of playing when you don't and when those elements of play Disappear you become less civilized and this is where I start to have a problem with him like it's like because he starts to introduce hierarchies of civilization how civilized you are based on how much play you have and for me this is where he starts using me uh whereas everything before I thought was super interesting and it made me think about Society about civilization about history in a Different Light which is quite amazing it's not often that you read a book and you're like oh I didn't think about that like that's really cool but then he starts saying stuff and I'm like what the [ __ ] are you talking about I have no clue what you're talking about and it's uh and yeah and this is where he enters in the uh in the the cranky Grandpa uh mood for the second half of the book and he starts use me but yeah yeah I guess for me it's it's I totally understand what you're saying about ordering Society according to rules and that there's like a play element to that I guess I just sort of felt like it's sort of a perversion of talking about the play element to try to it just like for some reason that connection did not fully connect for me however the part that okay so if I want to preface this um when we talk about more rules and more civilization uh there's no question the heisiga is culturally deeply insensitive he absolutely feels comfortable referring to other people's societies and religions as Savage like that's literally what appeared in the translation um you know he's not he's not with us in our modern era of talking about other people in other cultures um so I do want to preface that but at
the same time some of the stuff that he said about religion really did hit me and I think it's because I spent many years not realizing that I was an atheist because I was trying really hard to like play what felt to me like adult pretend games at church um and so you know the way that he talks about religion is really interesting where people are doing rituals with like this intense seriousness um but there's also a part of them that understands that they're just doing a ritual and I thought that that was very interesting and so you know he talks about rituals that involve like things that invoke fear like maybe um you know you're kind of in and out of belief at the same time where like maybe somebody is mimicking a ghost from your family or maybe like something you know Divine is happening you're interacting with some sort of divine figure but it's actually a person and like everybody knows that but then everybody agrees not to know it for the purposes of of getting through the ritual um I thought that that was so interesting because I felt like there was so much truth to that like the things that we engage in while we we take them very seriously and on some level you've gotten yourself to suspend your disbelief but also deep down if you were to push at the boundaries then the illusion would fall apart and I thought that he was really hitting on something real there at the same time um you know I I am fairly certain that my grandparents who do things like speak in tongues and get really excited in
their ceremonies probably I don't know if you asked them about their experience that they would see it that way and I just thought that was such a fascinating thing to to contemplate yeah I don't think that the thing that he describes as you say or as universal and as he says it is I think for a lot of people it is um but uh I so when I was um uh a student I've done some sociological studies on on on people that are born again Christians and and stuff like this in France and I actually looked into the I was very interested in what you were talking about uh people who are speaking in tongues like the glucose and understand how it happens and what does it mean for them and and what does it mean for the community surrounding them that they were actually going through that experience and I would definitely agree on the fact that for those people they are they might be in the magic circle but they don't know they are in there like it's like they are they for them it's not it's not a game like they are really feeling it the fact that it's true or not that's another debate I think it can be both psychological theological debate you can look at it from a lot of different angles but it's pretty clear for those people most of them at least that they are very serious and they're really feeling something and and and they are not playing whereas I do agree with you that there is a lot of people like that understand the ritual of religion and have that distance but I don't think that's necessarily the case for everyone today and certainly wasn't the case for a lot of people in the past
yeah and I I also think though that he would and unfairly right that kind of tie that self-awareness to I mean like it's basically the more self-aware you are the more like civilized you are for him in a lot of ways too like he's he's really got this idea that we become like more rational and like more you know aware of the rules and stuff like that over time and I don't think that it thinks that it's rational there is a quote in the book that I think is really beautiful is animals play so they uh so they must be more than merely mechanical things yes we play and know that we play and this is going back to what you're saying so we must be merely more than rational beings and this is where I think it's interesting is that he doesn't see play as something rational he's actually sees play as something that is more than that which I think is really great is understanding that like having the distance on what we do and and maybe see some of the absurdity of it like for example in war like we know the absurdity of War so we actually introduced rule in it to actually make it bearable and which I think is I think for me that's one of the powerful part of what he's saying is is that and that I love it's like playing is almost touching the Divine in a way like uh and yes it's not that it's it's not that it's rational it's that he's trying to rationalize it yes and that's it yeah yeah I agree but yeah I think the parts where he is the closest to touching the Divine himself right like when you're doing philosophical work like a lot of your
