The Castles of Burgundy: Special Edition - Early Prototype Review
Transcript
hi everyone my name is money and I'm Naveen from before you play and today we're going to be doing something a little different we're going to be reviewing the current prototype for the upcoming special edition of the castles of burgundy yes this is now published by both Elia as well as awaken Realms it's designed by Stefan Feld who is one of my favorite designers uh Castleberry D Monique and I have played many many times over the past several years and we're excited to talk about this one yeah if you're not familiar with the castles burgundy it's the game that was released I believe in 2011 and it is one of our favorite games of all time it was part of our top 50. I don't remember now exactly what number it was but we played this game so many times and the copy that we have is the original version from 2011. since then they've released another version of it which was the anniversary edition and now they have this new special edition and so I believe they've kind of pulled the community for any kind of changes that everybody wanted to see in this upcoming version it was on game found and now the pledge manager is open so if anybody kind of missed that game found campaign previously you can still get in on it so today we're not going to be teaching the game at all we're just going to be talking about kind of what this is and how it kind of Compares and contrasts to all the different versions if you are interested in castles of burgundy the game Monique and I a couple months ago made a gameplay of it which you can see up here that is the original 2011 art design and all that stuff so if you go and check that out and then come back here you'll kind of see the differences as well but if you are interested in checking out the campaign we'll include a link to it down below all right I think we're ready to begin so if you please direct your attention to the extent of the table we're all set up here for a two-player game of the
special edition of the castles of burgundy welcome to the new board we have new player boards we have new everything we even have new Miniatures to go along with the castles and we actually have the new expansion for the game that is upcoming called The Vineyard expansion all set up here as well as attached to our player boards so we're gonna go ahead and first start by discussing the new visual changes obviously and the functional changes that this new special edition brings and then towards the end of the video we'll discuss how the new vineyard expansion works because we did play a full game with this expansion all right so first things first wow what a difference right yeah it's different the layout of things are are not uh what you're kind of accustomed to yeah so that takes a little bit of time to kind of get used to when you're so experienced with the previous editions right and again we are coming from the Brown version so all of this is going to look very different if you are used to the anniversary edition you'll notice some similarities in the colors that they use um sort of some of the layout but really there's a lot of new things that they've done to this version of the game let's just go ahead and start with the main board now we are set up for a two-player game so the opposite side of this board is gonna have the three and four player uh layout so I'll just have more spots for the hex tiles this is specifically for the two player games so each uh area here only has spaces for two hex tiles each and I know you can kind of relate on this but the very first time we kind of pulled everything out and looked at this version compared to our original version I was a little bit culture shocked yeah totally I didn't know where anything was I was uh I was having I have like a difficult time kind of
making things out and I think that is a part of what comes with the art style of both this version as well as the anniversary edition honestly yeah I mean it's it's very things are labeled very well yeah so it's kind of easy to understand but when you go from like playing that game so many times yeah over the past like automatically like visually I'm like the the boat track should be here and the the one like Depot should be there and so now it's like kind of just takes a little bit of time to get kind of get used to it but honestly within one round I knew exactly where everything was and it all made sense to me yeah it's true it's not that we can't locate things but I will say the artwork is both a pro and a con for me I think the artwork is really nice it's really beautiful it's almost like a sketched sketch style it's a drawing right yep and I much prefer the artwork uh in this Edition over the artwork in the anniversary edition but this version of the game is just so saturated I mean it's not necessarily a problem per se but I do find myself almost like overwhelmed yeah it's very busy the board is very busy and so are the player boards like I said it's beautiful but because the tiles are all colored the rest of the artwork does distract a little bit for me sure and I know we're going to be including some photos of the previous versions but just so you know this board is also bigger everything is bigger than the original version this is our aboard just for reference you can see the special edition and this is the older version you see how much bigger that is from the the classic version of the game the more muted colors yeah this has a lot the original version has a lot more muted colors this one is much more more