ideas are just gonna and then some will have wings and I really think that he is hitting on something very very true when he's trying to balance the awareness and the non-awareness the belief and these you know and I mean and the the awareness that you're that you are playing and to me like if the whole book had just been trying to dig there I actually I think would have liked it better yeah in a lot of ways I felt that his agonistic description chapters were not as good as those like very base understandings yeah I agree with that completely agree with that for me there was two things that made the book uh a bit of uh uh like that I didn't make makes it so that I'm not in love with the book there is one thing about the categorization of play and I'll come back to this after and and and the conclusion when he's actually almost making his point and you realize that everything that he says about place to say something about the society that he's living in uh and that's maybe something that we can keep for for later regarding the categorization of play I feel like he's missing some critical things and my main issue with it is that I'm impressed by someone categorizing play in 1938 and thinking about it but I feel like he has a very legalist approach uh to play play his norms and I feel like he's um kind of missing the point because there is a lot of freeform play and we
see it today also we have the difference between tabletop RPGs and tabletop board games where we actually are on different ends of the spectrum when it comes to how do we interact with rules and what do we expect players to do and everything and it's maybe I'm going to mention the first book that I was reading in parallel to this one which was Roger the jewishism which was yes like writing more or less at the same time as as uzinga but with a very different perspective he knew usinga he read his book and everything but he introduces the idea of he doesn't himself a categorization of play and one of his character categories for play is the paella so the and here is like free form play and he talks about this and and I think it's really interesting because freeform play is a thing and looking at play only as in sense of norms then of course you can tie it back to civilization because civilization is a lot based on Norms but it's a bit finding good connection because you want to and excluding and cherry-picking what play is and I think he has at the same times sometimes you generalize this play too much and sometimes restricts it to something that is maybe a bit too narrow um just to support his foundational Theory and for me that was a bit something that I thought was a bit of yeah something that I didn't like and the other thing that I didn't necessarily like but maybe it's not his fault and it would come probably later is I think there is a biological aspect of play that he's not talking about at all like he I said the quote that I just
said but I think he misses really the scientific aspect about what is play in the context of evolution for example uh but that's that's a whole open all other kind of worms but uh but uh but yeah those were my main issues with the with the uh was it but yeah I think you were very very correct that he at times kind of twists what play can be to meet his his conclusion as opposed to drawing the conclusion from what we actually see play to be um you know I I understand where it comes from actually uh because this dude's clearly classicist there's a lot of like Latin and Greek and all that so you know if you read Plato you know Plato's got some stuff about how play can actually be good because it teaches rules and like you know if somebody's gonna grow up to be a good citizen if they are able to like kind of stick to the laws of the game as it were yeah um so like it has these like Greek philosophical Roots like the idea that play and like learning to follow rules go together at the same time like I teach high school if you leave kids alone long enough they will organically produce games yeah that just have their own changing shifting rules nobody gets mad about this um you know I always keep Uno decks in my classroom because you know like while I'm not necessarily an UNO person anymore like if you just leave it teenagers all have their own rules for how to play you know yeah they will argue about what those rules are and then they'll end up with like a hodgepodge of everybody's rules and it doesn't really seem to bother anyone um and you know I I think that there is a lot to be said you know play and
change go together just as much as play and stability um you know it's it has you have to part of being Mercurial right is about shifting a lot and it's also a playful word yeah I think it's it's really interesting you you see it organically I think you know is a great example of that I think that I've seen a lot of different like home uh home rules of Uno uh everywhere it was the same when I was a teenager and we're playing a um a table football I don't know how you said in English uh baby food but yeah everyone had special rules about what happens when you score from a specific player or if the ball comes out of the of the uh of the of the box and everything like you you had those things that happened and even in classical games like they've known different shapes uh like the the Indian game tigers and and them for example the abstract asymmetry game had a lot of different versions that evolved over time and you can actually analyze how it spread across uh different cultural uh areas so you you see that it is structured but actually very plastic uh so those rules are not that what's important in a way uh and and I think this is is also something that he's not really covering uh uh at all I guess like our own modern tendency to house rule is so yeah pervasive like I mean how can you think that play is pure structure like I mean you know recipes are like that too right you get a review of the recipe and it's like well I added