vibrant and then going back to the hex tiles the one thing that kind of uh bugs me about these because in general I really do like the hex tiles and we will get to the specifics of these in a second but the one thing that kind of bugs me about them is the orientation when you put them on the board specifically for the uh I think these are called the uh I want to say Technologies no monuments monuments or monasteries monasteries monasteries uh specifically for the monasteries as you kind of go around the board they start to rotate and so when I get to the side here I like I really want to be vertical to be vertical because in the original version of the game everything was straight you could read all the tiles straight on and that's just not the case uh for this version sure so I don't know that might just be a me thing no when I was setting it up I was like I took the tile I was ready to put it down and I was like it's not it's not just kidding it's like you have to kind of slightly yeah but that is sort of my Newt we just thought it was kind of funny thing that we noticed something that isn't as minute that kind of really bugged us the first time we set this up are the bonus tiles okay if you're not familiar with this game the way that this bonus tiles work is as soon as somebody fills up every single space of one color then they get to claim that bonus Styles if I did all the shipping tiles I get to take this one well there are two of them because the first time somebody does it they get the first one and then the next time another player does it they get the second one well they're not consistent so when we're setting up the board we had no idea where the second ones were yeah I don't really know I don't understand to
be honest oh see this is wrong well there you go I don't uh is that wrong is that Rob yeah this is not oh no that's that's right yeah the top one was wrong so there you go yeah that makes it hard see the issue there it's because what they did was they took the two colors like I think this is correct right these two it's good they took like two colors and they inverted them I wish that they just made them the same tile yeah just for consistency because it's really kind of hard to set it up setting it up the first time I was like what is going on over here you know because there's like a pattern I also that you can see like this is that circular pattern like that but you know I don't know yeah aesthetically it's not very pleasing for me yeah that's just a subjective opinion the shipping track which I'm not realizing this is wrong sorry but these are the tokens uh for the shipping truck and they're cool because they're stacked they're really nice yeah they are these are really nice I think they're technically like tops of castles um I'm not quite sure which uh pledge version I guess these ones come with because I know that there's like an upgrade for the Miniatures but uh if these come with the you know the regular version these are really nice yeah now moving on to the actual hex tiles so these ones I believe are much bigger than both the anniversary edition and the original version I think those versions both of those uh different hex tiles were the same size and these ones everything is so much bigger and chunkier and I really appreciate appreciate that about the special edition because it just makes things so much easier right yeah speaking of hexes uh Beyond just the the castles the tiles
that are here in the middle that have like the little black dot if you're familiar with the older games this is much more welcome for me uh having this extra big thick kind of chunky uh breaking down the game and putting things away it makes it so much easier because as this is on your player board and you want to put things away sometimes you see one of these you know with with like a little like a tiny little speck of a black and that ends up going into the main like blue pile right that means the odds of it coming out in the next game are they're not going to be there so that mistake that mistake is there so uh it's nice to have something very very thick like that also the backs of the tiles also have the same color so if somehow things kind of get jumbled around you can see that the blue this belongs in the bag or in the pile for the blue right it's really really nice and that's the same for these this is like black on the back side which is really nice yeah so making that more uh prominent is definitely a good move the other thing is the backs of the tiles have the a description it's super welcome yes I really enjoy that this is fantastic yeah because and you know even though we played this game so many times especially for the building tiles in the original game there was this little tiny this like chart on your player board yeah and uh even with that chart we would still be like so when you take that building what do you do like flipping through the book all the time so now this version of the game has all of the uh the bonuses and the effects of each tile written on the back yeah and it was very succinct and it like it explains it just like it I never saw myself flipping it over reading it and being like I still don't understand let's go to the rule book so uh yeah hold up now this new special edition also comes with these nice chunky Goods
tiles so these are really nice they're like they're wood they're thick and they kind of slot in your player board like this the only one thing is sometimes when like the let's say the one and the six yeah these are different types of goods the color Choice there that uh I would I would change it yeah and you can kind of see at a glance that they're different you know they have a different artwork but even the artwork in the background is sort of faint these Reds are just a little bit too close for me to know at a moment's glance which one I need so when we were playing the game I was constantly having to like reference my board reference back see main board it's not only that one but also the blue and the purple I I also had a little bit of trouble with that one yeah that's true and uh none of us have any issues Discerning different colors so this was still uh sort of difficult for us just to kind of see at a moment's glance when you're kind of trying to strategize yeah and I mean the pit values are there so it's it's you just you just have to like really focus in like you can't just at a glance yeah you know just like casually think that like that's a six it could be a one so you got to really pay attention there yeah and in the original version of the game even though the colors that they chose for the good Styles weren't the uh the cutest the most aesthetic they were still very functional super functional because they were so extreme I guess uh for the most part uh the one thing for me though with the good Styles is they are a little bit difficult to shuffle obviously like you're trying to keep them face down so uh getting them like nice and shuffled without like doing kind of like a mahjong Shuffle is a little bit difficult especially when you're setting up the game chunky because they're because they're like chunky and so like you have to then stack them and so what I found myself doing was just going to shaking it up