butter and I changed the cook time and I did this now but anyway it's a great recipe like uh thank you um so I'm just gonna tease you a little bit Alex left a couple good comments but uh he says not in love with the book names his channel after it so I used a comment yeah I explained that and I and and that's the first thing that I said because I knew that someone like Alexander would say make that a comment like this so what I say is I'm not in love with the book I'm in love with some of its Concepts I think it's a foundational and interesting book and one of the concepts that I like is the concept of umudance the fact that uh the the human race became civilized through uh through play and how that came to happen I think that's a great idea I think the concept of omudi dance is a great idea then yes I'm not in love with the book but I really like the concept and I think it's great for a channel name uh so that's so that's basically what it is yeah you can't let him have all the good Latin yeah take it for yourself so Alex I actually also wants another comment that I've been kind of holding on to for a bit which is uh heising I really hadn't foreseen the rise of solo board games I find this a very interesting observation so you know it's very clear that he sees play as something that's communal so I this might be wrong of me but I don't think so give her my time in this little Community I actually think that solo board gaming is an experience is communal just not in the way that you would think yeah um I think that people maybe don't play solo board games together but if you look at the group
sizes the solo bargaining Community is one of the most chatty interactive like social online groups of game players I have ever encountered um I think that it's just that the communal element of play for us isn't kind of analyzing what we did after the fact as opposed to um you know uh playing it together in the moment and I think it's just a different way to be social and most of the time there are at least two persons involved in a pseudo game the the the the player but also the person who designed the game and it's not that often that you play a sort of game that you design yourself it does happen and and I'm sure it does to you now yeah it does but uh but it's not always the case um and and that's uh and that's and I agree with you and once again like the concepts of uh that wizynga develops I think is not he doesn't talk about solo gaming it doesn't really exist in in at his point actually there is maybe something that I will come back to when we maybe talk about religion or knowledge because I think there is something that he missed that was relevant but uh I don't think it it contradicts the fact that there is solo play um in the end it's like if you're alone in the magic circle uh that's completely fine and as you say it's true that I find slow players more more keen on sharing their experience as a way to compensate the fact that they were playing alone I guess but but yeah I think that's uh that's an interesting point but I don't think it goes against
most of the concepts of the book no although I love your point and I think this is true of History too and I think that's going to lead us actually right back into some of the comments you made earlier about heising it so I really liked the you know your comment that's that the solo gamer isn't actually alone because they're interacting with the mind of the designer or designers and I think that reading is like that too um and I think that you know when you're doing history you're having two conversations you're having the conversation about what You observe historically and you're also having a conversation with your own time and with yourself yeah and so you can never like anything that you're interacting with that was created by another person um is not a fully lonely thing to interact with because somebody else made it and left it for you to interact with um and so you know I think that that in itself right like we you can still get all the same kind of aspects of a magic circle and stepping into a set of rules and having an immersive imaginative experience all those things um you know just just like you can with other people and if you want to be if you want to bring in religion um you know a lot of religious activities also take place alone and are highly ritualized I mean I actually think that there's a a lot to it and that's you're going in the direction that I wanted to go in so that's that's perfect but I I I I agree that the magic circle is is is really this idea of it's really connected to suspension of
disbelief when you're watching a movie and everything like when you decide suspension of disbelief like you are entering the magic circle of the movie and you are interacting with uh the the persons or the people that that made the movie and and I agree with the your point about religion the fact that it's something that is that has some elements of play and it's something that you can do a lot alone uh is also a good point and it's uh it's as a solo activity but in a way it is still communal by a lot of aspects and this is actually it made me think about one aspect that I wasn't a bit disappointed but one of his chapter was um uh where is it I don't remember uh I think there is something around uh knowledge uh uh yeah playing and knowing the chapter six uh and for me I expected that he would go in a very uh different direction and um I don't remember but he gets obsessed like he does like at some point like you know at some point he gets completely obsessed with wigs for for like 10 pages and you're like what what are you talking about it's it's really annoying and when it comes to playing and knowing he talks a lot about riddles and I feel like he's a bit missing the point and I think it's really interesting because he lived in an era where well cultism was like he lived through an era where occultism was really big and I think in occultism there is a lot of aspects of playing and knowing uh and I think a good example of that is tahu