yeah just put them in a bag putting them and then just laying them out face down that'll be the new uh the new way to to scramble these good Styles put them in a bag exactly next up we have our dice so if you're familiar with any of the previous editions of the game this is the first time that they are changing the dice at all the original game as well as the anniversary edition used the exact same dice they're very basic kind of a solid one color uh player color Dice and uh now this is the sort of custom upgraded version that they decided to go with I don't know now in the process where they're at with these I think I saw somewhere that these are going to be changing okay because these are super difficult to play with in my opinion I had a really hard time with with Discerning them even just with the first game even by the end of the first game yeah because there's so many other uh squares on the dice that I think there was a moment where you played you had you had a two and you thought it was a four yes remember that that's right yeah yeah I did do that um and that tends to happen throughout the game yeah sometimes I'll look down like right when I roll and I'm like what do you like with the white guys like you know how you feel refill the good Styles in the depot like I was sending tiles to the wrong Depots because of these four corners yeah obviously this this this point could be completely different because these may not be the dice in the in the long run so uh but just with our prototype version of it to review that I did have difficulty with these dice yeah which is kind of stuff for me because my favorite sort of upgraded I think it's always so nice but for a game like
this where it really relies on the use of your dice I think the less symbols on it the better yeah right especially when you have like pip lines when you have Pip like symbols you want to die that are not the Pips that that can make it really confusing yeah so super distracting for us now moving on to our dutchies and our player boards these are called datis by the way if you're not really familiar with the way that the game works each player has their own uh mat and you can actually remove this this is new to this version of the game and remove the mat because these can be switched out um there are several new dutchies I think they're double-sided too yes there's they're usually played with like an asymmetric uh side to the dutchies if you're playing if you're more familiar with the game and so I know that the Special Edition comes with new dutchies unfortunately neither of us are very well versed at the original dutchies or even the original expansion dutchies I know there's like one from the original that's like the like no one can play it it's illegal I think it's like number eight uh so I don't know if they've done any like what kind of balance testing everything honestly we're not well first enough at the dutchies to be able to speak on the new ones we did play with one of the new ones and I thought it was just as fun as otherwise so now in terms of the actual player board wow what a difference right this is a this is a really really uh sort of extreme upgrade from what we're used to I mean first of all you know you put the dutchie in here and it kind of slots in to this like double layered player board and then you put the overlay on top of it so that all of the tiles are held in place now is it 100 necessary not necessarily for me it's kind of a welcome yeah it's nice
it's nice it everything fits like I put this in there it all fits it's all the nice orientation by the way so all of your tiles are still kind of front on unlike the board right yeah everything kind of slots in and it doesn't move and it's just clean right and I think that's the bottom line just for reference this is these are the player boards that we're used to as you can see they're much smaller uh than the new version and even the dutchie itself is really tiny in there and and so now it's just it's much bigger the the art style is continued on the player board they're nice and for me between this player board and the anniversary edition this is a huge upgrade I was not a fan of the player boards that came with the anniversary edition now similar to the way that the tiles kind of fit into this overlay and everything stays clean we also have areas to keep everything else because of the fact that it's a dual layered board everything slots in and doesn't move so now we have a space to keep our Dice and when the dice are used they move down here which is a very functional thing I do like that yeah yeah I really like that it keeps everyone on top of it like this is the die that needs to be played this is the die that is now played before you kind of have to put it on your board take it off your board right people would be inconsistent yeah I really like that and there's now a place for the white dye yep I like that too because there are some expansion uh hex tiles that reference the White die where you're gonna have to um take an action or something based off of the white dye as a bonus and so just knowing where the white dye is at all times and having a slot for it I think it's nice now it's a part of the campaign there is an option