for example like reading the cards and cartoons and stuff like this and interestingly enough a book that I was reading on the side while I was reading this was was this I don't know if she knowski he's a comic book uh author uh science fiction comic book author and he's really obsessed with um uh reading Taro and he had this really interesting book about it and Tahoe is definitely playing like reading the cards I think they are obvious Play Elements first of all you're reading through a deck of cards and there is this idea of hidden knowledge and you're playing through the hidden knowledge and it's the whole game of understanding it uh and and and there is this whole idea of unstructured play non-leading or play role-playing and there is a lot of elements of it and I'm like well this is a almost a religious kind of activity and it's time to to knowledge and actually you use play to learn things so even without talking about Ludo pedagogy which is probably too early for using it to think about even if you can actually argue against that but just the fact that you can discover knowledge through play is something that he misses which is a bit weird I think I didn't really understand that especially as he's so interested in religion and all that and the fact that he doesn't even mention it is is off and then I thought about when he was born I think he was born in 1972 and and like the creek Spiel had been here for quite a while so you actually already had people that were learning their craft and in that case the craft of warfare through play and when he talks about play and War he doesn't talk
about how play can be a vector for knowledge and how it can be used and all that and I don't know I thought it was it was a bit weird um that that this didn't that this didn't come up uh and I don't understand really why see I'm not sure that's weird I kind of feel like it's convenient yeah probably convenience yeah like I feel like it's one of those things that you leave out because you want I mean I mean really you know he he's pretty committed to you know play being like a slightly more primitive thing that appears in our society as opposed to play being something that is actually pretty um Advanced and the complex way of communicating and yeah and I feel that that's something that he kind of Misses like when he talks about play Within the context of modernity he sees it only as a perversion of play as playing being a source of uh income uh playing being too democratized like he does touch a bit upon that too many people have access to Art too many people have access to play like like stuff like that which is a bit weird and but he doesn't see playing as also something that is actually renewed and used in different ways uh which is which is a bit of at his own time which is something that I was quite surprised about should we talk about what he thinks about his own time and maybe the the problem with the end of the book yes absolutely this is your your sauce let's do it yeah so the first thing that I would say is that there is something
that I didn't like that is early in the book is that he makes the year or key of of civilization depending on how much you play and there is one quote where I actually started to cringe and that's when he's talking about war and I'm trying to find it in my notes but he's basically saying that Savages like they also do War but they won't play enough when they do War so we can barely call it Warfare and he gives example and he talks about their Warfare like assassination or and he gives the example of head hunting which I think is really stupid as an example because heavy head-on thing is heavily ritualized and it goes completely against his arguments and I'm like and that's I was like you know what Joanne this is the worst argument you could have picked this is stupid but anyway so there is this but then yeah he starts talking at the end about how basically his theory is that everything went wrong at the end of the at the end of the 18th century uh before that everything was awesome and everything collapses afterwards so in a way he's also more critical of the western world than any other parts of the world so and and and and I feel like this is where I I don't follow him that much and he starts to cherry pick a lot of examples of uh why the world that they are in is going wrong and how it's linked to the fact that play is disappearing and I understand from the context like it's 1938 not great things are happening in Europe in 1938 and it's not going to get good for a long time
from that yeah and it's and the worst is just the head and he's basically seeing um like science becoming all-powerful and it would probably reach its peak he won't see it but I think when the atom bomb would have uh completely drive him uh nuts so it's probably good that he said before that um and and he sees the emergence of uh massive uh totalitarian bureaucratic uh States and everything and I can understand that he sees The Disappearance of play and everything but at the same time it feels like a very reactionary and nostalgic perspective and he starts to talk about like how awesome it was that men was were wearing such colorful uh garments in the past and it disappeared and everything and I mean fashion goes up and down like if that that's a bit of a weird argument he has the whole thing about wigs and it's like yeah I'm not sure that's a really good argument and then there is uh yeah and there is one thing where he starts talking about art and the fact that art becomes aware of itself and it loses its play element and I'm like wait a minute you're writing this in 1938 at the moment where you had the serious movement it's like we've never had a a an art movement that was as playful ever like it was the like I would say the the the the utmost moment where where art was playful more than than it ever was and I don't understand why he misses that he's like he's focused on the stuff that he doesn't like about the society that he lives in
which I can understand but then he has this really reactionary point of view around saying it was better before uh everything went wrong at the end of the 18th at the end of the 18th century and everything and the problem that I have is that is that the end of the 18th century is basically the end of the old regime and it's like if everything went wrong after that and you tell me that the problem is that too many people play and too many people have access to culture you start to paint a picture of well someone that I don't like like an Indian indeed well I'm also really fascinated by the idea that like somehow self-awareness is bad when the entire definition of play is that you're taking something yeah seriously and then being self-aware that it's not serious so like when where's the line between like good and bad self-awareness in the play element if like that's where we're gonna take it like yeah there's a massive Paradox here and I think that's a really good point and I didn't think about it but it's it's spot on it's like when when is this a problem like it's like why did does this come up all of a sudden and this is where it looks like it's just renting uh like in rumbling in the end and you're like and it leaves you a bit of a bad taste because the whole beginning of the book sometimes is a bit abstract and and weird but uh it it devs into interesting ideas and in the end the more the closer he comes to talking about his time the most uh like you feel like uh is becoming less and less interesting and making a a weakest point and actually devalues a lot of uh of what is in what
is in there yeah well he's flying high and then he starts though like the wax starts to melt um you know the other thing was sort of interesting too is that you know he kind of complains about it not being real play if you're doing it like too competitively or like making money off it like he's not interested in things like professional sports or you know he's clearly got some issues like with gambling and the the thing that tickles me about that is that like what do you think that the ancient Greek athletes got from their games that they won like uh you know like what you think that soldiers in Rome didn't carry dice in their mouths to gamble later and they just didn't want to get caught like that's it's just such a it was just a weird windmill to Tilt at because you know it was like why is that a problem now it's like if that's a problem it's been a problem since literally forever yeah um and I don't really see his problem I mean unless you have a cable condition in which case there yeah there's a problem but you know what I mean yeah of course we're not saying that gambling is good it's just that like on a philosophical level like it's it's not something that is new something that has existed for for quite a while yeah and there's certainly a play element as it were yeah so Adidas categorize him at play like it's part of the Alia but it's something that disregards a lot which I don't really necessarily understand why and I think the history of gambling is something that is super interesting and and also um seeing how gambling appears how it also structures part of uh Society I
think it's really interesting to see um how uh popular classes um uh took into their own hands the fact of gambling how it was perceived within those classes and everything I think gambling is a really interesting topic and I think this regarding it such a big part of play it's not the the most moral part in has a lot of issues I agree but uh but still it's a I don't know why too it has a very moralistic point of view on it but it's not really based on anything really solid um yeah and I also think it's it's perfectly possible to gamble for fun you know like my parents used to go to Vegas with some regularity and like they would Gamble and they would have a limit and you know they would go and sort of take it as like the entertainment is what you're paying for like the entertainment of playing this game and like being around all these like weird people in Vegas and having a great time um you know it doesn't have to be something that's like a moral sinkhole and it's you know I mean of course like you know I think a lot of early ideas about games do see it that way but at the same time you know John Truitt is interesting to talk to you about this um because he looks at games and like um Colonial Mexico like there's an idea of gambling is bad and there's also gambling like as a way of seeing whether the gods are favoring you right now and like gambling as an act of submitting yourself to Divine will and I think that that's something that heising ignores with tarot which you mentioned all these sorts of popular elements also like I don't know I sort
of feel like he's getting on board do you would have some interesting crossover in terms of which things Heiser considers like a marker of taste and perhaps ludic Capital as we were like I think it's a bit of a snob is where we're coming to yeah yeah it definitely falls into the distinction model about not seeing where is his cultural bias uh coming from I think that's uh I think that's really fair I think that's really fair but in a lot of ways you were saying something about a gambling can be also for fun and I think if you look at modern board gaming every push your back mechanic is a fun gambling mechanic like you're actually gambling for something to happen there is no money involved but it's still extremely exciting like it's uh so that's the and that's that's a form of gambling I mean when you play Lost Cities you're basically playing a dynamic blackjack in a in a kind of way and and it is gambling like you're gambling on the fact that you're gonna have uh the AIDS of uh of red and that you're gonna score the fact that you have the the two Expedition that's replaced at the beginning of your series it is gambling like it is fun oh yeah well the other thing though is like let's think about our value judgments too yeah you know um I think things have changed in in more recent known major right but you have Euro games which are rational and it's open information and they just see such clean Little Engines and you have ameritrash where people are like rolling Dice and you know oh there's no real order to this this is all just rolling dice it's crazy it's a dice chart like I mean I sort of feel like that actually maps onto our idea that gambling is