to get the sort of upgraded version that includes these Miniatures and so Miniatures look like this they are castles and the castle Miniatures are meant to go on top of the castle spots instead of placing a castle tile you would play with these right and so what do you think of them I mean these are really nice like just from a prototype perspective in terms of just looking at it aesthetically really really nice in terms of functionality and like is it absolutely necessary no yeah but uh but uh they are they are very nice to look at I will say that it it's always interesting to kind of look at a game like this from a Euro Gamers perspective because this is a euro game through and through right it's sort of dry in gameplay but then they made sort of this like upgraded version that that mixes the Two Worlds together the castle Miniatures are beautiful like this is a prototype and these are so beautiful yeah whether or not you need them is going to be a very personal decision so we I played with mine Naveen didn't want to play with his so that's kind of the difference like you're a Euro gamer through and through it's weird I played with the first one and then every time every Castle I built out after that I just took the chit and that's how some people are going to feel yeah um I will say these slightly obstruct the view of whatever tile is uh Beyond of the actual castle it's not a huge deal it's if anything it's just like one tile depending on what Dutchy your opponents are playing with I think you were playing with this exact this particular one and you didn't have this spot full filled right and I thought that Naveen was going to take the
shipping bonus tile because oh because you are physically sitting looking this way this is towering over yeah but if you do decide to play with the Miniatures the thing that I thought was cool is after you you know you fill up your board you look at your estate it sort of looks like an estate it does because you have these 3D castles and then everything else around it tiles and everything and the artwork on the hexes themselves are so beautiful I really like what they did with the actual hexes all the animal tiles are so nice they're like something out of like a like a painting yeah they're much nicer than the animals in in the original version for sure and the bit about these Miniatures is gonna hold true for like the score tokens these are these are really nice score tokens yeah it I I think they're nice too I think they're nice to sort of be able to move that around I think the if you don't get those upgraded versions you get these cardboard chips which I think are still nice like I like just having something 3D to move around the scoreboard I mean this is a prototype and the detail on this thing is amazing like the way his like his uh his draping goes all around and uh his headpiece wow so if you're looking to get the upgraded Miniatures and you've sort of made up your mind on that front I don't think you're going to be disappointed you're super nice and that's sort of it in terms of the visual and functional upgrades with the base game stuff right now this version of the game I think is going to come with all the original expansions which is kind of nice because coming from the classic version of the game it doesn't come with any expansions you know there are a ton of expansions that they release throughout the years that we kind of had the piecemeal anniversary edition I believe came with them and this version is going to not only come with those
expansions but also the never before seen expansion called The Vineyard expansion that's designed by stefanfeld so it's this as well as this bit that now attaches to your player board this is now your own personal Vineyard and so if you're familiar with the game the way that this expansion works is we're going to be building out our own Vineyard now with these uh double hex Vineyard tiles I just want to say the artwork on the vineyard expansion itself is not final these tiles are going to be much brighter is what they what we were told but the way that works is each phase AKA round you're going to have a certain number of these set out into the store and the depot this is actually a a stand that gets put out like this yeah I just kind of laid it down so that it's easier yeah easier to see on your turn you can spend one of your dice to claim a tile from this stand and the dice values that you have to spend are listed below uh the section of the hex that you're trying to go for so if I really want this tile I could spend either a one or two if that makes sense now when you take the hex they have to fit in two of your slots right and so that is the part of this expansion that is both super annoying and Brilliant yeah because you have to if you don't have enough space you have to make room which means you are costing yourself actions and time and you're regretting your life now because if you know this game it's very tight once you've collected a tile you can now spend a die to place it out into your Vineyard the first tile that you place has to go on the first layer of your Vineyard down here and so if you look closely at the spot that actually tells you what dye value you have to spend in order to place that yes you have a 4 and a one yeah and then