somehow lesser yeah art form and I would say that the probably the best game or the games that have a bit of both uh in a way uh War gaming maybe but also like this game often have an element of of gaming yes you have pure information but you're gonna draw something from a bag and you don't know what you're gonna get or uh yeah or you're gonna have a hand of card and you don't know what card you're gonna have and I mean better line is a perfect example of that it's the same thing like it's like you're hoping for having that uh that green three or something like this and that's and it's yeah it's all there it's very Euro in a lot of ways but you still have the the Alia that is here and actually that makes it so that those categorization are not that strict um can be part of the same thing like poker is very competitive for example yeah it talks a lot about Bridge actually so like he he should see that but it's uh he's not really talking about the about that overlapping uh categories of playing for sure yeah and play and I didn't find that like like you're seeing this nation because on the one hand I get it like I do feel that play is foundational to conscious existence because it's not just humans at play you know as you mentioned like animals play um I would say you know creatures without language play um to what extent do you want to say animals have culture I think they do they play
um you know I think that there's a much broader way to talk about it at the same time I don't think you can really kind of skip the game's part of play but I think that's that's something that I just briefly mentioned before and I didn't want to get into but I think that's all different aspect that I think was interesting to to think about and that's the biological aspects of play um and the fact that yes it what humans did that is interesting is that they saw the CV design civilizing function of play potentially but as you say it's interesting to see what how play is useful for animals like biologically how it is useful in the term of uh Evolution and you do have quite a wide range of animals who are playing not only mammals crows playing there are birds then we can think oh they have tiny brains but they're actually extremely smart and they actually have cross species playing like they play with other animals which is quite insane uh because we play with other animals but not a lot like we play with dogs and maybe with cats but it's like the fact that you have a crow that can actually play with other animal is interesting and there are more and more studies that are looking into the the fact that more playful crows have a better chance of reproducing because they have better chance of adding themselves to new situations and it's actually an evolutionary advantage and an evolutionary trait that can come up I think is actually quite quite interesting um to think about the fact that plays what we decide to do with play is is
interesting but the fact that it's already there like it's part of of the the it's not necessarily tied to conscience in a way or try to uh to to something that is specifically human which is an aspect that he doesn't he barely doesn't think about it like uh yeah uh yeah but he mentions it but it's not it's it's not really something that he that he really mentions he does yeah I think there were some books that were focusing specifically on this there was this researcher from new musician that I don't remember his name but we did the book specifically around the uh around the biological aspects of play and how useful is it yeah Brian Sutton Smith that's the that's the that's the guy which I think is a nice addition uh to to using his perspective maybe from a more rational point of view in a way I don't know yeah but yeah I mean this kind of comes right back around to taking homolutions as like a channel name right it's uh I mean all it means is human playing yeah yeah and and I think we we play in a very different way and I think it's really interesting and in the case of historical games it's even more interesting because it's like it's very meta like uh playing about history like it is uh taking an activity to actually engage with because as you say this place is a kind of abstraction like languages like uh we're gonna look at an object and saying this is a cup and the fact of naming an object is almost
magical in the sense that we were abstracting it to the to the to the to the state of an idea and the play is a bit like this it's a form of uh abstraction it's a very complex abstraction even more student language I think it's super interesting that we could play history we play human experiences from the past which is quite nuts and and and I think in that sense I think it's it's it's it's it's really cool and I think it's an interesting concept um and yeah omudi dance is I think we were yeah I think the fact that we play mix and the way we play makes our species quite special uh uh and that's what hence the name uh and I was thinking about something that actually well because that's another thing that I had in mind is there was a Sci-Fi book that I read a few years ago and when I was reading this I kept thinking about it um uh it's uh I am Banks the player of games I don't know if you've read this I you know what is that the one that's yes I have read this it's a Sci-Fi novel right yes it's a cipher and it's like it's got that game that's like that spatial puzzle yeah like cheats yeah okay yeah he doesn't cheat he doesn't cheat so but but that's the thing so he's actually sent so it's um it's uh the the hero of the book uh is sent by um uh by his kind of government it's called the culture uh but he's he's sent to uh to another uh to interact with
another civilization and create contact with them and that whole civilization is based on the concept of uh subspecialudy of wizinga the whole society is structured around one game uh and that game is called Azad and and and the game the result of the game is going to shape what kind of position you have in society what can and it's going to organize all of it and this guy is is a professional player but he's in in the culture there is no money there is nothing so decides to interact with his own humanity and everything like he occupies his time as a player and he's the best player of the culture and he's sent there to interact with that Society because it's a it's a it's a civilization based on on games and I think it's really interesting because it shows that seeing culture is only based on play is a bit absurd because we are not living in the in the Society of Azad obviously there are other aspects to it so I think it's an interesting but it also shows that um that there is the sediment and I think it was a good companion uh reading uh to get to that do you ever like have a moment where you remember something oh God it's not at all surprising I ended up like this so one of my one of the books that interested me the most when I was a teenager was um Herman hess's the glass bead game I haven't I haven't I haven't read that I would love to reread that wait a minute now that I've um now that I've engaged a lot huh I just did that yeah old Liz yeah I just turned 37 so I
read this book for the first time when I was like maybe 16 17. it's been a long time it's been decades now I feel like it would be a different a different experience a different experience for sure yeah what's the title of the book um there's you can either the English title is the glass bead game but it's also called Magister Ludy the master of the game um so it's got a Latin title as well and it's it's Herman has you know the guy who did like Siddhartha and Steppenwolf and Demian and all that stuff when I was a teen it blew my mind his narcissist I mean his uh his gnosticism there we go Obsession I mean I honestly look at myself too like I looked at gnosticism and then ended up studying monks in grad school but like it is no surprise that I found these things as little touchstones on the the path during my intellectual formation and like here we come back around I'm really not surprised at all but I'm gonna try to track this book because now you sold me on it I wanna I wanna read it yeah it's it's I remember it being really interesting my grasp of the details has faded with the years but now like maybe we should read it also um so I feel like this is a good moment to talk about so I really enjoyed this conversation I would like to do this again me too we shouldn't have another book club so uh do we want to decide ourselves what we're going to read or should we let others help us so I think we're gonna do that we'll put a poll in our discords yeah I think we should nominate two books as a follow-up and and but now that we talked about it actually yeah I wonder I'm thinking about other
candidates so maybe we need to to reconnect and agree on what would be the the two uh the two uh the two candidates and then we can share it on your Discord and on mine and the members of both Discord can can vote for for the next book of the of the of the play uh book club yes and you know Stewart has a great suggestion which is maybe we should do a book club about medieval ranged it's fine we don't need that we don't need that I will crossbows and the play element in culture yes that would be a whole new book that you will write just to make sure to make it into the book club and actually if you're wondering what we're talking about I'm gonna promote it once again if you haven't read the medieval crossbow by Stuart it is uh Gorman a weapon fit to kill King an excellent book on crossbows uh with a lot of nice illustrations uh and uh and very nice paper look at those illustrations oh yes I think that I think maybe his sequel needs to be the crossbow as cool toy the coolest yes exactly yeah yeah I wouldn't read this one this one I only looked at the images the one as a cool toy I would definitely um no no I'm joking it's a it's a great book I haven't finished it and I feel bad about it but one day I will uh Deborah also suggests medieval hats yeah I think hats are becoming a big part of the channel uh so at some point we probably have uh maybe we'll have a
hat Club something like this I mean I would kind of be down for a hat Club maybe in the next book club we should also surprise each other totally yeah I think that would be perfect I have a few hats on the on on the side so I can I can come up with something you know I almost never wear hats because I think I look very stupid in them but maybe that's just the point like maybe you just roll with it and accept it it's a matter of perception you have to enter the magic circle of uh wearing a hats and if the magic happened yeah exactly if they don't want to enter magic circle if you're wearing a hat that's their problem but it's
each nominate one book for the next one and and then we'll have to discuss secretly about which hats we're gonna wear I think that sounds like a perfect plan I think it's a great plan yes yeah and so thank you all of you for this extremely intellectually elevated discussion of hats
very intellectual yes I was very nerdy for sure very intellectual yeah I have my adults I have my reservations but as usual Fred thank you so much for coming on I hope we definitely do this again in the near future Miss pleasure it was awesome thanks Liz and uh thanks everybody for coming and commenting and giving us terrible ideas about what to do next we'll we'll put the vote in your hands all right until then um you know like subscribe comment go see homolutions go read homolutions ask questions and happy giving everybody see you