eventually for the first place when you place the hex tile um any future hex tiles must be orthogonally adjacent to any of the ones that are already on your board I don't believe you have to complete one section before moving on to the next I think because this is here you can now place here that's right if that makes sense and each uh hex double hex space shows two different bonuses and you get to take them both in whatever order you choose so if I were to place uh this double hex here I would get two silverlings and then I would get to take a building from the board and place it into my area so a majority of the bonuses are going to be variations of stuff that you've seen on various building tiles Etc so you're already very familiar with that yeah but it's just sort of a different thing that you can work on on your turn you can also spend two silverlings similar to the way that you purchase the tiles in the middle you can instead purchase a Vineyard tile from the store so that's how you purchase the ones from here and that's where there's a two sibling um underneath it yes this is a two player game so we only have one title out but depending on the player count you'll add more and so as soon as you complete one entire level of your Vineyard you get to take a bonus tile and the bonus tiles look like this they're basically going to be end game scoring multipliers for contiguous grouping of the same colored uh Grace so this is the same color as this so now it's in my best interest to continue getting the same color and kind of connect them oops I think it would go like this oh yeah by the way connect them in a snaking path so that at the end of the game I'm gonna score this is going to be three points for having one of these but there are several of them so if I were to collect more of them in the future now this is going to give me
uh two points for each hex right because of multiplier and each player starts the game with one of these a different one uh we played a game of this and we were supposed to play with this expansion but somebody didn't necessarily ignored it 100 ignored it and um it worked out yeah he ignored it completely and he won by a long shot I don't necessarily think that's a product of the expansion I think the expansion is actually quite good it definitely augments the game um in certain ways because it gives you something else to go towards yeah but you have to be strategic with it I will say I ignored it because the grape type that I had was just not present a lot of the time in the in the uh selection so I was like it's not there I'm not gonna go for it and I think that's going to be one of the limitations with a Vineyard expansion especially at two because of these selections that you see these don't change until then the next phase so it's every phase you get a new selection of these every every five rounds you're gonna see a brand new one so I was like well they're not there in the first five rounds yeah I'm gonna go build some other infrastructure then I found myself I need a bunch of sheep hey there's a bunch of sheep out there I'm gonna go deal with the Sheep so then by the time you know one of these tokens came out that I wanted I was like I'm kind of trying to close this area off maybe next time I'll you know they'll come into play speaking of the sheep that was the other issue that I had with it because I was taking the vineyard because I did play with this expansion unlike somebody because I was taking those tiles I was not taking something off the board and if you've played castles we're gonna get two players you're familiar with how uh so there's a hate wrapping in there how yeah it's a very uh tactical game I suppose you know
when I'm not taking a tile away from Naveen he's getting all of the sheep and so he had this massive sheep area which I know I had this board is that was probably my problem but I I let him have him and so he ended up scoring a ton of points it's still a couple of dice that you're taking out of circulation when you take these tiles that's the thing that's the thing and if you if you're familiar with this game but especially towards the end of the game the number of actions that you have can really determine the outcome of your gameplay because it could mean the difference between you completing an entire section and not right but I enjoyed playing with it yeah I think it's nice to just have it there so the threat of it is there like oh man Monique is gonna get four workers if she covers up that spot like shoot like okay then you know she's gonna be able to manipulate her dice to do other things that are really cool yeah I liked it it provided another option because sometimes when you play this game you're like well I have these two dice there's literally nothing no tiles me to take on the board yeah I don't really have anything it eliminates the excessive needs sometimes to play a diet to take workers yep right instead of doing that get it in your tires towards um your goals let it get you four workers instead of spending one die for two right I do appreciate the fact that they are double hexes that are combined so you can't just Spam this area here this is because of the math on this you know two to three so uh that that part I do appreciate for it I I would like to play it again and try to explore this map yeah it's just like I said those tiles were not coming out in the right order yeah so I just said you know what I'm just going to deal with regular old castles of burgundy and the last thing is there is a solo mode to this called
the shatoma I think I read a little bit about it but I wasn't able to play it due to our time constraints but it seems it seems cool you can actually integrate that in a two-player game to make it into a three-player game so I thought that was really cool I think that's essentially it so if you have any questions about anything that you saw here today please leave us a comment Down Below in general I think that this is the honestly this is the best version of castles of burgundy that you'll probably find sure are there things in this version that could be considered excessive definitely but it is the nicest most functional version of the game that you'll find totally there are things in the video that we mentioned that we hope they'll change like we said earlier nothing here is final I don't think and so if you're interested in kind of following along and seeing what they end up doing for the final version we encourage you to check out their game found which is linked in description below thank you all so much for watching the video we really hope you enjoyed it if you'd like to see more like this in the future please consider subscribing thank you you bye